Whether you’re craving a classic New York-style fold or a gourmet Neapolitan masterpiece, Elizabeth offers a selection of pizza spots that promise to satisfy every palate.
From crispy thin crusts adorned with local produce to hearty deep-dish wonders that ooze with molten cheese, Elizabeth’s pizza scene offers something to satiate every palate. This guide curates the city’s standout pizzerias, each offering a unique slice of culinary heaven.
Bella Pizza
9.2/10 (478 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 908-352-8888
Fresh Margherita IngredientsDelicious Garlic RollsExcellent Customer Service
Bella Pizza is a go-to spot for delicious pizza in a pleasant setting. The Deep Dish Margherita Pie is a standout, with fresh ingredients that make the sauce truly delightful. The crust offers a satisfying crunch while remaining thin and firm, a perfect base for any topping. The Garlic Rolls and Cannolis are also must-tries, with flavorful breading and creamy fillings that leave you craving more. The service is personable and attentive, adding to the overall enjoyable dining experience.
LEO’S PIZZERIA
9/10 (568 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 908-355-0259
Friendly receptionReliable deliveryStandout cheesesteak
Leo’s Pizzeria stands out with their friendly reception, clean open kitchen, and reliable delivery service. Despite some mishaps with orders, the cheesesteak and pizza are standout items worth trying. The cheese pizza, priced at $11, presents a good deal, standard quality wings are a safe bet, and the lasagna receives high praise. Leo’s offers a cozy dining experience with promising food options that keep customers coming back.
Eli’s Pizza Pasta Ristorante
8.8/10 (799 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 908-436-0436
Fresh pizzaFriendly staffDelicious pasta
Located conveniently near the airport, Eli’s Pizza Pasta Ristorante offers a variety of delicious options for those in search of a satisfying meal. With fresh and tasty pizza and pasta dishes, including a cheesy Fettuccine Alfredo with perfectly cooked chicken and a phenomenal pepperoni pizza with exquisite dough and quality cheese, this spot is sure to please any discerning palate. The friendly and helpful staff, along with a good beverage selection, make for a pleasant dining experience, whether you’re on a long layover or just passing through town.
Mario’s Famous Pizza
8.6/10 (649 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 908-558-1959
Exceptional ServiceDelicious PizzaCozy Ambience
Mario’s Famous Pizza is an Italian gem nestled in New Jersey, offering top-notch service and quality food that will make you feel right at home. Whether you opt for catering or a sit-down meal, Mario’s does not disappoint. The customer service is exceptional, with staff members like Joe and Jose going above and beyond to ensure a memorable dining experience. The food itself is a standout, from savory slices of pizza to mouth-watering garlic knots. The cozy ambience and welcoming staff truly set Mario’s apart from the rest, making it a must-visit spot for Italian cuisine lovers.
Slices Pizza
8.6/10 (215 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 908-662-3322
Tasty and affordable pizzaFriendly and attentive staffSpacious dining area
Slices Pizza stands out for its tasty and affordable pizza options, as well as their friendly and attentive staff. The menu offers a variety of classic pizza choices, as well as additional options like hamburgers, garlic knots, and pizza rolls. The spacious dining area makes it a great spot to enjoy a meal with the family. Customers have praised the quality of the food, with many highlighting the delicious garlic knots and perfectly made chicken roll. It’s clear that Slices Pizza has maintained a level of consistency and excellence over the years, making it a memorable dining experience for all.
Bruno’s Pizzeria
8.8/10 (568 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 908-354-3533
Delicious pizza varietyHomemade chicken noodle soupAffordable ready-to-go slices
Bruno’s Pizzeria is delivering fantastic food, even under new ownership, according to loyal patrons. The pizza, with a variety of types to choose from, is delicious and the chicken noodle soup is just like homemade. The cheese steak is fantastic, the French fries are great, and the service is very nice. The open kitchen allows customers to see their order being made in a clean environment. The ready-to-go slices are decent in selection and quality, and it’s hard to beat the price of one plain and one specialty slice for $5.50. Customers appreciate the affordable prices and the friendly staff, making this corner pizzeria a great neighborhood spot to frequent.
Pizzeria Montevideo
9/10 (607 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 908-355-2305
Authentic Uruguayan cuisineGenerous portionsFriendly service
Pizzeria Montevideo in Elizabeth, N.J offers authentic and delicious Uruguayan food that keeps customers coming back for more. The portions are generous, and the service is friendly, adding to the overall pleasant dining experience. From the flavorful pizza to the heavenly desserts, this family-owned restaurant serves up traditional dishes that are sure to satisfy your cravings. Additionally, the staff’s hard work and dedication shine through, making you feel like a part of the Montevideo family with each visit.
Pizza Express
9/10 (131 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 908-469-9595
Fresh ingredientsExcellent customer serviceMouth-watering Hawaiian pizza
Pizza Express in Elizabeth is a hidden gem with delicious pizza that will leave you wanting more. Their buffalo chicken and pepperoni pizzas are out of this world, with fresh ingredients and a perfect crust that will satisfy any pizza craving. The small restaurant is not a sit-down spot, but the food speaks for itself with excellent customer service from the friendly employees. And don’t miss out on trying their mouth-watering Hawaiian pizza; it’s truly the best in the area. You won’t be disappointed at Pizza Express!
John’s Caffe Pizza & Caterers
9/10 (574 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 908-354-5260
Bold flavorsVariety of optionsCozy atmosphere
John’s Caffe Pizza & Caterers is a must-visit spot in Elizabeth, offering a variety of delicious options like the cheesesteak pie, Buffalo chicken pie, meat lovers, garlic knots, and Sicilian pie. The flavors are bold and the quality is consistently top-notch, making it a favorite among locals and visitors alike. The menu also includes a range of options beyond pizza, such as burgers and pasta dishes that are equally impressive. The attentive staff and cozy atmosphere add to the overall experience, making John’s Caffe a standout choice for a satisfying meal.
New York Fried Chicken & Pizza (Halal)
8.6/10 (2077 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 908-527-0061
Delicious pizzaConvenient 24-hour availabilityExcellent customer service
New York Fried Chicken & Pizza (Halal) offers a delicious array of food options, including well-done rice and tasty chicken with white sauce. The falafel may not be the most authentic, but the pizza is an absolute standout. With a convenient location near the airport and 24-hour availability, this restaurant is a gem for those looking for a satisfying meal any time of day. The customer service is top-notch, with a quick-moving line and attentive staff members ensuring a pleasant dining experience for all patrons.
Michelinos
8.8/10 (1282 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 908-355-8393
Unique buffalo chicken pizzaBeef pepperoni optionExceptional customer service
Nestled in Rahway, Michelinos is a hidden gem offering a variety of delicious food options that keep customers coming back for more. The buffalo chicken pizza is a definite standout item, with a unique flavor that sets it apart from others in the area. But it’s not just the pizza that impresses – the beef pepperoni is a rare find for those looking for non-pork options, adding an extra layer of variety to their menu. The owner, John, goes above and beyond to ensure customer satisfaction, even personally delivering a fresh pie when an order was mistakenly made plain. It’s this dedication to quality and customer service that truly sets Michelinos apart from the rest.
Jersey Pizza USA
9/10 (331 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 908-955-8021
Fresh ingredientsImpeccable serviceHidden gem
Jersey Pizza USA truly shines in the realm of fresh, tasty pizza and impeccable service. The pizza is absolutely amazing, with fresh ingredients and a flavor that keeps getting better with each bite. The wings are fried to perfection, and the prices are just as good as the food. The staff goes above and beyond to ensure each pizza is made to perfection, being both caring and attentive. This spot is a hidden gem compared to other late-night pizza joints, and it’s definitely worth a visit for some of the best pizza you’ll find in the area.
Santillo’s Brick Oven Pizza
8.6/10 (1072 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 908-354-1887
Thin crust balanceFresh, flavorful ingredientsCustomizable menu options
Nestled in Elizabeth, Santillo’s Brick Oven Pizza serves up exceptional, well-done pizza that is as thin as can be while still maintaining structural integrity. Whether indulging in the 1957 Style Pizza Extra Thin or savoring the white pizza with creamy ricotta, every bite is a flavorful experience worth savoring. The absence of dine-in service may be a downside for some, but the care and dedication put into each pie by Al Santillo, a man of over 100 years of experience, make this pizzeria a local institution with a national reputation. From the customizable menu to the quality ingredients, Santillo’s is a must-visit for those seeking true authentic pizza.
Jerusalem Restaurant
8.6/10 (181 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 908-293-7394
Kosher pizza piesPrepared Kosher dishesFriendly staff
Nestled in the heart of town, Jerusalem Restaurant offers a unique dining experience with its selection of kosher pizza pies and prepared dishes. The freshly made pizzas feature generous toppings and crispy crusts, with options like mushroom and white ricotta spinach slices that are sure to satisfy any pizza lover. The clean and welcoming atmosphere, along with friendly staff members, create a comfortable setting to enjoy a casual meal. Whether you’re in the mood for a classic cheese pizza or a more adventurous breaded eggplant and spinach slice, Jerusalem Restaurant has something for everyone. The affordable prices make it a great spot for a quick and tasty meal, perfect for both locals and visitors alike.