20 Best Pizza Spots in Green Bay, WI

Whether you’re craving a classic New York-style fold or a gourmet Neapolitan masterpiece, Green Bay offers a selection of pizza spots that promise to satisfy every palate.

From crispy thin crusts adorned with local produce to hearty deep-dish wonders that ooze with molten cheese, Green Bay’s pizza scene offers something to satiate every palate. This guide curates the city’s standout pizzerias, each offering a unique slice of culinary heaven.

Alamo Pizzer1a

9.4/10 (131 reviews)

Website | Directions | +1 920-544-0571

Tasty herb blendFriendly and professional staffFair prices

Alamo Pizzer1a, situated on University Ave, offers delicious pizza that brings good memories of the renowned GB Pizza Co. The staff’s warmth and professionalism enhance the dining experience, making it a great spot for family outings. The menu showcases a variety of options beyond pizza, like the Italian beef sandwich, which is a hidden gem worth trying. The prices are fair, and the service is top-notch, making Alamo a standout in the area.

Olive’s Pizza and Sandwiches

9.4/10 (173 reviews)

Website | Directions | +1 920-492-0732

Thin crust pizzasHandmade sub bunsExcellent service

Nestled in an unexpected location, Olive’s Pizza and Sandwiches provides a delightful dining experience for both locals and visitors alike. The superb thin crust pizzas, especially the deluxe and sausage mushroom varieties, are a must-try. The turkey sub is another standout, and the handmade sub buns add an extra layer of freshness to the sandwiches. The mozzarella sticks make for a satisfying appetizer, and the excellent service ensures a pleasant visit. With a good wine selection and open hours accommodating late-night cravings, Olive’s is a solid choice for pizza lovers in Green Bay.

Riverside Pizzeria of Green Bay

8.8/10 (132 reviews)

Website | Directions | +1 920-489-2892

Homey thin crustFlavorful sauceWelcoming service

Nestled in Green Bay, Riverside Pizzeria brings a taste of home to customers with its thin-crust style pizzas originating from the Upper Peninsula of Michigan. The pizza is the star of the show, with a distinctly rich sauce and flavorful cheese. Fresh mushrooms are a highlight for those who appreciate the little details. The service is top-notch, with attentive staff and a warm welcome from the greeter making each visit inviting and memorable. Riverside Pizzeria also offers a comfortable environment with unique cutting and serving style, making it a local favorite for those craving a delicious slice.

Sammy’s Pizza & Italian Restaurant

9/10 (1499 reviews)

Website | Directions | +1 920-499-6644

Homemade pizzaWelcoming serviceElegant ambiance

Sammy’s Pizza & Italian Restaurant is a delightful surprise in Green Bay. The homemade pizza is fresh, delicious, and the crust is top-notch. The service is welcoming and attentive, making for a fantastic dining experience. The portion sizes are generous, and the homemade items like the sausage, crust, and pasta really stand out. The ambiance is elegant, and the staff is knowledgeable and friendly. Sammy’s will definitely become a favorite spot for those looking for a quality meal in a warm atmosphere.

Rosati’s Pizza Of Green Bay

9/10 (749 reviews)

Website | Directions | +1 920-468-4500

Impeccable ServicePerfectly Cooked FoodPositive Teamwork

Rosati’s Pizza Of Green Bay is a gem in the world of pizza. The food here is beyond amazing, from the crispy chicken to the Chicago deep dish, every dish is made to perfection. The service is impeccable, with friendly servers like Renita and Cali who go above and beyond to make your dining experience memorable. The care and compassion put into the food by the kitchen staff is outstanding, making every bite a delight. Additionally, the teamwork and positive energy among the staff create a welcoming atmosphere that only enhances the overall dining experience at Rosati’s.

Glass Nickel Pizza Co. – Green Bay

8.8/10 (932 reviews)

Website | Directions | +1 920-490-1000

Vegan pizzaSustainability effortsCommunity involvement

Nestled in the heart of Green Bay, Glass Nickel Pizza Co. offers an array of delightful treats, from vegan pizza to mouth-watering sub sandwiches. The staff, while occasionally overwhelmed, are eager to please and accommodate all guests, even those with furry companions. The unique touch of offering vegan cheese on their pizzas sets them apart from the rest, providing a delectable option for plant-based diners and pizza lovers alike. Additionally, their commitment to sustainability and community involvement shows a true dedication to making a positive impact in the local area. Despite occasional hiccups in service, the overall experience at Glass Nickel Pizza Co. is one of warmth, good food, and a genuine desire to please their patrons.

Happy Joe’s Pizza & Ice Cream – Green Bay

9.2/10 (953 reviews)

Website | Directions | +1 920-465-0690

Taco PizzaFamily-friendly atmosphereOutstanding service

Happy Joe’s Pizza & Ice Cream – Green Bay is a nostalgic spot that delivers on family-friendly fun and tasty eats. The Taco Pizza is a standout item that customers rave about, and the variety of options on the menu ensures there’s something for everyone, whether you’re a pizza or pasta person. The game area adds an extra layer of entertainment, making it a great spot for celebrations or casual dining. The staff is praised for their outstanding service, with special shoutouts to attentive and friendly waitstaff who go above and beyond to make the dining experience memorable. Happy Joe’s is a gem on the east side of Green Bay, offering a unique blend of delicious food and fun ambiance.

Book Now

Cranky Pat’s Pizzeria

9/10 (1129 reviews)

Website | Directions | +1 920-468-7777

Towering sausage/mushroom pizzaPat’s Special PizzaLocal house pilsner

Cranky Pat’s Pizzeria in Green Bay offers a unique pizza experience that stands out from other local pizzerias. The Pat’s Special Pizza is a towering creation with piled high sausage and mushrooms that will satisfy any pizza lover’s cravings. Despite the longer wait time, the quality of the pizza is worth it for those seeking a flavorful and filling meal. Pair your pizza with a refreshing pint of their own “Cranky Pat’s Happy Pils” pilsner for a complete dining experience that showcases the restaurant’s dedication to both food and drink.

Gallagher’s Pizza – East Green Bay

8.6/10 (693 reviews)

Website | Directions | +1 920-321-5555

Quality toppingsWide beer selectionCozy ambiance

Gallagher’s Pizza in East Green Bay welcomes diners with warm and traditional feeling surroundings and a clean environment that sets the stage for a satisfying meal. The menu offers a plethora of pizza choices with quality toppings that don’t skimp on flavor, accompanied by traditional and incredible cheese and sauce combinations. The adjoining brewery provides a wide selection of beverages to complement your dining experience, making it a great spot to enjoy a hearty and delicious meal.

Jake’s Pizza Green Bay

9.2/10 (557 reviews)

Website | Directions | +1 920-437-5542

Delicious pizzaTop-notch serviceCool ambiance

Jake’s Pizza Green Bay is a beloved institution that has been serving up delicious pizza for 50 years. The pizza is made with care and attention to detail, with a perfect crust that strikes the right balance between thin and thick. Toppings are plentiful and flavorful, making each bite a delight. The appetizers are also a hit, especially the meatball appetizer that customers can’t get enough of. Even on a busy night, the service is top-notch, proving that Jake’s knows how to handle a crowd. With craft cocktails, local brews, and a cool men’s bathroom decked out with a used skateboard wall, Jake’s is the perfect spot for a fun and delicious night out.

Gallagher’s Pizza – West

8.6/10 (994 reviews)

Website | Directions | +1 920-499-9918

Warm hospitalityFlavorful taco pizzaDiverse menu options

Gallagher’s Pizza – West offers a warm and welcoming atmosphere with a staff that goes above and beyond to ensure a pleasant dining experience. The taco pizza is a standout menu item, bursting with flavor and sure to delight your taste buds. Whether you’re a fan of classic toppings or more adventurous combinations, Gallagher’s Pizza – West has something for everyone, making it a go-to spot for delicious pizza in town.

Parker John’s BBQ & Pizza

8.8/10 (1452 reviews)

Website | Directions | +1 920-405-6705

Root beer on tapBBQ samplerHouse BBQ sauces

Luigi’s Italian Bistro

8.8/10 (438 reviews)

Website | Directions | +1 920-468-4900

Crispy crustFresh toppingsExcellent service

Luigi’s Italian Bistro is a must-visit for anyone craving delicious pizza and top-notch service. The crispy crust and fresh, flavorful toppings make their pizzas a standout, showcasing high-quality ingredients made with care. Not only does Luigi’s excel in food, but they also provide excellent service, with a friendly and accommodating staff who go above and beyond to ensure a great dining experience. The space itself may need a bit of a refresh, but the fabulous meals, great value, and customizable options more than make up for it. Luigi’s Italian Bistro is a hidden gem for those seeking authentic Italian fare that won’t disappoint.

Book Now

Shelsky’s Of Brooklyn Appetizing and Delicatessen

9/10 (471 reviews)

Website | Directions | +1 718-855-8817

Variety of bagelsQuality deli itemsFriendly staff

Shelsky’s Of Brooklyn Appetizing and Delicatessen is a standout in the Brooklyn bagel scene. The lox cream cheese bagel is a must-try, but don’t miss out on the whitefish option either. The variety of bagels and cream cheese choices, along with other deli items like pastrami sandwiches and smoked salmon, truly sets this place apart. The staff is friendly and the quality of the food is top-notch. The charm of the establishment shines through, making it a favorite spot for many.

Marco’s Pizza

8.8/10 (177 reviews)

Website | Directions | +1 920-497-1990

Convenient locationFlavorful sauceFriendly staff

Marco’s Pizza offers a delicious pizza experience that keeps customers coming back for more. With a convenient location near Target, friendly and efficient staff, and a menu that offers a unique take on classic pizza flavors, Marco’s Pizza is a solid choice for a quick and satisfying meal. The soft crust and flavorful sauce are standout features, although some may find the pepperoni a bit salty. Despite occasional mishaps with delivery services, Marco’s Pizza remains a popular choice for those seeking a reliable and tasty pizza option.

Angelina Restaurant

9/10 (796 reviews)

Website | Directions | +1 920-437-7248

Authentic Italian dishesCozy and inviting atmosphereKnowledgeable and attentive service

Nestled in a cozy setting, Angelina Restaurant offers a true taste of authentic Italian cuisine with a slightly upscale twist. The menu may be on the smaller side, but each dish is meticulously crafted and bursting with flavor. From the bruschetta to the Pollo al Marsala, every bite showcases the owner’s Sicilian roots and commitment to quality. The warm and welcoming atmosphere only adds to the overall dining experience, making it a must-visit for anyone craving a taste of Italy right in town.

Book Now

Oley’s Pepperoni Cannoli (Mobile Wood-Fired Pizza, Catering, Frozen Pizza)

9.2/10 (53 reviews)

Website | Directions | +1 920-632-6185

Fresh wood-fired pizzaOutstanding customer serviceAccommodating dietary restrictions

Oley’s Pepperoni Cannoli serves up some of the most delicious wood-fired pizza around. Guests rave about the freshness and flavor of the pizzas, whether it’s at a car show, wedding, or work lunch. The attention to detail and outstanding customer service is evident in every interaction, making Oley’s a top choice for catering events or simply enjoying a tasty meal. From accommodating dietary restrictions to setting up quickly and efficiently, Oley’s goes above and beyond to ensure a memorable and delicious experience for all. The pizza speaks for itself, with flavors like tomato basil and Greek style that are truly out of this world.