Whether you’re craving a classic New York-style fold or a gourmet Neapolitan masterpiece, Lancaster offers a selection of pizza spots that promise to satisfy every palate.
From crispy thin crusts adorned with local produce to hearty deep-dish wonders that ooze with molten cheese, Lancaster’s pizza scene offers something to satiate every palate. This guide curates the city’s standout pizzerias, each offering a unique slice of culinary heaven.
LUCA
9.2/10 (1590 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 717-553-5770
Friendly staffChef’s counter seatingAwesome food
LUCA truly lives up to the hype, offering an excellent Italian dining experience. The staff is top-notch, with friendly and attentive service that adds to the cool ambiance of the restaurant. Sitting at the chef’s counter is a treat, watching delicious creations come to life. The food is simply awesome, featuring simple dishes done with exceptional quality and immense flavor. Luca is a must-visit establishment for those who enjoy fine creative food.
Pizza Crossing Lancaster
9/10 (532 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 740-681-9889
Family-oriented atmosphereDelicious pizzasTop-notch service
Pizza Crossing Lancaster offers a welcoming, family-oriented atmosphere that is perfect for a relaxed meal with loved ones. The menu features a variety of delicious options, including mouth-watering pizzas, flavorful Italian subs, and fresh salads. The service is top-notch, with attentive staff members who ensure a pleasant dining experience. The food is consistently hot, fresh, and tasty, making it a favorite spot for locals and visitors alike. Whether you’re in the mood for a classic Meat Lovers Pizza or crave some BQ Buffalo Wings, Pizza Crossing Lancaster is sure to satisfy your cravings.
Gino’s Italian Restaurant
9/10 (631 reviews)
| Directions | +1 661-945-2791
Quick serviceFlavorful lasagnaFair prices
Gino’s Italian Restaurant excels in quick, amazing service and delicious, flavorful dishes. The lasagna is a standout, with its gooey cheese and perfect seasoning. Complimentary breadsticks add to the experience, melting in your mouth and leaving you craving more. The ambiance is perfect for a romantic night out or a casual dinner, and the fair prices ensure you leave satisfied and happy.
Round Table Pizza
8.8/10 (440 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 661-945-6677
Outstanding red sauceGooey cheeseExceptional customer service
Round Table Pizza is a gem with its outstanding red sauce and perfect amount of gooey cheese melting into the tasty pepperoni slices. The regular crust was a hit, delivering a perfectly delicious pizza that was well worth the wait. The salad bar is top-notch, and the customer service is exceptional, with staff members like Matt and the girl with the red hair going above and beyond to make the dining experience memorable. The complimentary pizza coupon for a previous mistake shows a commitment to making things right and ensuring customers leave satisfied. The large dining area is spacious, allowing for a safe and enjoyable dining experience, perfect for a family meal or celebration.
Big Belly Pizza Company
8.8/10 (363 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 661-941-3339
Delicious pizzasFlavorful wingsFresh and tasty toppings
Big Belly Pizza Company is a local gem known for its delicious pizzas and flavorful wings. The crust is crispy, and the toppings are fresh and tasty, truly standing out in the area. The BBQ chicken, pepperoni pizza, and wings are all worth trying, cooked to perfection and satisfying every time. The Mac and cheese bites are a hit with young diners, adding to the overall experience. The pricing may be a bit higher, but the quality and flavor make it well worth it. The only downside seems to be occasional inconsistencies in preparation, as some dishes may not always meet expectations.
RigaTony’s Pizza & Pasta
9.2/10 (873 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 661-943-4443
Authentic Italian flavorsSpeedy serviceQuality ingredients
Nestled in California, RigaTony’s Pizza & Pasta is a hidden gem worth discovering. From piping hot and cheesy pizzas to flavorful subs and meatballs, this spot delights customers with its authentic Italian fare. The staff’s efficiency and quality ingredients shine through, making it a favorite among locals. The inviting ambiance and speedy service add to the overall charm of this neighborhood joint.
Ciro’s Italian Bistro
9/10 (1023 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 717-560-5660
Authentic Italian cuisineTop-notch serviceGenerous portions
Ciro’s Italian Bistro is the ideal spot for those craving authentic Italian cuisine paired with top-notch service. The menu features standout dishes such as Chicken Piccata and Seafood Fra Diavolo that will have your taste buds dancing with delight. The welcoming staff, including owner Tony and server Stephanie, ensure a warm and hospitable dining experience. The generous portions leave you satisfied, especially when indulging in delectable desserts like cannoli from the gelato bar. While some minor imperfections may exist, the overall dining experience at Ciro’s Italian Bistro is sure to leave you planning your next visit.
The Fridge
9.2/10 (986 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 717-490-6825
Great craft beerDelicious thin-crust pizzaWelcoming staff
The Fridge delivers on both pizza and beer lovers’ expectations, boasting a great selection of craft beers and delicious thin-crust pizzas that are sure to satisfy your cravings. With indoor and outdoor seating options, including a new renovated area, there’s plenty of space to enjoy your meal, whether you’re a Lancaster local or just passing through. The welcoming staff is always ready to offer suggestions and share a laugh, making your dining experience even more enjoyable. Don’t miss the cumin-flavored popcorn paired with your beer for a unique and tasty treat.
The Raven’s Nest
9/10 (456 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 661-579-6982
Creative menuWarm and welcoming atmosphereThoughtful attention to detail
Upon indulging in the exquisite offerings at The Raven’s Nest, I found myself pleasantly surprised by the upscale yet warm atmosphere that enveloped me upon entry. The creativity and daring nature of the menu truly set this establishment apart, offering a refreshing change from the ordinary. The attention to detail put into every dish was evident, ensuring that each bite was a culinary journey worth embarking on. From delectable vegetarian options to the proclaimed best ceviche around, the flavors truly spoke for themselves. Though some may find it a tad pricey, the experience and quality of the food make it well worth every penny.
Little Nicki’s Pizza
9.4/10 (460 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 717-733-2400
Diverse menuGenerous portionsFriendly staff
Nestled in a small strip mall, Little Nicki’s Pizza offers a diverse menu with generous portion sizes at reasonable prices. The staff is informative and friendly, providing top-notch service. Their pizza stands out with a crisp crust, perfect sauce to cheese ratio, and ample toppings, making it the best in Ephrata. The cheesesteaks are a must-try, and the cheese fries are simply the best in the area. Whether you’re looking for a delicious Philly cheese steak or a quality Italian pizza, Little Nicki’s is sure to satisfy your cravings.