Whether you’re craving a classic New York-style fold or a gourmet Neapolitan masterpiece, Hayward offers a selection of pizza spots that promise to satisfy every palate.
From crispy thin crusts adorned with local produce to hearty deep-dish wonders that ooze with molten cheese, Hayward’s pizza scene offers something to satiate every palate. This guide curates the city’s standout pizzerias, each offering a unique slice of culinary heaven.
Bronco Billy’s Pizza Palace
8.8/10 (907 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 510-727-0532
Traditional pizzaPure cane sodaFamily-friendly ambiance
Bronco Billy’s Pizza Palace offers traditional, hot, and fresh pizza with amazing crust and pure cane soda options. The small arcade is a bonus for families and the spacious layout accommodates team dinners. The establishment might not be a fine dining experience, but the tasty food and nostalgic ambiance make it a must-try spot. The staff might not be perfect, but the overall atmosphere and value make it a solid choice.
Edgewater Pizza
8.6/10 (87 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 510-887-7900
Quality PizzasFamily-Owned AtmosphereFriendly Service
At Edgewater Pizza, the quality of their pizzas cannot be beaten. Whether you opt for the personal size or share a 14″ with a friend, the flavors of the chicken, pepperoni, and onion toppings are exceptional. The Hawaiian and Supreme pizzas are also standout options. The family-owned restaurant exudes a warm and welcoming atmosphere, with friendly customer service that truly elevates the dining experience. Plus, the Chicken Club Sandwich is a must-try dish that will keep you coming back for more.
Susie Q’s Pizza
9.2/10 (291 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 510-537-2888
Generous portionsUnique menu optionsFriendly staff
Hidden in the heart of downtown Hayward lies Susie Q’s Pizza, a family-owned pizzeria with reasonable prices and generous portions. The Godzilla pizza, available in a size fit for monsters, is a fan-favorite, lasting for days with its delicious flavors. The Chicken wings with Honey Garlic Flavor are crispy and flavorful, and the Cheesy bread is a must-try. Susie Q’s also offers unique options like halal meat on their pizzas and a gluten-free crust, making it a standout spot in the East Bay. The friendly staff provides fast and efficient service, adding to the overall pleasant dining experience.
Coop’s Pizza
8.8/10 (1460 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 715-634-3027
Spacious outdoor seatingMidwest-style pizza buffetFrozen pizzas to go
Coop’s Pizza in Hayward offers a warm and inviting atmosphere perfect for families. The spacious outdoor seating area was comfortable, and the table was stable – a rarity in outdoor dining. The buffet option is a hit, with a variety of tasty Midwest-style pizzas. The restaurant also sells frozen pizzas for those looking to enjoy Coop’s flavors at home. Don’t miss out on the cheesy bread and 1919 Root Beer, served in generous portions. While some staff may be young and inexperienced, their friendly service adds to the overall pleasant dining experience.
El Triunfo Pizzeria
8.8/10 (72 reviews)
| Directions | +1 510-732-8000
Delicious foodGreat customer serviceVariety of options
Nestled close to the bar, El Triunfo Pizzeria is a delicious oasis serving up delectable food that won’t disappoint. Their Hawaiian pizza is a standout favorite, while the wings and fries are a hit with customers – staying hot and fresh even after a journey home. With a variety of options like tortas that have customers raving, this spot is perfect for takeout or a sit-down meal. The friendly cashier and excellent customer service adds an extra charm to this hidden gem.
Rayo’s Pizza
9/10 (93 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 510-431-3302
Crispy crustFresh ingredientsEfficient service
Rayo’s Pizza is a hidden gem on the border of Hayward and Union City, where the dough takes center stage. The Carne Asada pizza is a must-try, featuring freshly diced brisket steak and a perfectly balanced blend of flavors. The crust is crispy on the edges and soft in the center, making each bite a delight. Beyond the Carne Asada, other pizzas like the Brisket BBQ and Chicken Parmesan are equally mouth-watering. The service is welcoming and efficient, with pizzas ready in just 20 minutes, and the atmosphere is no-frills but spacious, ideal for large groups. Rayo’s offers gourmet pizzas at a reasonable price, making it a top choice for pizza aficionados looking for quality ingredients and delicious flavors. Give Rayo’s a try for a culinary journey that will leave you coming back for more.
Acqua e Farina
9.2/10 (995 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 510-888-1568
Traditional Italian dishesAttentive serviceSpacious interior
Located in a charming spot in Hayward, Acqua e Farina is a gem serving up traditional Italian dishes with attentive service. The Veal Saltimbocca is a must-try, paired perfectly with creamy polenta. The Gnocchi della Casa is pillowy soft and coated in a delicious creamy tomato sauce. Don’t skip out on the complimentary bread, especially the herb focaccia. The spacious interior with murals depicting an Italian street scene adds to the dining experience. A great spot for authentic Italian cuisine with generous portions and decent prices.
Buon Appetito
8.6/10 (948 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 510-247-0120
Exquisite cappuccinoDelicious tiramisuHelpful staff
Buon Appetito offers an exquisite cappuccino that is a definite standout, with a foamy texture and a taste that will leave you craving more. The tiramisu is also a must-try, delivering a delicious fusion of flavors in every bite. The staff goes above and beyond with helpful recommendations, making your dining experience truly delightful. Whether you’re a regular or a first-timer, the delectable food and welcoming atmosphere at Buon Appetito make it a must-visit destination for any foodie.