Whether you’re craving a classic New York-style fold or a gourmet Neapolitan masterpiece, Greeley offers a selection of pizza spots that promise to satisfy every palate.
From crispy thin crusts adorned with local produce to hearty deep-dish wonders that ooze with molten cheese, Greeley’s pizza scene offers something to satiate every palate. This guide curates the city’s standout pizzerias, each offering a unique slice of culinary heaven.
Fusco Pizza
9/10 (150 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 970-515-6421
Perfectly cooked crustGenerous salad portionsFriendly and efficient service
Fusco Pizza stands out as a solid choice for a satisfying meal. The pizza crust is perfectly cooked, with each square slice topped to perfection. The full salad portion is generous, offering a great start to the meal. A single slice is ample for one person, making it easy to sample different styles of pizza. The service is friendly and efficient, with every staff member treating guests kindly. The variety of flavors in the pizzas, including gluten-free options, ensures there is something for everyone to enjoy.
Santeramo’s Pizza House and Italian Food
9/10 (1465 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 970-353-4844
Homemade noodlesFabulous chicken parmeseanCozy old house setting
Santeramo’s Pizza House and Italian Food is a gem of a restaurant that offers delicious food in a cozy old house setting. The homemade noodles steal the show, especially when paired with the fabulous chicken parmesean. The staff is attentive and the atmosphere is welcoming, making it the perfect spot for a satisfying Italian meal that won’t disappoint.
Bravos Philly’s & Pizza
9/10 (383 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 970-353-0068
Tasty GyrosCrispy FriesFriendly Staff
Bravos Philly’s & Pizza has quickly become a must-visit spot for those looking for a satisfying meal. The Philly cheese steak and pizza are a definite standout and will have you coming back for more. The cozy ambiance, friendly staff, and clean environment make it a pleasant dining experience. The Gyros are a fan favorite and highly recommended, along with the fresh and crispy fries. If you’re in the mood for a Chicago dog, Bravos is the place to be. While the prices may be a bit steep, the quality and taste of the food make it worth every penny.
Empire State Pizza
8.8/10 (971 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 970-353-1706
Customizable optionsArcade atmosphereConsistent quality
Empire State Pizza may not taste like New York pizza, but it has its own unique charm. The customizable options, such as switching red sauce for ranch, make it stand out. The friendly service and willingness to accommodate allergies make for a pleasant experience. The arcade adds a fun touch, perfect for families or nostalgic adults. While some customers have had issues with the cleanliness and alternative crusts, Empire State Pizza seems to cater well to a variety of tastes and preferences.
Fonta’s Pizza Restaurant
9/10 (696 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 970-356-9200
Distinctive FlavorCharming AtmosphereFriendly Service
Fonta’s Pizza Restaurant truly stands out as a local gem in Greeley. The unique and flavorful pizzas are a cut above the rest, showcasing a distinct taste that sets them apart from chain pizzerias. The welcoming atmosphere, complete with charming booths and eye-catching paintings on the walls, adds to the overall dining experience. The attentive and friendly service only enhances the already enjoyable visit, making it a top choice for both locals and visitors alike. Fonta’s commitment to quality ingredients shines through in every bite, cementing its reputation as a must-visit spot for pizza lovers.
Blackjack Pizza & Salads
8.8/10 (463 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 970-353-6262
Delicious PizzasAffordable PricesExceptional Service
Located in the heart of the city, Blackjack Pizza & Salads boasts a mouth-watering lineup of pizzas that will leave you craving for more. From the classic pepperoni to the loaded Supreme, each slice is packed with flavor and satisfaction. The generous amount of sauce and the option to customize your toppings ensure that your pizza is nothing short of perfection. And despite the high quality and taste of their pies, the prices are surprisingly affordable. But what makes Blackjack truly stand out is their exceptional service – they are always willing to go the extra mile to ensure that your dining experience is top-notch.
Pellegrini Cucina Italiana – Italian Market-Style Cuisine
8.8/10 (646 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 970-515-5332
Homemade pastaFlavorful red sauceAttentive staff
Pellegrini Cucina Italiana – Italian Market-Style Cuisine offers a unique dining experience where you order at the counter and then enjoy a delicious meal brought to your table. The homemade pasta with flavorful red sauce is a standout, and the pizza is a sight to behold. The staff is attentive, the prices are reasonable, and the atmosphere is clean and cozy. With the owner’s Italian roots adding an authentic touch, the simple yet flavorful dishes made with fresh ingredients are a true delight that will have you coming back for more.
Bulldog Pub & Grub
9/10 (882 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 970-515-6398
Unique decorDelicious Reuben SandwichFriendly and attentive service
Bulldog Pub & Grub offers a unique mix of delicious food and quirky decor, making it a must-visit spot in Greeley. Customers rave about the Reuben Sandwich, hailed as the best in town, and the amazing pizza appetizers. The service is top-notch, with friendly staff like Marissa, adding to the overall experience. The atmosphere is described as cool and kewl, filled with comic book and movie artifacts that set it apart from other restaurants in the area. The only downside seems to be the occasional delay in orders and limited beer selection, but the attentive staff and great food help to make up for it.
Pinocchios Incredible Italian
9.2/10 (150 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 720-899-0949
Innovative dishesImpeccable serviceCozy atmosphere
Upon entering Pinocchio’s Incredible Italian, the warm welcome from the staff sets the tone for a delightful dining experience. The service is attentive and impeccable, ensuring that patrons feel well taken care of throughout their meal. The innovative and delicious food offerings are the true shining stars here, with top-quality dishes that are sure to please even the most discerning palates. From the heavenly bread to the mouth-watering pasta and calzones, each bite is a true delight. The cozy atmosphere adds to the overall charm of the restaurant, making it a must-visit spot in Greeley for Italian cuisine enthusiasts.
Wing Shack West Greeley
9/10 (1439 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 970-356-4651
Improved wing sizeExcellent customer serviceFlavorful hot sauces
Wing Shack West Greeley offers an improved experience for customers, with larger wings that have more meat on them now. The staff, particularly Raelynnn and Amber, go above and beyond in providing excellent customer service, making sure patrons feel welcome and satisfied. The menu boasts a variety of flavorful options, including the standout hotter and teriyaki hot sauces, perfect for those who enjoy spicy and sweet flavors. The dining experience is enhanced by the attentive and accommodating staff, making Wing Shack West Greeley a top choice for delicious wings and great service.
Wing Shack 10th Street
9.2/10 (569 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 970-515-6061
Friendly staffDelicious wingsWarm atmosphere
Nestled in a quaint corner of town, Wing Shack 10th Street stands out not only for its delectable wings but also for its welcoming staff. From Trey’s friendly service to Sage’s attentiveness, guests are made to feel right at home. The menu boasts a variety of mouth-watering options, from the always brilliant wings to the tantalizing sandwich and sweet tots. The atmosphere exudes warmth and hospitality, with staff members like Angel, Madi, and Nemiah going above and beyond to ensure a memorable dining experience. With fantastic service, delightful food, and a cozy ambiance, Wing Shack 10th Street is a true gem in the neighborhood.
Taste of Philly
8.8/10 (676 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 970-336-0100
Authentic Philly flavorsTop-tier serviceDelicious cannolis
Taste of Philly in Greeley, Colorado offers a truly authentic Philly experience, with delicious and filling food that hits the spot. The traditional Philly sandwich is a standout, and the service is top-tier, with staff going above and beyond to ensure a great dining experience for all customers. The atmosphere could use some improvement, but the outstanding service and flavorful food make up for any shortcomings in ambiance. If you’re in the mood for a classic Philly cheesesteak or some tasty onion rings, this is the place to be.
Cheba Hut “Toasted” Subs
9.2/10 (1246 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 970-673-8733
Unique sandwich optionsFriendly and personable staffSeparate bar area
Located in a welcoming atmosphere, Cheba Hut “Toasted” Subs offers a unique experience for sandwich lovers. The delicious sandwiches paired with a wide selection of drinks create a laid-back environment perfect for socializing. The friendly and attentive staff, including standout employees like Justin and Nevaeh, elevate the overall experience. Despite some minor mishaps like slow service and occasional mistakes in orders, the fresh food and separate bar area make this a spot worth returning to. Whether you’re a regular or a first-time visitor, Cheba Hut promises a satisfying meal with a side of good vibes.
The Centennial Public House
9.6/10 (404 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 970-573-5616
Unique ambianceFlavorful menuAttentive service
The Centennial Public House offers a unique and welcoming ambiance that makes it stand out in Greeley. The beautiful setting and friendly staff create a memorable dining experience. The menu features a variety of delicious options, such as the white wine garlic mussels and pub brussels appetizer, which are flavorful and generously portioned. The cocktails are well-crafted, although a bit sweet for some tastes. Despite some minor shortcomings like sticky floors and a lack of shades in the outdoor dining area, the overall dining experience is enjoyable and worth a visit.
Chicken Salad Chick
9.2/10 (239 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 970-616-0039
Flavorful chicken saladsRefreshing tea selectionsAttentive and accommodating staff
Chicken Salad Chick offers a unique dining experience with a wide variety of flavorful chicken salad options, delicious soups, and refreshing tea selections. The attentive and accommodating staff make every visit a pleasant one, ensuring excellent customer service from start to finish. The menu boasts creative dishes like the Barbie-Q chicken salad and the Dixie Chick chicken melt, both of which are must-tries for flavor enthusiasts. The option to sample different chicken salads before ordering is a thoughtful touch that sets this restaurant apart. The inviting atmosphere, clean dining space, and reasonable prices make Chicken Salad Chick a top choice for a satisfying and enjoyable meal.
Fat Albert’s
9/10 (1142 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 970-356-1999
Homemade dessertsCozy atmosphereFriendly service
Located in Greeley, Fat Albert’s is a hidden gem offering a cozy and welcoming atmosphere. The menu features hearty and delicious dishes like the French dip, jambalaya soup, and crispy onion rings. The desserts are the star here, with standout options like the German cheesecake and key lime pie. The attentive and friendly service, along with the charming decor, make dining at Fat Albert’s a memorable experience.
Roma – Evans
8.6/10 (439 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 970-515-5706
CarolisFriendly staffAtmosphere
Roma – Evans has a lot of room for improvement based on customer feedback. The prices seem to be higher than expected for the portions and quality of food received. Customers have mentioned issues with the size of pizzas, lack of flavor, and burnt crusts. Inconsistencies in portion sizes and missing items have also been reported. Despite some negative experiences, some customers have praised the Carolis and the friendly staff at the restaurant. The atmosphere and service have received positive comments, but overall, the food quality and value for money seem to be the main concerns for customers.