Whether you’re craving a classic New York-style fold or a gourmet Neapolitan masterpiece, Cincinnati offers a selection of pizza spots that promise to satisfy every palate.
From crispy thin crusts adorned with local produce to hearty deep-dish wonders that ooze with molten cheese, Cincinnati’s pizza scene offers something to satiate every palate. This guide curates the city’s standout pizzerias, each offering a unique slice of culinary heaven.
Goodfellas Pizzeria – OTR
9/10 (2336 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 513-381-3625
Late-night slicesAl Pacino meatball subWiseguy Lounge upstairs
Goodfellas Pizzeria – OTR is a beloved pizza spot that has satisfied customers for years. The late-night slice options draw in crowds, and the Al Pacino meatball sub is a fan favorite. The expansive menu offers whole pies, subs, calzones, salads, and desserts, ensuring there’s something for everyone. The unique layout of the restaurant, with a bar upstairs and various seating options including a balcony and courtyard, creates a dynamic and exciting dining experience.
Adriatico’s
9/10 (2018 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 513-281-4344
Customizable PizzasSavory and Sweet SauceCozy Atmosphere
Nestled in the heart of Cincinnati, Adriatico’s stands out as a premier pizza destination. Offering a wide array of customization options, from Sicilian-tossed to hand-tossed pizzas, this spot caters to every pizza lover’s taste buds. The Parmesan breadsticks, warm and fluffy with a generous coating of Parmesan, make for a delightful appetizer. The sauce, with its perfect blend of savory and sweet flavors, is hailed by many as the best they’ve ever tasted. With a cozy atmosphere, good selection of beer on tap, and an attentive staff, Adriatico’s truly delivers a top-notch dining experience that keeps customers coming back for more.
Dewey’s Pizza
9.4/10 (1337 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 513-221-0400
Cozy atmosphereUnique pizza optionsAttentive staff
Dewey’s Pizza in Clifton is a must-visit spot in Cincinnati. The cozy and clean atmosphere, along with the friendly staff, make for a welcoming experience. The menu offers a variety of options, from salads to calzones to unique pizzas like Don Corleone and Porky fig. The ability to create your own pizza or do a half-and-half option adds a fun twist to the dining experience. The flavor combinations are delicious, with a slightly sweet sauce and a touch of spice. The staff is attentive, the food comes out quickly, and the overall value is great. It’s definitely a place worth visiting while in Clifton.
Fireside Pizza
9/10 (1101 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 513-751-3473
Cozy atmosphereDelicious pizzaFriendly service
Fireside Pizza exudes a cozy, trendy vibe that’s very inviting with an affordable price point. The pizza here is a culinary masterpiece, fresh and absolutely delicious. The in-house cannoli is a must-try and the overall atmosphere is friendly and welcoming. The service is quick and attentive, making the dining experience even better. Definitely a hidden gem in Cincinnati that’s worth a visit for top-notch pizza and great ambiance.
TAGLIO OTR
8.8/10 (565 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 513-321-0454
Gourmet pizzasFriendly serviceSpacious ambiance
TAGLIO OTR is a must-visit pizza spot in Over The Rhine, offering gourmet pizzas at great prices. The hot honey pepperoni pizza is a standout, with a flavorful sauce and a perfect balance of heat and sweetness. The homemade penne rustica is absolutely delicious, a must-try for pasta lovers. The bar table service is top-notch, providing a friendly and accommodating dining experience. The spacious and beautiful ambiance adds to the overall charm of the restaurant, making it a perfect spot for any occasion.
Goodfellas Pizzeria – Pleasant Ridge
8.8/10 (689 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 513-351-0592
Generous serving sizesAuthentic Italian tasteCozy WiseGuys lounge
Goodfellas Pizzeria – Pleasant Ridge offers a unique dining experience with its WiseGuys lounge upstairs, providing a cozy atmosphere to enjoy a slice and a beer. The pizza itself is a standout, with customers raving about the flavorful toppings and perfectly cooked crust. The generous serving sizes ensure you won’t leave hungry, and the authentic Italian taste is sure to please any pizza lover. Despite some minor hiccups reported by customers, such as delayed appetizers or uncooked portions, the overall quality of the food and the inviting ambiance make Goodfellas Pizzeria – Pleasant Ridge a solid choice for a casual meal out.
TAGLIO Columbia Tusculum
8.8/10 (605 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 513-321-0454
Vegan cheese optionsUnique pizza offeringsFlavorful Bianco crust
TAGLIO Columbia Tusculum is a pizza joint that seems to have a mix of both highs and lows. Some customers rave about the vegan cheese options and unique pizza offerings, like the Pepperoni+Hot Honey Detroit style Pizza. The Bianco New York style crust has also garnered positive reviews for its flavor and texture. On the other hand, some patrons have mentioned issues with pricing, wait times, and overall ambiance. While the food seems to be the main draw here, improvements in service and atmosphere could make a big difference in the overall dining experience.
Dewey’s Pizza
9.4/10 (935 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 513-731-7755
Soft crustFlavorful toppingsTop-notch service
Nestled on the bustling streets, Dewey’s Pizza is a hidden gem that surprises even the most discerning pizza connoisseurs. While some may find it merely “okay,” others are enamored by the relaxed yet lively atmosphere and top-notch service. However, the real star of the show is the pizza itself. With a soft crust that melts in your mouth and an array of flavorful toppings to choose from, Dewey’s offers a unique dining experience that is sure to leave your taste buds tingling. And let’s not forget about their delectable selection of drinks and mouth-watering salads that perfectly complement the main attraction.
Ramundo’s Pizzeria
9/10 (377 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 513-321-0978
Delicious NY-style pizzaQuick and convenient for lunchExcellent customer service
Ramundo’s Pizzeria serves up delicious NY style pizza with the perfect crunch and thickness. The Supreme pizza is a must-try, and being able to buy pizza by the slice makes it a quick and convenient stop for lunch. The friendly customer service adds to the overall experience, making it a top choice for pizza lovers in town.
Werkhaus Pizza
9/10 (728 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 513-451-9911
Chicago-style perfectionDelicious homemade dessertsFriendly and accommodating staff
Werkhaus Pizza in Cincinnati is a hidden gem offering delicious Chicago-style deep dish pizza that truly hits the spot. The Lumberman Special and Meat Lovers Deep Dish options are standout choices that keep customers coming back for more. The garlic bread is also a must-try, adding the perfect touch to your meal. While the decor may be a bit outdated, the homemade desserts, like the caramel brownie, are highly recommended and worth the visit. The accommodating staff and friendly atmosphere make Werkhaus Pizza a neighborhood treasure for pizza lovers.
19 Cleveland
8.8/10 (697 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 914-825-4793
Bursting flavorsHospitable staffCozy atmosphere
At 19 Cleveland, the food is bursting with flavors that will leave you satisfied and craving more. From the avocado toast with perfectly cooked egg to the shakshuka and beet appetizer, each dish offers a unique and delicious experience. The staff is hospitable and accommodating, making every visit feel welcoming. The decor adds to the overall charm of the restaurant, creating a cozy and inviting atmosphere that will keep you coming back for more.
Goodfellas Pizzeria – Mainstrasse Village
9/10 (1926 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 859-916-5209
Insane cheese pullSavory sausageVintage speakeasy vibes
Nestled in Mainstrasse Village, Goodfellas Pizzeria is a must-visit spot for fans of New York-style pizza and craft cocktails. The cheese pull on their pies is a sight to behold, with fresh ingredients that truly shine, especially the savory sausage. The bartenders are not only friendly and informative but also mix up top-notch drinks, making the Wiseguy Lounge a hidden gem worth exploring. The atmosphere oozes a vintage vibe, reminiscent of a Prohibition-era speakeasy, adding to the overall charm of the dining experience.
Krimmer’s Italianette Pizzeria
9/10 (1692 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 513-521-7650
Gourmet toppingsCrispy crustGenerous portions
Nestled in Cincinnati, Krimmer’s Italianette Pizzeria offers a delightful dining experience with a menu that delights the taste buds. The Deluxe Seven pizza is a standout, with fresh and loaded toppings that please the palate. The meat lover’s pizza is a carnivore’s dream, with generous portions of sausage and bacon. The buffalo wings pack a flavorful punch, though some may prefer them cooked a tad longer. The crispy crust on the pizzas is a true highlight, striking a perfect balance between focaccia and hand-tossed styles. The family-sized portions are generous and can easily satisfy a crowd, making it a great spot for gatherings. Don’t miss out on the loaded fries, featuring gooey cheese and hearty chunks of bacon. Krimmer’s is a true gem in the local dining scene, drawing in crowds with its delectable offerings and warm service.
LaRosa’s Pizza Hyde Park
8.6/10 (607 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 513-347-1111
Friendly serviceVaried menuNice atmosphere
LaRosa’s Pizza Hyde Park offers a varied dining experience, as evident from the mixed reviews. Some customers praise the friendly service and delicious pizza, while others express disappointment in the quality of their meals. The standout aspects of this establishment seem to be the welcoming atmosphere and the potential for improvement in the food quality and consistency.
The Kitchen Factory
9/10 (291 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 513-591-3333
Diverse menuRich flavorsAttention to detail
The Kitchen Factory is a gem in Northside, offering a diverse menu that caters to all dietary needs. From the Le Sigh pasta dish with a beautiful balance of flavors to the perfectly cooked pizza, each dish is crafted with care. The Crack & Cheez pasta with its rich flavors will leave you full and satisfied, while the petit and flavorful cannolis make for a delightful dessert option. The attention to detail and commitment to excellence truly shine at The Kitchen Factory.
Rosie’s Italian
9.4/10 (362 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 513-381-1243
Homemade pastasCozy atmosphereAttentive service
Rosie’s Italian is a gem in Cincinnati, offering delicious Italian dishes with a cozy and inviting atmosphere. The homemade pastas and sauces are standout items on the menu, with the Gnocchi and Bucatini Carbonara being fan favorites. The generous portions and reasonable prices make it a great value for the quality of food. The attentive and friendly service adds to the overall experience, with staff members like Miri and Madison going above and beyond to ensure a memorable dining experience. Whether you’re looking for a romantic date night spot or a casual weeknight dinner, Rosie’s Italian provides a welcoming environment for all diners.
Pepp & Dolores
9.4/10 (1474 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 513-419-1820
Creative pasta dishesProfessional and attentive serviceInviting upscale atmosphere
Pepp & Dolores offers a delectable dining experience with a diverse menu of handmade pasta dishes that are sure to please any palate. The complimentary bread sets the tone for the meal, while standout dishes like the eggplant, Butternut Mascarpone, and lobster with squid ink pasta showcase the chef’s creativity and dedication to quality. The service is top-notch, with attentive staff like Mark offering expert recommendations and ensuring a memorable visit. The atmosphere is inviting and upscale, making it an ideal spot for both casual outings and special occasions.
Sotto
9.4/10 (2494 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 513-977-6886
Memorable dining experienceStandout dishesExtensive cocktail selection
Sotto, an Italian restaurant in Cincinnati, has quickly become a go-to spot for those seeking top-notch cuisine with a unique ambiance. With a dimly lit, intimate setting perfect for special occasions or date nights, diners are treated to a memorable dining experience. The service here is exemplary, with attentive staff who go above and beyond to ensure your visit is enjoyable. The menu features standout dishes like the goat cheese and honey bread, cappellacci, and ricotta doughnuts, all made with fresh ingredients and bursting with flavor. The cocktail and wine selection is also extensive, catering to all preferences. Though reservations may be hard to come by, the wait is definitely worth it to indulge in the culinary delights that Sotto has to offer.
Chameleon
9/10 (591 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 513-541-2073
Fantastic drinksPhenomenal pizzaWelcoming staff
Chameleon is a beloved hangout spot in Northside known for its fantastic drinks and great bar food. The pizza and stromboli are standout items on the menu, with each bite being simply phenomenal. The staff is welcoming and efficient, ensuring that customers have a positive experience and leave satisfied. However, consistency seems to be an issue as some customers have reported burnt food and missing seasonings. Despite these occasional mishaps, Chameleon remains a go-to spot for delicious food and a friendly atmosphere.
O’hanlon’s
9/10 (520 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 212-533-7333