Home / United States / Wisconsin / Madison

Get more leads!

Get featured here for 6 months.

20 Best Pizza Spots in Madison, WI

Whether you’re craving a classic New York-style fold or a gourmet Neapolitan masterpiece, Madison offers a selection of pizza spots that promise to satisfy every palate.

From crispy thin crusts adorned with local produce to hearty deep-dish wonders that ooze with molten cheese, Madison’s pizza scene offers something to satiate every palate. This guide curates the city’s standout pizzerias, each offering a unique slice of culinary heaven.


Sant Ambroeus Madison

8.8/10 (741 reviews)

Website | Directions | +1 212-570-2211

Fresh high-quality foodCharming ambianceWide dessert selection

Sant Ambroeus Madison on the Upper East Side is a favorite among locals and visitors alike, known for its consistently fresh and high-quality food. The charming ambiance, perfect for people-watching by the window, adds to the dining experience. The wide variety of dessert options is a must-try, and the friendly staff always make patrons feel welcome. With meticulously prepared dishes and select ingredients, Sant Ambroeus Madison truly offers a delightful dining experience for those looking for authentic Italian cuisine in NYC.

Book Now


Patrizia’s Of Manhattan

8.8/10 (1281 reviews)

Website | Directions | +1 212-597-9999

Authentic Italian cuisineGenerous portionsAttentive staff

Patrizia’s Of Manhattan is a destination for those seeking authentic Italian cuisine with a twist. The focaccia basket with garlic dipping oil is a standout, while the avocado salad with walnuts is a generous portion perfect for sharing. The eggplant parmesan is a must-try, with thinly breaded slices and homemade sauce. The overall vibe is casual, with cute outdoor tables and a bustling atmosphere. The food here is delicious, with garlic-infused flavors and perfectly seasoned dishes. The all-you-can-eat option is a great deal, complete with drinks, appetizers, entrees, and desserts. The staff is attentive and friendly, making for a pleasant dining experience. The only downside is the loud music, but this shouldn’t stop you from visiting Patrizia’s Of Manhattan.

Book Now


Carmine’s

9/10 (16047 reviews)

Website | Directions | +1 212-221-3800

Generous PortionsVibrant FlavorsImpeccable Service

Carmine’s in NYC is a must-visit for anyone craving authentic Italian flavors in hearty portions. From the moment you step inside, you’re greeted with a warm and inviting atmosphere that sets the stage for a truly exceptional dining experience. Each dish that arrives at your table is a masterpiece in itself, bursting with vibrant flavors and attention to detail that showcases the culinary expertise of the chefs. The generous portions here aren’t just impressive; they’re downright jaw-dropping, ensuring that every guest leaves fully satisfied. And the wine selection? A perfect accompaniment to elevate your meal to new heights. If you’re looking for a place that offers delicious food, impeccable service, and an unforgettable dining experience, Carmine’s is the place to be.

Book Now


Eleven Madison Park

9/10 (2704 reviews)

Website | Directions | +1 212-889-0905

Unique Tasting MenuCreative Vegan CuisineAttentive Service

Eleven Madison Park is a culinary experience like no other. From the innovative and meticulously crafted vegan dishes to the impeccable service, every aspect of dining here is a delight. The flavors are so well-balanced and the presentation is exquisite. The ambiance is elegant yet warm, and the staff is attentive and knowledgeable. The unique experience of being invited into the kitchen and meeting the talented Chef Dominique Roy truly sets this restaurant apart. Each bite is a revelation, and the whole evening is a truly exceptional dining experience.

Book Now


II Corallo Trattoria

9/10 (1645 reviews)

Website | Directions | +1 212-941-7119

Seafood pastasCozy ambianceFriendly staff

Located in the heart of SoHo, II Corallo Trattoria offers a cozy, inviting atmosphere perfect for a casual date night. The seafood pastas are a standout, with generous portions that can easily serve as a meal on their own. The grilled octopuses and mussels appetizer is a must-try, and the burrata and Quatro Formaggi pizza are absolute winners. The staff is friendly and attentive, providing quick and professional service. The menu features a variety of authentic Italian dishes, from fresh pasta to oven-baked pizza, all reasonably priced. Overall, a great spot for a delicious Italian meal in a charming setting.

Book Now


Toscana 49

9/10 (1038 reviews)

Website | Directions | +1 212-256-0190

Delicious foodExcellent serviceCozy atmosphere

The food at Toscana 49 is simply divine. From the ravioli with asparagus and prosciutto to the salmon and homemade fettuccine, every dish is expertly crafted and bursting with flavor. The bartenders are skilled and the drinks are impeccable, with even the wine attracting unwanted attention from a fly. The atmosphere is cozy and inviting, perfect for a romantic date or dinner with friends. The service is top-notch, with friendly and attentive staff who make you feel right at home. Whether you’re a fan of Italian cuisine or just looking for a delicious meal, Toscana 49 is a must-visit spot in New York City.

Book Now


Slate Cafe NoMad

9.2/10 (1376 reviews)

Website | Directions | +1 212-683-7800

Quick serviceDelicious foodBeautiful decor

Slate Cafe NoMad excels in providing quick and friendly service, making it an ideal spot for a delicious and efficient breakfast or brunch experience. The menu offers a variety of tasty options, including the Salmon and Egg sandwich with insanely good bread and the Avocado White sandwich. The cafe’s beautiful and modern decor enhances the overall dining experience, making it a popular choice among visitors and locals alike. The food is served promptly, with dishes like the Dijon Chicken Pea salad sandwich and the Rose Berry waffles impressing customers with both their beauty and flavor. If you’re looking for a charming cafe with great food, fast service, and a lovely atmosphere, Slate Cafe NoMad is the place to be.


L’Artusi

9.2/10 (1894 reviews)

Website | Directions | +1 212-255-5757

Creative dishesIntimate settingExcellent service

The dishes at L’Artusi are truly a work of art, with standouts like the scallops and steak stealing the show. The unique combinations like the mushroom and egg dish are surprisingly delicious, showcasing the chef’s creativity in the kitchen. While some customers found the pastas underwhelming, the chicken and desserts were mind-blowing, making it a great spot for an intimate dinner in a beautiful setting. The service, atmosphere, and overall experience make it a must-visit spot in NYC.

Book Now


Grand Apizza Madison

9/10 (355 reviews)

Website | Directions | +1 203-245-8438

New Haven-style pizzasExceptional Buffalo wingsCozy and inviting atmosphere

Grand Apizza Madison is a standout gem for pizza lovers in Connecticut. Their New Haven-style pizzas are thin and crispy with a delightful char on the crust that sets them apart from the rest. The cheese pie is a must-try, and the Buffalo wings are next level. The service is exceptional, with fast and courteous staff ensuring a pleasant dining experience. The atmosphere is inviting, whether you choose to dine in at the cozy restaurant or enjoy a change of pace at the bar. The prices are reasonable, making it a great choice for anyone in the area looking for top-notch pizza and a welcoming atmosphere.


Yard House

9/10 (3016 reviews)

Website | Directions | +1 646-434-2448

Wide beer selectionReasonable food pricesAttentive and friendly staff

Yard House’s menu offers a wide variety of beers, making it a top spot for beer lovers. The food prices are reasonable, and diners praise the delicious appetizers and entrees, such as the Maui pineapple chicken. The Oreo brooky dessert is a must-try and never disappoints. Staff members are highlighted for being attentive, friendly, and patient, making it a great spot for families and those looking for a quick, well-priced meal. The self-service kiosk at each table provides detailed descriptions and photos of drinks and appetizers, adding a tech-savvy touch to the dining experience.

Book Now


Hangawi

9.2/10 (1700 reviews)

Website | Directions | +1 212-213-0077

Unique dining experienceFlavorful Korean dishesAttentive service

Hangawi stands out among Korean restaurants in New York City for its unique dining experience, requiring guests to remove their shoes and sit on a floor-level bench. This adds an extra layer of authenticity to the atmosphere. The menu offers a delectable array of Korean dishes, with highlights including truffle dumplings, spicy cauliflower, and flavorful vegan options. The service at Hangawi is top-notch, with attentive staff ensuring a pleasant and memorable dining experience for each guest. While the prices may be on the higher side, the quality of the food and the ambiance make it well worth a visit.

Book Now


Pennsylvania 6

8.6/10 (997 reviews)

Website | Directions | +1 212-727-3666

VarietyTop-tier atmosphereExceptional staff

Pennsylvania 6 offers a unique dining experience with a wide variety of food options. From delicious brunch pizzas to mouth-watering filet and French onion soup, this spot has something for everyone. The atmosphere is top-tier, making you feel right at home whether you’re catching a game or grabbing a bite before a show. The staff goes above and beyond, handling any situation with grace and ensuring a memorable dining experience.

Book Now


Stout NYC

9/10 (365 reviews)

Website | Directions | +1 212-840-0414

Spacious barFestive ambienceGreat beer selection

Stout NYC is a spacious bar with a nice glass frontage for people-watching. Prices are reasonable for Manhattan. The ambience is cozy and festive, perfect for catching up with friends over a great beverage and food selection. However, the service can be hit or miss, and the food may not always live up to expectations. The hot honey chicken and waffles lacked flavor, while the Stout burger was juicy but bland. Despite these issues, the overall experience at Stout NYC is still enjoyable, especially for sports fans looking to watch games in a lively atmosphere.

Book Now


Wine:30

8.6/10 (402 reviews)

Website | Directions | +1 212-481-0197

Extensive wine selectionSeasonal, innovative menuFriendly, knowledgeable staff

Nestled within a cozy setting, Wine:30 is a hidden gem that caters to both wine connoisseurs and food enthusiasts. With an extensive wine selection that accommodates every palate and a seasonal menu crafted from top-quality ingredients, each dish is a delightful experience. The flavors are thoughtfully paired with expertly curated wines, creating a memorable dining experience that is sure to impress.

Book Now


The Grey Dog—Flatiron

8.8/10 (612 reviews)

Website | Directions | +1 212-462-0041

VarietyHappy HourHospitable service

Nestled in the heart of Flatiron, The Grey Dog exudes a cozy and inviting atmosphere perfect for a delicious breakfast or a relaxed happy hour. Their menu boasts an array of options, from the mouthwatering chilaquiles and cheesy spinach artichoke dip to the soft French toast and delectable chicken sandwich. For vegetarians and vegans, the avocado toast topped with a poached egg is a must-try. The service is always top-notch, with shoutouts to Omane for her hospitality. Don’t miss out on their unbeatable happy hour deals on wines, cocktails, and craft beers. The Grey Dog is a gem in the city, offering great food, fast service, and a cool vibe.

Book Now


The Hugh

9.2/10 (479 reviews)

Website | Directions

Variety of cuisinesComfortable seatingBeautiful interior design

The Hugh is a top-quality food hall in Midtown NYC, offering a variety of gastronomic delights that are definitely worth trying. From the creamy and hearty Tom Kha soup at the Thai restaurant to the well-prepared fish and chips at Pesce Lulu, the options here are sure to satisfy any craving. The comfortable seating, beautiful interior design, and plethora of cuisines make it a great spot to visit with family and friends. Whether you’re in the mood for a mouthwatering sandwich from Alidoro or some addictive hot spread from Fratelli, The Hugh has something for everyone, making it a must-visit dining destination in the area.


Eat the Best Pizza

8.8/10 (84 reviews)

Website | Directions | +1 608-819-6019

White pizzaPepperoni sliceBuffalo chicken pizza

Eat the Best Pizza is a hidden gem located below street level, making it a unique find. The white pizza is a standout, with dollops of fresh ricotta elevating it to garlic cheese bread perfection. The plain cheese and pepperoni slices are also impressive, with a perfect crust and ideal sauce to cheese ratio. The buffalo chicken pizza offers a flavorful kick without being overpowering. The foldable, generous slices make it a great value, and the location below the university bookstore adds to the charm. Eat the Best Pizza is a must-visit for anyone craving a taste of New York-style pizza in Madison.


Ian’s Pizza Madison | State Street

9.2/10 (3058 reviews)

Website | Directions | +1 608-257-9248

Unique pizza varietyLively atmosphereEfficient service

Ian’s Pizza Madison | State Street offers a vibrant atmosphere with a wide variety of unique and delicious pizza slices. With options like Mac and Cheese pizza and Barbecue Chicken Bacon Ranch, there is something for every pizza lover to enjoy. The service is efficient and friendly, ensuring that customers get exactly what they ordered. The renovated location has elevated the overall experience, with standout pizzas like the Drunken Ravioli impressing even longtime fans of the restaurant.


Cooper’s Craft & Cocktails

8.8/10 (1277 reviews)

Website | Directions | +1 646-661-7711

Delicious truffle friesGreat craft beer selectionCozy atmosphere with candlelight

Cooper’s Craft & Cocktails is the perfect spot to unwind with friends or enjoy a relaxed date night. The truffle fries are a must-try and the craft beer selection is top-notch. The cozy atmosphere, complete with candlelight in the evenings, creates a welcoming vibe that keeps patrons coming back for more.

Book Now


Empire Diner

8.6/10 (1923 reviews)

Website | Directions | +1 212-335-2277

Chic ambianceElevated menuRetro vibes

Empire Diner is a chic establishment with a rich New York City history and a fantastic outdoor dining setup, perfect for enjoying amazing weather. The menu offers elevated selections compared to a traditional diner, and while the food quality is decent, the atmosphere is worth the visit alone. The service can be a bit slow, as is typical with outdoor dining, but the experience is overall enjoyable, especially with the retro vibes and friendly staff.

Book Now