Whether you’re craving a classic New York-style fold or a gourmet Neapolitan masterpiece, Lexington offers a selection of pizza spots that promise to satisfy every palate.
From crispy thin crusts adorned with local produce to hearty deep-dish wonders that ooze with molten cheese, Lexington’s pizza scene offers something to satiate every palate. This guide curates the city’s standout pizzerias, each offering a unique slice of culinary heaven.
Lexington Pizza Parlour
8.6/10 (456 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 212-722-7850
Charming atmosphereVaried menuFriendly staff
Lexington Pizza Parlour is a charming spot to grab a meal, offering a delightful atmosphere with covered sidewalk tables that add to the experience. The menu boasts a variety of options, from watermelon burrata salad to meatball calzones, all of which leave a lasting impression on diners. While some may find the portion sizes a bit small for the price, the quality of the food is undeniable. The attentive and friendly staff, along with the cozy ambiance, make this restaurant a must-visit, perfect for a cozy dinner as the sun sets in the city.
Pies & Pints – Lexington, KY
9/10 (1421 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 859-231-7437
Generous portionsExtensive beer selectionDelicious pizza options
Pies & Pints in Lexington, KY offers generous portions of fresh, high-quality food with an extensive beer selection, including root beer on tap. The variety of pizza options, from steak and mushroom to chicken gouda, will leave you satisfied and craving more. The salads are a great value, and the service is friendly and attentive.
Smashing Tomato Italian Pizzeria by Fayette Mall
9.2/10 (490 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 859-273-0184
Authentic Neapolitan pizzaFriendly and attentive staffCozy atmosphere
Nestled near Fayette Mall, Smashing Tomato Italian Pizzeria serves up some of the best Neapolitan pizza in Lexington. The staff is kind, respectful, and goes above and beyond to ensure a memorable dining experience. The tomato and chicken soup is a standout dish, packing a flavorful punch that is perfectly balanced by the accompanying bread. The cozy atmosphere adds to the overall dining experience, making it a must-visit spot for pizza lovers in the area.
Goodfellas Pizzeria – Mill Street
8.6/10 (1138 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 859-281-1101
Unique atmosphereFlavorful pizzaFriendly staff
Goodfellas Pizzeria – Mill Street is a local gem, serving up piping hot slices in a cool, lively atmosphere. Despite some occasional missteps like burnt bottoms, the pizza shines with its sweet sauce, perfect grease levels, and thin, flavorful crust. The staff, though sometimes forgetful with orders, make up for it with their friendly, energetic personalities that elevate the dining experience. The calzone may be hit or miss, but the overall vibe of the place, complete with singing staff and good music, makes it a must-visit for a casual night out.
Joe Bologna’s Restaurant & Pizzeria
9/10 (984 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 859-252-4933
Historic charmGiant breadsticksFlavorful tomato sauce
Nestled in an old church, Joe Bologna’s Restaurant & Pizzeria offers a unique dining experience with its historic charm and delicious giant breadsticks that customers can’t get enough of. The crust and dough are standout features that set their pizzas apart, complemented by a different but flavorful tomato sauce. The attentive staff and welcoming ambiance make dining here a delightful experience that keeps customers coming back time and time again.
West Coast Gourmet Pizza
8.6/10 (161 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 859-317-8234
Unique pizzasDelicious house-made white sauceQuick service
West Coast Gourmet Pizza offers unique pizzas with delicious house-made white sauce and gluten-free options. The Malibu Barbie Pizza, cooked perfectly and delivered early, is a standout. The Popeye Calzone shines, but the chicken wings are disappointing. The restaurant’s fair treatment of customers and quick service make it a hidden gem in the city. The dipping ranch is a must-try. Delivery mishaps and inconsistent quality may be issues to be aware of, but overall, the gourmet quality and competitive pricing make West Coast Gourmet Pizza a worthwhile stop for those seeking a unique pizza experience.
Smashing Tomato Pizzeria at Hamburg
9.2/10 (645 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 859-264-1500
Incredible crustFriendly staffMust-try tomato soup
Nestled in Hamburg, Smashing Tomato Pizzeria is a hidden gem worth experiencing. The environment is smooth and casual, with a friendly staff that goes above and beyond to ensure a delightful dining experience. The tomato soup and artichoke dip are must-try items, served at the perfect temperature and accompanied by delicious toasted bread. What truly sets this pizzeria apart is their incredible crust, which is simply unmatched in flavor and texture. While the sauce may be a bit plain for some, the quality of the ingredients and overall attention to detail shine through in every bite. If you’re in the mood for a break from the ordinary, Smashing Tomato Pizzeria is the perfect place to indulge in a truly exceptional meal.
West Coast Gourmet Pizza
8.6/10 (170 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 859-253-5247
Fresh ingredientsMassive calzonesPrompt delivery
West Coast Gourmet Pizza is a hidden gem worth discovering. The pizza is fresh, not greasy, and bursting with quality ingredients. Their calzones are massive, sandwiches are scrumptious, and the unique toppings set them apart. The breadsticks are truly life-changing and the delivery service is prompt and sweet with small touches that make a big difference. This place feels like a cozy neighborhood spot run by dedicated individuals passionate about their craft, making it a must-try spot.
PieTana
9.4/10 (520 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 859-687-0333
Unique wood-fired crustExceptional customer serviceFresh and generous toppings
PieTana in Lexington, KY is a hidden gem with unique offerings that set it apart from traditional pizza joints. The wood-fired oven creates a crust that is soft yet crunchy, with perfectly browned bits that add texture to each bite. The toppings are fresh and generously topped with cheese, making each slice a delightful experience. The customer service is exceptional, with staff going above and beyond to ensure a positive dining experience. Despite a small space, the lively vibe adds to the charm of this local favorite.
Pie Five Pizza
9.2/10 (482 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 859-271-6839
Variety of pizzasIndividual size optionsPlayful decor
As a food journalist, I am pleased to share my thoughts on Pie Five Pizza. The variety of pizza options and toppings, along with the individual size pie choices, make it easy for everyone to find something they enjoy. The restaurant’s playful decor and friendly staff create a welcoming atmosphere that adds to the overall dining experience. The crispy crust and delicious flavors of the pizza, along with the great value for the price, make it a fantastic choice for a quick lunch or dinner.
Blaze Pizza
9/10 (443 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 859-523-4340
Fast serviceCustomizable pizzasModern design
Blaze Pizza is a consistent favorite among customers for its fast service and delicious customizable pizzas. The staff are known to be speedy and kind, creating an efficient and pleasant dining experience. The Build Your Own (BYO) pizzas are a standout, with endless customization options that cater to a variety of tastes. The Cheesy Pesto Garlic Bread and warm desserts like brownies and s’mores add a delightful touch to the meal. The modern and sleek design of the restaurant, with a designated line area, adds to the overall appeal of Blaze Pizza.
Stoner’s Pizza Joint
9.4/10 (701 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 859-303-6088
Fresh toppingsFriendly serviceCommitment to community
Stoner’s Pizza Joint delivers a mixed bag of experiences, with some customers voicing complaints about missing items and incorrect orders, while others praise the delicious pizzas and friendly service. One customer claims the pizza is the best they’ve ever had in Lexington, while another laments the subpar quality of the garlic knots and cheese sticks. However, the Cheesecake Stromboli, Italian Steak Sandwich, and Pep-n-Rollie all receive mixed reviews, with some items arriving cold or with incorrect toppings. Overall, Stoner’s seems to have some room for improvement in terms of consistency and accuracy in fulfilling orders.
Puccini’s Pizza Pasta-Chevy Chase Place
8.8/10 (508 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 859-269-0404
Unique pizzaFresh saladsVegan options
Puccini’s Pizza Pasta at Chevy Chase Place offers a unique dining experience with delicious food, especially the Shrimp Santa Cruz and vegan options like the Humble Pie with vegan cheese and sausage. The salads are fresh, the blue cheese dressing is a must-try, and the service is top-notch. While some past experiences have been hit or miss, the overall quality of the food and the affordable prices make Puccini’s a hidden gem worth visiting.
Pearl’s Pizza
9/10 (232 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 859-309-0321
Signature breakfast sandwichVariety of fresh ingredientsInviting atmosphere
Pearl’s Pizza in Lexington is more than just a pizza joint—it’s a dining experience not to be missed. The star of the show is their signature breakfast sandwich, a flavor explosion with fluffy eggs, crispy bacon, melted cheese, and a delicious aioli. The variety on the menu ensures that there’s something for everyone, whether you’re a meat lover or veggie enthusiast. But what truly sets Pearl’s apart is the inviting atmosphere and incredibly friendly staff, making you feel right at home. Trust me, a visit to Pearl’s Pizza is an experience you won’t soon forget.
Mad Mushroom
8.8/10 (174 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 859-296-9646
Unique pick-up conceptTasty pizza flavorsConsistent quality
Mad Mushroom offers a unique pick-up and delivery experience, with no indoor seating. Customers rave about the tasty pizza, favoring it over popular chain options. The quick and polite phone service, alongside clean facilities and appropriately dressed workers, add to the overall positive experience. Located just minutes away from Fayette Mall, Mad Mushroom continues to impress with consistent quality and good food, making it a top choice for pizza lovers in town.
Mancino’s Pizza & Grinders
9/10 (846 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 859-253-2299
Fresh doughColossal cookiesHomemade bread
Mancino’s Pizza & Grinders offers fresh, made daily dough and colossal cookies that are worth every tasty morsel. Whether you dine in or opt for carry-out, you are in for a treat with their hot Italian offerings. The in-house homemade bread used for all products sets the foundation for delicious grinders and cheesy bread. The friendly staff adds to the warm ambiance of this neighborhood gem, making each visit a pleasant experience.
Damiano Pizza and Pasta
9.4/10 (69 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 859-303-8373
Quality ingredientsFriendly staffFair pricing
Damiano Pizza and Pasta offers a delicious and comforting dining experience that won’t break the bank. From the perfectly cooked crust to the flavorful sauce, the attention to quality ingredients is evident in every bite. The friendly staff adds to the welcoming atmosphere, making it a great spot for a casual and fun meal. The diverse menu options cater to different tastes, ensuring that there is something for everyone to enjoy.
Donatos Pizza
8.6/10 (283 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 859-543-1818
Delicious pizzaFast serviceFriendly staff
Donatos Pizza stands out for its delicious pizza and the sweeter pizza sauce that gives it a unique flavor. Whether choosing a thin or thicker crust, the quality is consistent. The customer service is always fast and friendly, with employees showing patience and politeness towards customers. Despite a few hiccups, the overall experience is enjoyable, especially with the fresh and tasty pizza options available.
Apollo Pizza Meadowthorpe Taproom
8.8/10 (390 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 859-523-2992
Gattitown
8.6/10 (2526 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 859-277-2323