Whether you’re craving a classic New York-style fold or a gourmet Neapolitan masterpiece, Fayetteville offers a selection of pizza spots that promise to satisfy every palate.
From crispy thin crusts adorned with local produce to hearty deep-dish wonders that ooze with molten cheese, Fayetteville’s pizza scene offers something to satiate every palate. This guide curates the city’s standout pizzerias, each offering a unique slice of culinary heaven.
Pizza Palace Italian Restaurant
9.2/10 (1060 reviews)
| Directions | +1 910-424-4657
Chicken Alfredo PizzaSteak and Cheese SubSpaghetti Deluxe
Pizza Palace Italian Restaurant offers a mix of traditional and unique dishes that will satisfy any craving. The chicken alfredo pizza is a standout item with its delicious flavor. The steak and cheese sub is also highly recommended, served hot and fresh. The Spaghetti Deluxe is a hearty portion that will leave you feeling satisfied. The restaurant’s welcoming atmosphere and attentive service make for an enjoyable dining experience. Don’t forget to try the homemade ranch dressing, a fan favorite. With a wide variety of menu options, from pizzas to calzones to burgers, there’s something for everyone at Pizza Palace.
Elizabeth’s Pizza & Restaurant
8.6/10 (1252 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 910-487-0588
Flavorful Brooklyn-style pizzasCustomizable menu optionsConvenient attached bar and dessert shop
Nestled in a quiet neighborhood, Elizabeth’s Pizza & Restaurant has perfected the art of crafting thin Brooklyn-style pizzas that are both flavorful and cheesy. The Deluxe pizza, adorned with fresh basil, packs a delightful punch, while the Vegetarian pizza can be customized to your liking, ensuring a satisfying meal. The convenience of a bar and dessert/coffee shop attached to the restaurant adds an extra layer of enjoyment, allowing patrons to pair their pizza with a cold beer or a sweet treat. Despite any shortcomings in the ambience department, Elizabeth’s dedication to delicious pies shines through, making it a must-visit spot for pizza aficionados.
Mellow Mushroom Fayetteville
8.8/10 (2021 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 910-779-2442
Expansive menuGluten-free optionsInviting environment
Mellow Mushroom Fayetteville offers a unique and delightful dining experience that stands out from other pizza places. The menu is expansive, with gluten-free options that cater to a variety of preferences. The drink selection is impressive, and the environment is inviting and well taken care of. The Jamaican jerk sub adds a flavorful twist to the traditional fare, and the prices are reasonable, making it a great spot for families and pizza lovers alike.
Brooklyn Pizzeria
8.6/10 (993 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 910-491-4585
Thin, crispy crustFlavorful toppingsFriendly staff
Nestled in Hope Mills, Brooklyn Pizzeria is a hidden gem for pizza enthusiasts. The house special pizza is a must-try with its thin, crispy crust and flavorful toppings. The veggie Stromboli is also a hit, packed with fresh ingredients. The friendly and accommodating staff add to the overall enjoyable experience, making it a go-to spot for both locals and visitors. The bustling atmosphere and visible kitchen give customers a firsthand look at the pizza-making process, adding an extra layer of excitement to the dining experience.
Little Italy Pizzeria and Restaurant
8.6/10 (1114 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 910-867-8700
Reasonable pricesFresh ingredientsGluten-free options
Nestled in the heart of Fayetteville, Little Italy Pizzeria and Restaurant has been serving up delectable Italian delights that keep customers coming back for more. The menu offers a variety of options, from classic Sicilian pan pizzas to flavorful chicken Stromboli. One standout feature is the customization available for those with dietary restrictions, ensuring everyone can enjoy a delicious meal. The ambiance enhances the dining experience, with light Italian music playing in the background and impeccable service from the friendly staff. For those seeking a romantic spot for a special evening out, Little Italy Pizzeria and Restaurant delivers an unforgettable dining experience.
Gusto Napoletano Italian Restaurant and Pizzeria
9.2/10 (267 reviews)
| Directions | +1 910-779-0622
Authentic flavorsBrick oven pizzasCurated wine selection
Review: At Gusto Napoletano Italian Restaurant and Pizzeria, the flavors truly transport you to Italy. The brick oven taste of their pizzas is unmatched, with a Margherita pizza that is a standout favorite. The owner’s dedication to authentic Italian cuisine shines through in the attention to detail in each dish. The wine selection is carefully curated, adding to the overall dining experience. While the pricing may be on the higher side, the quality of the food and the welcoming ambiance make it worth a visit. You’ll leave feeling like you’ve just dined in Italy itself.
Primo Pizza
8.8/10 (226 reviews)
| Directions | +1 910-864-6360
Authentic NY sliceFresh, thin crustFriendly and accurate staff
Primo Pizza lives up to its reputation as one of the best spots for a classic NY slice. The fresh, thin crust, high-quality cheese, and tasty sauce all come together to create a delicious slice that passes the test for any pizza purist. While the mall prices may be a bit steep, the flavor and quality of the pizza make it worth every penny. The friendly and accurate staff ensure that your order is made to your liking, whether you’re a New York native or a pizza lover from anywhere else.
Capri Italian Restaurant & Pizzeria
8.8/10 (343 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 910-779-2622
Perfect pizza doughHouse-made sauceFriendly, attentive staff
Capri Italian Restaurant & Pizzeria in Fayetteville is a hidden gem serving up some of the best pizza and Italian cuisine in town. The dough is perfect – firm enough to hold toppings but foldable without making a mess. The house-made sauce is not too sweet, just right. The garlic parmesan wings are crisp and juicy, and the tiramisu is a heavenly way to end the meal. The staff, including the real Italians in the kitchen, are friendly and attentive, making you feel right at home. With reasonable prices and a cozy ambiance, Capri is a must-visit for pizza lovers in the area.
Romeo’s Pizza
9/10 (94 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 910-912-6200
Wide pizza selectionFriendly staffQuality food
Nestled within the Walmart plaza, Romeo’s Pizza offers a wide selection of mouthwatering options to satisfy your pizza cravings. From their indulgent deep dish pizzas to their cheesy breadsticks, every bite is a delight. The staff at Romeo’s, including Customer Relations Manager Lynn Lacourse, radiates positivity and friendliness, making the dining experience even more enjoyable. While some may find the sweet sauce intriguing, others may wish for thicker pepperoni slices. Nevertheless, the impeccable service and top-notch quality of food make Romeo’s Pizza a must-visit spot for pizza enthusiasts in North Carolina.
Pizza Time
8.6/10 (118 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 910-263-8265
Varied menuDelicious pizzaFriendly staff
Pizza Time is a must-visit spot for those craving a delicious and satisfying meal. The owners are kind and welcoming, making the dining experience even more enjoyable. The extensive menu offers a variety of options, with the food coming out in a timely manner. The pizza, especially the Deluxe thin crust option, is flavorful and well-made, reminding me of the pies in NYC. The gyro pizza and buffalo wings were also a hit, with the staff providing excellent service. While some may find the speed of the drive-thru lacking, the prices and quality of the food make Pizza Time a top choice for a satisfying meal.
Elizabeth’s Pizza And Italian Restaurant
8.6/10 (1806 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 910-424-2848
Excellent flavor profilesHospitable and attentive serviceQuick QR code payment
Elizabeth’s Pizza And Italian Restaurant offers an array of delicious dishes with excellent flavor profiles that aren’t overly salty. The staff is hospitable and attentive, providing a warm welcoming atmosphere without any hint of rushing even close to closing time. The calamari is a fan-favorite, while the pasta white clam sauce and ricotta pistachio cake are standout menu items. The service is top-notch, with servers like Page and Zach going above and beyond to ensure a memorable dining experience. The option for QR code payment and minimal wait times on busy nights add to the convenience of dining at this establishment.
Antonella’s Italian Ristorante
9.2/10 (1172 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 910-486-0046
Blue crab ravioliAttentive serviceIntimate atmosphere
Antonella’s Italian Ristorante in Fayetteville offers a delightful dining experience with a charming pet-friendly patio and delicious food. The blue crab ravioli and mango martini are standout dishes that customers rave about. The attentive and knowledgeable servers, like Susan and Andrew, go above and beyond to make guests feel welcome. The osso buco and mango martini are must-try items that will leave you craving for more. The intimate atmosphere and friendly staff make Antonella’s a top choice for a memorable meal in the heart of Fayetteville.
Brooklyn Pizzeria
9/10 (1059 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 910-436-5666
Unique flavorGenerous toppingsGarlic knots
Brooklyn Pizzeria is a must-visit for pizza lovers seeking a unique and satisfying experience. The crust, sauce, and cheese blend together perfectly, creating a mouthwatering combination that keeps customers coming back for more. The Brooklyn Special pizza is a standout, offering ample toppings and flavor that is simply unbeatable. The garlic knots, while small, are packed with deliciousness and are perfect for indulging in a snack. Despite a few minor setbacks like oily pizza and tiny wings, the overall experience at Brooklyn Pizzeria is one worth savoring.
Bubba’s 33
8.8/10 (3757 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 910-223-2601
Flavorful foodExcellent wait staffLively atmosphere
Bubba’s 33 is a thriving sports bar with a diverse menu and great atmosphere. The food, including burgers, chicken tenders, tots, and wings, was juicy and flavorful. The fried pickles were a bit too salty for some, but the twisted mozzarella sticks and wings did not disappoint. The wait staff was excellent – professional, polite, and punctual with drinks. Families seemed to enjoy their time together in this lively setting. The decor was nice and there were plenty of TVs throughout, although some may find the music too loud. The only downside seemed to be long wait times and a potential issue with food allergies.
Blue Moon Cafe
9/10 (885 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 910-860-4700
Friendly serviceCreative dishesHidden gem
Blue Moon Cafe is hands down the best spot for brunch in town. The staff is kind, helpful, and awesome, making the experience exceptional. The Smoked Salmon Devil Eggs, Breakfast Tacos, and seasonal French toast, made with croissants, are must-tries. The service is prompt, the dishes are creative, and the food is next-level excellent, ensuring a pleasant dining experience. The cozy spot is a hidden gem, with fast service and delicious offerings that make it worth a visit.
Olea Mediterranean Kitchen
9.2/10 (1507 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 910-745-8415
Fresh flavorsFriendly staffQuick service
Olea Mediterranean Kitchen offers a warm and inviting atmosphere with absolutely wonderful food. The speed at which the food comes out is impressive, especially for a sit-down restaurant. The staff are friendly and helpful, and the flavors of the home-cooked dishes are reminiscent of a Mediterranean vacation. The chicken shawarma is recommended, along with the sampler platter and shawarma platter. The grape leaves and Baklava are also standout dishes that are always fresh and delicious.
Zorba’s Gyro
9/10 (1644 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 910-484-1010
Delicious foodFriendly staffReasonable prices
Zorba’s Gyro is a hidden gem with delicious food at reasonable prices, making it a local favorite. The staff is incredibly friendly, providing excellent service and helpful recommendations on the menu items. The variety of options, including gyros, sandwiches, spaghetti, and baklava, all receive high marks from satisfied diners. The cozy ambiance and open concept seating contribute to a welcoming and family-friendly atmosphere. Despite some minor issues with the parking lot, location, and dining room seating, Zorba’s Gyro remains a go-to spot for flavorful meals and attentive service.
George Garden
9.6/10 (602 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 910-491-6433
Intimate ambianceFlavorful Mediterranean dishesOwner’s dedication to customer satisfaction
George Garden is a small, cozy spot with a welcoming ambiance that appeals to those seeking a more intimate dining experience. The gyro pizza is a standout dish, boasting a generous portion of 5 cheeses without a trace of tomato sauce, topped with flavorful tzatziki sauce. Despite the occasional mishap with overcooked baked potatoes and uncooked mozzarella sticks, the Alfredo chicken pizza is a hit among kids for its unique twist. The owner’s dedication to customer satisfaction shines through, as seen in his quick response to feedback and willingness to go above and beyond to ensure a pleasant dining experience. George Garden’s Mediterranean offerings, such as the lamb gyro and steak shawarma wrap, are flavorful and satisfying, promising a return visit for those craving authentic cuisine.