Whether you’re craving a classic New York-style fold or a gourmet Neapolitan masterpiece, Lakeland offers a selection of pizza spots that promise to satisfy every palate.
From crispy thin crusts adorned with local produce to hearty deep-dish wonders that ooze with molten cheese, Lakeland’s pizza scene offers something to satiate every palate. This guide curates the city’s standout pizzerias, each offering a unique slice of culinary heaven.
Palace Pizza
9.2/10 (3043 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 863-688-0045
Authentic Italian tasteCrispy deep dish pizzaFriendly and fast service
Palace Pizza is a must-visit spot in Lakeland for those craving a taste of authentic Italian cuisine. With fast service, a cozy atmosphere, and delicious pizza slices made fresh in front of you, this place is a gem. The deep dish pizza is surprisingly crispy and the marinara dipping sauce strikes the perfect balance between sweet and savory. The calzones, garlic knots, tiramisu, and house salad are also top-notch. Whether you’re a local or just passing through, Palace Pizza is worth a visit for a satisfying and mouthwatering meal experience.
That 716 Pizza Joint
9.2/10 (297 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 863-884-4252
Authentic Buffalo flavorsLaid-back atmosphereDelicious, fresh food
That 716 Pizza Joint serves up authentic Buffalo, New York flavors that leave customers coming back for more. From the meat lover’s pizza to the boneless wings, every dish is a hit. The dough is reminiscent of what you would find in upstate NY, and the pepperoni is a must-try. The laid-back atmosphere with Buffalo sports memorabilia adds to the charm, making it a must-visit spot for delicious food and a taste of home.
Primo’s Pizzeria
9.2/10 (804 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 863-669-1020
Fresh flavorsWarm hospitalityTop-notch service
Primo’s Pizzeria in Lakeland is hailed for its fresh and flavorful dishes that leave customers feeling like family with the warm hospitality provided by owner Sal and his staff. The Bake Ziti with meatballs, ham & cheese hot sub, chicken tender with fries, garlic knots, and Specialty Italian antipasto salad are all popular menu items that customers rave about. The service is described as attentive and the food is well-priced, making it a worthwhile dining experience. The deep dish pizzas are a must-try, and the customer service is consistently top-notch, ensuring a satisfying visit each time.
Il Forno Italian Restaurant and pizzeria
9/10 (1190 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 863-607-6030
Homemade AlfredoCozy atmosphereAttentive service
Il Forno Italian Restaurant and pizzeria delivers a pleasant dining experience according to numerous guests. The menu offers an array of delectable dishes including fettuccine Alfredo and gnocchi, with homemade Alfredo sauce stealing the show. The service is efficient and attentive even during busier times, with large portions catering to hungry diners. The restaurant’s atmosphere is charming and welcoming, perfect for a cozy Italian meal. Il Forno is a delightful option for those seeking authentic Italian cuisine with a touch of warmth and hospitality.
Pizza Odyssey
9.6/10 (99 reviews)
| Directions | +1 863-937-5562
Creative specialty pizzasFresh and flavorful ingredientsConvenient location in Lake Morton Market & Deli
Pizza Odyssey, located in the Lake Morton Market & Deli, offers a unique and delicious pizza experience in Lakeland. The dough is crispy yet soft, the sauce is flavorful, and the cheese is perfectly balanced. The menu features specialty options with creative toppings and sauces, such as the “Not Your Momma’s” with cup pepperoni, mushrooms, spinach, and garlic ricotta. The atmosphere may be more suited for takeout, but the quality of the pizzas is outstanding. The location is perfect for a leisurely meal, with chairs outside to enjoy the surroundings or a quick walk to the nearby park around the lake for a peaceful dining experience.
Romeo’s Pizza & Pasta
8.8/10 (1227 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 863-816-8100
Fresh ingredientsFlavorful meat ravioliWelcoming environment
Romeo’s Pizza & Pasta has been making waves in the local dining scene for all the right reasons. The freshness of their ingredients shines through in every bite, from the perfectly chewy dough to the flavorful toppings. The meat ravioli is a standout dish, with a sauce that truly makes a difference. The friendly service and welcoming environment make it a top choice for a delicious meal out. Even the garlic knots are a must-try, showcasing the quality and care put into each dish. If you’re looking for a local gem that outshines national pizza chains, look no further than Romeo’s Pizza & Pasta.
Mellow Mushroom Lakeland
8.6/10 (2314 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 863-825-6000
Unique decorQuick serviceDelicious Pretzel Bites
Mellow Mushroom Lakeland is a unique and fun chain pizza joint that offers a great atmosphere and variety of freshly made pizzas with unique combinations. The location in Lakeland stands out with its fun decor and quick, attentive service from kind staff. In addition to their delicious pizzas, Mellow Mushroom offers decent salads and non-pizza items, such as the heavenly Pretzel Bites with Beer Cheese. The large menu includes vegetarian and gluten-free options, making it a great spot for all types of diners. With a relaxed feel and food that’s a total flavor explosion, Mellow Mushroom is truly a standout pizza destination.
Pizzeria Valdiano
8.6/10 (620 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 863-686-3730
Authentic flavorsCrispy wingsGenerous portions
Pizzeria Valdiano offers a taste of true Italian flavors with its perfectly cooked pizzas and delicious wings. The buffalo chicken pizza with Gorgonzola cheese stands out, allowing the toppings to shine on a not-too-thick crust. The crispy wings add a delightful crunch to the meal, though the crust could use a bit more flavor. The atmosphere is welcoming, making it a great spot for families to enjoy an authentic Italian meal. The generous portions and reasonable prices make it a place worth returning to.
KC’s Artisan Pizza and Wine Bar
9.2/10 (560 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 863-644-8000
Diverse menuScratch-made foodExcellent service
KC’s Artisan Pizza and Wine Bar offers a delightful dining experience with exceptional service and a menu that goes beyond your typical pizza joint. The diverse range of offerings includes unique items like eggplant Melanzana, Turkish-inspired lunch options, and an array of vegan and gluten-free choices. The attention to detail and quality shine through in dishes like the Saffron pesto pasta and the flavorful Chef’s Special Pork Kebab. The commitment to fresh, scratch-made food is evident, making KC’s a standout gem in the area.
J. Burns’ Pizza Shop
8.8/10 (853 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 863-450-2986
Thin, crispy pizzaIndividual-sized 7” pizzasEfficient service
J. Burns’ Pizza Shop offers a unique dining experience with its thin and crispy pizza cut into bite-sized squares, perfect for sharing or enjoying on your own. The option of a 7” pizza is a standout feature, catering to individual appetites. The inclusion of sub sandwiches alongside the pizza menu adds variety to the offerings. The quick and efficient service, complemented by ice-cold drinks and a clean environment, ensures a pleasant dining experience. The overall attention to detail and commitment to quality make J. Burns a must-visit spot in Lakeland.
Cicala’s Pizzeria & Restaurant
9/10 (69 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 863-859-4911
Huge portionsClassic NY styleFriendly service
Cicala’s Pizzeria & Restaurant offers classic NY style pizza by the slice, with huge portions that won’t disappoint. The Stromboli is a standout item, loaded with meat and flavors that hit the spot. The meatball sub is another winner, with a delicious taste that makes it worth a try. The calzones are massive and under $20, perfect for sharing or enjoying as leftovers. While some menu items may miss the mark, the overall experience at Cicala’s is worth a visit for the friendly service and great food.
Palace Southside
9/10 (620 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 863-619-5919
Seafood SpaghettiExceptional serviceVaried menu options
Palace Southside is a dining gem that consistently delivers delicious food and exceptional service. The seafood spaghetti is a standout dish that will leave you craving more, and the tiramisu is an absolute must-try for dessert. The staff goes above and beyond to ensure a memorable dining experience, making sure every need is met with kindness and attentiveness. The menu offers a variety of options beyond just pizza, including stromboli, calzones, and pasta, all of which are expertly prepared and bursting with flavor. Whether dining in, taking out, or ordering delivery, Palace Southside’s commitment to excellence shines through in every bite.
Jet’s Pizza
9/10 (634 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 863-709-0999
Delicious deep dishFlawless online orderingFriendly staff
Jet’s Pizza in Lakeland is known for serving up the best deep dish pizza in town, with customers raving about the delicious flavors and generous toppings. The Detroit-style pan pizza is a crowd favorite, rich and filling, making it a must-try for pizza lovers. Customers also appreciate the convenient online ordering system, ensuring their hot and ready meals are always prepared on time. The friendly staff adds to the overall positive experience, making Jet’s a top choice for a quick and satisfying family dinner in the area.
Palace Italian Restaurant north
8.8/10 (1599 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 863-853-1316
Consistent menuLarge portion sizesCozy atmosphere
Located in North Lakeland, Palace Italian Restaurant north is a gem that shouldn’t be missed. The menu, which has remained consistent over the years, boasts delicious options such as stuffed pizza with a double crust and garlicky flavor that will leave you craving more. The Lobster Ravioli and the calzone are also standout dishes that are bound to impress even the pickiest of eaters. With a bright and inviting atmosphere, excellent service, and generous portion sizes, Palace Italian Restaurant north is a must-visit spot for authentic Italian cuisine.
MJ’s Pizza & Wings
8.6/10 (162 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 863-816-6950
Unbeatable garlic knotsDeep-fried wingsNY-style pizza
MJ’s Pizza & Wings offers a truly unique dining experience with standout menu items that keep customers coming back for more. The garlic knots are a fan favorite, boasting unbeatable flavor that leaves a lasting impression. The Hawaiian pizza, cheese pizza, and regular salad with Italian dressing are all solid choices, but the real star of the show is the garlic knots that are so irresistible, they are sure to leave you craving more. The wings are deep-fried to perfection, while the NY-style pizza is a hit with locals and visitors alike. MJ’s also scores points for its friendly service and clean dining area. If you’re in Lakeland, MJ’s Pizza & Wings is a must-visit destination for a delicious and satisfying meal.
J. Burns’ Pizza Shop South
9/10 (109 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 863-377-9997
Thin-crust pizzaFresh ingredientsFriendly staff
J. Burns’ Pizza Shop South offers a delightful experience with top-notch service and a cozy atmosphere. The thin-crust deluxe pizza is a standout, with fresh ingredients that shine in every bite. The tomato base is light, allowing the toppings to truly be the star. The teriyaki sauce on the boneless wings is a crowd pleaser. The staff is friendly and attentive, making for a pleasant dining experience every time.
Jet’s Pizza
8.6/10 (104 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 863-333-0322
Flavorful pepperoniFriendly staffFresh and hot pizzas
Jet’s Pizza is a beloved pizza spot that has captured the hearts of many customers over the years. Their menu is filled with delicious options like the Greek deep dish pizza and the Hawaiian on cauliflower crust, all of which are cooked to perfection. Customers rave about the flavorful pepperoni and how fresh and hot the pizzas are upon arrival. The staff is known for being friendly and accommodating, making the ordering process a breeze. While some may have experienced a minor hiccup with their order, the overall consensus is that Jet’s Pizza is a must-try for pizza lovers everywhere.
Palace Pizza Highland City
8.6/10 (599 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 863-709-8683
Fast serviceLarge portionsTasty pizza
Palace Pizza Highland City delivers on its promise of fast service and delicious food. The garlic knots and wings were cooked to perfection, and the large combo Stromboli truly lives up to its size. The loaded fries, meatballs, and sausage were also hits amongst customers. While some reviews mentioned issues with dessert quality and lackluster customer service, the overall consensus is that the pizza is consistently tasty and worth a try.
Wabash Pizzeria and Ice Cream company
9.2/10 (197 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 863-937-3773
Fresh, flavorful pizzaPersonalized, welcoming serviceFamily-friendly atmosphere
Wabash Pizzeria and Ice Cream company is a local favorite, known for its delicious pizza and welcoming atmosphere. The owner, who often interacts with customers, adds a personal touch to the dining experience. The food is fresh and flavorful, with options like a large meatlovers pizza and garlic knots with a tasty garlic herb sauce. The small, family-friendly setting with arcade games and friendly staff creates a comfortable and enjoyable vibe. The ice cream is also a hit, completing the meal with a sweet treat. If you’re in the area, it’s definitely worth stopping by for a satisfying meal and a warm, welcoming atmosphere.
Nick & Moes
9.2/10 (358 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 863-858-0928
Fresh foodConvenient minitruck stopStellar service
Nick & Moes is a hidden gem worth visiting for its unique offerings. The minitruck stop setup is convenient for those on the go, with good food options, a well-stocked liquor store, and propane services. The standout employee Sebastian provides top-notch service and ensures the food is always fresh. Despite some inconsistency with other staff members, Nick & Moes is a reliable stop for a quick bite or essentials, just make sure to check your receipts carefully for accurate pricing.