Whether you’re craving a classic New York-style fold or a gourmet Neapolitan masterpiece, Columbia offers a selection of pizza spots that promise to satisfy every palate.
From crispy thin crusts adorned with local produce to hearty deep-dish wonders that ooze with molten cheese, Columbia’s pizza scene offers something to satiate every palate. This guide curates the city’s standout pizzerias, each offering a unique slice of culinary heaven.
Shakespeare’s Pizza – Downtown
9.2/10 (2466 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 573-449-2454
Cozy atmosphereVariety of toppingsClassic cornmeal crust
Located in the heart of Columbia, Missouri, Shakespeare’s Pizza – Downtown offers a cozy and inviting atmosphere with ample seating options. The pizza menu boasts a variety of specialty options as well as the opportunity to create your own masterpiece with a plethora of toppings. The crust, with its unique cornmeal base, is evenly sauced and always hits the spot. While the prices may be a bit steep for some, the quality of the pizza is undeniable, making it a must-visit spot for locals and visitors alike.
PaPPo’s Pizzeria & Pub W Nifong Columbia, Mo
9/10 (614 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 573-818-1790
Lively atmosphereDelicious pizzaFriendly staff
PaPPo’s Pizzeria & Pub W Nifong in Columbia, Mo, has become a local favorite for good reason. The atmosphere is lively, with multiple TVs playing sports, perfect for beer enthusiasts. The food is a standout, particularly the crispy yet gooey pizza with a variety of toppings. The service is top-notch, with friendly staff ensuring a pleasant dining experience. Whether you’re in the mood for a homemade pizza or a chicken Philly, PaPPo’s has it all, along with a wide selection of cocktails and beers on tap.
Pizza Tree
9.2/10 (624 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 573-874-9925
Fresh IngredientsUnique ToppingsOption for Slices
Pizza Tree in Columbia offers a variety of delicious pizzas, from classic pepperoni to unique topping combinations. Customers rave about the Instant Classic and the Jalapeno Papa, praising the fresh ingredients and flavorful pairings. The option to purchase pizza by the slice is a convenient feature, catering to those who want a quick and tasty meal. With a reputation for being the best pizza joint in town, Pizza Tree is a must-visit for anyone craving a satisfying slice or a whole pie to share with friends. The homemade salads with pickled onions and croutons are also a hit, adding a refreshing and tangy complement to the hearty pizzas. Despite limited seating and the absence of an interior space for dining, Pizza Tree stands out as a top choice for pizza lovers in Columbia.
Arris’ Pizza
9/10 (404 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 573-441-1191
Consistently deliciousWarm atmosphereTop-notch service
Arris’ Pizza has been a go-to spot for many loyal customers who rave about the consistently delicious food, whether it’s the classic Greek salad, Canadian bacon pizza, or the Atlas pizza. The toppings are fresh, the flavors are well-balanced, and the crust is just right. The warm and welcoming atmosphere is perfect for a casual meal with family or friends, and the service is top-notch. With locations in various cities, Arris’ Pizza continues to impress with their tasty offerings that keep customers coming back for more.
Shakespeare’s Pizza – West
9/10 (1210 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 573-447-1202
Fun ‘Shakesperience’Fresh toppingsCozy atmosphere
Shakespeare’s Pizza – West offers a unique and fun experience for families with the ‘Shakesperience’ where guests can make their own individual pizzas. The kid-friendly atmosphere, with workers entertaining children by throwing dough, adds to the playful vibe of the restaurant. While some customers have noted inconsistencies in service and crust texture, the fresh toppings and delicious cheese on the pizza are standout features. The cozy atmosphere and convenient parking make it a great spot for a casual meal or a quick stop while passing through Columbia.
Tony’s Pizza Palace
9/10 (704 reviews)
| Directions | +1 573-442-3188
Crisp crustGenerous toppingsFriendly staff
Located in Columbia, Tony’s Pizza Palace is a local gem that has become a go-to spot for pizza enthusiasts and lovers of Greek cuisine alike. The pizza, with its perfectly crisp crust and generous toppings, is undoubtedly the star of the show here. The house-made sausage steals the spotlight, while the gyro and Souvlaki offer a taste of Greece right in Missouri. The family-owned establishment may not be fancy, but the warm, inviting atmosphere and friendly staff make you feel right at home. While service may have its hiccups at times, the delicious food, reasonable prices, and generous portions more than make up for any shortcomings. Tony’s is a must-visit for anyone craving a comforting slice of pizza or a hearty gyro in Columbia.
Shakespeare’s Pizza – South
9.2/10 (1292 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 573-447-7435
Large, flavorful pizzasFamily-friendly atmosphereUnique dining experience
Shakespeare’s Pizza – South is known for its large, delicious pizzas that leave customers satisfied and coming back for more. With a family-friendly atmosphere, friendly staff, and the option to watch your pizza being made, it’s a unique dining experience that many enjoy. Customers rave about the flavorful toppings, generous portions, and the variety of options available. While some may have experienced longer wait times, the quality of the food makes it worth the visit.
George’s Pizza and Steak
8.8/10 (616 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 573-214-2080
Unbeatable lunch specialsFresh ingredientsCharming atmosphere
Nestled in Columbia, George’s Pizza and Steak is a hidden gem offering unbeatable lunch specials that are a steal for the quality you receive. The breaded tenderloin sandwich is a crowd favorite, perfectly seasoned and paired with a baked potato topped with real butter and sour cream. The owner, George, is a delightful host who takes pride in providing excellent service and fresh ingredients. The restaurant exudes a charming atmosphere, making it a must-visit for those seeking a cozy dining experience with generous portions and a caring staff.
Gumby’s Pizza
8.8/10 (518 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 573-874-8629
Unique toppingsSatisfying crustFriendly staff
Gumby’s Pizza in Columbia offers a fun selection of pizzas that are absolutely delicious. From the unique toppings like fries and Doritos to the satisfying texture of the crust, the pizzas are worth every penny. The friendly staff and great atmosphere add to the overall experience, making it a must-visit spot in the area.
G & D Pizzaria
9/10 (1244 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 573-445-8336
Outstanding serviceDelicious thin crust pizzaWelcoming staff
G & D Pizzaria, a Columbia institution, offers outstanding service and delicious food. From their perfectly crispy thin crust pizzas to their savory gyros and fries, every bite is a testament to their commitment to quality. The welcoming staff creates a positive atmosphere that makes you feel right at home. While the decor may not be fancy, the wholesome and affordable food more than makes up for it.
Southside Pizza & Pub
8.8/10 (930 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 573-256-7337
Welcoming atmosphereAttentive serviceDelicious menu options
Nestled in the heart of Columbia, Southside Pizza & Pub is a hidden gem waiting to be discovered. The welcoming atmosphere and attentive service make any dining experience truly memorable. From perfectly cooked fried pickles to mouth-watering pizzas like the Big E, the menu is filled with delicious options that will leave you satisfied. Whether you’re celebrating a special occasion or just looking for a casual night out, Southside Pizza & Pub is the place to be. Don’t miss out on this culinary delight in Columbia!
Angelo’s Pizza & Steak House
8.8/10 (548 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 573-443-6100
GyroChicken Fried ChickenConsistency
At Angelo’s Pizza & Steak House, the Gyro and the chicken fried chicken were standout dishes on the menu. The service was quick and efficient, adding to the overall dining experience. The pork loin and fries were mouth-watering, showcasing the kitchen’s ability to execute classic dishes flawlessly. If you’re a fan of nostalgic vibes, the interior ambiance is sure to transport you to a different era, enhancing the overall dining atmosphere. The consistency in taste and quality makes Angelo’s a reliable choice for a satisfying meal, whether you’re a regular patron or a first-time visitor.
The Italian Village
8.6/10 (203 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 573-442-8821
Crispy Chicken ParmesanOn-time BBQ PizzaGyro Sandwich
The Italian Village is a gem hidden in town with a genuine desire to please customers. The chicken Parmesan hoagie is a standout, with perfectly crispy tender chicken and flavorful sauce. The BBQ chicken pizza is also a hit, arriving on time and full of delicious flavor. While the garlic bread and cheese may not have hit the mark and some orders had minor mishaps, overall, The Italian Village is a solid choice for a tasty meal.
Columbia University
9.2/10 (2499 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 212-854-1754
Expert facultyVibrant city locationBeautiful campus
Columbia University is a stunning campus located in the heart of Manhattan, offering a perfect blend of academic rigor and vibrant city life. The faculty are experts in their fields and the curriculum is thought-provoking. The university provides numerous extracurricular activities and resources, making it a hub of knowledge and ambition. The campus itself is sprawling, featuring lush green spaces, modern buildings, and historic landmarks that add to the overall grandeur and beauty of the university.
Pickleman’s Gourmet Cafe
8.8/10 (644 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 573-875-2400
Generously portioned mealsEfficient delivery serviceFriendly staff
Pickleman’s Gourmet Cafe offers a reliable and satisfying dining option, with a focus on quality ingredients and efficient delivery service. The menu features a variety of options, including sandwiches, pizzas, and cookies, all generously portioned. Customers appreciate the friendly and helpful staff, with special shout-outs to particular delivery drivers who go above and beyond to ensure a positive experience. The cleanliness of the restaurant and the timely delivery adds to the overall appeal of Pickleman’s, making it a go-to choice for many hungry diners.