Whether you’re craving a classic New York-style fold or a gourmet Neapolitan masterpiece, Cape Coral offers a selection of pizza spots that promise to satisfy every palate.
From crispy thin crusts adorned with local produce to hearty deep-dish wonders that ooze with molten cheese, Cape Coral’s pizza scene offers something to satiate every palate. This guide curates the city’s standout pizzerias, each offering a unique slice of culinary heaven.
The Spot
9.6/10 (191 reviews)
Unique saucesFlavorful dishesRelaxing atmosphere
The Spot is truly a hidden gem, offering a menu filled with inventive and flavorful dishes. The mac & cheese bites, hot honey chicken sandwich, and Hogwarts pizza are standouts. The homemade sauces, including the raspberry sweet Thai chili, add depth to the dishes. The ambiance is relaxed and inviting, making it a perfect spot for a casual and delicious meal. The dessert offerings may need some improvement, but overall, The Spot is a must-visit for those craving hearty comfort food and great service.
Luciano’s Pizza
8.8/10 (817 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 239-360-8112
Authentic New York-style pizzaFlavorful XL pizzasTop-notch indoor dining service
Nestled in Cape Coral, Luciano’s Pizza offers a taste of authentic New York-style pizza that keeps customers coming back for more. The XL Margherita and XL BBQ chicken pizzas are flavorful and exceed expectations, while the sausage, pepperoni, and garlic pizza provides a delicious combination, despite some adjustments needed. The attention to detail is evident in the generous cheese portions and the delicious sauce and dough. The indoor dining service is top-notch, and the small loaf of bread on the house adds a thoughtful touch to the dining experience. Luciano’s commitment to quality ingredients and consistency shines through in every savory slice, making it a must-visit spot for pizza aficionados in the area.
Paradise Pizza of Cape Coral
9/10 (969 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 239-945-1555
Oven-fired pizzasGenerous portionsFriendly staff
Paradise Pizza of Cape Coral is the hidden gem that residents and visitors alike are raving about. The pizzas are cooked to perfection in their oven, with the dough/crust hitting just the right notes. The menu is expansive with competitive prices and generous portions, making it a go-to spot for those craving a delectable meal. The Chef Salad and Calzones are fan favorites due to their sizable portions and delicious flavors. The white pizza, chicken bacon ranch, and taco pizza are bursting with unique tastes that keep customers coming back for more. The friendly staff, particularly Brooke, go above and beyond to ensure each customer’s dining experience is exceptional, making Paradise Pizza a must-visit spot for all pizza enthusiasts.
Lelulo’s Pizza Life
8.6/10 (1079 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 239-205-6935
Fresh ingredientsFlavorful crustLarge buffalo wings
Lelulo’s Pizza Life offers a delicious menu that is sure to satisfy any pizza craving. The fresh ingredients really make a difference, and the flavorful crust adds the perfect touch to each slice. The variety of options, including the meat lover pizza and stromboli, ensure there’s something for everyone to enjoy. The buffalo wings are a fan favorite for their large size and bold flavor. The friendly service and inviting atmosphere make it a great spot to grab a drink at the bar while waiting for your meal. Don’t forget to check out the Pittsburgh sports decor while you’re there.
Chicago Pizza
8.6/10 (1547 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 239-945-2262
Authentic Chicago flavorsFresh Midwest ingredientsExcellent deep dish pizza execution
Chicago Pizza offers a taste of Chicago right in Florida, with ingredients sourced from the Midwest and recipes staying true to the original. The Deluxe Meat deep dish pizza is a standout, with fresh ingredients that are sure to satisfy any deep dish pizza lover. The attention to detail in the flavors shines through, making it a must-try for anyone looking for an authentic Chicago pizza experience. While some may find the thin crust lacking in sauce or the toppings not traditional, overall, Chicago Pizza delivers a delicious taste of the Windy City.
Overtime Pizzeria & Sports Pub
9/10 (2048 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 239-541-3367
Delicious Mahi sandwichOutstanding pizzaSpacious venue with many TVs
Overtime Pizzeria & Sports Pub in Cape Coral, FL, is more than just a sports bar – it’s a hidden gem with delicious food and exceptional service. The Mahi sandwich was a standout item, bursting with flavor. The pizza was outstanding, with generous portions and a perfect balance of toppings. The staff is friendly and attentive, making the overall dining experience enjoyable. The venue is spacious, perfect for watching NFL games with plenty of TVs. Whether you’re grabbing a quick lunch or hosting a special event, Overtime Pizzeria & Sports Pub is a must-visit spot in Cape Coral.
Joe Daddy’s Pizza
8.8/10 (420 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 239-573-6600
Flavorful sauceFresh ingredientsFriendly staff
If you find yourself craving a slice of the Big Apple in SWFL, look no further than Joe Daddy’s Pizza. Customers rave about the flavorful sauce and cheese, the well-balanced crunch and cheese ratio, and the fresh ingredients. Some even claim it to be the best NY Style pizza in the Cape Coral and Fort Myers area. With an inviting ambiance and friendly staff, Joe Daddy’s promises a pleasant dining experience for pizza enthusiasts. Though some customers have expressed concerns about inconsistent topping distribution and past saltiness, the overall consensus remains overwhelmingly positive.
Cicis Pizza
8.6/10 (1772 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 239-573-7225
Affordable pricingFriendly and attentive staffWide variety of pizza options
Cicis Pizza is a hidden gem that offers a family-friendly atmosphere with a variety of delicious pizza options. The buffet and ordering options make it a great deal, especially if you have a craving for unique pizzas like the Mac and Cheese or Meat Eater. The new Oreo dessert pizza is a must-try, adding a sweet touch to your meal. The staff is friendly and attentive, always willing to accommodate special requests and ensure a satisfying dining experience. While the atmosphere could use a little sprucing up, it doesn’t impact the quality of the food, which is consistently well-prepared and tasty.
Gino’s Pizza
8.8/10 (153 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 239-673-9309
Homey flavorsCrispy crustFriendly owners
Gino’s Pizza in Cape Coral truly brings the taste of home to its customers with its flavorful pies that are a cut above the rest. The crust is perfectly crispy, the sauce strikes the ideal balance, and the toppings are generous without overwhelming the pizza. The owners, Brad and his wife, add a personal touch to the experience, making you feel like a valued guest. The aroma of fresh pizza greets you as soon as you walk in, setting the stage for a memorable dining experience that will have you coming back for more.
Leone’s Italian Market & Pizzeria
9.6/10 (579 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 239-458-0013
Hand-stretched doughGenerous portionsScratch-made food
Leone’s Italian Market & Pizzeria offers a unique dining experience that may appear chaotic at first, with no menus and people milling about, but once you immerse yourself in the atmosphere, you’ll find a warm and friendly environment where the staff treat you like old friends. The food speaks for itself, with generous portions and top-notch quality. The hand-stretched dough going into the oven is a sight to behold, and the pizzas, Stromboli, Italian beef, and more are made with care and attention to detail, reminiscent of homemade napolitan dishes. It’s a hidden gem in the Cape Coral area that shouldn’t be missed.
Grado’s Pizza
9.4/10 (115 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 239-900-3003
Flavorful Bronx pizzaThin, crisp crustPennsylvania-style sauce
Grado’s Pizza has quickly gained a reputation for serving up some of the best pizza in town. Customers rave about the flavorful Bronx pizza, packed with fresh and delicious ingredients. The thin, crisp crust holds up perfectly, allowing you to savor every bite. The sauce, with its Pennsylvania style twist, adds an extra layer of deliciousness to each slice. This is truly a hidden gem worth trying.
Jet’s Pizza
8.6/10 (563 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 239-257-3270
Detroit-style pizzaTurbo sticksDirect ordering
Jet’s Pizza delivers a pizza experience that stands out in a sea of options. The Detroit-style pizza is a standout, with a crust that strikes the right balance of crispy and airy. The Turbo sticks and double cheese four corner option are crowd-pleasers, providing a satisfying and delicious meal. The attention to detail in the cooking process ensures that the pizza is always done just the way you like it, with generous portions of toppings. While the dine-in experience may not be anything to write home about, the clean tables and floors create a pleasant atmosphere for enjoying your meal. Ordering directly from the restaurant is recommended for the best value and service, ensuring a seamless experience from beginning to end. With options like the Detroit-style pizza, Jet’s Pizza offers a unique and tasty option that will leave you satisfied and coming back for more.
Two Meatballs in the Kitchen – Cape Coral
9/10 (1827 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 239-347-3013
Vibrant atmosphereFlavorful Italian dishesGenerous portions
Located in Cape Coral, Two Meatballs in the Kitchen offers a unique dining experience that combines classic Italian dishes with a vibrant atmosphere. The restaurant’s diverse menu features a variety of options, from traditional pasta dishes to flavorful pizzas and hearty dinners. Diners can enjoy generous portions of delicious food, such as the fettuccine with peas, chicken, and mushrooms. The ambiance blends elegance and rustic charm, creating a warm and inviting space for guests to savor each bite. Whether you opt for the meatball appetizer or Gina’s chicken, the flavors truly celebrate Italian cuisine. While the downstairs area may be loud, the Venice room upstairs provides a more intimate setting with excellent acoustics. The attentive staff, delicious food, and lively atmosphere make Two Meatballs in the Kitchen a must-visit spot in Cape Coral.
Dairon’s Cuban Pizzeria
9.2/10 (183 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 239-471-7280
Crispy cheese edgesFlavorful Cuban pizzaDiverse drink selection
In the heart of Cape Coral, Dairon’s Cuban Pizzeria stands out as a must-visit culinary destination for those seeking a unique and flavorful pizza experience. The crispy cheese on the edges of their Cuban pizza sets it apart, creating a delightful texture that perfectly complements the light crust. The stretchy and melty cheese, combined with just the right amount of sauce, showcases the attention to detail and commitment to quality that defines Dairon’s Cuban Pizzeria. With a diverse drink selection and mouthwatering ice cream sandwiches, this spot offers a complete dining experience worth savoring.
IL Primo Pizza & Wings
9/10 (777 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 239-573-3435
Family-friendly atmosphereQuick serviceDelicious food
IL Primo Pizza & Wings offers an exceptional dining experience with a family-friendly atmosphere, quick service, and delicious food. The restaurant features unique amenities such as a self-service fountain machine for drinks, granite tables, and a designated area for kids to watch movies while dining. The manager, Pedro, is known for his excellent customer service, ensuring that all guests feel welcomed and well taken care of. The menu offers a variety of pizza and wing options, with the buffalo chicken pizza and wing sauce standing out as customer favorites. The restaurant also provides a full bar with beer and wine options, making it a great spot to enjoy a meal with family or friends. IL Primo Pizza & Wings is a must-visit for those looking for a memorable dining experience in Cape Coral, Florida.
Pi Theory Pizza
9.2/10 (60 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 239-257-1715
Diverse menuFlavorful pizzasWelcoming atmosphere
Pi Theory Pizza offers a diverse menu of delicious pizzas that will satisfy any craving. From classics like pepperoni mushroom and sausage to unique options like BBQ chicken and Hawaiian, there is something for everyone. The crispy, flavorful pizzas are clearly made with care and attention to detail, making each bite a true delight. The dining experience is equally impressive, with friendly and welcoming staff that create a relaxed atmosphere reminiscent of quaint cities up north. Pi Theory Pizza is a hidden gem that deserves to be visited again and again.
Domino’s Pizza
8.6/10 (465 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 239-772-5060
Efficient deliveryExcellent customer serviceQuality pizzas
Domino’s Pizza has proven to be a reliable option for customers looking for a quick and easy meal. With efficient delivery service and eager staff like Ali, who goes above and beyond to ensure customers are satisfied, it’s clear that this location takes pride in their work. The convenience of ordering through the app and the quality of the pizzas make for a pleasant experience. The team’s dedication to customer service, even in challenging weather conditions, is commendable and sets them apart from other locations.
Domino’s Pizza
8.6/10 (281 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 239-549-5500
Delicious pizzaTimely deliveryConsistent quality
Domino’s Pizza on Del Prado South in Cape Coral is a hit with customers for its consistently delicious pizza and timely delivery service. Customers rave about the perfectly cooked pizza with just the right amount of toppings and sauce, making it an ideal choice for a quick and satisfying meal. Although some have experienced issues with the quality of their orders recently, the majority of customers agree that Domino’s Pizza remains a top choice for a reliable and tasty pizza option.
Domino’s Pizza
8.6/10 (476 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 239-945-0040
Quick deliveryUser-friendly appCoupons and rewards
Dominos Pizza is a popular choice for many, offering fresh and hot pizzas with quick delivery. The app is user-friendly, providing easy access to deals and rewards. While some may have experienced issues with pizza quality, many appreciate the courteous staff and fast service Domino’s provides. The coupons and rewards program are a hit among customers, ensuring savings and customization options for a personalized pizza experience.
Nice Guys Pizza, Beer, and Cocktails
9.2/10 (2066 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 239-549-7542
Unique pizzasEclectic decorExcellent service
Nice Guys Pizza, Beer, and Cocktails offers a unique and inviting atmosphere that draws you in with its eclectic decor and friendly service. The diverse selection of pizzas, from Hot Honey to Chicken and Waffles, are must-tries, while the garlic knots and euro trash donuts are perfect for sharing. The bar serves top-notch cocktails, like the Golden Girls, and the service is always attentive. Whether you’re a regular looking for a new favorite spot or a first-time visitor ready to be impressed, Nice Guys is the place to be for excellent food and a great vibe.