Home / United States / Colorado / Fort Collins

Get more leads!

Get featured here for 6 months.

18 Best Pizza Spots in Fort Collins, CO

Whether you’re craving a classic New York-style fold or a gourmet Neapolitan masterpiece, Fort Collins offers a selection of pizza spots that promise to satisfy every palate.

From crispy thin crusts adorned with local produce to hearty deep-dish wonders that ooze with molten cheese, Fort Collins’s pizza scene offers something to satiate every palate. This guide curates the city’s standout pizzerias, each offering a unique slice of culinary heaven.


Beau Jo’s Fort Collins

8.6/10 (2711 reviews)

Website | Directions | +1 970-498-8898

Gluten-free optionsWarm and friendly serviceFlavorful sausage combo pizza

Beau Jo’s Fort Collins truly stands out in the realm of pizzerias. Their commitment to accommodating dietary restrictions, such as offering a delicious cauliflower crust option, is commendable. The expansive gluten-free menu is perfect for mixed groups, ensuring everyone can enjoy a tasty meal together. The dedication to providing quality service, as experienced through the warm and friendly manager Candace, enhances the overall dining experience. Despite a slightly higher cost, the exceptional cuisine, like the flavorful sausage combo pizza, more than makes up for it. The unique touch of honey provided at each table to drizzle on the crust adds an unexpected and delightful twist to the meal, making a visit to Beau Jo’s Fort Collins well worth it.


Totally 80’s Pizza & Museum

9.4/10 (1781 reviews)

Website | Directions | +1 970-867-5309

Nostalgic atmospherePersonal-sized pizzasUnique toppings

Totally 80’s Pizza & Museum offers a delightful trip down memory lane with its charming 80’s atmosphere and delectable pizza options. The attention to detail in the decor, filled with vintage memorabilia and classic music videos playing in the background, creates a nostalgic vibe that truly sets this place apart. The personal-sized pizzas are a clever touch, allowing everyone to customize their order. The menu offers a wide variety of specialty pizzas, like the Yippe Ki Yay Mother Clucker, with unique toppings that add a twist to classic flavors. The pizza crust is soft and flavorful, making each slice a satisfying experience. The addition of a penny-press machine and a Zoltar fortune teller adds to the fun and quirky ambiance of this gem of a restaurant.


Slyce Pizza Co.

9.2/10 (1309 reviews)

Website | Directions | +1 970-221-9000

Expansive pizza selectionInnovative combinationsVegan options

Slyce Pizza Co. has garnered a loyal following with its expansive pizza selection, from unique creations like macaroni and pickle pizzas to classic favorites like pepperoni and sausage. The variety of toppings and the innovative combinations set Slyce apart from other pizza joints in Fort Collins. The robust tomato sauce and tasty ingredients shine in every bite, and the dough, while occasionally sporting a burnt crust, generally delivers a decent flavor. The vegan options, like the Tri Veg with vegan cheese and pretzel crust, offer a tasty alternative for plant-based eaters. And let’s not forget the standout hot pepper flakes that pack a spicy punch, adding an extra kick to every slice.


The Corner Slice

9.2/10 (168 reviews)

Website | Directions | +1 970-698-6057

Consistent flavorsUnique in-house sodasAttentive staff

The Corner Slice truly stands out in Fort Collins, offering consistent, delicious pizza with simple yet amazing flavors. The in-house sodas are unique and complement the food perfectly. The staff is attentive and friendly, creating a welcoming atmosphere for guests. Live music nights and daily specials only add to the charm of this cozy pizza joint, making it a must-visit for all pizza lovers.


Panhandler’s Pizza – Fort Collins, CO

8.6/10 (805 reviews)

Website | Directions | +1 970-232-9328

Delicious deep dishExcellent vegan optionsFun atmosphere

Panhandler’s Pizza in Fort Collins has been a beloved staple for over 30 years and continues to serve up some of the best deep dish pizza in town. The Dsayuno breakfast pizza, with its generous toppings and gooey cheese, is a clear favorite among customers. Not to mention, the restaurant offers exceptional vegan and plant-based options, making it a go-to spot for those with special dietary needs. The Lovehandler thin crust pizza is another standout, and the fun atmosphere with live music adds to the overall dining experience.


JJ’s Wood Fired Pizza

9.2/10 (737 reviews)

Website | Directions | +1 970-286-2501

Flavorful wood-fired pizzaExtensive beer selectionQuality gluten-free option

Nestled in Fort Collins, JJ’s Wood Fired Pizza has become a destination for both locals and those willing to travel for good eats. The clean and open atmosphere makes it the perfect spot for families, while the pizza itself shines with just the right amount of toppings and flavors. The gluten-free option stands out for its quality, a welcomed departure from typical cardboard-like alternatives. Despite some small hiccups, like slightly light spice and the occasional freshness issue with salads, JJ’s dedication to quality food and good service make it a worthy stop for any pizza lover.


Pizza Casbah

8.6/10 (1036 reviews)

Website | Directions | +1 970-221-9144

Savory Handcrafted PiesCozy SettingGourmet Creations


Krazy Karl’s Pizza and Sport Bar

8.6/10 (1786 reviews)

Website | Directions | +1 970-224-2000

Mouth-watering pizzasOutstanding customer serviceWide beer selection

Krazy Karl’s Pizza and Sport Bar is a hidden gem, offering mouth-watering pizzas with a wide selection of toppings. The pizza showcases a perfect balance of flavors with every bite, making it a delightful experience for your taste buds. The beer selection is commendable, and the service is top-notch, with attentive staff who go above and beyond to ensure a pleasant dining experience.


Krazy Karl’s Pizza and Sports Bar

8.6/10 (1512 reviews)

Website | Directions | +1 970-223-8600

Flavorful toppingsGluten and dairy-free optionsFriendly and attentive staff

Upon first visit to Krazy Karl’s Pizza and Sports Bar, the pizza blew me away with its unique and flavorful toppings that were both plentiful and delicious. The Italia pizza had a crust that was simply amazing, showcasing the quality and attention to detail that goes into creating each pie. Additionally, the gluten and dairy-free options offered here are a rare find, providing inclusive choices for those with dietary restrictions. Despite the occasional longer wait times for orders, the exceptional workers and friendly staff make the overall experience enjoyable and worth it. The bustling atmosphere and dedication to providing diverse menu options solidify Krazy Karl’s as a must-visit pizza destination.


otto PINT

8.8/10 (1312 reviews)

Website | Directions | +1 970-226-1464

House-made crispy crustSavory duck and burrata comboFresh arugula garnish

As you step into otto PINT, you’re welcomed by a symphony of flavors that are sure to tantalize your taste buds. The crispy, flavorful thin crust pizza is a true standout, with house-made dough boasting a perfect balance of smokiness and char. The star of the show, however, is the burrata and duck pizza, where tender, savory duck and creamy, luxurious burrata come together in a perfect harmony of textures and tastes. Each bite is a burst of juicy goodness, complemented by a vibrant tomato sauce that adds a touch of sweetness and tanginess. The addition of fresh arugula or baby spinach provides a peppery bite and refreshing finish, completing this culinary masterpiece.


Mama Roni’s Pizza

8.6/10 (319 reviews)

Website | Directions | +1 970-224-9000

Tasty pizzaAccommodating serviceKind gestures

Mama Roni’s Pizza is a spot that prides itself on serving up delicious pies and providing top-notch service. Despite some inconsistencies mentioned in a few reviews, it’s clear that many customers have had positive experiences with the food and staff at this pizza joint. With a variety of options to choose from, Mama Roni’s is known for its tasty pizzas, hot wings, and accommodating service. It’s the kind gestures, like helping out a customer on crutches or making things right when there’s an error, that truly set this place apart. Whether you’re dining in, picking up, or getting delivery, Mama Roni’s aims to please and make sure you leave satisfied.


D.P. Dough

8.6/10 (704 reviews)

Website | Directions | +1 970-224-0202

Unique calzonesTasty flavorsPrompt service

D.P. Dough stands out with their unique calzones that are more than just folded pizzas. Despite some instances of inconsistency in portion sizes and long wait times, the flavors remain top-notch. Some customers have raised concerns about the lack of attention to detail, hygiene practices, and overall customer service. For those seeking a satisfying calzone experience, D.P. Dough is worth a visit, but be mindful of potential drawbacks.


Panino’s Italian Restaurant

8.8/10 (744 reviews)

Website | Directions | +1 970-498-8292

Delicious pizzasFriendly staffHidden gem

Nestled in a cozy setting, Panino’s Italian Restaurant offers a delightful dining experience for those seeking traditional Italian fare. The menu boasts a variety of delicious options, from classic pizzas to flavorful pastas. The staff, including waitress Shelby W, is attentive and eager to assist with any dietary restrictions, such as gluten sensitivity. While the portion sizes may vary, the quality of the food is undeniable. With generous serving sizes and friendly service, Panino’s is a hidden gem worth returning to.


Oregano’s

9/10 (1713 reviews)

Website | Directions | +1 970-449-6121

Varied menuAttentive staffCozy decor

Oregano’s offers a variety of delicious choices from pizza to pasta, salads, and more. The portion sizes are substantial, ensuring you get your money’s worth. The staff is attentive and accommodating, creating a welcoming atmosphere. The cozy decor adds to the overall dining experience, making it a great spot to visit with friends and family for a satisfying meal. While the ambience and service are top-notch, some may find the prices slightly high for drinks, but overall, Oregano’s is a must-visit for those looking for a tasty meal in a pleasant setting.


Nick’s Restaurant And Bar

8.8/10 (1328 reviews)

Website | Directions | +1 970-631-8301

Flavorful sandwichesAmazing tomato sauceTop-notch service

Nestled on College Avenue between Prospect and Laurel, Nick’s Restaurant And Bar is a must-visit spot for sandwich lovers. The Steak Bomb, Meatball Grinder, and Cubano are standout dishes, full of flavor and generously filled. The unique entrance might be inconspicuous, but the experience is anything but ordinary. The tomato sauce on the pizza is downright amazing, and the fresh and tasty food here is a refreshing change from the typical fast-food fare. The service is top-notch, adding to the overall ambiance of this hidden gem.

Book Now


Cozzola’s Pizza

8.8/10 (276 reviews)

Website | Directions | +1 970-229-5771

Fast serviceFresh ingredientsCustomization options

Cozzola’s Pizza stands out for its incredibly fast service and fresh ingredients. The vegetables are juicy, and the pizzas are generously topped, creating a fresh and flavorful experience. In addition to the quick service, customers appreciate the reasonable prices and the option to customize their pizzas. The Take and Bake option is a hit, with customers loving the quality of the crust, whether they opt for the herb variety or not. Cozzola’s commitment to using quality ingredients and providing efficient service has made it a beloved pizza spot in Fort Collins.


Postcard Pizza

10/10 (60 reviews)

Website | Directions

Detroit-style deep dishFlavorful sauceLively atmosphere

Postcard Pizza in Fort Collins truly stands out with its Detroit-style deep dish pizzas that are a game-changer. The combination of crispy cheese edges, flavorful toppings, and perfectly seasoned pans result in an unforgettable pizza experience. The sauce, in particular, is a standout element that elevates the overall taste. The pizza is generously topped with high-quality cheese, allowing each bite to be a delicious explosion of flavor. The atmosphere, located inside Equinox brewing, adds to the experience, making it a must-visit spot for pizza lovers in Colorado.


La Piadina – Italian Flatbread Sandwiches

9.6/10 (112 reviews)

Website | Directions | +1 970-632-3019