Whether you’re craving a classic New York-style fold or a gourmet Neapolitan masterpiece, Kansas City offers a selection of pizza spots that promise to satisfy every palate.
From crispy thin crusts adorned with local produce to hearty deep-dish wonders that ooze with molten cheese, Kansas City’s pizza scene offers something to satiate every palate. This guide curates the city’s standout pizzerias, each offering a unique slice of culinary heaven.
Nick’s Italian Pizza
9.4/10 (297 reviews)
| Directions | +1 913-321-1610
Generous lunch specialVariety of toppingsThin flavorful crust
Nick’s Italian Pizza is a popular spot known for their lunch special of 2 large slices and a drink, making it a great value for those looking for a quick and filling meal. The chicken bacon ranch pizza with a white sauce is a standout favorite, but all of the toppings are well-loved by customers. The fairly thin crust adds to the overall experience, with many customers returning multiple times for a satisfying meal. While the atmosphere may not be the most glamorous, the warm and friendly staff make up for any shortcomings, creating a welcoming environment for pizza lovers in Kansas City.
Italian Delight
9.2/10 (1857 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 913-287-4323
Olive saladStromboliCozy atmosphere
Italian Delight is a cozy spot serving up classic Italian dishes that hit the spot. The olive salad and Stromboli are standout items that are worth a try. The service may be a bit slow during their soft opening, but the welcoming staff and delicious food make up for it. The cozy atmosphere and decently priced menu make this a great option for a laid-back Italian meal.
Pizza Stop
9.2/10 (420 reviews)
| Directions | +1 913-334-2803
Real dough breadFresh ingredientsFriendly staff
Pizza Stop is unlike any other pizza joint in town. Their Mexican pizza is a standout, featuring real dough bread that is light and not greasy. The freshness of the ingredients truly shines through in each bite, making it a top choice for any pizza lover. The clean and welcoming atmosphere adds to the charm of this mom and pop shop that has been serving pizzas since the 70s. The staff is friendly and attentive, ensuring a pleasant dining experience. While the prices may be slightly higher than the chain pizza spots, the quality at Pizza Stop is truly unmatched.
Imo’s Pizza
9/10 (540 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 913-677-4667
Unique StLouis-style pizzaFriendly and knowledgeable staffGenerously topped pizzas
Imo’s Pizza is a must-visit spot if you find yourself passing through Kansas City. The unique St. Louis-style pizza with its cracker-thin crust and signature Provel cheese sets it apart from the traditional pizza joints. The pizzas are generously topped, allowing you to see each delicious ingredient, from the crispy bacon to the fresh veggies. The staff is knowledgeable and friendly, always willing to provide a warm and welcoming dining experience. Imo’s commitment to quality shines through in every bite, making it a standout choice for pizza lovers looking for something different.
1889 Pizza Napoletana
8.8/10 (519 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 913-608-5889
Cozy atmosphereQuality ingredientsPerfectly cooked pizza
Walking into 1889 Pizza Napoletana is like stepping into a cozy Italian eatery. The atmosphere is warm and inviting, with top-notch service to match. The pizza is definitely the star of the show here, cooked to perfection in a stone-fired oven. Each bite showcases a crunchy crust with a soft interior, complemented by quality ingredients and a good tomato sauce. While some may find the sausage to be a bit bland, the variety of pizzas offered, like the Piccante or the pizza of the month with prosciutto and sweet onions, make up for it. The relaxed environment is perfect for families, and the staff, including the sweet and accommodating hostess Liz, go above and beyond to ensure a memorable dining experience.
Peter Piper Pizzeria
9.2/10 (166 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 816-441-7570
Great pizza buffetFresh saladsFun arcade
Peter Piper Pizzeria offers a great pizza buffet with hot and fresh slices, crisp and tasty crust, and good marinara dipping sauce. They also provide a selection of fresh salads and a fun atmosphere with vintage video games and a bar. The staff is friendly, accommodating, and willing to make any kind of pizza upon request to ensure a positive dining experience. The carry-out options and overall menu look promising, making it a great stop for lunch or a casual dinner outing. The clean and inviting space is ideal for families, couples, and anyone looking for a delicious pizza experience.
Third Coast Pizza
9.4/10 (418 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 913-232-9313
Authentic Chicago deep dishDelicious carrot cakeFriendly service
Third Coast Pizza is a hidden gem serving up delicious Chicago style deep dish pizza in Lenexa. The deep dish pizzas are loaded with top-notch ingredients and offer a unique dining experience not often found in Kansas City. The generous portions and friendly service make this family-run pizzeria a standout choice for pizza lovers looking for a taste of the Windy City right in their backyard. And don’t overlook the dessert options – the carrot cake is a must-try, with its moist and flavorful layers that will leave you craving more.
Pizza West
9.2/10 (878 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 913-422-9010
Creative pizzasExcellent servicePerfect crust
Pizza West impresses with its delicious pizza and excellent service. The menu features creative and original pizzas, with high-quality toppings and a perfect crust that left me impressed from start to finish. The warm and welcoming atmosphere, complete with engaging service from Grant, makes for a memorable dining experience that is worth every bite. While the prices may have crept up slightly, the portions and quality of the food still offer good value. Overall, Pizza West is a must-try for any pizza lover looking for a family-friendly place with top-notch offerings.
Pizza Tascio Waldo
9/10 (118 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 816-442-7032
New York styleFresh ingredientsFriendly service
Pizza Tascio Waldo is a hidden gem that delivers incredible New York style pizza. The crust is perfectly crunchy on the outside and chewy on the inside, made with love and fresh ingredients. Toppings are top-notch, and the slices are large. The dining room is clean with cute pizza pictures on the walls, and the staff is friendly and helpful. The service is fast, and the prices are fair. This pizzeria is definitely worth a visit for a delicious and satisfying meal that will leave you wanting more.
Paulie D’s Pizza
9.4/10 (161 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 913-608-5544
Perfectly crafted pizzasFresh and flavorful ingredientsPersonalized and attentive service
Paulie D’s Pizza in Mission, Kansas, has garnered quite the loyal following for good reason. The pizza, crafted solely by Paulie himself, is a standout. With simple yet carefully crafted pies, each bite is a testament to the passion and dedication put into every pie. The dough, sauce, and fresh ingredients come together to create a perfect balance of flavors and textures, making it a must-visit spot for pizza enthusiasts. The inviting atmosphere and personalized service only add to the overall dining experience, making it a top choice for those seeking a delicious, no-fuss pizza fix.
Avelluto’s
9.8/10 (68 reviews)
| Directions | +1 913-232-9834
New York Style PizzaFresh IngredientsClassic Italian Dishes
Avelluto’s is a beloved spot in Mission, known for bringing back the flavors of Italian Delight with a modern twist. The Stromboli and pizza are outstanding, delivering New York style with a unique crispness. The restaurant may lack some amenities like boosters and highchairs, but the food more than makes up for it. Customers can expect fresh ingredients, reasonable prices, and the same great taste that keeps them coming back. The new location is a refreshing update, adding a touch of modernity to the classic Italian dishes. Don’t miss out on the lasagna, it’s truly out of this world.
Hot Rocks Pizza Kitchen
8.8/10 (414 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 816-209-1616
Family-friendly atmospherePerfectly cooked thin-crust pizzaVariety of menu options
Hot Rocks Pizza Kitchen is a family-friendly spot with a clean sports bar atmosphere that isn’t too loud. The pizza, with its perfectly cooked thin crust, is a stand-out dish, and the calzones are a hit with many customers. The arcade area is a favorite among kids, and the attentive servers add to the overall experience. The menu offers a nice variety, making it suitable for a date night, a family dinner, or a celebratory meal with a large group. The only minor downside seems to be the inconsistent service, but the delicious food and welcoming atmosphere make it a worthwhile dining destination.
Buffalo State Pizza Co.
9/10 (733 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 913-648-1313
Thin-thick crustFantastic breadsticksVariety of unique pizzas
Buffalo State Pizza Co. really stands out for its unique crust, starting thin and gradually thickening. The breadsticks are a must-try, some of the best around. The happy hour deal of pizza and beer for $10 is a steal. The variety of pizzas, like the Pesto Pete, offer something different from the usual. However, the thin crust can be a challenge to eat by hand, requiring utensils. The atmosphere is standard, but the staff is helpful and efficient.
Toppers Pizza
9.2/10 (935 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 913-262-7849
Plant-Based MenuCulinary ExcellenceExemplary Customer Service
Toppers Pizza sets itself apart with its delectable Plant-Based (vegan) menu options, showcasing a thoughtful selection that includes the scrumptious Vegan Buffalo Chick’n pizza and the satisfying Vegan Cheeze Bread. The commitment to culinary excellence is evident in the harmonious fusion of flavors in each pizza, a testament to the dedication to quality ingredients. Alongside the exceptional menu offerings, Toppers Pizza shines in its exemplary customer service, with staff displaying professionalism and a genuine eagerness to ensure a delightful dining experience. From prompt and courteous service to attentiveness in addressing customer inquiries or special requests, Toppers Pizza sets a high standard in customer care.
Minsky’s Pizza
8.8/10 (1349 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 816-436-8818
Unique pizzasFresh ingredientsFriendly service
Minsky’s Pizza offers a wide range of unique and delicious options that are sure to satisfy any pizza craving. The Spicy Thai pizza is just the right amount of spice, pleasing customers of all ages. The Tostada pizza is a unique twist, combining the flavors of a soft taco with the convenience of pizza. The attention to detail in the preparation of the toppings ensures that every bite is fresh and flavorful.
Minsky’s
8.6/10 (566 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 913-262-6226
Unique pizza creationsFriendly staffEasy parking
Minsky’s pizza is known for its unique Chicken Cordon Blue pizza with grilled chicken and perfect thin crust. However, some customers have faced issues with greasy pizzas and incorrect orders. The Prairie Village location has received mixed reviews, with some praising the friendly staff while others feel the kitchen staff could use more training. Despite some hiccups, Minsky’s is still a beloved spot for quality ingredients and delicious pizzas.
The Pizza Man
9.4/10 (574 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 913-492-2116
Authentic Chicago flavorsRetro decor and arcade gamesReasonable prices
The Pizza Man offers a taste of Chicago right here in KC, with their authentic Chicago dogs, Italian beef sandwiches, and thin crust pizzas. The retro decor and arcade games add to the old school vibe, making it a cool spot to grab a bite. The prices are reasonable and the food is flavorful, making it a hidden gem worth trying out. With a side of au jus with your pizza and a variety of Chicago-style options, The Pizza Man is a must-visit for those looking for a taste of the Windy City right here in Kansas City.