Whether you’re craving a classic New York-style fold or a gourmet Neapolitan masterpiece, Buffalo offers a selection of pizza spots that promise to satisfy every palate.
From crispy thin crusts adorned with local produce to hearty deep-dish wonders that ooze with molten cheese, Buffalo’s pizza scene offers something to satiate every palate. This guide curates the city’s standout pizzerias, each offering a unique slice of culinary heaven.
Uncle Sam’s Pizza
9.8/10 (1097 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 646-876-1111
Crispy crustFlavorful sauceAuthentic New York ambiance
Uncle Sam’s Pizza is a must-visit spot for pizza lovers in NYC. The slices are truly exceptional, with crispy crusts, flavorful sauce, and a generous amount of cheese and toppings. The menu offers something for everyone, whether you’re in the mood for a classic slice or a unique specialty option. The authentic New York ambiance and friendly service only add to the overall dining experience. Pay a visit to Uncle Sam’s Pizza for a taste of delicious pizzas made with love and care.
Rubirosa
9.2/10 (4495 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 212-965-0500
Thin crustHalf-and-half optionFlavorful toppings
Rubirosa in SoHo is a must-visit for pizza enthusiasts. The thin and crispy crust is a standout feature, perfectly complementing the flavorful toppings. The half-and-half option is a great way to sample different flavors, with the Hot Honey and Tie Die pizzas receiving rave reviews. The arugula salad is a delightful side dish that pairs well with the pizzas, making for a truly satisfying meal.
Tappo NYC Thin Crust Pizza
9/10 (1102 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 212-807-9200
Authentic thin crustFresh, quality ingredientsExcellent service
Tappo NYC Thin Crust Pizza prides itself on serving up authentic New York-style thin crust pizza, leaving deep-dish Chicago pies in the dust. The focus here is on the simplicity and quality of the ingredients – fresh mozzarella meets savory toppings, making for a delicious and satisfying experience. The ambiance of the restaurant is a nod to Art Deco style, adding to the overall charm and appeal of the dining experience. The service is top-notch, adding to the overall enjoyment of a visit to this establishment.
Grand Street Pizza
9.2/10 (329 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 646-918-6194
Thin crustCozy ambianceFriendly service
Nestled on Grand Street, Grand Street Pizza is a cozy hotspot serving up delicious slices in a classy atmosphere. The thin crust pizzas offer a satisfying savory cheesy bite, with standout selections like the burrata and the white slice. The ambiance is warm and inviting, perfect for a quick snack or a casual date night. With friendly service and quick turnaround, Grand Street Pizza is a must-try for all pizza lovers in NYC.
Song’ E Napule
9.4/10 (1821 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 212-533-1242
Authentic Italian flavorsCozy and chic ambianceTop-notch espresso coffee
Located in the heart of NYC, Song’ E Napule is a hidden gem that captures the essence of authentic Italian cuisine. The brick oven pizzas are a standout, with a crust that is airy, soft, and perfectly thin. The Diavola pizza, topped with fresh mozzarella, basil, and spicy salami, is a must-try. But it’s not just the pizza that shines here – the espresso coffee is on point and the pasta dishes are fresh and flavorful. The cozy atmosphere adds to the experience, making it a top choice for both locals and visitors alike.
$1.50 Fresh Pizza
9/10 (602 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 212-967-3310
AffordableDeliciousQuick service
Located in the heart of the city, $1.50 Fresh Pizza offers a quick and affordable slice that many customers find to be the best in town. The warm and delicious pizza, despite its recent price increase, continues to draw locals and visitors alike who appreciate the value and quality of the product. While the ambiance may not be the most upscale, the efficient service and the tasty slice make it a must-visit spot for a satisfying meal on the go.
Joe’s Pizza
9/10 (8592 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 212-366-1182
Authentic NY slicesPerfect crustFresh flavorful toppings
Joe’s Pizza in Manhattan is a must-visit for anyone seeking a true New York-style pizza experience. The crust is the perfect balance of crispy and chewy, providing the ideal base for the flavorful toppings that burst with freshness. The sauce-to-cheese ratio is spot on, creating a symphony of taste with every bite. While the hustle and bustle may be a bit chaotic, it only adds to the authentic atmosphere of this iconic establishment where folks eagerly line up for a slice of heaven.
Champion Pizza – Soho
9.2/10 (2222 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 212-226-3777
Crispy thin crustVariety of slicesAffordable prices
Champion Pizza – Soho offers a delicious and affordable pizza experience in New York City. With a crispy thin crust that perfectly balances the sauce, cheese, and toppings, it’s a great spot for a quick and satisfying meal. The variety of slices available goes beyond the usual options, making it a standout choice for a casual bite. The welcoming atmosphere and ample seating options cater to both solo diners and groups, making it a versatile destination for any occasion.
Rosetta Pizza
8.6/10 (786 reviews)
| Directions | +1 212-414-4800
Wide pizza varietyFriendly staffOutdoor seating
Rosetta Pizza offers a wide range of delicious pizza options, with unique combinations like the half bruschetta and half margarita gluten-free pizza. The staff is friendly, accommodating, and quick to serve customers, creating a cozy and inviting atmosphere inside. Additionally, there is outside seating available for patrons to enjoy their slices on nice days. The variety of menu items, including salads, calzones, wraps, and more, makes Rosetta Pizza a must-visit spot for a tasty meal in NYC.
Joe’s Pizza
9/10 (3316 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 212-388-9474
Hot and delicious pizzasEfficient and friendly serviceAffordable New York-style slices
Nestled in the heart of New York City, Joe’s Pizza offers a classic slice of nostalgia with their hot and delicious pizzas. With a decent amount of toppings and lots of gooey cheese, their New York-style pizzas are a steal at $4-6. The service is efficient and friendly, adding to the overall experience. While the sauce may not be the most flavorful, the sweet notes add a unique touch that sets Joe’s apart from other pizza joints. Whether you’re a tourist looking for a taste of NYC or a local craving a reliable slice, Joe’s Pizza delivers a satisfying and affordable option for pizza lovers everywhere.
2 Bros Pizza
8.6/10 (4165 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 646-916-4541
Fantastic tasteBudget-friendly pricesQuick service
2 Bros Pizza offers a pizza paradise with mind-blowing prices and fantastic taste. The pizza slices are a steal, with the perfect crispy and doughy balance, flavorful tomato sauce, and light cheese. The service is quick, and combo deals with soft drinks make it a great value. While some may find the pizza just okay, the variety of toppings and generous sizes make it a good value for the price. The casual atmosphere and budget-friendly prices make 2 Bros Pizza worth a visit whether you’re in the neighborhood or simply craving a slice.
Una Pizza Napoletana
8.6/10 (588 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 646-476-4457
Fresh ingredientsInnovative flavor combinationsIndulgent desserts
Una Pizza Napoletana offers an unparalleled dining experience for pizza enthusiasts. The restaurant’s focus on fresh ingredients shines through, with standout dishes like the Margarita and Bianca pizzas showcasing the quality of the tomatoes and dough. The Specialty Pizza, such as the Apollonia, presents innovative flavor combinations that leave a lasting impression. The attention to detail extends to the dessert menu, with the Almond Cremolata standing out as a creamy and indulgent treat. The welcoming ambiance, complete with a view of the kitchen, adds to the overall charm of this must-visit pizza destination.
Prince Street Pizza
8.8/10 (7548 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 212-966-4100
Bold flavorsCrispy crustFresh toppings
Prince Street Pizza in NYC is a hot spot for pizza lovers, offering a unique take on classic slices that keeps customers coming back for more. The flavors are bold, with options like the Spicy Vodka Pizza and the Naughty Square standing out among the crowd. The crust is crispy, the toppings are fresh, and the sauce is the real star of the show. While the line can be intimidating, the wait is worth it for a taste of the Sicilian pepperoni that elevates this pizza to a new level of deliciousness.
Famous Famiglia Pizza
8.8/10 (1335 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 212-382-3802
Fresh ingredientsTraditional techniquesUnbeatable prices
Famous Famiglia Pizza in Times Square is a must-visit for delicious pizza that won’t break the bank. From classic cheese to gourmet toppings, their pies are made with fresh ingredients and traditional techniques that will leave you craving more. With friendly service and unbeatable prices, it’s a slice of New York you won’t want to miss.
Emmett’s on Grove
8.6/10 (192 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 646-370-3858
Unique pizza flavorsGenuine serviceDelicious bleu cheese stuffed olives
Emmett’s on Grove is a little gem in the heart of New York, offering unique and flavorful pizzas that will leave you craving more. The deep dish crust is perfect, and the toppings are fresh and tasty. The customization option allows you to create your own perfect pizza. The mozzarella sticks and fries are also a hit, with just the right amount of cheese and crunch. The bleu cheese stuffed olives in the martini are not to be missed, and the service is genuine and attentive. While the ambience may be a bit loud and chaotic, the delicious food and drinks make Emmett’s a must-visit spot for pizza lovers in New York.
Sottocasa
9.2/10 (1009 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 718-852-8758
Authentic Italian pizzasCozy atmosphereFriendly service
Sottocasa is a must-visit gem in New York City. The authentic Italian pizza here is unparalleled, with a range of delicious options that will leave you craving more. The friendly service and cozy atmosphere make you feel right at home, transporting you to a trattoria in Italy. Whether you opt for the Ripieno calzone or the perfect GF pizza, every bite is a taste of perfection. The homemade tiramisu is a top-notch way to end your meal, complemented by the welcoming staff and fast service that make every visit a delightful experience.
$1.50 Fresh Pizza
9/10 (1473 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 212-661-6221
FastFreshTasty
Nestled among the bustling streets of New York City lies $1.50 Fresh Pizza, a humble spot offering delicious slices at an unbeatable price. The pizza here is fast, fresh, and quite tasty, making it a go-to spot for those seeking a quick and budget-friendly meal. The crust may be a bit spongy for some, but the flavors of the cheese and sauce truly shine through. The dough is soft and crispy, providing the perfect base for a classic NYC slice. With a variety of toppings available for just 50 cents each, you can customize your slice without breaking the bank. Cash only, but the value you get in return is absolutely worth it.
Little Italy Pizzeria and Deli
8.6/10 (1274 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 212-571-7700
Flavorful crustGarlic knotsBeer on tap
Little Italy Pizzeria and Deli is a neighborhood gem that serves up delicious pizza with toppings that stay put and a crispy, flavorful crust thanks to an extra bread crumb coating. Their garlic knots are a standout, loaded with plenty of garlic and sure to satisfy any craving. The pizzeria also offers beer on tap for those looking to enjoy a cold brew with their meal. Whether you dine in or take out, Little Italy Pizzeria and Deli is a great spot to grab a slice or a whole pie, making it a must-visit for pizza lovers in the area.
99 Cent Fresh Pizza
9/10 (4019 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 212-245-2155
Authentic pizzaAffordable pricesQuick service
Nestled in the bustling streets of New York City, 99 Cent Fresh Pizza is a shining beacon of affordable and consistent quality. For just a dollar, you can treat yourself to a slice of authentic, delicious pizza that rivals even the pricier options around. The cozy ambiance and quick service make it a perfect grab-and-go spot for a satisfying meal on a budget. Whether you’re craving a classic cheese slice or feeling adventurous with toppings, this establishment delivers on taste without breaking the bank. Don’t let the low prices fool you—99 Cent Fresh Pizza is a hidden gem worth a visit.
Numero 28 Pizzeria
9/10 (815 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 212-463-9653
Authentic Italian foodFlavorful truffle pizzaWelcoming atmosphere
Numero 28 Pizzeria is a delightful Italian spot nestled in the West Village. The welcoming atmosphere and friendly staff add to the genuine Italian vibe, making it a perfect setting for a leisurely lunch or dinner. The pizzas are the main event here, transporting you to Italy with each bite. The truffle pizza is an absolute must-try, with its thin, crispy crust and flavorful toppings. While the cash-only policy may be a setback in this digital age, the culinary experience at Numero 28 Pizzeria is undeniably worth it.