Whether you’re craving a classic New York-style fold or a gourmet Neapolitan masterpiece, Amarillo offers a selection of pizza spots that promise to satisfy every palate.
From crispy thin crusts adorned with local produce to hearty deep-dish wonders that ooze with molten cheese, Amarillo’s pizza scene offers something to satiate every palate. This guide curates the city’s standout pizzerias, each offering a unique slice of culinary heaven.
575 Pizzeria
9.2/10 (975 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 806-322-5575
Delicious pizzaExcellent serviceCool atmosphere
Nestled at the end of a shopping center, 575 Pizzeria may not catch your eye from the outside, but once inside, you are greeted with seriously delicious food and excellent service. The cheese breadsticks and Bender Pizza are must-tries, and the build your own pizza option is a great way to customize your meal. Live music adds to the ambiance, making it a perfect spot to unwind after a long day. Despite its unassuming exterior, 575 Pizzeria is a hidden gem in Amarillo that serves up fantastic pizza and appetizers, all while providing top-notch service that goes above and beyond.
Big Jim’s Pizza Co.
8.8/10 (1070 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 806-352-5050
Cozy/Homie FeelingFriendly StaffFresh Ingredients
Nestled in a cozy setting, Big Jim’s Pizza Co. offers a welcoming vibe and freshly made pizzas that hit the spot. The variety of toppings and tasty pasta dishes ensure there’s something for everyone. The environment is enhanced by the friendly team serving up juicy chicken and on-point cheese pies, keeping customers coming back for more. Whether it’s the heartwarming gesture of collecting donations for a good cause or the delicious food prepared with quality ingredients, Big Jim’s hits the mark with their homely atmosphere and satisfying fare.
Pizza Planet
8.8/10 (1069 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 806-353-6666
Irresistible pizzaScrumptious saladsFriendly staff
Pizza Planet, located in Amarillo, truly stands out for its mouthwatering pizza and scrumptious salads. Customers rave about the irresistible flavors and the variety of options available on their menu. The jalapeno popper pizza is a fan favorite, although some patrons found the cream cheese sauce a bit overwhelming. Despite some minor mishaps with orders like charred chicken wings and incorrect salad toppings, Pizza Planet’s staff is always friendly and accommodating. The buffet during lunchtime and Sunday nights is a must-try, offering a chance to sample a wide array of their delicious pizzas. For a tasty and satisfying dining experience, Pizza Planet is the place to go.
Fire Slice Pizzeria
9/10 (499 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 806-331-2232
Outstanding pizza crustCozy family-friendly ambianceVaried beer and wine selection
Fire Slice Pizzeria exudes warmth and charm, with a cozy ambiance that makes you feel like you’re part of the family. The menu boasts an array of special pizzas, and the create-your-own option allows for endless possibilities. The standout feature, however, is the exceptional crust – thin and crispy yet delightfully soft on the inside. The beer and wine selection adds to the laid-back atmosphere, making it a perfect spot for a casual, yet memorable dining experience.
575 Pizzeria
9/10 (1003 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 806-322-5575
Unique and delicious piesTop-notch craft beer selectionCasual yet modern ambiance
575 Pizzeria in Amarillo is a must-visit for pizza lovers, with unique pies like The Phoebe and the Pizza Kamehameha that are both delicious and satisfying. The craft beer selection is top-notch and pairs perfectly with any slice. The ambiance is casual yet modern, with an open kitchen that adds to the dining experience. Whether you’re a meat lover or a veggie enthusiast, 575 has something for everyone and is sure to leave you coming back for more. Seated quickly. Great customer service!!!! House salad was good, except the cucumber was soggy 😕 Small pizza crust was crunchy n chewy on the inside, and the large pizza was soft and doughy. Kinda confussed on the inconsistent crust… which was the right way, considering they were both cooked in a brick oven????
Palio’s Pizza and Bar
9/10 (717 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 806-398-7256
Flavorful Greek PizzaUnique Feta PoppersDelicious Nutty Hawaiian Salad
Palio’s Pizza and Bar offers a delightful dining experience with exceptional food and attentive service. The Greek pizza, piled high with delicious ingredients, stands out as a flavorful and satisfying menu item. The jalapeño poppers, uniquely made with feta cheese, are a must-try appetizer. The Nutty Hawaiian salad with chicken is a delicious option featuring a perfect balance of flavors, including pineapple chunks and sun-dried tomatoes. With a welcoming atmosphere and quick service, Palio’s Pizza and Bar is a top choice for pizza lovers in Amarillo.
Vince’s Italian Pizza
9/10 (336 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 806-352-2656
Inviting ambianceQuality ingredientsAuthentic Italian cuisine
Located in the heart of the bustling city, Vince’s Italian Pizza is a gem worth exploring. The ambiance of the restaurant is warm and inviting, perfect for a casual meal with friends or family. The menu boasts a variety of Italian classics, all prepared with quality ingredients that guarantee a delicious experience. The Italian sub with fries is a standout item, fresh and flavorful, sure to leave you satisfied. Vince’s is a must-visit spot for anyone craving authentic Italian cuisine that is both satisfying and memorable.
Pizzeria Nomad
9/10 (317 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 806-477-2660
Flavorful SaladsUnique BBQ-inspired PizzasCool Mural Vibes
Pizzeria Nomad in Amarillo is a hidden gem that offers unique wood-fired pizzas and flavorful salads. The Spinach Arugula salad with dark Grapes, Walnuts, Sun-Dried Tomato, Feta with a Creamy Bacon Vinaigrette is a must-try, while the Brisket Pie is a delicious nod to traditional BBQ flavors. The friendly and knowledgeable staff, along with the cool mural on the building, adds to the overall experience. The crust on the pizzas is just right, and the wings have a unique flavor that sets them apart from other places. If you’re looking for a local spot with creative pies and a relaxed vibe, Pizzeria Nomad is worth a visit.
Pizza Planet
8.6/10 (147 reviews)
| Directions | +1 806-381-2333
Classic, topping-heavy pizzasGenerous portionsFriendly staff
Pizza Planet offers classic, topping-heavy pizzas with generous portions, making it an ideal spot for takeout or delivery. The jalapeno popper and chicken bacon ranch pizzas are standout menu items, along with the chef salad. The service is top-notch, whether opting for pickup or delivery, and the staff is always welcoming. The prices are reasonable for the quality and quantity of food provided, making it a go-to spot for feeding a crowd or indulging in a satisfying meal. The North side of Amarillo may be missing out on the opportunity to enjoy the delicious offerings at Pizza Planet, but those in the know appreciate the fresh ingredients and flavorful pizzas available at this establishment.
Pizza Planet
8.6/10 (303 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 806-352-6666
Diverse MenuDrive-Through ConvenienceFriendly Staff
Pizza Planet in Amarillo is a hidden gem that offers a diverse menu with delicious options from mouth-watering pizzas to fresh salads. The chicken barbeque pizza was a standout, with generous portions that led to satisfying leftovers. The drive-through option makes it convenient for those on the go, while the friendly staff ensures a pleasant dining experience. Whether you’re craving a classic pepperoni or a unique jalapeño popper pizza, Pizza Planet delivers hot and tasty pies that are sure to please.
Giovanni’s Pizzeria
8.6/10 (299 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 806-358-3535
Hand-tossed doughFlavorful toppingsClean establishment
Giovanni’s Pizzeria stands out for its hand-tossed, tasty dough with ample cheese and flavorful toppings. The pizza is prepared quickly and correctly, with a clean establishment and friendly employees. The texture, flavor, and crust are all on point, making it a standout option compared to chain pizzas. While a few reviews mentioned issues with grease or customer service, the overall consensus points to Giovanni’s Pizzeria as a top choice for delicious pizza that surpasses the competition in taste and quality.
La Bella Pizza Hillside
8.6/10 (388 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 806-352-1600
Fresh ingredientsFriendly serviceQuick turnaround
La Bella Pizza Hillside is a local favorite in Amarillo, known for their delectable pizzas and quick service. The staff is friendly and offers helpful recommendations, making the ordering process a breeze. The pizzas are loaded with fresh, high-quality ingredients, and the crust is perfectly cooked to crispy perfection. Whether you’re a fan of classics like pepperoni or adventurous toppings like jalapeño poppers, La Bella Pizza Hillside has something for everyone. Additionally, their speedy service and generous portions make them a go-to spot for groups or individuals looking for a satisfying meal.
CAVA
9/10 (978 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 718-502-9282
Customizable bowlsDelicious and healthyFriendly staff
The true star of CAVA is the customizable nature of their bowls. With a wide variety of bases, proteins, dressings, and toppings to choose from, you can truly make your meal your own. The staff, while sometimes hit or miss, are generally patient and kind, making sure your bowl is made perfectly. Despite the sometimes rushed atmosphere during lunch hours, the delicious and healthy food at CAVA makes it a go-to spot for many. And with the option to take your food to go, you can enjoy your meal anywhere, making it a great option for a quick and satisfying lunch on the go.
La Bella Pizza 34th & Osage
9/10 (156 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 806-331-2200
Customer-centric serviceQuality pizza ingredientsCommitment to improvement
Hidden in a quiet corner of town, La Bella Pizza 34th & Osage is a hidden gem waiting to be discovered. The small gestures, like drawing silly pictures on the box, showcase their dedication to customer satisfaction. Despite some negative feedback, the pizza retains its quality and flavor, rivaling that of other local favorites. The dedication to improvement is evident, as they strive to regain their former glory. The raw dough issue may be a hiccup, but their commitment to consistency shines through. The service may have its ups and downs, but the potential is there for a truly memorable dining experience.
Napoli’s
8.8/10 (1027 reviews)
| Directions | +1 806-220-2588
Generous Portion SizesIndulgent DessertsAttentive Service
Napoli’s is a charming spot that is perfect for those looking to enjoy some authentic Italian fare. The garlic knots are a standout, light and buttery, and the lasagna is a must-try, with a generous portion size. The pasta dishes like veal Parmigiano and Linguini with shrimp are also crowd-pleasers, served in large portions. Desserts like the chocolate mousse cake and turtle cheesecake are indulgent and satisfying. The attentive service and cozy atmosphere make Napoli’s a great choice for a delicious Italian meal.
Pescaraz Italian Restaurant
8.6/10 (937 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 806-350-5430
Flavorful Cajun Chicken & TortelliniExceptional service catering to dietary restrictionsCharming atmosphere with delicious house specialties
Pescaraz Italian Restaurant in Amarillo, TX provides a cozy atmosphere with top-notch service and delicious food that will leave you satisfied. The Cajun Chicken & Tortellini is a must-try dish that packs a flavorful punch. Despite limited vegan options, the chef and staff go above and beyond to cater to dietary restrictions, ensuring a delightful dining experience. The house grilled chicken, meat lasagna, and chicken Alfredo are hot and delicious options for a family gathering or special event. With attentive service and mouthwatering dishes, Pescaraz Italian Restaurant is a standout choice in Amarillo.
Bubba’s 33
9/10 (3548 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 806-353-0033
Delicious foodFriendly staffVibrant atmosphere
Bubba’s 33 is a must-visit spot in Amarillo, Texas with delicious food and excellent service. The menu boasts mouth-watering dishes like pizza, wings, and pasta, all served in a vibrant atmosphere with live music and sports broadcasting. The staff is friendly and attentive, ensuring that every visit is a memorable one. Whether you’re looking for a casual hangout or a place to indulge in tasty bites and drinks while watching a game, Bubba’s 33 has it all.
Joe’s Pizza & Pasta
9.4/10 (363 reviews)
| Directions | +1 806-356-8191
Generous portionsQuality meatExcellent service
Nestled in Amarillo, Joe’s Pizza & Pasta is a must-visit for those craving hearty Italian fare. With a generous serving of meat sauce and quality meatballs, the spaghetti is a standout menu item. The grated Parmesan and crushed red pepper on the table add a personal touch, while the cozy atmosphere invites you to sit back and enjoy. The staff here are not only helpful but also provide top-notch service, making your dining experience all the more enjoyable. Truck drivers passing through should definitely make a pit stop here for a satisfying meal and a welcoming ambiance.
Macaroni Joe’s
9/10 (625 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 806-358-8990
Charming ambienceExcellent serviceFlavorful and generous dishes
Macaroni Joe’s is a charming Italian eatery that excels in both ambience and service. Step inside, and you’ll feel transported to an outdoor cafe in Italy. The decor is cozy and inviting, setting the perfect backdrop for a delightful dining experience. The service is top-notch, with attentive and knowledgeable waitstaff ensuring a seamless meal from start to finish. The menu offerings are equally impressive, with dishes like bone-in pork chop and blackened bayou pasta standing out for their bold flavors and generous portions. And don’t forget to save room for dessert – the vanilla creme brulee and bread pudding with bourbon vanilla caramel sauce are simply divine. Whether you’re a local or just passing through Amarillo, Macaroni Joe’s is a hidden gem that’s well worth a visit.
CAVA
8.6/10 (666 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 212-206-2524
FreshTastyEfficient
CAVA is a haven for food enthusiasts seeking fresh and tasty options with a touch of love and service excellence. The crew at this Wall Street hotspot works at lightning speed, ensuring efficient service without compromising accuracy. There’s a vegan/vegetarian oasis here, offering a plethora of healthy choices at great prices. The portions are generous, and the vibrant staff, such as TEE and Ashley (Ash), go above and beyond to ensure a pleasant dining experience. The positive vibes emanating from Nia R, Tess, and Marleni add to the overall charm of CAVA, making it a must-visit for those craving flavorful food and exceptional service.