Whether you’re craving a classic New York-style fold or a gourmet Neapolitan masterpiece, Athens-Clarke County offers a selection of pizza spots that promise to satisfy every palate.
From crispy thin crusts adorned with local produce to hearty deep-dish wonders that ooze with molten cheese, Athens-Clarke County’s pizza scene offers something to satiate every palate. This guide curates the city’s standout pizzerias, each offering a unique slice of culinary heaven.
Little Italy Pizzeria
8.8/10 (1281 reviews)
Perfectly crispy crustGenerous portionsFriendly service
Nestled in the heart of downtown Athens, Little Italy Pizzeria is a gem for locals and visitors alike. The pizza here is a standout, with the crust being crispy yet not overdone, perfectly complementing a variety of fresh and flavorful toppings. The William special pizza is a must-try, with a perfect balance of four cheeses, extra mozzarella, pepperoni, and meatballs that will leave your taste buds singing. The portions are generous, the service is friendly, and the ambiance is laid-back and inviting. Make sure to stop by for a meal that will leave you satisfied and coming back for more.
Johnny’s New York Style Pizza
8.6/10 (795 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 706-354-1515
Crispy wingsChewy crustFresh fillings
Johnny’s New York Style Pizza offers a delightful menu with standout favorites like the Johnnys special sub, featuring fresh, flavorful fillings that are sure to satisfy. The friendly staff adds to the warm atmosphere, making you feel right at home. The crispy wings and chewy crust on the pizza truly stand out, providing a delicious experience for anyone looking for a tasty meal. While some have mentioned inconsistencies with their orders, the overall quality of the food and service make Johnny’s a must-try for any pizza enthusiast.
Peppino’s Pizzeria
9/10 (939 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 706-613-1616
Perfectly balanced pizzaLively atmosphereGreat customer service
Peppino’s Pizzeria is a neighborhood gem with some unique and standout qualities. The pizza here is a real star, boasting a perfect balance of sauce, cheese, and fresh produce. The atmosphere is lively, although it can get a bit loud at times. The customer service is worth mentioning, as it is both great and patient, adding to the overall dining experience. Despite a few minor hiccups, Peppino’s Pizzeria is definitely a spot to consider when craving a delicious pizza.
Athens pizza
8.6/10 (440 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 706-850-9292
Perfectly crisp crustHigh-quality ingredientsBest halal pizza
Athens Pizza is a must-visit spot for pizza lovers seeking an unforgettable dining experience. The signature pizza boasted a perfectly crisp crust, fresh toppings, and a heavenly blend of cheeses. The attention to detail and high-quality ingredients shone through in every bite, making it the best pizza I’ve ever had. It’s a true gem that caters to fans of both Greek and Italian cuisine – a culinary delight in every sense.
Automatic Pizza
9/10 (554 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 706-850-2037
Unique atmosphereDelicious Margherita pizzaFriendly staff
Automatic Pizza, located in what used to be a gas station, offers a unique dining experience with its charming old brick walls and covered outdoor seating. The food is consistently delicious, with fresh, loaded toppings on a crisp thin crust that remains tasty even when reheated properly. The staff is friendly and the service is quick, making it ideal for a casual meal or a small family outing. The limited seating may require some flexibility in dining arrangements, but the huge portions and great taste of the Margherita pizza make it a must-try, especially for those looking for the best New York style pizza in the south. With unique decor, great service, and top-notch pizza, Automatic Pizza is definitely worth a visit.
Pizza Factory
9/10 (143 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 706-850-6169
Delicious gluten-free optionsWelcoming and clean ambianceFriendly and professional staff
Pizza Factory has quickly become a favorite among customers for its tasty and flavorful pizzas. The gluten-free options receive high praise, with many noting that it is the best they have ever had. The ambiance of the restaurant is welcoming and clean, with friendly and professional staff making the dining experience even more enjoyable. The selection of pizzas, including the cauliflower crust and regular gluten-free crust, leave customers impressed and satisfied. Overall, Pizza Factory stands out for its delicious offerings and excellent service.
Ted’s Most Best
8.8/10 (839 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 706-543-1523
Delicious pizzasVariety of toppingsQuick service
At Ted’s Most Best, patrons can enjoy delicious Italian-style pizzas at this casual downtown Athens spot. The small pizzas are perfect for individual orders, and there are plenty of seating options, including indoor and outdoor areas with a sandbox for kids. The service is quick, and the food is tasty, providing a nice and relaxing dining experience. While there may be a bit of a wait during busy times, the quality of the pizzas makes it worth the visit.
Fully Loaded Pizza Kitchen
8.8/10 (322 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 706-215-9348
Local favoriteTeam service ethosHot and tasty food
Fully Loaded Pizza Kitchen fully embodies the local pizzeria/bar concept with crowds flocking in for a fun and lively atmosphere. The team service approach ensures impeccable care with checks from passing staff. The hot and tasty food, including flavorful wings and delightful pizza, keeps customers satisfied. With designated parking and a popular covered outdoor dining area, this restaurant remains an excellent option for group outings or casual dates. Despite minor hiccups such as late dishes or pricey large party fees, Fully Loaded Pizza Kitchen distinguishes itself with exceptional service and a vibrant social setting, offering a must-visit experience in Athens.
Amici Athens
8.6/10 (594 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 706-353-0000
Freshly baked crustSweet chili wingsCozy atmosphere
Amici Athens serves up delicious pizza and wings in a cozy atmosphere that makes you feel right at home. The freshly baked crust on the pizzas is a standout, and the sweet chili wings are a must-try. The friendly staff goes above and beyond to ensure a pleasant dining experience, making this restaurant a top choice for both locals and visitors alike.
Cicis Pizza
9/10 (849 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 706-613-2424
Easy buffet experienceFriendly staffFresh and tasty food
Cicis Pizza offers an easy and convenient buffet experience, allowing guests to choose from a variety of pizzas, breadsticks, soup, salad, and desserts. The option to customize a 9″ personal pizza adds a nice touch, and the pricing is quite reasonable at $8.99 for the buffet and $2.69 for a regular drink. The staff is friendly and attentive, ensuring a pleasant dining experience. The cleanliness of the restaurant and the fresh, tasty food further contribute to the positive atmosphere at Cicis Pizza.
DePalma’s Italian Cafe – Eastside
9/10 (565 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 706-369-0085
Cozy atmosphereDelicious pastaFriendly staff
DePalma’s Italian Cafe – Eastside is a beloved Athens staple, known for its delicious pasta dishes and cozy atmosphere. The Pasta DePalma is a fan favorite, although some may find it a bit lacking in flavor. The garlic bread and stuffed mushrooms are absolute standouts, while the service provided by the friendly staff helps create a welcoming dining experience. While there may be some minor hiccups with time management and the occasional overcooked noodles, the overall consensus is that DePalma’s is a must-visit for Italian food lovers in the area.
Fully Loaded Pizza Co.
8.6/10 (451 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 706-705-6150
Diverse menuEnthusiastic staffFlavorful pizza
Nestled in Watkinsville, Georgia, Fully Loaded Pizza Co. is a charming eatery boasting a diverse menu beyond just wings and pizza. The meatballs paired with ravioli and garlic bread offer a comforting and filling option for diners looking for a hearty meal. The wings, though piping hot, are perfect for a quick and delicious snack. While some customers have expressed issues with delivery services and leftover pizza slices, the overall experience seems to be saved by the enthusiastic and attentive staff. For those craving a diverse and flavorful pizza option, Fully Loaded Pizza Co. promises a satisfying dining experience that won’t disappoint.
DePalma’s Italian Cafe – Westside
8.6/10 (742 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 706-552-1237
Veal specialMashed potatoesCozy atmosphere
DePalma’s Italian Cafe – Westside is a reliable spot for a solid Italian meal. The veal special stands out as a top-notch choice, with perfectly reheated leftovers. The mashed potatoes are a must-try, flavorful and satisfying. The service may be a bit slow, but the attentive and friendly staff make up for any delays. The cozy atmosphere adds to the overall dining experience, making it a great option for a nice Italian meal.
Osteria Athena
9/10 (171 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 706-353-3911
Unique Jazz Club AestheticPassionate and Generous DishesExcellent Staff Recommendations
Osteria Athena is a true gem in the heart of Athens. The atmosphere exudes a charming jazz club aesthetic, transporting diners to a cozy vintage loft. The passion put into each plate of food is undeniable, with generous portions and beautifully crafted dishes that are uniquely Osteria. The attentive and engaging staff ensure a memorable dining experience, always ready with excellent recommendations. The restaurant is a perfect spot for a romantic date or a cozy evening with friends, offering delicious wine, pasta, and Aperol Spritz that will keep you coming back for more. Look no further for an authentic Italian dining experience in Athens.