Whether you’re craving a classic New York-style fold or a gourmet Neapolitan masterpiece, Columbus offers a selection of pizza spots that promise to satisfy every palate.
From crispy thin crusts adorned with local produce to hearty deep-dish wonders that ooze with molten cheese, Columbus’s pizza scene offers something to satiate every palate. This guide curates the city’s standout pizzerias, each offering a unique slice of culinary heaven.
Ortomare Ristorante Pizzeria
9.4/10 (483 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 212-665-2970
Cozy atmosphereDelicious wood-fired pizzasAttentive and friendly staff
Upon entering Ortomare Ristorante Pizzeria, guests are transported to the heart of Italy with its cozy and welcoming atmosphere. The wood-burning fire oven is a standout feature, adding a unique touch to the delicious pizzas. The Diavola and The Norcina pizzas were both hits, with a flavorful red sauce and perfectly cooked crust. The pasta bolognese did not disappoint, with a generous amount of meat and perfectly cooked pasta. The panna cotta dessert with caramel drizzle was a light and satisfying end to the meal. While small details like the sliced bread and spices oil could use a bit of improvement, the overall experience at Ortomare is definitely worth a visit for a delightful evening filled with exceptional food and warm hospitality.
Patsy’s Pizzeria
8.6/10 (1441 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 212-579-3000
Thin, Sicilian crustFresh, quality toppingsCozy, welcoming atmosphere
Patsy’s Pizzeria is a hidden gem in the Upper West Side, perfect for a casual meal with friends or a cozy date night. The atmosphere is welcoming and the staff are attentive, making it an ideal spot to unwind after a day of exploring the city. The star of the menu, however, is the pizza. The thin, Sicilian crust is perfectly baked and the fresh toppings make each bite a delight. While the menu may be limited, the quality of the ingredients and the care put into each pizza truly shine. Whether you opt for a classic Margherita or a meatball and mushroom pie, you’re sure to leave satisfied and planning your next visit.
Hounddog’s Pizza
9/10 (3749 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 614-261-4686
Handmade Hot Buffalo sauceCrispy wingsThin crust squares
Upon entering Hounddog’s Pizza, one is immediately struck by the tavern-like decor and welcoming ambiance. While the customer service may come across as slightly brusque, the staff is accommodating when it comes to scheduling pick-up times for orders. The pizza itself is a mixed bag – some find it greasy and lacking in flavor, while others swear by unique creations like The Russell, a chicken/bacon/ranch pizza with fresh green onions. The real winners here are the house-made Hot Buffalo sauce and the crispy wings, as well as the thin crust cut into squares, which is a favorite among regulars. Overall, Hounddog’s Pizza seems to have a loyal following and is worth a visit for a casual dining experience with some standout menu items.
East Coast Pizzeria
9.2/10 (369 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 614-885-0101
Local gemNY-style pizzaFlavorful toppings
East Coast Pizzeria, a true local gem, welcomes guests with kindness and a friendly atmosphere. The NY-style pizza, reminiscent of being in the Big Apple, is a standout on the menu. The brick oven pizza is a must-try, with flavorful toppings and a crispy crust that leaves you wanting more. The East Coast Bourbon Chicken Pizza is a unique and tasty option, combining bold flavors that are sure to satisfy your cravings. With generous toppings and great tasting crust, this pizzeria is a top choice for a delicious meal.
Harvest Bar + Kitchen – Brewery District
9.2/10 (795 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 614-947-7950
Fresh and flavorful dishesAttentive and knowledgeable staffCreative twists on classic favorites
Nestled in the lively Brewery District, Harvest Bar + Kitchen offers an array of mouthwatering dishes that are sure to please even the pickiest of eaters. The food menu is a delightful mix of classic favorites and creative twists, with options for vegans and vegetarians that are just as tasty as their meaty counterparts. From the epic hummus crudité to the perfectly seasoned gluten-free pizza crust, every dish showcases fresh ingredients and thoughtful preparation. The attentive and knowledgeable staff go above and beyond to ensure a top-notch dining experience, making recommendations and accommodating special requests with a smile. Whether you’re a pizza aficionado or looking for a new favorite spot, Harvest Bar + Kitchen is a must-visit destination that will leave you planning your next return.
Mikey’s Late Night Slice
8.8/10 (2483 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 614-737-3801
Signature Unicorn PunchThicc cut pepperoniUnique unicorn sauce
Mikey’s Late Night Slice offers a whimsically decorated and spacious environment for patrons to enjoy their signature Unicorn Punch, a deliciously flavorful drink that packs a punch. Their Sabawesome pizza was a pleasant surprise, with thicc cut pepperoni slices that are reminiscent of New York style pizza. While the pizza may not have been perfect for some, the overall atmosphere, friendly service, and unique unicorn sauce make Mikey’s Late Night Slice a go-to spot for late-night bites in downtown Columbus.
Pies & Pints – Columbus, OH
8.8/10 (1503 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 614-478-7437
Delicious specialty pizzasFriendly and knowledgeable staffGreat atmosphere
Nestled in Columbus, Pies & Pints offers a delightful dining experience that won’t disappoint. The atmosphere is great and the food is delicious, especially the specialty pizzas like the Nashville hot chicken. The service here is top-notch, with friendly and knowledgeable staff making sure your visit is unforgettable. The pizza selection is varied and tasty, making it a perfect spot for a laid-back meal with friends or family.
Adriatico’s New York Style Pizza
9.2/10 (1669 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 614-421-2300
Customizable SicilianMassive Buckeye PizzaDelicious gelato
Adriatico’s New York Style Pizza is a must-try for any pizza lover. Their Sicilian pizza with customizable toppings is a fan favorite, and the gelato options are plentiful. The staff is welcoming and attentive, making the dining experience enjoyable. They offer mass orders for events, like their massive Buckeye pizza, perfect for feeding a crowd. The deep dish cheese pizza is a standout, reminiscent of authentic New York pizzerias. The crust is crispy yet soft, the sauce is tangy, and the oversized pepperonis add the perfect touch. The breadsticks are a must-try, some of the best in Central Ohio. Whether you’re a fan of thin crust or Sicilian, Adriatico’s has something for everyone.
GoreMade Pizza
9.2/10 (692 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 614-725-2115
Creative Chef’s SpecialsAuthentic Naples OvenKnowledgeable and Passionate Staff
GoreMade Pizza is a hidden gem in Columbus that offers a cozy vibe and unique personality. The wood-fired pizza oven imported from Naples is a sight to see and sets the tone for the whole experience. The Chef’s special pizzas are a must-try, showcasing a creative combination of flavors that are truly top-notch. The menu offers fresh, seasonal ingredients and a variety of options, including gluten-free choices. The staff’s knowledge and passion for pizza-making add to the overall enjoyment of the dining experience, making GoreMade Pizza a standout in the area.
Osteria Cotta
8.8/10 (1044 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 212-873-8500
Reliable menuInviting atmosphereStellar Italian fare
Osteria Cotta remains a steadfast staple on the upper west side, beloved by loyal customers for over a decade. The menu boasts indulgent dishes that are sure to satisfy, from the rosemary wings to the shrimp scampi appetizers. The Italian fare is consistently tasty, making it an ideal spot for all occasions. The inviting atmosphere, a harmonious blend of medieval and upscale elements, sets the stage for a memorable dining experience. Whether you’re seeking a casual meal with friends or a romantic evening out, Osteria Cotta delivers exceptional value without compromising quality.
Ange’s Pizza
9/10 (176 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 614-670-8864
Flavorful pizzaExceptional customer serviceConvenient location
Upon dining at Ange’s Pizza, it’s evident that their team is dedicated to providing exceptional customer service. The staff is highly attentive, ensuring that every order is flawless. The location offers a convenient and friendly atmosphere that adds to the overall dining experience. Additionally, the pizza itself surpasses expectations, with a flavorful sauce and a perfectly balanced thin crust that keeps customers coming back for more. While the online ordering website may have its flaws, the quality of the food and the efficiency of the service more than make up for any minor inconveniences.
Plank’s Cafe & Pizzeria
8.6/10 (790 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 614-445-7221
Historic charmUnique pizza flavorsCozy atmosphere
Plank’s Cafe & Pizzeria is a historic gem in the South End that holds a special charm for many patrons. The variety of menu options, including a hint of sweetness in the sauce that pairs perfectly with the thin and crispy crust, sets this place apart. While some may find the prices on the higher side for certain items, the warm and attentive service, cozy atmosphere, and delightful free peanuts served add to the overall dining experience. The inconsistency in the quality of the pizzas is a drawback for some, but those seeking a unique and welcoming spot will appreciate what Plank’s has to offer.
Pizza Pizza 007
9.6/10 (166 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 614-869-0005
Flavorful Supreme PizzaChocolate Lava CakeExcellent Service
Pizza Pizza 007 is a hidden gem that delivers on its promise of delicious pizza. The 10-inch Supreme with added Italian sausage is a standout, packed with flavor and the ideal combination of toppings. The owner takes pride in every order, ensuring that pizzas are consistently hot and mouth-watering. The Chocolate Lava Cake is a sweet ending to a satisfying meal, even if slightly frozen, and the gyro is surprisingly tasty according to my partner. This spot is a must-visit for pizza lovers looking for a memorable dining experience.
Central Park Cafe
8.6/10 (268 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 646-861-0054
Great valueTop-notch pizzaPleasant atmosphere
Central Park Cafe is a versatile spot for a pre-concert coffee or post-park pizza. The menu features standout items like borscht and chicken breast with béchamel sauce, offering great value for the price. The atmosphere is pleasant, making it a gem for a post-bike ride sip or satisfying meal. While the sangria may not impress all, the top-notch pizza more than makes up for it. The service is polite and efficient, enhancing the overall experience of this Central Park eatery.
Pizza Town
9.2/10 (550 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 718-789-4040
Custom dietary optionsDelicious mozzarella sticksFriendly staff
Pizza Town in Brooklyn is a beloved neighborhood spot that has been serving up delicious pies for years. The mozzarella sticks are a must-try and have become a fan favorite among regulars. The staff is friendly and accommodating, with one employee going above and beyond to create a custom pizza for a customer with dietary restrictions. The pizza itself is top-notch, with the perfect crust-to-cheese ratio and a sauce that isn’t overly sweet. The clean space, welcoming atmosphere, and affordable prices make Pizza Town a standout choice for a family-friendly dining experience in Brooklyn.
Gatto’s Pizza
9/10 (275 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 614-263-3737
Traditional Columbus-style pizzaOven-baked wingsAffordable menu
Gatto’s Pizza offers a traditional Columbus-style pie with a delicious crust and flavorful toppings. The atmosphere is cute and inviting, but what truly stands out are the oven-baked wings and the quality of their pizzas. The homemade veggie sub on Audino’s Italian Bakery bread is also a must-try option. The affordability of the menu, along with the quick carry-out and delivery options, make Gatto’s a top contender in the local pizza scene.
The Original Little Italy
9/10 (328 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 212-661-1425
Phenomenal pizzaFriendly staffCozy atmosphere
The Original Little Italy is a gem hidden in the heart of New York City. The pizza is phenomenal, with a variety of options to choose from and fresh, quality ingredients that truly stand out. The staff is incredibly friendly and attentive, making you feel like family as soon as you walk through the door. The cozy atmosphere and great music add to the overall dining experience, making it a must-visit for any pizza lover looking for a delicious and authentic meal.
Arte Cafe
8.6/10 (1118 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 212-501-7014
Unique floral platesDelicious squid ink pastaFantastic set lunch meal
Arte Cafe is a lively spot with great food and friendly service. The unique floral plate presentation adds a special touch to each dish. The Orvieto white wine and perfect tiramisu make for a delightful dining experience. The squid ink pasta is a standout dish, while the set lunch meal offers a fantastic deal with a variety of options to choose from.
Highline Pizzeria
8.6/10 (788 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 212-564-3330
Solid pizza sliceWood-fired piesSicilian pizza perfection
Highline Pizzeria in NYC offers a solid pizza slice close to the Art Gallery, perfect for a quick and tasty bite. The wood-fired pies with fresh, high-quality ingredients elevate the experience, with generous toppings and a thin crust that stays true to New York style. The Sicilian pizza stands out for its airy dough and square pieces, making it a must-try for any pizza enthusiast looking for an authentic and delicious slice in the city.