Whether you’re craving a classic New York-style fold or a gourmet Neapolitan masterpiece, Broken Arrow offers a selection of pizza spots that promise to satisfy every palate.
From crispy thin crusts adorned with local produce to hearty deep-dish wonders that ooze with molten cheese, Broken Arrow’s pizza scene offers something to satiate every palate. This guide curates the city’s standout pizzerias, each offering a unique slice of culinary heaven.
Andolini’s Pizzeria Broken Arrow
9/10 (2091 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 918-940-2770
Delicious pizzaAttentive serviceWarm, inviting atmosphere
Andolini’s Pizzeria Broken Arrow truly offers an exceptional dining experience. From the warm welcome upon arrival to the attentive service provided by the staff, the atmosphere is inviting and enjoyable. The garlic knots, dripping in olive oil and Parmesan cheese, are a must-try appetizer that sets the stage for delicious pizza. The menu boasts a variety of options, including the Demarco and Americano Neopolitan pizzas, both of which are highly recommended. The restaurant’s dedication to fresh, quality ingredients shines through in every bite, making it a standout pizzeria in the area.
Jimmy’s New York Pizzeria Broken Arrow
8.8/10 (249 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 918-252-0333
Quality serviceDelicious pizzaClean environment
Jimmy’s New York Pizzeria in Broken Arrow has earned quite the reputation for its New York-style pizza, and it’s easy to see why. The staff is friendly, the restaurant is clean, and the pizza is undeniably delicious. What sets Jimmy’s apart is their dedication to quality – when a mistake was made with a pizza order, they didn’t hesitate to make it right by replacing it without even being asked. The spacious and clean restaurant makes for a pleasant dining experience, and the service is consistently top-notch. Whether you’re a fan of classic pepperoni or looking to try something more adventurous like the Bronx Chicken Alfredo, Jimmy’s has a pizza for everyone. While some may find the prices slightly on the higher side, the quality and flavor of the pizzas make it worth every penny.
Old World Pizza
9.4/10 (186 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 539-367-2563
Genuine customer serviceDelicious cheese breadHidden gem location
Old World Pizza is a hidden gem located in the northwest section of a mini-mall. The service is top-notch with genuine smiles and sincere customer service. Customers appreciate the owner/manager’s personal touch, ensuring orders are accurate and expressing gratitude for their business. The quality of the pizza and cheese bread surpasses that of tired old chain restaurants, making it a must-try spot. The atmosphere is inviting, and the cheese bread is a standout menu item, leaving diners eager to come back for more.
Hideaway Pizza
9/10 (2227 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 918-286-1777
Unique pizzasCozy atmosphereExcellent food quality
Hideaway Pizza stands out for its delicious food and cozy atmosphere, with unique pizzas like the Sicilian and the Pepperoni Palooza being crowd favorites. The menu offers a variety of options, including cheesy stuffed mushrooms and a chicken sandwich, all served fresh and hot. The crust is a standout feature, perfectly cooked and flavorful. While some customers have mentioned issues with service, interactions with staff like bartender and manager Danny have exceeded expectations. The restaurant’s dedication to customer satisfaction, along with tasty food offerings, make it a dining destination worth visiting.
Uncle Vinny’s NY Pizzeria
9.4/10 (828 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 918-251-6666
Chewy crustDelicious garlic knotsFresh ingredients
Uncle Vinny’s NY Pizzeria is a local gem that has been delighting patrons for almost two decades. The pizza here is top-notch, with a chewy and toasty crust that keeps customers coming back for more. The menu is filled with delicious options, from the fan-favorite pepperoni/mushroom/fresh mozzarella combo to the amazing garlic knots. The hot oil is a must-try for those who enjoy a little kick to their meal. The salads are fresh and loaded with goodies, while the cheesecake selection is a sweet ending to a satisfying meal. The pay it forward board adds a heartwarming touch to the dining experience, making Uncle Vinny’s a place worth returning to time and time again.
Franco’s Pizza & Trattoria
8.8/10 (482 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 918-258-6464
Authentic Chicago pizzaHomemade pastaCozy family atmosphere
Franco’s Pizza & Trattoria is a true gem in the heart of Broken Arrow, offering authentic Chicago-style deep dish pizza that will transport you straight to the Windy City. The homemade sauce, flaky crust, and generous cheese toppings make every bite an unforgettable experience. The cozy atmosphere and welcoming service will make you feel like part of the family from the moment you walk in. Whether you’re indulging in a classic pizza, savoring homemade pasta, or treating yourself to a decadent cannoli, every dish at Franco’s is made with love and care. Don’t miss out on this hidden culinary treasure in Oklahoma.
Marco’s Pizza
8.6/10 (444 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 918-615-3500
Fluffy CrustDelicious WingsFriendly Service
Marco’s Pizza offers an excellent dining experience that sets it apart from the average pizza joint. The pizza, specifically the pepperoni, is a standout item. The pizza has a light and fluffy crust that will convert even non-crust eaters. The wings are also a must-try, well-cooked and slathered in delicious sauces. The service at Marco’s Pizza is top-notch, with friendly and interactive staff members such as John, the general manager, leading the way. Prices are budget-friendly, making Marco’s a fantastic option for a casual, delicious meal.
Cheri Ann’s Trattoria
9.4/10 (381 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 918-251-0221
Traditional Italian musicRavioli with perfect sauceExcellent service
Nestled in a quiet space, Cheri Ann’s Trattoria offers a relaxing atmosphere with traditional Italian music setting the mood. The ravioli, with a perfect sauce, is a standout dish, and the cannolis are a sweet treat not to be missed. The service is excellent, with knowledgeable staff ready to provide personalized recommendations based on your preferences. The rosemary chicken and garlic mashed potatoes are outstanding, while their cheesecake is a must-try. The family-owned vibe adds to the charm of this cozy spot, making it a worthwhile dining experience that leaves you looking forward to your next visit.
The Rooftop
8.6/10 (1050 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 918-806-2603
AtmosphereDrinksExceptional service
The Rooftop offers a great atmosphere and delicious drinks with exceptional service that makes you want to come back. The staff, especially Jesse in the bar area, was professional and welcoming, creating a great experience. The food was quick and the prices were fair, with good-sized dishes like pretzels with cheese/mustard, cheese pizza, and sandwiches. The food presentation was excellent, making it a good place to return to for a pleasant dining experience.
Savastano’s
9/10 (2903 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 918-369-9387
Deep dish perfectionMultilevel diningFriendly service
Nestled in a three-level building, Savastano’s offers a unique dining experience that caters to all ages and tastes. The first floor transforms into an adult bar with pool tables, while the second and third floors are dedicated to the restaurant, complete with patio seating for those seeking to dine al fresco. The deep dish pizza is the star of the show, living up to its reputation and leaving diners satisfied and eager to return for more.
Tulsa’s Incredible Pizza Company
8.8/10 (6275 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 918-294-8671
Variety of activitiesGluten-free pizzaPackage deal value
Located in Tulsa, Incredible Pizza Company offers a wide range of activities to keep both kids and adults entertained for hours. The buffet offers a variety of kid-friendly options, including pizza and desserts that are sure to satisfy any sweet tooth. While the food may not be gourmet, the gluten-free thin crust pizza stands out as a surprisingly tasty option. The $37.99 package deal provides great value, with buffet access, ride passes, and a game card to keep everyone busy. The arcade games, while a bit pricey, offer a mix of nostalgia and new options that both kids and adults can enjoy. The trampoline area adds an extra element of fun for the whole family. The overall experience at Incredible Pizza Company is one that promises a day filled with entertainment and excitement.
Casey’s
8.8/10 (416 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 918-553-7605
Best pizzaAmazing coffeeExceptional customer service
Casey’s offers the best pizza, especially in the morning. The freshly ground coffee is amazing, and the staff provides top-notch customer service. The clean environment and small-town charm create a welcoming atmosphere that keeps customers coming back. Additionally, great prices on gas make Casey’s a convenient stop for all your needs. The friendly and helpful employees truly make this location stand out.