Whether you’re craving a classic New York-style fold or a gourmet Neapolitan masterpiece, Elgin offers a selection of pizza spots that promise to satisfy every palate.
From crispy thin crusts adorned with local produce to hearty deep-dish wonders that ooze with molten cheese, Elgin’s pizza scene offers something to satiate every palate. This guide curates the city’s standout pizzerias, each offering a unique slice of culinary heaven.
Maciano’s Pizza & Pastaria
8.8/10 (1993 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 847-697-1400
Cracker-thin crustReal cheeseDelicious cheesecakes
Maciano’s Pizza & Pastaria offers a unique twist on traditional pizza, with a cracker-thin crust that perfectly balances the sweet sauce. The real cheese used is undeniably delicious, even if it leans on the salty side. Despite limited space inside, their focus on carryout orders ensures customers can enjoy their food comfortably at home. And let’s not forget the delightful cheesecakes, topped with caramel or berry sauce, that are sure to satisfy any sweet tooth. While the selection of beers on tap may be small, the overall experience at Maciano’s is a tasty one.
Village Pizza and Pub Elgin
8.6/10 (1347 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 847-551-1088
Rustic atmosphereDouble Decker PizzaFamily-friendly
Nestled near the Randall Road, Village Pizza and Pub Elgin offers more than just great pizza. With a rustic bar and grill vibe, this family-friendly spot boasts a southern den-style theme complete with vintage decor, an arcade for kids, and a full bar. The highlight is the 3+ story open ceiling around a fireplace, giving off a cozy barn or lodge feel. The Double Decker Pizza, stacked with two flavorful pies, is a must-try. The menu is reasonably priced, and the gluten-free options cater to all tastes. Perfect for a casual lunch or a special event, this restaurant is a hidden gem in Elgin.
Chicago Pizza Authority
9/10 (2277 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 847-742-8802
Consistent thin-crustFresh ingredientsExcellent service
Chicago Pizza Authority is the go-to spot for consistent thin-crust pizza made with fresh ingredients. The service is top-notch, with servers like Indian Joe Alverez going above and beyond for customers. The cleanliness of the restaurant is a standout, and the competitive prices make it a great value. Whether you’re dining in, getting delivery, or doing carryout, you can always count on the food being delicious and the service being excellent.
Mel’s Pizza
8.8/10 (176 reviews)
| Directions | +1 847-695-8180
Delicious deep dishCrispy wingsAffordable prices
Mel’s Pizza is a standout in Elgin for their delicious deep dish pizza, crispy wings, and impeccable service. The menu may be simple, but the flavors are anything but, with each bite leaving customers craving more. The thin crust, topped with savory sausage and gooey cheese, is a must-try for pizza lovers in the area. However, the cleanliness of the kitchen may leave some patrons feeling uneasy, overshadowing the tasty pies that Mel’s Pizza has to offer.
Geno Nottolini’s Pizza
8.6/10 (250 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 847-888-4884
Generous portionsAttentive deliveryQuality ingredients
Geno Nottolini’s Pizza offers a satisfying dining experience with generous portions that leave guests delighted and with leftovers to spare. The quality and taste of the beef, meatballs, salad, and mostaccoli shine, although some might find the cheese topping on the mostaccoli abundant. The attentive delivery driver’s willingness to go the extra mile, calling upon arrival and offering assistance, enhances the overall dining experience. Despite some inconsistencies in service and quality noted by a few customers, the overall sentiment is positive, reflecting a commitment to customer satisfaction and delicious food.
Nick’s Pizza & Pub
8.8/10 (1744 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 847-531-5550
Cozy atmosphereFriendly serviceDelicious Bruschetta pizza
Nick’s Pizza & Pub offers a warm and inviting atmosphere with a variety of food options that will please any palate. The Bruschetta pizza stands out with its perfectly crispy thin crust and burst of flavors. The rustic decor adds to the charm of the restaurant, making it a great spot for families and friends to gather. The attentive service and knowledgeable staff enhance the dining experience, with many customers praising the friendly and helpful servers. Whether you’re craving a Hawaiian pizza or some Parmesan chicken, Nick’s Pizza & Pub has something for everyone to enjoy.
Giordano’s
8.6/10 (519 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 847-841-8700
Delicious deep dishFriendly staffAuthentic Chicago flavor
Giordano’s pizza never fails to impress with their delicious deep dish pies. The crust is always spot on, the sauce is flavorful, and the gooey cheese is just the right amount of stretchy. The staff is friendly and attentive, making sure your experience is top-notch. Even if you’re not in Chicago, Giordano’s brings the authentic deep dish experience right to you, with every bite as satisfying as you’d hope.
Lou Malnati’s Pizzeria
8.6/10 (492 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 847-760-6500
Flavorful pizzasGood serviceReasonable prices
Lou Malnati’s Pizzeria is a beloved establishment known for its high-quality pizzas offered at a reasonable price. The restaurant prides itself on providing delicious deep-dish pizzas with generous toppings, garnering a loyal customer base over the years. Despite some mixed reviews, many customers rave about the flavorful pizzas they receive, especially the large pepperoni pizza with sausage pieces. Lou Malnati’s also offers good service and efficient pick-up options for those looking to enjoy their meal quickly. Ultimately, Lou Malnati’s stands out for its consistent positive experiences and commitment to delivering a tasty dining experience.
Riverside Pizza & Pub – South Elgin
9/10 (673 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 224-227-7744
Generous portionsHalf-price pizza TuesdaysTop-notch service
Nestled in South Elgin, Riverside Pizza & Pub offers a delightful dining experience for families and friends. Known for their generous portions, the California burger is a standout dish that will leave you craving more. Additionally, their half-price pizza special on Tuesdays is a steal, making it a go-to spot for delicious and affordable pizza cravings. The Southwest Salad is a popular choice, boasting a chipotle dressing that adds a flavorful kick. The service is top-notch, with friendly and efficient staff like Sara providing a welcoming atmosphere. While some dishes may vary in quality, the overall experience at Riverside Pizza & Pub is worth a visit for a satisfying meal.
Cafe Roma
9.4/10 (402 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 847-836-7662
Golden beet saladFantastic pizzaTop-notch service
Nestled in the suburbs, Cafe Roma offers a delightful Italian dining experience. The golden beet salad, fantastic pizza, and melt-in-your-mouth Tiramisu and Cannoli are standout menu items. The service is top-notch, ensuring a pleasant dining experience. Despite some misses in the menu, this family-owned establishment is a hidden gem worth a visit.
Louie Angelo’s Fast Casual Italian
8.6/10 (180 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 847-622-8000
Unique pasta dishesNon-dairy pizza optionsWarm and inviting atmosphere
Louie Angelo’s Fast Casual Italian truly shines in its unique offerings. The food is the standout here, with pasta dishes like Alfredo and lasagna being top picks among customers. The veggie panini and Napoli pizza also receive high praise. The restaurant also offers non-dairy pizza options, catering to various dietary needs. The staff is warm and inviting, creating a friendly atmosphere that feels like a family restaurant. The cheese is particularly lauded, and customers appreciate the absence of loud music, adding to the overall enjoyable dining experience.
Chicago Street Pour House
9/10 (193 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 847-214-1708
Unique Detroit pizzaFlavorful pot stickersFriendly and inviting atmosphere
Chicago Street Pour House boasts a unique atmosphere perfect for gathering with friends and enjoying a delicious meal. The Detroit style pizza, such as the all meats option, is a standout dish that customers rave about. The flavorful pot stickers with red sauce are a hit, offering a tasty side option. The menu also features daily specials, including half-price pizza Mondays, providing great value for customers. The friendly and conversational staff, along with the cozy and inviting vibe, make this spot a must-visit for game nights or casual dining. The Chicken Club Sandwich is another must-try item, according to patrons, showcasing the excellent food quality at this Elgin gem. Enjoy crispy and seasoned scoop fries alongside your meal for a satisfying dining experience. Experience the fantastic service and homemade taste at Chicago Street Pour House for a memorable meal in Dundee.