Whether you’re craving a classic New York-style fold or a gourmet Neapolitan masterpiece, Lafayette offers a selection of pizza spots that promise to satisfy every palate.
From crispy thin crusts adorned with local produce to hearty deep-dish wonders that ooze with molten cheese, Lafayette’s pizza scene offers something to satiate every palate. This guide curates the city’s standout pizzerias, each offering a unique slice of culinary heaven.
Pizza Village
9.2/10 (1255 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 337-232-1418
Cool saladsLively atmosphereCracker crust pizza
Pizza Village is a must-visit spot in Lafayette, with cool and refreshing salads that don’t even need dressing. The atmosphere is lively, with folks engaged in conversations and laughter, truly embodying a sense of community. The cracker crust pizza is a unique and acquired taste that is definitely worth a try. And let’s not forget the small details, like a stirring spoon instead of a straw in your tea, adding to the charm of this long-standing establishment.
Sant Ambroeus Lafayette
8.8/10 (756 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 212-966-2770
Authentic Milano treatsWelcoming ambianceStellar service
Nestled in the heart of Manhattan, Sant Ambroeus Lafayette offers a taste of high quality, authentic treats from Milano in a beautifully designed space inspired by classic Milanese decor. The welcoming staff and delectable wine selection add to the overall experience, making it a must-visit destination in the city. While some dishes may lack bold flavors, the ambiance and service truly shine, creating a dining experience that keeps customers coming back for more.
Pizza Village
9/10 (1146 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 337-706-8644
Thin crust perfectionPremium and unique toppingsStellar pizza experience
Pizza Village delivers a pizza experience like no other in Lafayette. The thin and crispy crust is the star of the show, holding up perfectly under the weight of premium toppings that truly make the pizzas something special. The Pizza Village special is a must-try, showcasing the unique flavors and quality ingredients that set this place apart from the rest. Whether you’re a fan of loaded pizzas or just looking for a delicious thin crust option, Pizza Village has something for everyone.
Jim Deggys (Lafayette) Brick Oven Pizza & Brewery
9.6/10 (58 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 337-345-1122
Budget-friendly pricesDelicious whole wheat pizza crustFriendly and attentive staff
Jim Deggys (Lafayette) Brick Oven Pizza & Brewery offers a welcoming atmosphere with excellent service and delicious food that won’t break the bank. The whole wheat dough base on their pizzas is slightly sweet and pairs perfectly with the tangy sauce and fresh toppings. The fried habanero cheese bites appetizer and cheesebread are standout items that are a must-try. The staff is incredibly nice and attentive, making sure every customer is seated promptly and well taken care of. With budget-friendly prices, a fun and inviting atmosphere, and a wide selection of pizzas, Jim Deggys is certainly worth a visit for a delightful dining experience.
Pizza Artista
9.2/10 (710 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 337-706-7631
Customizable pizzasFriendly staffClean atmosphere
Pizza Artista is a top-tier spot for delicious, personalized pizza with a large selection of toppings. The ability to create your own pizza exactly to your liking is a definite highlight, perfect for picky eaters or those with specific preferences. The staff is friendly and efficient, providing great service in a clean and welcoming environment. The cauliflower crust pizza is a standout, while the option to customize your own pizza is a hit, making it a great spot for families or groups with varying tastes. The overall experience at Pizza Artista is sure to satisfy any pizza cravings, with the only downside being the inconsistent customer service according to some longtime patrons.
DeanO’s Pizza Bertrand
9.2/10 (1713 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 337-233-5446
Unique pizzasSpeedy serviceFriendly staff
DeanO’s Pizza Bertrand is a hidden gem in Lafayette, offering a unique dining experience that keeps customers coming back for more. From their innovative pizzas like the shrimp and blue crab pizza with a sweet Cajun seasoning to their flavorful turkey burger, the menu is full of surprises that are sure to tantalize your taste buds. The restaurant’s speedy service, reasonable prices, and friendly staff create a welcoming atmosphere where you can sit back, relax, and enjoy a delicious meal. Whether you’re a fan of their iconic pizzas or looking to try something new like the pizza burger, DeanO’s will leave you satisfied and eager to return.
LOS TACOS No.1
9.6/10 (738 reviews)
Fresh ingredientsEfficient serviceGenerous portions
LOS TACOS No.1 in NYC is a bustling taco joint that doesn’t disappoint. The simplicity of the menu, the efficient service, and the quality ingredients make it stand out amongst a sea of taco spots. The street-style tacos are fresh and flavorful, rivaling even some of the best on the West Coast. The cactus plate with no rice is a unique and delicious option, and the option to customize your order at the prep area ensures your meal is exactly to your liking. The front-of-house manager Luis ensures top-notch service, while the clean environment and generous portions make it a must-visit in the city.
Osteria Morini
8.8/10 (1282 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 212-965-8777
Fresh charcuterieLively atmosphereMixed service
Osteria Morini offers a hit-and-miss dining experience, with some customers raving about the fresh and delicious pasta and meat dishes, while others found the meals to be bland and overpriced. The charcuterie boards seem to be a standout item, with meats and cheeses cut to order, adding a touch of authenticity to the dining experience. The atmosphere of the restaurant is described as gorgeous, with a quiet ambiance early on that transforms into a lively and bustling scene as the night progresses. The service receives mixed reviews, with some praising the attentive and friendly staff, while others note instances of rudeness or overcharging. Although the location and setup cater more towards smaller groups, Osteria Morini seems to be a decent choice for a casual Italian meal, with potential for improvement in consistency and pricing.
CENTRAL Pizza & Bar
9.2/10 (868 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 337-534-0887
Flavorful wingsCrispy crustInviting atmosphere
CENTRAL Pizza & Bar in Lafayette is known for serving some of the best pizza in town, according to loyal customers. The wings are a standout dish, perfectly fried and covered in flavorful sauce. The pepperoni pizza is a fan favorite, with a crispy crust and plenty of flavor. The garlic knots with three dipping sauces are a must-try appetizer, scoring high marks from diners. The atmosphere is inviting, the service is friendly, and the food is top-notch, making this spot a popular choice for pizza lovers.
Alesi Pizza House
8.6/10 (619 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 337-984-1823
Consistent qualityDelicious red sauceWelcoming atmosphere
Alesi Pizza House has been a Lafayette staple for over 50 years, known for its consistent quality and delicious red sauce with a hint of sweetness. Customers praise dishes like the Chicken Cacciatore, Seafood Manicotti, and the generous portion sizes of the Alesi’s Italian Feast. The restaurant’s welcoming atmosphere and broad wine list make it a favorite among locals and out-of-town visitors alike. Despite some mixed reviews on specific dishes and service, Alesi Pizza House continues to draw in crowds looking for classic Italian comfort food made with care and tradition.
BJ’s Pizza & Deli
8.6/10 (501 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 337-534-4234
Classic pizzasWelcoming staffUpdated decor
BJ’s Pizza & Deli has managed to retain the essence of its classic pizzas while infusing a few modern updates. The table service and revamped decor breathe new life into this nostalgic spot. The flavors of their pizzas, like the Full House, are bold and diverse, offering a delightful medley of toppings that make every bite a unique experience. The welcoming and friendly staff add an extra layer of warmth to the dining experience, ensuring that your visit is not just about the food, but about the overall atmosphere and hospitality.
DeanO’s Pizza South
9/10 (1054 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 337-534-8092
Unique pizza combinationsFresh and flavorful toppingsTake and bake option
Nestled in the heart of the bustling South, DeanO’s Pizza South is a must-visit for any pizza lover. The crust strikes the perfect balance of crunch and chewiness, while the toppings are fresh and flavorful. The Parrain pizza stands out as a fan favorite, with its unique combination of two types of pepperoni, two cheese toppings, and a drizzle of pepper jelly. The shrimp scampi pizza is a delightful surprise, showcasing the kitchen’s creativity and skill. The take and bake option is a great convenience, perfect for those not local to the area. DeanO’s Pizza South is definitely worth a visit for a delicious and enjoyable dining experience.
Ribalta
8.8/10 (2290 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 212-777-7781
Unique wood-oven pizzaOutstanding serviceCozy Italian atmosphere
Ribalta stands out for its wood oven pizza, with unique flavors and an excellent Mr. Purple option that will leave you wanting more. The decor is refreshing and the service is outstanding, with attentive waitstaff. The restaurant offers a cozy atmosphere reminiscent of typical Italian eateries, although limited space may be an issue for some diners. The fried calamari appetizer and margherita pizza with french fries on top are of excellent quality, making this a must-visit spot for authentic Italian cuisine lovers.
Blaze Pizza
9.2/10 (885 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 337-205-0402
Customizable pizzasAffordable pricesOpen kitchen concept
Blaze Pizza offers a unique dining experience where you can customize your pizza with all the toppings you desire at an affordable price. The staff is friendly and efficient, ensuring you get your pizza just the way you want it. The open kitchen concept allows you to watch your pizza being cooked fresh in the oven, adding to the overall enjoyable dining experience. While the menu may lack more specialty pizzas with a variety of toppings, the quality of the food and the cleanliness of the restaurant make it a great spot for a quick and tasty meal.
Little Charli
9.6/10 (245 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 917-261-6303
Cozy atmospherePassionate chefDelicious food
Little Charli is the perfect spot for a cozy and intimate date or a fun night out with friends. The atmosphere is inviting, with candles adding a charming touch. The wood fire oven adds a unique element to the pizza-making experience, making it both entertaining and delicious. Chef Salvatore’s passion for pizza shines through in his helpful guidance during the class, making it a memorable and enjoyable activity. The food, from the appetizers to the dessert pizza, is top-notch and sure to leave you wanting more. Little Charli is a hidden gem that offers a one-of-a-kind dining experience that will have you coming back for more.
Upside Pizza
8.6/10 (619 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 917-409-2989
Vodka slicePepperoni squareThin crust
Upside Pizza has quickly become a local favorite, with customers praising their vodka slice and ground red pepper topping that covers every inch of the pizza. The deep dish may be fine, but it’s the thin crust slices that truly shine here. While some may find the sauce a bit acidic and the cheese slices disappointing, the pepperoni square steals the show with its delicious crust. The Sicilian slice may look a bit unusual, but it hits the spot with its unique flavor. The staff is welcoming and the stone ovens ensure you leave with a piping hot slice in hand. Upside Pizza is definitely worth a visit for a satisfying slice of New York pizza.
Pasquale Jones
8.8/10 (718 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 917-453-0339
Perfectly cooked pizzasThoughtful selection of winesImpeccable service
Nestled in the vibrant heart of NYC, Pasquale Jones embodies the essence of wood-fired cuisine. The star of the show is undoubtedly their crispy, blistered pizzas, cooked to perfection in a wood-fired oven. The clam pie, with its rich flavors, is a must-try, while the lemon-charred chicken showcases the kitchen’s mastery over its technique. A thoughtful selection of Italian wines beautifully complements the robustness of the food, adding a touch of authenticity to the dining experience. Impeccable service from knowledgeable and attentive staff members makes you feel well-cared for, creating a dining experience that is nothing short of flawless.
Emporio
9/10 (1158 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 212-966-1234
Delicious wood-fired pizzaFlavorful kale saladCozy and chic atmosphere
Emporio is a delightful Italian spot nestled in SoHo, offering a cozy atmosphere and a menu filled with fresh and flavorful dishes. The pizza here is a standout, with a wood-fired crust that’s a definite crowd-pleaser. The kale salad is another must-try, bursting with delicious ingredients that are sure to please any palate. While some dishes may fall short, like the undercooked pasta, the overall experience at Emporio is one that shouldn’t be missed.
L’Amore Restaurant
9.4/10 (1821 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 212-810-6063
Delicious lobster ravioliAttentive and friendly staffCozy and inviting atmosphere
L’Amore Restaurant is a hidden gem in the heart of Little Italy, offering a cozy and inviting atmosphere for delicious Italian cuisine. The lobster ravioli is a standout dish, bursting with flavor that will leave you craving more. The attentive service from staff like Ayman and Alex adds to the overall experience, making you feel like a welcomed guest. Whether you’re enjoying a leisurely meal outside or seeking a quick bite, L’Amore Restaurant is a must-visit spot for an authentic taste of Italy.
Arturo’s Pizzeria & Restaurant – Lafayette
9/10 (380 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 973-383-4414
Affordable, Delicious, Hospitable
Nestled in the heart of Lafayette, Arturo’s Pizzeria & Restaurant is a hidden gem that offers delicious, affordable Italian cuisine. With a diverse menu featuring favorites like pizza, rice balls, and chicken francese, this local spot has something for everyone. The staff is known for their warm hospitality, making each visit a memorable experience. Whether you’re looking for a quick lunch or a family dinner, Arturo’s is sure to satisfy your cravings with their perfectly cooked pizzas and giant calzones. Don’t miss out on trying their turkey panini or fresh garlic knots – you won’t be disappointed!
.