Whether you’re craving a classic New York-style fold or a gourmet Neapolitan masterpiece, Durham offers a selection of pizza spots that promise to satisfy every palate.
From crispy thin crusts adorned with local produce to hearty deep-dish wonders that ooze with molten cheese, Durham’s pizza scene offers something to satiate every palate. This guide curates the city’s standout pizzerias, each offering a unique slice of culinary heaven.
Pizzeria Toro
9/10 (1860 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 919-908-6936
Diverse PizzasCozy AtmosphereFriendly Staff
Pizzeria Toro offers a diverse selection of pizzas, from classics to innovative creations like Myer Lemon and Venison sausage. The cozy atmosphere, complete with an open kitchen and a large community table, adds to the charm of the dining experience. While some customers have noted occasional menu inconsistencies and slow service, the delicious food and friendly staff make Pizzeria Toro a must-try for pizza enthusiasts in downtown Durham.
Devil’s Pizzeria
8.6/10 (935 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 919-286-3090
New York authenticityMassive pizza slicesMust-try cannoli
At Devil’s Pizzeria, customers are transported back to New York with every bite. The massive, thin, and crunchy pizza crusts are unforgettable, while the eggplant parm leaves taste buds in awe. The serving sizes are generous, the staff friendly, and the must-have cannoli and cheesecake are a heavenly duo. The spotless vibe and strong vegan options make this pizzeria a local gem not to be missed. As for the food, it speaks volumes- you won’t find better pizza this side of town.
Mellow Mushroom Durham
8.8/10 (1858 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 919-680-8500
Diverse menuHigh-quality ingredientsConvenient location
Mellow Mushroom Durham offers a wide variety of menu options, including vegan, vegetarian, and gluten-free choices, all made with high-quality and fresh ingredients. The diverse selection of wing sauces is a standout, with flavors such as sweet chili Thai, garlic Parmesan, and honey sriracha impressing diners. The House special pizza, pepperoni pizza, and kid-friendly options like meatballs with marinara sauce are all top-notch selections. The restaurant’s proximity to Durham Bulls Stadium and DPAC make it a convenient stop for visitors to the area, with attentive service and a family-friendly atmosphere adding to the overall dining experience.
Pie Pushers
9/10 (798 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 919-294-8408
Flavorful thin-crustFriendly staffCreative toppings
Located in downtown Durham, Pie Pushers offers a unique dining experience that combines delicious thin-crust pizza with a friendly and efficient staff. The menu features a variety of creative toppings, including favorites like mushroom and ricotta, along with classic options like pepperoni. The fresh and flavorful pies are served hot and are perfect for sharing or enjoying solo. The restaurant has a laid-back vibe, with indie music playing in the background, making it a great spot to grab a bite to eat before exploring the city. Whether you’re a local or just passing through, Pie Pushers is definitely worth a visit.
Napoli Pizzeria & Gelateria – Durham Food Hall
8.6/10 (117 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 919-294-6498
Authentic Margherita pizzaVibrant house saladConsistently delicious pies
Napoli Pizzeria & Gelateria at Durham Food Hall serves up consistently delicious pies with fresh ingredients and a nice crisp edge from the wood fire oven. Their house salad is vibrant and flavorful, large enough to share between two adults. The Parma pizza with honey is a go-to order, and the gelato, while a bit soft, offers tasty flavors. The only downside is the inconsistent service and sometimes lengthy wait times. The Margherita pizza stands out, offering an authentic Italian pizza experience. While there is room for improvement, this spot is a solid choice for a bite in downtown Durham.
Tomato Jake’s Pizzeria
8.8/10 (719 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 919-572-7722
Fresh pizzaFlavorful wingsFun atmosphere
Tomato Jake’s Pizzeria is the perfect spot for a satisfying meal. The fresh pizza with a variety of tasty toppings on soft dough will leave you craving more. Their wings are saucy and meaty, perfect for those who love a flavorful bite. With a fun and inviting atmosphere, this spot is not only great for food but also a place to relax and enjoy. Whether you’re a regular or a first-timer, Tomato Jake’s is sure to impress with their delicious offerings and reasonable prices.
Ricky’s New York Pizza
8.6/10 (428 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 919-477-2800
Authentic NY pizzaFriendly staffDelicious menu options
Ricky’s New York Pizza is a must-visit destination for those craving authentic, delicious NY pizza. The Roma Spinach pizza comes highly recommended, showcasing the perfect balance of flavors and a warm, welcoming family atmosphere. From the moment you walk in, the friendly staff ensures you feel like a regular customer, while the garlic parm French fries and margarita pizza are standout menu items that will have you coming back for more.
Enzo’s Pizza Co.
8.6/10 (899 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 919-309-3696
Variety of PizzasAffordable PricesFriendly Staff
Enzo’s Pizza Co. stands out as a top pizza spot in the Durham area, offering a variety of delicious pies that are sure to satisfy any pizza lover. The menu boasts unique creations like “The Forester” and classics like the “heartland” and “heater” pizzas. The dough, red sauce, and cheese are consistently rated at a high level, with add-ons like pepperoni earning top marks. The staff is friendly and helpful, enhancing the overall dining experience. Customers appreciate the generous portion sizes, affordable prices, and quick service. Whether you’re a fan of hearty and slightly sweet sauce or looking for something original, Enzo’s has something to offer every pizza enthusiast.
Sofia’s Pizza
9/10 (309 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 984-219-3656
Delicious pizzaAmazing wingsFriendly staff
Sofia’s Pizza in Durham is a hidden gem that serves up delicious pizza with a crust that’s a must-try. The supreme pizza is loaded with fresh meats and vegetables, and the Sofia’s dough blend and sauce make it stand out. The garlic knots may not meet expectations, but the marinara sauce is a highlight. The restaurant offers great customer service, a clean environment, and ample parking. The salad may need improvement timing-wise, but the overall experience is impressive and definitely worth a return visit.
Randy’s Pizza
9/10 (1587 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 919-941-7755
Huge 18-inch pizzaWell-done pizza optionAwesome staff
Randy’s Pizza in the Raleigh Durham area is a go-to spot for those craving a hearty meal. The massive 18-inch pizza is a standout, leaving diners satisfied after just a few mouthwatering slices. The option to order pizzas well done ensures a quality pie every time, worth the extra cost for a delicious end result. The staff at Randy’s is top-notch, providing awesome service that enhances the overall dining experience. With generous portions and tasty toppings, Randy’s Pizza is a reliable choice for a satisfying meal.
Italian Pizzeria
8.6/10 (592 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 919-471-0664
Comfort foodGenerous portionsAmazing ranch dressing
Italian Pizzeria is a classic spot that has stood the test of time, offering comfort food that’s perfect for family outings or casual dinners. The Fettuccine Alfredo is a standout dish, with a generous portion size that ensures you won’t leave hungry. The cheese pizza is a favorite among regulars, and the salads with their amazing ranch dressing are an unexpected delight. While the decor may be a bit dated, the quality of the food and the friendly service more than make up for it.
Cugino Forno Durham
9.2/10 (277 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 919-908-0122
Authentic Neapolitan-styleImported Italian ingredientsPizza-making classes
Cugino Forno in Durham offers a unique experience with authentic Neapolitan-style pizzas. Imported Italian ingredients and ovens, along with local fresh produce, create a truly delicious and distinctive flavor. The option to take pizza-making classes adds an interactive and engaging element for all ages. Whether dining in or grabbing a frozen pizza to go, the menu is diverse and satisfying, with salads and desserts that complement the pizzas perfectly.
Italian Pizzeria
9/10 (413 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 984-219-6101
Classic pizzasEfficient serviceVariety of menu options
Italian Pizzeria truly stands out for its delicious and classic pizzas with a perfect balance of toppings and dough. The chewy yet slightly crunchy crust combined with generous cheese portions is a winning combination. The service is efficient and attentive, with employees ensuring that orders are quickly brought to tables. Additionally, the menu offers a variety of options beyond just pizza, including mouth-watering Philly cheesesteaks and a range of Italian favorites like lasagna and subs. This pizzeria is a perfect go-to spot for a quick and satisfying meal with family or friends.
Pop’s Backdoor
8.6/10 (372 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 919-493-0169
Unique toppingsFriendly serviceFresh ingredients
Pop’s Backdoor is a unique pizza joint that offers some stand-out dishes. One customer raved about the “Northerner Pizza,” which apparently features shaved beef that tastes more like a pot roast – a comforting meal for a gloomy day. The diversity in the menu shines through with options like a custom calzone, which unfortunately didn’t quite hit the mark for another diner. Despite the hit-or-miss dishes, the overall consensus seems to be positive, praising the friendly service and the freshness of the ingredients used in the pizzas. With unconventional offerings like Granny Smith apples on a pizza, Pop’s Backdoor is definitely a place to check out if you’re looking for something different in the pizza scene.
Bella Napoli pizzeria & Italian grill
8.8/10 (187 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 984-439-8118
Generous portionsFriendly serviceMouthwatering Chicago pizza
Bella Napoli pizzeria & Italian grill offers a warm and welcoming atmosphere, where customer service shines. The staff is attentive, friendly, and ensures your experience is pleasant. The portions are generous, the bread rolls served with olive oil are fresh and delicious, and the family-sized salads are value for money. But the star of the show is the Chicago-style pizza, which boasts a tantalizing cheese pull that will leave you wanting more. The crust, the sauce, the toppings – everything comes together to create a pizza experience that is simply out of this world. Whether you’re a local or a visitor, Bella Napoli is a must-visit destination for pizza aficionados looking for a memorable dining experience.
IL Forno Italian Kitchen
8.6/10 (85 reviews)
| Directions | +1 919-660-3900
Delicious pizzasFlavorful wingsCustomizable pasta
Located in the Brodhead Center at Duke, IL Forno Italian Kitchen is known for their delicious pizzas and flavorful wings. With a variety of pasta options available, diners have the opportunity to customize their order, adding a nice personal touch to their dining experience. The pizzas are a standout, making it a great spot for a quick bite, especially for those craving a yummy slice. Despite some mixed reviews on pasta dishes, the overall consensus is that this is a solid choice for a college dining option.
Durham House of Pizza
9/10 (260 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 603-868-2224
Consistent pizzasMagnificent crustFriendly service
Durham House of Pizza shines with its consistently delicious pizzas. The Mediterranean, pepperoni, and broccoli pies are standout options that never disappoint. The crust is truly magnificent, setting it apart from other pizza joints in the area. The friendly service adds to the overall dining experience, making it a go-to spot for a satisfying meal.
Pizza Mia
8.6/10 (560 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 919-294-8736
Thin crust pizzaChicken AlfredoSpeedy takeout service
Pizza Mia is a hidden gem that offers delicious pizza and other mouthwatering options like steak quesadillas and fries. The thin crust pizza stands out for its homemade taste and ample toppings, even if the pepperoni might be a bit sparse. The Chicken Alfredo is a must-try dish, and the speedy takeout service makes dining here a breeze. The friendly owner and consistently good food quality keep customers coming back for more. If you’re in the mood for a satisfying meal that won’t disappoint, give Pizza Mia a try.
The Loop Restaurant
8.6/10 (324 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 919-408-7448
Flavorful dishesGenerous portion sizesAttentive staff
Nestled in a vibrant neighborhood, The Loop Restaurant offers a delightful dining experience with generous portion sizes and flavorful dishes prepared to perfection. Whether you opt for the Cajun chicken sandwich or a cheesy white pinsa, each bite is a burst of deliciousness. The staff goes above and beyond to ensure a memorable visit, from attentive service to personalized touches like checking in on your meal. The menu caters to all preferences, making it a must-visit spot for those craving a mouthwatering meal in a cozy, inviting atmosphere.
Golden Pizza & Subs
8.8/10 (380 reviews)
| Directions | +1 919-401-4447
Homey atmosphereChicken Philly perfectionAccommodating staff
Nestled in Durham, NC, Golden Pizza & Subs offers a welcoming, homey atmosphere with a solid menu of daily specials. The chicken Philly stands out, perfectly seasoned and served in just minutes. The staff’s attention to detail and willingness to accommodate orders adds to the dining experience. While the prices may vary slightly from what’s listed online, the quality and taste of the food are well worth a visit. From crispy wings to flavorful pitas, Golden Pizza & Subs is a local gem that food enthusiasts shouldn’t miss.