Whether you’re craving a classic New York-style fold or a gourmet Neapolitan masterpiece, Gilbert offers a selection of pizza spots that promise to satisfy every palate.
From crispy thin crusts adorned with local produce to hearty deep-dish wonders that ooze with molten cheese, Gilbert’s pizza scene offers something to satiate every palate. This guide curates the city’s standout pizzerias, each offering a unique slice of culinary heaven.
Oregano’s
9/10 (2269 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 480-882-9336
Exceptional foodOutstanding bartendersVibrant atmosphere
Oregano’s, located in Gilbert, provides a vibrant atmosphere for pizza lovers. Customers rave about the exceptional food, such as the Stuffed Riga Tony. The bartenders are outstanding, offering friendly and attentive service. However, some diners have experienced long waits and mediocre service during busy times. Despite some inconsistencies, Oregano’s provides a fun and colorful dining experience with flavorful dishes when it hits the mark.
Fire & Brimstone – Wood Fired Pizza Restaurant
9.2/10 (514 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 480-687-3490
Unique seating experienceDiverse menu optionsCharming ambiance
Fire & Brimstone – Wood Fired Pizza Restaurant offers a unique experience with open seating and a fun ambiance. The seasonal special pizza, Plate Lunch Pie, stood out with flavorful toppings and a great crust. The addition of non-pizza items like the yellowtail collar and Reuben sandwich showcase a diverse menu. The antique silverware adds a charming touch to the dining experience. The revamped menu includes tasty options like the buffalo chicken pizza and quick spam bite. While there may be some inconsistency with the food, the quality ingredients shine through in dishes like the Italian salad and Neapolitan style pizzas. The option to bring your own beer or purchase from the nearby brewery adds to the laid-back atmosphere of this local gem.
Vito’s Pizza & Italian Ristorante
9/10 (865 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 480-245-4554
Wood-fired pizzasMouthwatering pastaImpeccable service
Vito’s Pizza & Italian Ristorante is a true gem of Italian cuisine. The wood-fired pizzas are a work of art, boasting a thin and crispy crust that perfectly complements the generous toppings. The pasta dishes are cooked to perfection and accompanied by rich, mouthwatering sauces. The attention to detail and passion of the chefs shine through in every bite, and the friendly staff further elevate the dining experience. Whether you’re seeking an authentic taste of Italy or simply looking for a delightful evening out, Vito’s is sure to deliver an unforgettable meal that will leave you craving more.
Buonos pizza
9.4/10 (318 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 480-899-1200
Authentic New York-style pizzaReasonably priced menuOutstanding customer service
Buonos pizza is a hidden gem in the valley that delivers on the promise of authentic New York-style pizza. The menu is reasonably priced, and the staff goes above and beyond to ensure a great dining experience, catering even to the needs of families with young children. The pizzas come out piping hot, perfectly cooked with just the right amount of toppings, creating a delicious and satisfying meal every time. The attention to customer service is apparent, making every visit to Buonos pizza a delightful outing.
Fired Pie
8.6/10 (386 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 480-272-7150
Customizable pizzasThin crustVegan options
Fired Pie offers customers the unique experience of a Subway-style pizza shop, where they can choose toppings and watch their pizza being made right away. The thin crust is a standout feature that many customers appreciate. The option to customize pizzas is a plus, and the availability of vegan cheese and meat alternatives is a welcome touch. While some reviewers have encountered issues with their orders, many have found the service to be attentive and the staff to be friendly. The atmosphere is overall clean and welcoming, making Fired Pie a place worth trying for a quick and customizable pizza experience.
Rosati’s Pizza
8.6/10 (1014 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 480-987-0888
Unique “stuffed” styleGenerous cheese portionsRange of toppings
Rosati’s Pizza has gained a fervent following for their “stuffed” style pizzas, with toppings like Alfredo sauce, bacon, chicken, mushroom, onion, broccoli, and garlic shining brightly as fan favorites. The thin crust pizza, particularly admired for the generous and high-quality cheese used, has also earned praise. While some critics have pointed out inconsistencies in order accuracy and temperature, the unique flavors and toppings at Rosati’s make it a tempting option for pizza lovers craving something beyond the ordinary. Despite some service mishaps, the pizza itself remains a standout feature that keeps customers coming back for more.
Salerno’s
9/10 (908 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 480-892-0040
Thin crust pizzaFriendly staffDelicious Italian cuisine
Salerno’s is a local gem serving up delicious Italian cuisine in a warm and welcoming atmosphere. The thin crust pizza is a standout, with the perfect crunch and a delicious bake on top. The lasagna is fresh and hearty, while the lunch deal offers great value with a salad, two slices of pizza, and a drink for only $11. The staff is friendly and informative, making it a lovely spot to enjoy a meal with loved ones or solo. Salerno’s attention to quality and flavor truly shines through in every dish.
Rino D’s Pizza & Wings
8.6/10 (272 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 480-545-2700
Delicious pizzaFlavorful hot wingsSmooth delivery service
Rino D’s Pizza & Wings keeps customers coming back with their delicious pizza and top-notch service. The pizza has a soft, airy crust with the perfect amount of cheese and toppings. The wings are a must-try, with a crispy exterior and flavorful hot sauce. The delivery service is smooth and timely, making it easy to enjoy their incredible food from the comfort of your own home. Their menu offers a variety of options, from classic favorites like pepperoni pizza to tasty sides like chicken alfredo. Rino D’s truly hits the mark when it comes to providing a satisfying dining experience.
Barro’s Pizza
8.6/10 (1056 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 480-279-4644
Flavorful pizzasFriendly serviceCozy ambiance
Hidden in the bustling streets of the city center lies a hidden gem that is Barro’s Pizza. The inviting ambiance draws you in, setting the perfect stage for a feast of flavorful pizzas that are sure to delight your taste buds. The diverse selection of pizzas offers something for everyone, with generous toppings that are both plentiful and delicious. The staff’s quick and friendly service adds an extra layer of warmth to your dining experience, making you feel right at home. Whether you’re here for a family dinner or a casual night out, Barro’s Pizza is the place to be.
Barro’s Pizza
8.6/10 (1091 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 480-892-6265
Affordable lunch specialsFlavorful Chicago-style pizzaFun and relaxed atmosphere
Barro’s Pizza has been a Valley tradition for over 40 years, serving up delicious Chicago-style pizza with a thicker crust that is perfect for pizza lovers. The lunch specials provide a great value with various options of pizza slices, salad, and soda. The menu also includes wings, pasta, and sandwiches, all reasonably priced for a quick bite with friends. The chill ambiance of this throwback pizza joint, with plenty of seating and TVs showing the game, makes Barro’s Pizza a great spot for a casual and tasty meal.
Barro’s Pizza
8.6/10 (857 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 480-917-0111
Consistent qualityVariety of wingsExceptional customer service
Barro’s Pizza is a tried-and-true favorite among many, offering a consistent experience that keeps customers coming back. The pizzas are known to be hot, loaded with generous toppings and cheese, making them a satisfying choice. The wings also receive praise for their quality and variety of flavors. The restaurant itself is described as clean, with a friendly staff that contributes to a welcoming atmosphere. The dedication to cleanliness and customer service stands out, with employees going above and beyond to rectify any issues that may arise. Barro’s may not claim the title of the absolute best, but it offers a reliable option with a level of convenience that rivals larger chain pizzerias.
Crust Simply Italian Gilbert
8.8/10 (271 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 480-656-0085
Generous portion sizesDelicious garlic knotsImpeccable service
Crust Simply Italian Gilbert truly stands out in the crowded pizza restaurant scene. With generous portion sizes and delicious dishes, this spot is a must-visit. The garlic knots are a must-try, and the calzone is a standout item on the menu. The ambiance is top-notch, especially when you can snag a spot outside near the fire pit. The service is impeccable, with friendly and attentive staff who go above and beyond to ensure a great dining experience. The open and modern style of the restaurant adds to the overall appeal, making it a fantastic choice for a meal out. The food is flavorful and the prices are reasonable, making Crust Simply Italian Gilbert a gem in the culinary world.
Eatalio Pasta & Wine
8.6/10 (205 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 480-625-3860
Authentic Italian Indian fusionGenerous portionsAttentive service