Whether you’re craving a classic New York-style fold or a gourmet Neapolitan masterpiece, Indianapolis offers a selection of pizza spots that promise to satisfy every palate.
From crispy thin crusts adorned with local produce to hearty deep-dish wonders that ooze with molten cheese, Indianapolis’s pizza scene offers something to satiate every palate. This guide curates the city’s standout pizzerias, each offering a unique slice of culinary heaven.
Bazbeaux
9/10 (2378 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 317-636-7662
Unique crispy crustFresh and plentiful toppingsFriendly and attentive staff
Located in the heart of Indy, Bazbeaux offers unique and flavorful pizzas that will surely satisfy your cravings. From the perfectly crispy crust to the fresh and plentiful toppings, each pizza is cooked to perfection. The friendly and attentive staff are always ready to make recommendations, ensuring a memorable dining experience. Whether you’re a pepperoni lover, a fan of the Tchoupitoulas, or enjoy a classic Quattro Formaggio, Bazbeaux has something for everyone. Families and pizza enthusiasts alike will feel right at home in this welcoming and delicious establishment.
Jockamo Upper Crust Pizza
9.2/10 (3443 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 317-356-6612
Unique menu optionsFriendly atmosphereTangy and sweet sauce
Jockamo Upper Crust Pizza offers a unique dining experience with a cozy atmosphere in the heart of Irvington. The menu features a variety of creative options, including specialty pizzas with interesting toppings and sauce choices. While some customers found the cheese to be overwhelming on certain pies, the tangy and sweet sauce and perfectly cooked crust received high praise. The friendly service and extensive drink selection add to the overall experience, making it a must-visit spot for pizza lovers in Indianapolis. Be sure to try the Sweet Caroline and breadsticks with creamy Parmesan dipping sauce for a delicious meal that will leave you wanting more.
Pearl Street Pizzeria & Pub
9/10 (1121 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 317-638-3110
Creative pizzasKid-friendly atmosphereQuick service
Nestled on Pearl Street, this pizzeria and pub offers a unique dining experience that keeps customers coming back for more. From the buttery garlic crust to the stuffed calzones bursting with cheese and toppings, every bite is a delight. The diverse menu features creative pizzas like pear and gorgonzola, along with classic favorites like pepperoni basil. The welcoming atmosphere, quick service, and fair prices make it a must-visit spot for both locals and tourists alike.
Giordano’s
8.8/10 (1919 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 317-288-3415
Authentic deep dishCrispy pizza crustFriendly service
Giordano’s in downtown Indianapolis is a must-visit spot for authentic Chicago-style pizza lovers. The classic deep dish pizza is extremely flavorful, with a perfect balance of sauce, cheese, and toppings. The crust is hands down the best part, deliciously crispy on the bottom. Despite some minor setbacks with other menu items like the calamari, the overall experience is top-notch. The service is friendly, knowledgeable, and attentive, making for a pleasant dining atmosphere. The wait for the pizza is worth it, and the rustic and stylish decor adds to the overall charm of this pizza joint.
Blaze Pizza
8.6/10 (2188 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 317-300-7360
Build-your-own conceptVariety of toppingsFriendly staff
Blaze Pizza offers a unique dining experience with a build-your-own concept and a variety of crust and topping options to choose from, catering to both health-conscious and indulgent pizza lovers. The cauliflower crust stands out as a genius idea for those looking for a healthier alternative, while the wide range of toppings ensures there is something for everyone. The friendly and efficient staff adds to the overall pleasant dining experience, making it a great spot for families and pizza enthusiasts alike.
Bazbeaux Pizza
9.2/10 (1228 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 317-255-5711
Unique toppingsPerfect crustOutstanding service
Nestled in the heart of Indianapolis, Bazbeaux Pizza is a must-visit for pizza lovers. The menu offers a variety of unique toppings, from eggplant to vegan cheese, ensuring there’s something for everyone. The crust strikes the perfect balance between crispy and chewy, making every bite a delight. The service is top-notch, with a standout team member named Declan who goes above and beyond to ensure a memorable dining experience. Whether you’re a local or just passing through, Bazbeaux Pizza is sure to impress with its flavorful pizzas and friendly atmosphere.
Brozinni Pizzeria
9.2/10 (1613 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 317-865-0911
Flavorful pizzasFresh ingredientsCozy atmosphere
Nestled in Indiana, Brozinni Pizzeria has quickly become a local gem known for its flavorful pizzas and fresh ingredients. With offerings like the Grandmas Madison Avenue and the Garden State Parkway Pizza, each bite is packed with robust flavors and savory toppings. The Garlic Knuckles are a must-try, crispy on the outside and oozing with garlic butter on the inside. While some crust inconsistencies have been noted, the overall quality and taste of the pizzas make Brozinni Pizzeria a memorable dining experience.
Giorgio’s Pizza
9/10 (977 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 317-687-9869
New York-style pizzaEfficient and helpful staffFair prices
Giorgio’s Pizza in downtown Indy is a must-try for those craving New York-style pizza. The pizza, served by the slice with 2 breadsticks and a drink, is the perfect lunch or quick dinner option. The staff is efficient and helpful, and the prices are very fair. The stuffed meat pizza and pepperoni slice are highly recommended, with big, fluffy breadsticks to complement. While the cheese dipping sauce could use an upgrade, the overall experience is solid. The lady running the counter is particularly kind, making the visit even more enjoyable. If you’re in the area, definitely give Giorgio’s Pizza a shot!
Futuro
9.6/10 (625 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 317-360-4725
Unique toppingsDetroit-style crustAttentive staff
Futuro, a quaint pizza spot in Fountain Square, offers unique toppings like ricotta, hot honey, and bacon on their Spotted Pig pie that will make your taste buds sing. The lunch special is a steal, providing a generous portion that will fill you up for hours. The staff is attentive and welcoming, adding to the overall positive experience. The Detroit-style crust is a standout, perfectly crispy and flavorful. While the prices may lean towards the higher end, the delightful pizzas and friendly service make it a worthwhile dining destination for any pizza lover.
Pronta Pizzeria
9.4/10 (463 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 317-220-8177
Filling slicesInviting atmosphereFreshly prepared crust
Pronta Pizzeria is a downtown gem that offers delicious pizza at a great value. The slice of pepperoni pizza was satisfyingly filling, and the cordial service added to the pleasant dining experience. The inviting atmosphere makes you want to linger over another slice, and the freshly prepared crust with flavorful toppings is simply irresistible. While some aspects of the pizza may have room for improvement, the overall quality and affordability make Pronta Pizzeria a must-visit spot in the bustling city of Indianapolis.
Goodfellas Pizzeria – Mass Ave.
9/10 (2161 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 317-602-3401
Authentic NY styleGenerous portion sizesFriendly staff
Nestled in the heart of Mass Ave., Goodfellas Pizzeria offers a slice of New York right here in Indianapolis. The specialty cheese pizza is a crowd-pleaser, with quality ingredients and a generous portion size that will leave even the heartiest of appetites satisfied. The atmosphere is reminiscent of a classic corner pizza shop, complete with cityscape views and large TVs for sporting events. The staff is friendly and efficient, ensuring that even during peak hours, the line moves quickly and service is top-notch. Whether enjoying a slice with friends after a concert or grabbing a calzone at the bar, Goodfellas Pizzeria is a must-visit for pizza lovers in Indy.
Lou Malnati’s Pizzeria
8.8/10 (502 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 317-899-9908
Fresh ingredientsButtered crustFamily-friendly atmosphere
Lou Malnati’s Pizzeria stands out for its fresh ingredients and family-friendly atmosphere. The unique buttered crust on their thin-crust pizzas is a delightful touch that sets them apart from other pizzerias. The homemade ranch dressing adds a delicious twist to their generously sized salads. The friendly and knowledgeable staff go above and beyond to make customers feel welcome and ensure a memorable dining experience. With a wide variety of options, including classic Chicago-style deep dish pizzas and pasta dishes, Lou Malnati’s is a must-visit spot for pizza lovers looking for a high-quality dining experience.
Byrne’s Grilled Pizza
8.6/10 (361 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 317-737-2056
Grilled crustFast serviceFriendly staff
Byrne’s Grilled Pizza offers a unique dining experience that stands out in the crowded pizza scene in Indianapolis. The 10″ pizzas are perfect for one person and the grilled crust is a game-changer. The Forager pizza is a standout, while the bruschetta is a must-try appetizer. The staff is known for being friendly and the service is fast, making it a great spot for a casual meal. Overall, Byrne’s Grilled Pizza is a hidden gem that is definitely worth a visit.
Enzo Pizza
8.8/10 (127 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 317-634-1144
Delicious slicesFriendly staffOld-school vibes
Enzo Pizza is a no-frills joint with delicious, greasy slices that may require some extra napkins. The old-school vibes and friendly staff add to the experience, making it a great spot for a quick and satisfying lunch. The vegetarian options are a bit limited, but the Veggie Pizza and Spinach Roll are both tasty choices. The Ricotta on the pizza is a standout element that adds a great flavor. The generous slice sizes and welcoming atmosphere make it a nice place to stop by for a meal, especially if you’re in a rush.
Goodfellas Pizzeria – Broad Ripple
8.8/10 (534 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 317-744-0491
Generous ToppingsGood CrunchConvenient By-the-Slice Option
Goodfellas Pizzeria – Broad Ripple serves pizzas with a good crunch to the crust and a delicious cheese. The toppings on their pizzas are generous, and the sauce is flavorful. The menu offers a variety of options, and the pizzas are well-priced for the quality. The staff is helpful and accommodating, even during busy times. The convenience of being able to buy pizza by the slice is a plus. The location may have limited seating, but the overall experience of dining at Goodfellas Pizzeria – Broad Ripple is worth the visit.
Pizza Di Tito
9/10 (59 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 317-236-0075
Delightful atmosphereOutstanding scratch-made foodFast and friendly service
Nestled in the heart of Indianapolis, Pizza Di Tito promises a delightful culinary experience with friendly staff and a warm, inviting atmosphere. The breakfast and scratch-made offerings shine, with outstanding salads, pizza, and pepperoni breadsticks. Consistent good food and service make it a must-stop for downtown workers and a favorite lunch spot since 2004. An overcooked slice aside, the delicious pizza and fast service keep customers coming back for more. Interacting with co-workers and owner Tito adds to the appeal, creating a slice of heaven worth revisiting.
Napolis Pizza
9/10 (811 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 317-545-1907
Delicious pizzaFresh saladsCharming service
Napolis Pizza is a hidden gem in Indy that offers excellent pizza and breadsticks. The salads are top-notch, loaded with fresh veggies and grilled chicken, and the house Eye-talian dressing is a standout. The service may be a bit rough around the edges, but it adds to the charm of this lunch joint. The dining area can feel a bit stuffy, but the New York-style pizza is worth it, with gooey slices and a variety of delicious toppings available. Overall, Napolis is a real place with reasonable prices and great food.
Blaze Pizza
8.6/10 (1470 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 317-300-7490
Fresh ingredientsEnthusiastic staffWelcoming environment
Blaze Pizza on Michigan Road is a hidden gem, with fresh ingredients, enthusiastic staff, and a clean, welcoming environment that keeps customers coming back. The convenience of the location and the consistent quality of the pizza make it a favorite among patrons, with friendly and respectful service setting it apart from other fast-food options. The engaging atmosphere and personalized attention from the staff make each visit a pleasant experience that leaves a lasting impression on diners.
Magoo’s California Pizza
9.2/10 (1355 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 317-293-4411
Zabiha halal pizzaFresh and juicy ingredientsAuthentic flavors
Magoo’s California Pizza offers a unique dining experience with their Zabiha halal pizza options. Customers rave about the fresh and juicy meat on options like the meat lover pizza, kebab pizza, and chicken tikka pizza. The perfectly seasoned sauces and authentic flavors make each bite a delight. The staff at Magoo’s always go the extra mile to ensure customer satisfaction, making you feel welcomed and valued every visit.
Enzo Pizza
9.2/10 (1291 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 317-808-2284
Huge slicesFast serviceConvenient drive-thru
Enzo Pizza offers huge slices cooked to order, with a nice light crisp crust and plenty of toppings. The service is fast and friendly, the restaurant is clean, and the prices are reasonable, making it a solid choice for those looking for good pizza without breaking the bank. While not everyone may have had a perfect experience, Enzo’s consistency and convenience, including a drive-thru option, make it a popular spot worth trying out.