Whether you’re craving a classic New York-style fold or a gourmet Neapolitan masterpiece, Birmingham offers a selection of pizza spots that promise to satisfy every palate.
From crispy thin crusts adorned with local produce to hearty deep-dish wonders that ooze with molten cheese, Birmingham’s pizza scene offers something to satiate every palate. This guide curates the city’s standout pizzerias, each offering a unique slice of culinary heaven.
Post Office Pies
8.8/10 (1279 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 205-599-9900
Fresh, European-style pizzasIn-house made ingredientsCozy atmosphere
Post Office Pies is a must-visit pizza restaurant with delicious, European-style pizzas that are true gems. The pizza dough is fresh and buttery, and the variety of toppings allows you to go all out. The cozy atmosphere, attentive staff, and quick service make dining here a delightful experience. The in-house made ingredients, including the pizza dough, sauce, and meat products, are fresh and add an extra layer of quality to the food. The buttery garlic bread and cheese sticks are mouthwatering starters, and the wood-fired pizzas are a standout. This place truly offers a unique culinary experience that is worth returning for.
Tortugas Pizza
9.4/10 (692 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 205-730-9249
Authentic Chicago-styleHomemade flavorful sauceCozy, spacious ambiance
Tortugas Pizza captures the essence of Chicago-style pizza perfectly, transporting diners to the Windy City with each delicious bite. The Carne Special pizza, with its generous portions of cheese and flavorful homemade sauce, is a standout choice that will leave you craving more. The restaurant’s cozy yet spacious dining area, adorned with Chicago Cubs memorabilia, adds to the overall experience. Despite some minor hiccups such as longer wait times, Tortugas Pizza undeniably delivers on taste and ambiance.
Slice Pizza & Brew
9/10 (1426 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 205-715-9300
Thin-crust pizzasLocal craft beersLunch special
Nestled in the heart of the city, Slice Pizza & Brew stands out with its delicious thin-crust pizzas and impressive selection of local craft beers. The 14” Italian sausage and basil/oregano pizza is a fan-favorite, perfectly complemented by the Urban South Gose. The menu offers a variety of unique pizza choices, including the flavorful Soul Pie and traditional Old School options. The restaurant also caters to beer enthusiasts with an array of local brews on tap. Don’t miss the lunch special for a steal deal of a slice of pizza and a salad. Despite some occasional misses with pizza quality, Slice Pizza & Brew is a must-visit for a casual dining experience.
Pies & Pints – Birmingham, AL
8.8/10 (1510 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 205-716-1085
Flavorful pizzasExtensive beer selectionCozy atmosphere
Nestled in Birmingham, AL, Pies & Pints sets itself apart with a stellar pizza lineup and an extensive beer selection that won’t disappoint. Diners rave about the hand-tossed, brick oven-fired pies that are cooked to perfection. With unique options and quality ingredients, choosing just one pie can be a challenge. The cozy environment and friendly patrons create a welcoming atmosphere, making it the perfect spot to enjoy a delicious meal with family and friends. The standout feature of this eatery is undoubtedly the flavorful pizzas and diverse beer offerings that cater to every taste preference. While service may be lacking at times, the exceptional food and drink options make Pies & Pints a must-visit for any pizza enthusiast.
Sanpeggio’s Pizza
9.2/10 (171 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 205-623-2777
Fresh ingredientsGenerous portionsWide variety
Sanpeggio’s Pizza truly shines with their fresh and delicious offerings, like the super duper supreme pizza, buffalo wings, and Greek salad. The portions are generous, ensuring you get your money’s worth. While their Spinach & Bacon Alfredo pizza is a standout, it’s important to note that this spot is more suited for a quick lunch or takeout option. Despite minor hiccups like mix-ups with online orders or inconsistent pricing between delivery apps, the overall quality of the food remains consistently excellent. With a wide variety of pizzas and other menu items, Sanpeggio’s Pizza is a solid choice for a satisfying meal.
Capella Pizzeria
9.8/10 (376 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 205-438-6108
Authentic wood-fired pizzaHigh-quality ingredientsFriendly owners
Capella Pizzeria certainly knows how to captivate pizza lovers with their authentic Italian wood-fired brick oven creations. From the perfectly crispy crust achieved through their wood-burning oven to the freshly made dough, every slice is a celebration of quality ingredients and traditional Italian flavors. The Siena pizza with San Marzano tomato sauce and the delicious pepperoni are standout items that truly showcase the high quality of their offerings. This pizzeria is a gem filled with friendly owners, great service, and an inviting atmosphere that will transport you straight to Italy with every bite.
The Filling Station Bham
8.8/10 (1407 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 205-592-3455
Great serviceDiverse menuCozy atmosphere
The Filling Station Bham is a bustling restaurant located in Birmingham, offering a variety of dishes from pizza and wings to sandwiches and salads. The standout aspect of this spot seems to be the service, as multiple reviewers have praised the attentive and friendly servers, making sure customers feel welcomed and well taken care of during their visit. Another highlight is the diverse menu options, with burgers, Stromboli, calzones, and more to choose from, ensuring there is something for everyone. The cozy atmosphere, complete with multiple TVs for watching games, and the dog-friendly patio with special offers further add to the appeal of The Filling Station Bham.
Davenport’s Pizza Palace – Mtn Brook
9/10 (1187 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 205-879-8603
Premium cheeseDelicious crustCharming atmosphere
Davenport’s Pizza Palace in Mountain Brook has been serving up delicious pizza for over 60 years, and it’s clear why they have such staying power. The pizza is top-notch, with premium cheese, fresh toppings, and a seriously delicious crust that stands out as a highlight. The atmosphere is charming, with arcade games to entertain while you wait for your food. The staff is friendly and the service is quick, making for a delightful dining experience. If you’re a pizza lover looking for a classic, no-frills slice, Davenport’s is the place to be.
Salvatore’s Pizza & Pasta
8.6/10 (440 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 205-991-2881
Authentic NY pizzaHuge portionsFriendly and helpful staff
Salvatore’s Pizza & Pasta offers a taste of New York right in Birmingham, with a flavorful and texturally satisfying crust that holds up without flopping over. The menu boasts huge portions packed with ingredients, like the veggie calzone that’s well worth the price. The staff here goes above and beyond to provide a great experience, evidenced by the manager Joel’s helpfulness and the friendly atmosphere they cultivate. Whether you’re in for a slice of pizza, a plate of pasta, or a creamy cheesecake, Salvatore’s Pizza & Pasta is sure to hit the spot.
Mellow Mushroom Birmingham
8.6/10 (1257 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 205-212-9420
Delicious pizzasWelcoming atmosphereGenerous portions
Mellow Mushroom Birmingham stands out for its delicious food offerings, with options like the Mighty Meaty and Great White pizzas that leave customers satisfied and with leftovers to spare. The pretzels are a hit, especially when paired with the flavorful beer cheese and marinara sauce. The atmosphere is welcoming, located conveniently near UAB campus and perfect for gatherings with family and friends. The only area that could use improvement is the service, as some customers have noted inconsistencies. However, the overall experience at Mellow Mushroom is well worth a visit.
Bettola
8.8/10 (648 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 205-731-6499
House-made pastaFresh ingredientsCharming patio
Nestled in Birmingham, Bettola offers a transcendent dining experience. The house-made pasta steals the show, with perfectly cooked Carbonara that leaves a lasting impression. The fresh ingredients shine through in every dish, from the flavorful sauces to the chewy pizza crust. The atmosphere is elegant yet inviting, with a charming patio perfect for enjoying a meal al fresco. Service is top-notch, and the attention to detail truly sets Bettola apart as a culinary gem in the city.
Giuseppe’s Cafe
9.2/10 (1212 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 205-324-2626
Flavorful penneCozy ambianceFriendly staff
Giuseppe’s Cafe is a hidden gem in Birmingham, offering delicious Italian cuisine without the hefty price tag. The cozy ambiance with warm lighting and ample outdoor seating creates the perfect setting for a memorable dining experience. The chicken and prosciutto penne is a standout dish, indulgent and flavorful, while the house chardonnay complements it perfectly. The portion sizes are generous, and the staff is attentive and friendly, adding to the overall enjoyable meal. The bread served with the pasta is surprisingly fresh and tasty, and the tiramisu is light and delicious, making Giuseppe’s Cafe a must-visit spot for Italian food lovers.
2 Dough Girlz
9.2/10 (66 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 205-201-6248
Fresh, flavorful pizzaHot honey wingsWarm cinnamon breadsticks
2 Dough Girlz in Woodland serves up delicious, fresh pizza with a unique twist. The 10” 2 Dough Girlz (And A Cadillac) pizza is a must-try, with a perfect combination of crispy, chewy crust, flavorful tomato sauce, bubbly cheese, and a hearty mix of meats. The hot honey wings are a hit, marinated and seasoned to perfection, and the Get Your Roll On cinnamon sugar breadsticks are warm, soft, and not overly sweet. Don’t forget to wash it all down with a classic Coca-Cola in a glass bottle – a perfect meal for any day of the week.
Sanpeggio’s Pizza
8.6/10 (64 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 205-709-8585
Quick serviceClean establishmentFresh salad
Sanpeggio’s Pizza offers a hit-or-miss experience based on recent customer reviews. While some praised the quick service, delicious salad, and clean establishment, others criticized the soggy crust, undercooked pizza, and lack of flavor in certain dishes. The inconsistency in food quality and customer service seems to be a recurring theme, with some diners vowing to never return while others are willing to give it another chance. Overall, it seems that Sanpeggio’s has potential to improve, but for now, it may be best to temper expectations.
Trattoria Zaza
9.4/10 (704 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 205-202-6207
Unique crustDaily specialsLiving wages
Trattoria Zaza serves up a one-of-a-kind pizza experience with their unique crust that is both soft and crunchy. Offering daily specials that are worth making a special trip for, this restaurant truly stands out. It’s also worth noting that they pay their staff living wages, eliminating the need for tips.
Lavagna
9/10 (388 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 212-979-1005
Generous portionsLovely serviceCozy atmosphere
Lavagna, a quaint Italian spot in the East Village, offers a bustling energy and great atmosphere. While the food portions are generous, the dishes like the rigatoni and ravioli are just okay. The service staff is lovely, and the restaurant has a decent wine selection. Overall, Lavagna is a cute spot for a dinner with friends or family.
Pizzeria G.M.
9/10 (830 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 205-905-3266
Fresh and flavorful foodUnique outdoor seatingAttentive staff
Pizzeria G.M. offers a wide variety of fresh and flavorful food options, from appetizers like prosciutto mozzarella and meatballs to main dishes like jambalaya pasta and lamb ribs. The outdoor seating is a unique and pleasant feature, providing a cool and semi-private dining experience. While service may have been a bit slow for some customers, the overall dining experience is complemented by the attentive staff and delicious food choices available.
Dave’s Pizza
8.8/10 (648 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 205-871-3283
Lively atmosphereSweet and accommodating staffUnique pizzas
Dave’s Pizza is a lively spot with a sweet and accommodating staff and a great open-air dining area. The thin crust kids pizza was a hit with our little one, and the cheesy garlic bread was delightful. The marinara sauce and cold drinks added a nice touch to our dining experience. While some may find the prices a bit high, the unique pizzas and friendly service make it a worthwhile visit.
Pizza Hut
9.2/10 (58 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 205-778-1905
Consistently baked pizzasFriendly and organized staffFresh ingredients
Pizza Hut on Valleydale Road in Birmingham stands out as a shining beacon among the chain’s locations. Customers flock to this particular spot for its consistently baked pizzas, friendly service, and overall pleasant experience. Unlike other locations where the crust may be pale and toppings slide off, the pizzas at Valleydale come out just right every time. The staff here are not only organized, but they go above and beyond to ensure orders are correct and customers are satisfied. With fresh ingredients and a well-baked crust, this Pizza Hut has earned its reputation as the best in the area.
Lé Fresca
9.6/10 (410 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 205-593-4241
Attentive serviceDiverse drink menuFresh, curated dishes