Whether you’re craving a classic New York-style fold or a gourmet Neapolitan masterpiece, Colorado Springs offers a selection of pizza spots that promise to satisfy every palate.
From crispy thin crusts adorned with local produce to hearty deep-dish wonders that ooze with molten cheese, Colorado Springs’s pizza scene offers something to satiate every palate. This guide curates the city’s standout pizzerias, each offering a unique slice of culinary heaven.
Duomo51
9.2/10 (373 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 646-398-8098
Lobster and shrimp saffron dishStunning viewsImpeccable hospitality
Duomo51 offers a truly special dining experience that exceeds expectations. From the attentive and cheerful staff to the impeccable food, every aspect of the evening is top-notch. The lobster and shrimp saffron dish comes highly recommended, and the rib eye steak is not only huge but tender. The ambiance is beautiful and the views are stunning, creating a lovely atmosphere to enjoy the incredible Cacio E Pepe pasta. The hospitality at Duomo51 is unparalleled, making guests feel at home and truly valued. Each dish is expertly prepared, with the Polpo Allá Grilia and Tartufo receiving particular praise for their flavors and quality. It’s a fantastic choice for a perfect night out.
b’artusi
9.2/10 (131 reviews)
Beef tartareCheese/meat boardLate night ambience
b’artusi in the West Village offers a stunning culinary experience that will satisfy your cravings for Italian fare. The beef tartare and cheese/meat board are absolute must-tries, bursting with flavor that will leave you craving more. The late night ambience is magical, with just the right amount of low lighting to set the mood. While the menu may not be cheap, the overall experience is worth every penny, making it a go-to spot for a fabulous weeknight outing. The service is top-notch, providing a wonderful balance of professionalism and a relaxed atmosphere. If you’re a fan of Italian food, this is the place to be!
Gabriel’s Bar & Restaurant
8.8/10 (496 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 212-956-4600
Welcoming atmosphereDelicious and unique dishesExcellent service
Gabriel’s Bar & Restaurant is a true gem located just opposite Central Park. The welcoming and friendly atmosphere is highlighted by the excellent service provided by the staff, particularly Eddie and owner Gabriel. The food is simply out of this world, with standout dishes like the Ravioli Zucca and Brasato di Costolette di Manzo. The bomboloni dessert is a must-try and one of the best in town. It’s the ideal spot for a delicious meal before a show at Lincoln Center or a weekend brunch with friends, offering a classy setting and mouth-watering dishes like Eggs Benedict and banana pudding. The hospitality, beautiful bar, and family-business vibe make Gabriel’s a highly recommended dining experience in the heart of NYC.
CICCIO Bar & Alimentari
9.2/10 (343 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 646-476-9498
Attentive serviceFlavorful Italian cuisineCozy ambiance
CICCIO Bar & Alimentari is a standout restaurant that goes above and beyond in terms of service. The staff here are attentive and perceptive, ensuring that guests have a top-notch dining experience. Not only do they provide exceptional service, but they also excel in accommodating special requests, making diners feel truly valued and cared for. The cozy and inviting interior creates a warm atmosphere that enhances the overall dining experience, making it a must-visit spot for those seeking not just great food, but also outstanding service and ambiance.
Bambino’s Urban Pizzeria
9.2/10 (1940 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 719-630-8121
Customizable pizzasFast serviceFriendly staff
Bambino’s Urban Pizzeria offers a unique dining experience, allowing customers to customize their pizzas with a variety of ingredients. The fast service and delicious food make it a standout choice for pizza lovers. The friendly and attentive staff adds to the overall pleasant atmosphere of the restaurant, making it a must-visit spot for those craving a tasty and quick pizza fix.
Barbalu Brooklyn
9.4/10 (317 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 347-294-4287
Fresh flavorsAttentive staffCozy atmosphere
Barbalu Brooklyn is a cozy restaurant with a chic yet comfortable atmosphere. The food is fresh, flavorful, and perfectly portioned, leaving diners feeling full and energized. The staff is attentive and friendly, providing top-notch service. The menu offers a variety of delicious options, from pasta dishes to pan-roasted Arctic char and delectable tiramisu. The cocktails are top-notch, and the outdoor seating provides a great dining experience. Barbalu Brooklyn is a reliable and consistent choice for a quality meal in a welcoming setting.
Leon Gessi New York Pizza
9.2/10 (2700 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 719-635-1542
Authentic New York pizzaFriendly and fast staffGreat lunch special
Leon Gessi New York Pizza is the go-to spot in town for authentic New York-style pizza. The lunch special is a steal, offering a decent salad, bread, pizza slice, and a drink for under $9. The staff is fast, friendly, and accommodating, making the experience a pleasure. The hot food is hot, the cold food is cold, and there’s even an ice cream spot next door for a sweet treat post-meal. For a quick and delicious bite, Leon Gessi is the place to be.
Slice 420
9.4/10 (2824 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 719-368-6977
Delicious pizzaFlavorful hot wingsInviting atmosphere
Slice 420 stands out for its delicious pizza offerings and unique mission to raise awareness about plant-based medical treatments. Located in Old Colorado City, it provides a perfect post-pizza stroll destination. The honey garlic knots are a must-try, and the variety of options ensures there’s something for everyone. Quick service, military discounts, and indoor seating make it a convenient choice for a satisfying meal that also supports a good cause. While prices may be slightly higher, knowing that part of the proceeds go towards helping children with medical care adds to the overall experience.
White Pie Pizzeria
8.6/10 (726 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 719-755-4144
Thin, crispy crustExpertly crafted cocktailsCozy patio setting
White Pie Pizzeria in Colorado Springs has been receiving rave reviews from happy customers. The thin and crispy crust pairs perfectly with a variety of toppings, from the Porky Pepperoni to the Ava Angelini with prosciutto and ricotta. Unique cocktails like the Paloma and Old Fashioned are expertly crafted, complementing the flavorful pizzas. The Burrata Cheese appetizer receives accolades with its perfectly marinated tomatoes and hot honey. The servers at White Pie, like Amanda and Ivy, go above and beyond to ensure a top-notch dining experience. The cozy patio with fireplaces adds to the kool and contemporary atmosphere, making this spot a must-visit for pizza lovers in Colorado Springs.
Louies Pizza
8.6/10 (1019 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 719-635-5565
AffordableDeliciousCourteous
Louies Pizza in Colorado Springs offers delicious, affordable pizza that won’t disappoint. The cheesy garlic bread is a must-try, and the service is top-notch. The pizza itself is flavorful and worth every penny. The atmosphere may be simple, but the welcoming staff and tasty food make it a great spot for a quick and satisfying meal.
Pizza Time Colorado
8.8/10 (587 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 719-282-4177
Cozy atmosphereDelicious pizzasFriendly staff
Pizza Time Colorado manages to stand out from the rest with its cozy and unpretentious atmosphere. While it might not be the most elegant spot, the relaxed vibe and lack of crowds create a welcoming environment perfect for families and friends looking to enjoy a meal together. The real star of the show, however, is the food. The pizzas are surprisingly delicious, with just the right amount of flavor and a perfectly balanced crust that is both crunchy and light. The menu offers a variety of options at reasonable prices, making it easy to find something for everyone. The staff is friendly and attentive, adding to the overall positive experience.
Parry’s Sliceria & Taps
8.8/10 (709 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 719-985-8951
Delicious pizza slicesFriendly staffWide beer selection
Parry’s Sliceria & Taps is a cozy spot that impresses with its delicious, authentic, and non-greasy New York-style pizza. The giant pizza slices come packed with fresh toppings like cheese and flavorful sauces, making each bite a delight. The addition of a bar with a wide selection of beers on tap adds to the lively ambiance, perfect for sports fans dining in. The friendly staff offers excellent service, with personal touches that make the dining experience even more enjoyable. Prices are reasonable, making it a great spot for families or anyone looking for quality food at great prices. Whether you’re in the mood for pizza, Stromboli, a juicy chicken sandwich, or a flavorful burger, Parry’s has something for everyone to enjoy.
High Rise Pizza Kitchen
9/10 (205 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 719-375-5694
Crunchy-soft crustFresh toppingsCozy ambiance
High Rise Pizza Kitchen is a local gem offering top-notch pizzas with a crunchy exterior and soft interior crust that never disappoints. The fresh and well-distributed toppings are delightful, and the care put into making each pizza is evident. The value for the quality of ingredients is unbeatable, and the variety of topping options is sure to please any palate. The cozy and clean atmosphere, along with the courteous staff and prompt service, make it a must-visit establishment for any pizza lover looking for an authentic and delicious experience.
Colorado Springs Pies and Grinders
9.2/10 (609 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 719-282-6888
Flavorful piesExceptional customer serviceWelcoming atmosphere
Located in Colorado Springs, Pies and Grinders offers a unique dining experience that keeps customers coming back for more. With a commitment to quality and attention to detail, this New York-style pizza spot stands out from the rest. The buffalo wings are moist and flavorful, the garlic cheesy bread is gooey and satisfying, and the pies are an absolute flavor explosion. A standout feature of this place is the exceptional customer service, with staff going above and beyond to ensure every order is perfect. From accommodating dietary sensitivities to providing a welcoming atmosphere with live music, Pies and Grinders delivers a memorable dining experience that is sure to impress even the pickiest of pizza lovers.
Dion’s Pizza
9/10 (2086 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 719-265-4645
Flavorful pizzaFresh saladsComfy atmosphere
The bustling atmosphere at Dion’s Pizza on a Friday night added to the anticipation of our meal. Our small Duke City pizza was bursting with tasty ingredients atop a thin crust while the chef salad was fresh and well-balanced, a testament to the generous portions offered at this establishment. The Lemonade was a standout, evoking memories of fairground lemonade shakeups. The staff was welcoming and attentive, further enhancing the overall dining experience.
Slice 420
9.2/10 (1142 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 719-375-0393
Colossal Parmesan chickenVegan Pizza RollAttentive service
Slice 420 in Colorado Springs offers a plethora of delicious options, from colossal Parmesan chicken to vegan pizza rolls. The flavors and quality of the food are undeniable, with attentive service and a welcoming atmosphere adding to the dining experience. The sheer variety of choices on the menu is a draw, enticing customers to return and explore more of what Slice 420 has to offer. Whether you’re a pizza aficionado or looking to try something new, Slice 420 is a must-visit destination for a satisfying meal.
Walter’s303 Pizzeria & Publik House | Flying Horse
9.2/10 (1212 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 719-487-3006
Flavorful deep dishExtensive beer selectionFriendly service
Nestled in a charming shopping center, Walter’s303 Pizzeria & Publik House | Flying Horse offers delicious pizza in a bright and clean setting with ample seating and a welcoming bar. The garlic bread with marinara sauce is a must-try starter, setting the stage for the perfectly crafted pizzas with generous toppings. The service is top-notch, ensuring a pleasant dining experience. The extensive beer selection and the cozy atmosphere make it an ideal spot to watch a game while enjoying a delectable meal. Special shoutout to the deep dish pizza and the flavorful wings with Italian buffalo sauce, adding a unique twist to the menu.
Parry’s Sliceria & Taps
9.2/10 (346 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 719-300-5767
Delicious New York-style pizzaCrispy fries and cheesy breadExceptional service
The New York-style pizza at Parry’s Sliceria & Taps is a must-try, with a crispy yet chewy crust and flavorful sauce that isn’t too sweet. The selection of toppings ensures there’s something for everyone, and the white pearl pizza is a standout favorite. In addition to the delicious pizzas, the fries and cheese bread are top-notch, with perfectly crispy fries and gooey, cheesy bread that will leave you wanting more. The service is also exceptional, with Pam receiving high praise for her welcoming and helpful demeanor. Whether you’re a pizza lover or looking for a great dining experience, Parry’s Sliceria & Taps is definitely worth a visit.
Black Forest Pies & Grinders
8.8/10 (658 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 719-495-8555
Fantastic thin crustFlavorful wingsAuthentic East Coast experience
Nestled in Black Forest, Black Forest Pies & Grinders serves up fantastic pan crust pizzas, flavorful wings, and delectable desserts. The cozy restaurant exudes character, providing a great place for dining in or taking out. The Buffalo Hot wings and lemon pepper rubbed wings are excellent choices, along with the carrot cake for dessert. While the inside dining area may be a bit older and run down, the friendly and genuine staff more than make up for it, providing a welcoming atmosphere for guests. The thin crust pizza stands out with the perfect amount of crunch, making it a definite must-try. For those craving a taste of the East Coast, Black Forest Pies & Grinders delivers an authentic pizzeria experience, making it a top spot for pizza lovers looking for quality and flavor.
Blackjack Pizza & Salads
9.2/10 (575 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 719-633-1200