Whether you’re craving a classic New York-style fold or a gourmet Neapolitan masterpiece, Cary offers a selection of pizza spots that promise to satisfy every palate.
From crispy thin crusts adorned with local produce to hearty deep-dish wonders that ooze with molten cheese, Cary’s pizza scene offers something to satiate every palate. This guide curates the city’s standout pizzerias, each offering a unique slice of culinary heaven.
Rigo’s Pizzeria
9.4/10 (894 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 919-319-3232
Amazing pizzaOutstanding serviceImproved hours
Rigo’s Pizzeria has quickly become a favorite among locals with its delicious and amazing pizza offerings. The Sicilian pies are a standout, and the grandma’s pizza is a must-try with its perfectly baked crust and flavorful taste. The menu boasts more than just pizza, with meatballs and Chicken Parmesan dishes that are described as out of this world. The new management has also won over customers with their improved hours, including being open on Sundays, making it a top spot for those craving the best pizza and Italian food in the area. The service is outstanding, and the overall experience at Rigo’s Pizzeria keeps customers coming back time and time again.
V Pizza – Cary
8.8/10 (786 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 919-650-1821
Flavorful ingredientsExcellent serviceInviting atmosphere
V Pizza – Cary offers a clean and spacious setting with very friendly staff. The Classic Margherita pizza stood out with its high-quality pasta sauce, while the Habanero Chicken Wings provided a tasty kick. Despite some dryness in the wings, the overall food quality impressed customers. The value seemed fair, with $45 covering a pizza, wings, and an appetizer. The praise for V Pizza’s flavorful and authentic ingredients, excellent service, and inviting atmosphere is consistent throughout the reviews, making it a must-visit spot for Italian food enthusiasts.
Salvio’s Pizzeria
9.2/10 (774 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 919-467-4600
Crispy cheese pizzaFair pricingExcellent service
Salvio’s Pizzeria stands out for its very crispy, well-balanced cheese pizza, although some feel the crust lacks flavor. The pricing is fair, with a lunch special that includes two huge slices of cheese pizza and a soda at a great value. The friendly service and New York-style pizza make it a top choice for many. The pizza is made well with good ratios of cheese and sauce, earning it a place as a go-to option for takeout or parties. Salvio’s has a welcoming staff and a welcoming vibe, making it a standout in the area.
Johnny’s Pizza (Cary)
8.8/10 (1021 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 919-460-5566
Flavorful PizzasInviting AtmosphereExceptional Service
Johnny’s Pizza in Cary stands out for its inviting atmosphere, with modern decor and plenty of seating options. The real highlight is the food, bursting with flavor and cooked to perfection. The crispy crust of the pizza, generous toppings, and impressive appetizers and salads make for a delightful dining experience. What truly sets Johnny’s Pizza apart is the exceptional customer service provided by the friendly and knowledgeable staff. For anyone seeking delicious food, great service, and a welcoming environment, Johnny’s Pizza is a must-visit gem in the local dining scene. Give it a try and you won’t be disappointed.
Ruckus Pizza, Pasta and Spirits
8.6/10 (1374 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 919-851-3999
Welcoming atmosphereAttentive staffDelicious Philly sandwiches
Nestled in the heart of town, Ruckus Pizza, Pasta and Spirits is a local favorite that never fails to impress. With a warm and welcoming atmosphere, patrons rave about the attentive staff, particularly manager Cindy, who goes above and beyond to ensure a pleasant dining experience. The menu boasts a variety of delectable options, from perfectly seasoned fries to mouth-watering Philly sandwiches. Outdoor seating adds to the charm, perfect for enjoying a meal al fresco. Despite occasional mishaps with takeout orders, the overall consensus is that the food is top-notch and the prices are reasonable.
The Original NY Pizza
8.8/10 (389 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 919-677-8484
Authentic NY pizzaExtra cheeseFriendly staff
The Original NY Pizza stands out with its authentic NY style thin crust pizza that doesn’t skimp on toppings. The extra cheese is a crowd pleaser, and the value for the quality of food is excellent. While some menu items might not hit the mark, the XL cheese pie is a fan favorite. The staff is friendly and efficient, adding to the pleasant dining experience, making it a go-to spot for those craving a taste of New York in North Carolina.
Brothers Of New York Pizza
9/10 (416 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 919-629-6000
Welcoming atmosphereTasty NY-style pizzaThoughtful service
Brothers Of New York Pizza immediately stands out for its welcoming atmosphere and attentive staff. The eggplant Parmigiana sub, while tasty, could benefit from a bolder flavor. The pizza, especially the Supreme version, is a hit with both kids and adults alike, making it a must-visit spot. The restaurant’s NY-style Margherita pizza impresses, with a thin, crispy crust and perfect balance of flavors. The cheesesteak, though not quite authentic, still delights with its mix of veggies and gooey cheese. The service goes above and beyond, with thoughtful gestures like surprise popsicles for kids. Fast service and friendly staff round out the experience, making Brothers Of New York Pizza a top choice for pizza lovers looking for a taste of New York.
Jet’s Pizza
9.4/10 (71 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 919-230-0083
Delicious Detroit-stylePerfectly crispy crustFriendly staff
Jet’s Pizza in Cary offers a taste of home for many, serving up delicious Detroit-style deep dish pizzas that has won over many customers. The crust is what truly sets this place apart, perfectly crispy on the bottom and sides, with hearty toppings like pepperoni and mushrooms. The atmosphere inside the restaurant is just as inviting, with friendly staff and a welcoming vibe that adds to the overall experience.
The Original NY Pizza
8.6/10 (375 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 919-852-2242
Authentic NY pizzaFriendly staffQuality ingredients
The Original NY Pizza in Cary has been a local favorite for decades, offering up authentic New York-style pizza that transports you back to the streets of the Big Apple. The pizza here is paper-thin with a generous amount of cheese, making each bite a delight. The selection of toppings is varied, and the ingredients used are top-notch, resulting in a truly satisfying pie. The service might have its occasional hiccups, but the friendly staff and the welcoming atmosphere more than make up for it. This is not just another gimmicky NY pizza joint – it’s the real deal, and it’s worth a visit to experience a slice of New York right here in Cary.
Mellow Mushroom Cary
8.6/10 (1935 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 919-463-7779
Whole grain crustTasty mushroom soupAttentive service
Mellow Mushroom Cary is a pizza restaurant with a wide variety of delicious pizzas to choose from, including the whole grain crust option that adds a unique twist to your meal. The mushroom soup also stands out as a tasty option on the menu. The attentive and friendly service is worth noting, with servers like Skyler and Adrienne going above and beyond to ensure a pleasant dining experience. The speedy food delivery during busy times and the consistent quality of the pizzas showcase the restaurant’s commitment to customer satisfaction. The only downside seems to be occasional delays in service, but overall, Mellow Mushroom Cary provides a great dining experience for pizza lovers in the area.
Brixx Wood Fired Pizza + Craft Bar
8.6/10 (783 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 919-674-4388
Crispy crustFlavorful sauceLate night hours
Brixx Wood Fired Pizza + Craft Bar offers a delightful dining experience with its unique offerings. The crust of the pizzas is crispy, the sauce is garlicky, and the pepperoni is flavorful. The atmosphere is clean and cozy, making it a great spot to enjoy a meal with family and friends. The fact that Brixx stays open until 11pm on weekdays is a major bonus in an area with limited dining options during late hours. The variety of pizzas, including buffalo chicken and spicy shrimp, are delicious, though some customers wish for larger portions of the toppings. Overall, Brixx is a fantastic choice for a casual meal with quality food.
Tazza Kitchen Stone Creek Village
9/10 (1023 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 919-651-8281
Flavorful goat cheesePerfectly cooked scallopsWonderful atmosphere
Tazza Kitchen Stone Creek Village offers a cool vibe with great cocktails and a decent menu. The goat cheese appetizer comes highly recommended, with a sauce full of delicious flavor that’s hard to resist. The scallops are seared and cooked perfectly, making them incredibly delicious. The atmosphere is fantastic, making it a great spot for date night or a casual meal with friends or family.
Enrigo Italian Bistro
9/10 (898 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 919-854-7731
Warm hospitalityGenerous seafood portionsCozy Italian atmosphere
Enrigo Italian Bistro is a warm and welcoming place that feels like dining in a cozy Italian village among friends. The staff goes above and beyond to make you feel like part of the family, with impeccable service and a genuine sense of hospitality. The food is delicious with freshly made pasta and generous portions of seafood in dishes. The calamari and bruschetta are standouts, and the homemade pastas are satisfying. The atmosphere is inviting, and the service is top-notch. Don’t miss out on the great experience of dining at Enrigo Italian Bistro.
Colletta
8.6/10 (657 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 919-766-0062
Generous portionsExceptional serviceUnique flavors
Colletta offers a standout dining experience with generous portions and exceptional service. Dishes like the chicken Parmesan and lasagna are crowd favorites, bursting with flavor and satisfyingly hearty. The unique flavors of the meatballs and the indulgent spumoni Alaska dessert are definite must-tries. The casual and open ambiance, along with the welcoming staff, make this spot ideal for any occasion. With a carefully curated menu and flavorful dishes, Colletta shines as a top choice for an unforgettable meal.
Pro’s Epicurean Market & Café
9.2/10 (609 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 919-377-1788
Diverse wine selectionCharming outdoor seatingItalian-inspired menu
Pro’s Epicurean Market & Café stands out for its diverse wine selection, charming outdoor seating, and delicious entree options. The cozy café offers a mix of Italian-inspired dishes, from pastas to seafood and steak choices. The restaurant also doubles as a cocktail bar, tucked away in the back for those seeking a tasty libation. While the wine shelves may encroach on the dining space, the attentive and knowledgeable staff make up for it by guiding guests to the hidden prices. With a warm and welcoming atmosphere, Pro’s Epicurean Market & Café is a must-visit spot in downtown Cary for a delightful dining experience.
Rosati’s Pizza
9/10 (1665 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 919-380-7000
Authentic Chicago deep dishWelcoming and accommodating serviceDelicious stuffed mushrooms
Rosati’s Pizza in Morrisville is a must-try for pizza lovers, providing an authentic Chicago deep dish experience that won’t disappoint. The crust remains crunchy, and the sauce is packed with flavor. The service is top-notch, making you feel right at home with welcoming staff who cater to your preferences. The menu offers unique options like the half and half pizza, accommodating various tastes without compromising on quality. Despite some minor hiccups like mix-ups in orders, the overall dining experience is a delightful one, with the deep dish pizza stealing the show every time.
Bosphorus Restaurant
9/10 (2379 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 919-460-1300
Authentic Turkish flavorsWarm and inviting ambianceExceptional service
Upon stepping into Bosphorus Restaurant, located in the heart of downtown Cary, NC, one is immediately transported to the vibrant culinary world of Turkey. The cozy mid-sized eatery exudes warmth and authenticity, offering a menu that perfectly balances tradition with innovation. The Adana Kebab Lunch tray, accompanied by freshly baked sesame bread, is a must-try for first-timers, delivering a burst of flavors that will leave your taste buds begging for more. From the flavorful mezes to the perfectly seasoned kebabs, every dish is a testament to the family-owned restaurant’s dedication to showcasing the rich culinary heritage of Turkey. Whether you’re looking for a casual lunch spot or a special dinner experience, Bosphorus promises an unforgettable journey through the tastes and hospitality of Turkey, right in the heart of North Carolina.
Georgina’s Restaurant & Pizzeria
8.8/10 (593 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 919-388-3820
Flavorful Garlic KnotsCreamy Fettuccine AlfredoAuthentic NY-style pizza
Georgina’s Restaurant & Pizzeria is a cozy spot that puts a strong emphasis on quality and hospitality. The Garlic Knots are a standout, with flavorful garlic pieces and buttery bottoms that are perfect for soaking up. The Fettuccine Alfredo is creamy and satisfying, perfect for a comforting meal. The service here is top-notch, with staff like Kevin and Roe providing attentive and friendly customer care. The pizza is a must-try as well, with a crust that strikes the perfect balance between crispy and chewy, along with delicious sauce and cheese. Georgina’s offers a genuine and welcoming atmosphere that makes you feel right at home.
Craft Public House
9/10 (1432 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 919-851-9173
Diverse menuLarge portionsTop-notch service
Located in a bustling area of town, Craft Public House offers a diverse menu that caters to a variety of tastes and dietary restrictions. From hearty country fried chicken salad to flavorful crispy fried shrimp, the portions are large and satisfying. The atmosphere is inviting with plenty of indoor and outdoor seating options, making it a perfect spot to catch a game on one of their many TVs. The service has consistently been top-notch, ensuring a pleasant dining experience each visit. With breakfast, lunch/brunch, and dinner options, Craft Public House is a versatile spot for any occasion.
ACME Pizza
9/10 (167 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 919-650-2902
Garlic knotsMeat Head StromboliAttentive staff
ACME Pizza serves up some unique and noteworthy dishes that are definitely worth a try for first-timers. The garlic knots are described as huge, delicious, and worth the money, while the deep dish pizza is flavorful and filling. The cheese pull on the slices is a sight to behold, adding to the overall experience. The Meat Head Stromboli has been praised for its perfection – from the soft crust to the just-right ingredients. The food is not the only standout at ACME Pizza; the wait staff has been commended for their attentiveness and the store manager Jim stands out for his incredible customer service. Despite some feedback on the lack of Chicago-style authenticity, the care and dedication put into each dish at ACME Pizza are evident in the flavors and textures that customers rave about.