18 Best Pizza Spots in Evansville, IN

Whether you’re craving a classic New York-style fold or a gourmet Neapolitan masterpiece, Evansville offers a selection of pizza spots that promise to satisfy every palate.

From crispy thin crusts adorned with local produce to hearty deep-dish wonders that ooze with molten cheese, Evansville’s pizza scene offers something to satiate every palate. This guide curates the city’s standout pizzerias, each offering a unique slice of culinary heaven.

Turoni’s Pizzery & Brewery – Forget Me Not

9.2/10 (1517 reviews)

Website | Directions | +1 812-477-7500

Exquisite crustMeticulously cut ingredientsCheesy bread perfection

Turoni’s Pizzery & Brewery – Forget Me Not truly shines with its exquisite crust that perfectly holds the sauce, preventing any sogginess. The ingredients are meticulously cut and expertly combined to create a delectable pizza experience that can only be described as art. Their cheesy bread, made with actual bread pieces, is a standout menu item that’s a must-try. The cozy atmosphere, enhanced by dim lighting and nostalgic decor, adds an extra layer of charm to the dining experience at Turoni’s.

Franklin St. Pizza Factory and “The Sterling Room “

9.2/10 (953 reviews)

Website | Directions | +1 812-602-3028

Generous ToppingsOutdoor SeatingSteampunk Vibe

Franklin St. Pizza Factory offers a unique pizza experience with their thin crust and generous toppings. The emphasis on veggies and meat rather than sauce might not be for everyone, but for those looking for a filling and flavorful pizza, this is the place to be. The outdoor seating is a nice touch, offering a cozy date night or hangout spot. The customer service is top-notch, with quick turnaround times in the kitchen and friendly wait staff. The vibe of the restaurant is a mix of steampunk and class, adding to the overall experience of dining at Franklin St. Pizza Factory.

Deerhead Pizza

9/10 (778 reviews)

| Directions | +1 812-425-2515

Crispy thin crustUnique checkerboard cutDelicious double decker pizza

Deerhead Pizza is a local treasure in Evansville, offering delicious pizza with a crispy thin crust that has a touch of sweetness. The unique checkerboard pizza cut style for easy sharing adds to the experience. The diverse menu includes options like the Greek salad and soulvakia, with flavors that are truly fantastic. The double decker pizza is a must-try, stuffed with generous toppings and served with delicious pizza sauce on the side. Deerhead Pizza’s commitment to quality and flavor ensures a memorable dining experience every time.

Pizza King | Evansville, IN

8.6/10 (584 reviews)

Website | Directions | +1 812-424-7976

Delicious StromboliKing Skins surpriseFriendly service

Pizza King in Evansville, IN is a local gem known for its delicious and fresh Stromboli. The ham & cheese Stromboli is a standout, with flavor that hits all the right notes. The restaurant’s King Skins potato skins are a must-try, surprising diners with their quality and taste. Miss Jaimie LeAnn, known for her warm and welcoming demeanor, adds a personal touch to the overall experience. If you’re in town, make sure to grab a Stromboli and savor the flavors at Pizza King.

Turoni’s Pizzery & Brewery

9.2/10 (1067 reviews)

Website | Directions | +1 812-424-9871

Thin cracker crustCold beer selectionOld-fashioned interior

Located on the historic Main St. in Evansville, Turoni’s Pizzery & Brewery offers a unique pizza experience that transports diners to a different era. The thin cracker crust pizzas, loaded with fresh toppings, are the standout items on the menu, perfectly complemented by a selection of cold macro and micro-brew beers. The old-fashioned interior and attentive service add to the overall charm of the restaurant, making it a must-visit destination for anyone craving delicious pizza and a relaxed atmosphere.

Azzip Pizza

9.4/10 (1068 reviews)

Website | Directions | +1 812-401-3572

Quick serviceFresh and hot pizzasNice patio area

Azzip Pizza is not your typical pizza place – it’s like the subway of pizza, where you can order and be out in just a few minutes. The employees are nice and engaging, and it’s fun to watch them make your pizza. The selection is awesome, with a variety of sauces, meats, veggies, and sizes to choose from to create the pizza of your desire. The pizzas come out fresh and hot, tasting very good. The West side location has quick service and a nice patio area for outside seating. The dining room is kept clean, providing a good pizza experience.

Lombardi’s New York Pizza & Wings

9.2/10 (341 reviews)

Website | Directions | +1 812-602-5255

Perfect crustFresh ingredientsSecret menu item

Nestled in Evansville, Lombardi’s New York Pizza & Wings offers a taste of the Big Apple right in Indiana. The New York-style pizza stands out with its perfect crust, much better than any chain can offer. The garlic knots are a fan-favorite, and the menu even features a secret item that loyal customers swear by. The Stromboli and Chicken Alfredo are must-tries, made with fresh, hand-rolled ingredients that elevate every bite. Whether you’re grabbing a slice to go or settling in for a meal, Lombardi’s is a hidden gem not to be missed.

Azzip Pizza

9.4/10 (1272 reviews)

Website | Directions | +1 812-901-0490

Customizable thin-crustConsistent tasteFamily-friendly atmosphere

Azzip Pizza is a must-visit in Evansville for a reason. The ability to customize your own thin-crust pizza with a quick turnaround time is truly impressive. The consistency in taste over the years is a testament to their commitment to quality. While some locations may skimp on toppings, the West Side Azzip is the one to go to for a fully loaded pizza experience. The family-friendly atmosphere, excellent staff, and variety of options make it a great choice for a casual meal. The only drawback seems to be occasional issues with burnt pizzas at certain locations, so it might be worth checking in on your order to ensure a perfect pie. With Azzip, the delicious offerings and welcoming environment make it a top choice for pizza lovers in the area.

Spankey’s Una Pizza

9/10 (895 reviews)

Website | Directions | +1 812-402-6776

Wide variety toppingsDelicious crustExcellent service

Spankey’s Una Pizza offers a cozy, family-friendly atmosphere with cute touches like coloring pages for the kids and real flowers on the tables. The pizza is highlighted by a wide variety of toppings and a delicious crust. Customers rave about the cheesy bread and the option of gluten-free and cauliflower crust. The excellent service rounds out the dining experience, making Spankey’s a must-visit for delicious pizza and sandwiches.

Dontae’s Highland Pizza Parlor

9.2/10 (435 reviews)

Website | Directions | +1 812-777-0016

Crispy crustFlavorful toppingsClean and welcoming atmosphere

Dontae’s Highland Pizza Parlor is a locally owned gem that offers delicious pizza and a welcoming atmosphere. The crispy crust and flavorful toppings make the pizzas a standout, and the garlic cheese bread is a must-try. The restaurant’s clean and well-kept interior adds to the overall experience, while the fun kids games in the back are a bonus for families looking to enjoy a meal together. With fast and friendly service, Dontae’s Highland Pizza Parlor is a great spot for a casual and enjoyable dining experience.

Kipplee’s

8.8/10 (1055 reviews)

Website | Directions | +1 812-476-1936

Delicious pizzaLively atmosphereFamily-friendly

Nestled in the heart of town, Kipplee’s is a local gem that boasts delicious food and a lively atmosphere. The menu offers a variety of options, from mouth-watering pizzas to savory sandwiches. The Grilled Chicken Sandwich and wings are must-tries, guaranteed to satisfy any craving. The family-friendly restaurant caters to all ages, with a game room for kids and a cozy bar area perfect for a date night or catching up with friends. With a welcoming staff and a Hoosier twist, Kipplee’s is a fun spot to enjoy good food and good company.

Azzip Pizza

9.4/10 (260 reviews)

Website | Directions | +1 812-250-8947

Wide dietary optionsGenerous portionsAttentive staff

Azzip Pizza offers a unique dining experience with a wide range of options suitable for all dietary restrictions. The square cheese bread is a must-try, and their plant-based meats and cheese have great taste. The staff is quick, helpful, and thoughtful, making sure to accommodate any allergy needs. The portions are generous, and the variety of choices is impressive. The only downside mentioned in reviews was the loud music, but overall, Azzip Pizza provides an upbeat and enjoyable dining experience.

Rounders Pizza

8.8/10 (229 reviews)

Website | Directions | +1 812-424-4960

Unique pizza optionsExcellent serviceCozy atmosphere

Rounders Pizza is a hidden gem, offering delicious and unique pizza options at great prices. The hot ham and cheese is a must-try, while the Nameless pizza will leave you craving for more. The owner and staff go above and beyond to provide excellent service, making you feel right at home. The cozy atmosphere, complete with big TVs and tasty finger bread, creates the perfect setting for a casual dining experience. If you’re in the mood for a mouthwatering pizza and friendly service, Rounders Pizza is the place to be.

Noble Roman’s Craft Pizza & Pub

8.8/10 (242 reviews)

Website | Directions | +1 812-303-4010

Delicious breadsticksFlavorful Big Daddy BBQ pizzaRoot beer on tap

Noble Roman’s Craft Pizza & Pub offers a unique dining experience with its delicious breadsticks, top-notch ingredients, and flavorful pizza options. Customers rave about the breadsticks, describing them as a must-try item that never disappoints. The Big Daddy BBQ pizza stands out with its caramelized edges and standout cheddar cheese. The root beer on tap adds a fun touch to the dining experience. While some customers have noted occasional issues with service or specific menu items, overall, Noble Roman’s Craft Pizza & Pub is a hidden gem on the west side worth visiting for a satisfying meal.

Noble Roman’s

9/10 (190 reviews)

Website | Directions | +1 812-473-4606

Nostalgic atmosphereDelicious personal pan pizzasFriendly staff

Noble Roman’s is a nostalgia-inducing spot that has been serving up delicious pizza and breadsticks for decades. The personal pan pizzas are perfect for a quick bite, and the breadsticks with cheese sauce are a must-try. The staff take pride in their food, ensuring every meal is fresh and delicious. The atmosphere is cozy, with large screen TVs for sports viewing, making it a great spot to enjoy a meal with family or friends.

Pangea Kitchen

9.4/10 (1182 reviews)

Website | Directions | +1 812-401-2404

Unique Detroit-stylePrompt online ordersVaried, quality menu

Pangea Kitchen is a hidden gem in the pizza scene, offering delicious Detroit style options that are sure to please even the pickiest of pizza aficionados. The service is top-notch, with online orders arriving promptly and a friendly staff that goes above and beyond to ensure a great dining experience. The menu is varied, with standout dishes like the Pistachio pizza and Drunken Noodles that keep customers coming back for more. Despite a few misses, the quality and unique offerings at Pangea Kitchen make it a must-visit spot in town.

K’s Pizza

8.8/10 (55 reviews)

Website | Directions | +1 812-303-2381

Generous StromboliFriendly serviceMouthwatering chicken Philly cheesesteak

K’s Pizza in Evansville is quickly becoming a local favorite for its mouthwatering menu offerings. The chicken Philly cheesesteak has been raved about by many first-time customers, with one patron even calling it one of the best they’ve ever had. The Hawaiian pizza may be a bit light on the toppings, but it still manages to impress with its flavors. The Stromboli is a standout, offering a generous serving that is sure to satisfy any appetite. While the garlic cheese bread may not be everyone’s cup of tea, the cheese itself is top-notch. And though some may find the pizza sauce a bit on the sweeter side, it still manages to hit the spot for many. Prices are reasonable and the service is friendly, making K’s Pizza a must-visit spot in Evansville.

Pangea Pizzeria

9.6/10 (63 reviews)

Website | Directions | +1 812-401-2500

Unique flavorsFriendly staffInviting atmosphere

Pangea Pizzeria is a hidden gem in town, serving up thin crust pizzas with unique flavors that set them apart from the rest. The pepperoni pizza is a standout with a generous amount of thick-cut pepperoni and a hint of honey sauce that adds a delicious twist. The seasoned breadsticks are a great indicator of the bold flavors to come in the pizza. The atmosphere is inviting, the staff is friendly, and the gelato is a perfect ending to the meal. Prices are a bit on the higher side, but the quality and portion sizes make it worth it. Great spot for a pizza lover looking for something different.