Whether you’re craving a classic New York-style fold or a gourmet Neapolitan masterpiece, McAllen offers a selection of pizza spots that promise to satisfy every palate.
From crispy thin crusts adorned with local produce to hearty deep-dish wonders that ooze with molten cheese, McAllen’s pizza scene offers something to satiate every palate. This guide curates the city’s standout pizzerias, each offering a unique slice of culinary heaven.
Mama Mia Pizzeria
9/10 (2200 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 956-664-2671
Authentic Italian optionsFlavorful foodCozy atmosphere
Mama Mia Pizzeria is a hidden gem along Bus-83, offering a great variety of Italian dishes and delicious pizza. The Chicago-style options like Italian beef and deep dish pizza are a big bonus, truly standing out as a highlight. The food is consistently flavorful, and the atmosphere is nice and relaxing, making it a must-visit for those looking for an authentic Italian meal in the Rio Grande Valley.
Pieology Pizzeria McAllen
8.6/10 (191 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 956-843-0083
Customizable pizzasExcellent customer serviceHealthy menu options
Pieology Pizzeria McAllen offers a delightful experience for customers, with friendly and knowledgeable staff guiding guests through the menu. The cauliflower crust pizza with customizable toppings is a standout, ensuring a delicious meal every time. The management team, particularly Cris, goes above and beyond to rectify any issues promptly, further enhancing the overall dining experience. The clean and welcoming ambiance, along with a diverse selection of healthy pizza options, make this spot a must-visit for pizza lovers seeking a unique and enjoyable meal.
NAPO Today’s Pizza
9.4/10 (176 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 956-627-4045
Flavorful pizzasFresh ingredientsAttentive service
As I arrived at NAPO Today’s Pizza with my family for a casual lunch, the first thing that caught my eye was the visually appealing theme of the place. The menu offered a good variety of options, and we decided on the half pepperoni half mozzarella pizza. The cheese and toppings were cooked to perfection, creating a flavorful experience. While the middle of the pizza was slightly undercooked, it didn’t detract from the overall taste. The sauces, especially the creamy gorgonzola and Serrano, were a highlight. The service was consistent and attentive, adding to the pleasant dining experience. The fresh taste of the pizza and garlic breadsticks will definitely make this my go-to spot for pizza from now on. The chill atmosphere, outstanding service, and variety of drink options further enhance the appeal of NAPO Today’s Pizza.
Marco’s Pizza
8.8/10 (152 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 956-468-4100
Unique flavorsFriendly staffReasonable prices
Marco’s Pizza offers a unique twist on traditional pizza flavors, such as the Chicken Florentine pizza that comes highly recommended by customers. The menu provides a refreshing change from the standard pizza fare, making it a favorite among many diners. While customer service may vary, the friendly staff and reasonable prices make it a popular choice for those looking for a tasty meal with a different experience.
Il Forno a Legna
8.6/10 (769 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 956-688-9528
Charcuterie boardFlavorful brick oven pizzasGenerous salad portions
Nestled on 10th Street just south of Nolana, Il Forno a Legna serves up delectable brick oven pizzas and mouthwatering entrees. The charcuterie board is a standout, offering a delightful mix of flavors and textures. The fresh salad is a generous portion and the pepperoni pizza boasts a flavorful crust that can be customized to your liking. The dining atmosphere is a perfect backdrop to enjoy the impressive selection of wine and affordable steak options.
Peter Piper Pizza
8.8/10 (1614 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 956-682-5251
Friendly managerFully functioning arcade gamesSpacious play area
Located on 10th Street, Peter Piper Pizza is a standout among pizza restaurants for its exceptional service and impressive gaming options. The manager, Mr. Willie G.M., stands out for his friendly demeanor and hands-on approach with both guests and staff. The restaurant boasts an array of fully functioning arcade games, providing a diverse gaming experience that caters to all ages. The spacious layout of the play area is ideal for families, ensuring a comfortable and enjoyable visit each time. The food is undeniably delicious, making it a great spot for both kids and adults looking for a fun and satisfying dining experience. Its popularity is evident, with loyal customers returning time and time again for the top-notch service and entertainment offerings.
Pizza Patrón West Nolana Ave.
8.6/10 (212 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 956-661-9199
Unique pizza flavorsFlavorful breadsticksFriendly staff
Pizza Patrón West Nolana Ave. has quickly become a favorite among locals for its delicious pizzas, with the chorizoqueso pizza stealing the spotlight. The menu offers a variety of unique flavors, like the Mexicana with chorizo and the carne asada, perfect for those looking to step out of their comfort zone. Additionally, the restaurant’s version of breadsticks and spicy ranch sauce are must-tries, adding an extra layer of flavor to any meal. While the service may not be top-notch, the friendly staff more than make up for it with their helpful attitude and welcoming demeanor, making every visit a pleasant experience. Be sure to visit their website for deals and combos, and don’t hesitate to ask the workers about any specials to avoid any confusion or overcharging situations.
Pizza Hut
8.6/10 (870 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 956-682-4115
Clean restroomsExcellent serviceVariety of menu options
Pizza Hut offers an enjoyable dining experience with clean restrooms, excellent customer service, and a generous supply of napkins. The staff, like Lizzy, provide top-notch service, enhancing the overall dining experience. While some customers may have encountered issues with online ordering, the food itself consistently delivers a delicious and satisfying meal. The menu offers a variety of options, including the beloved classic pizzas and new melts, ensuring there is something for everyone. Despite minor setbacks, Pizza Hut remains a reliable choice for a tasty and convenient meal.
Peter Piper Pizza
8.8/10 (784 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 956-331-2478
Family-friendlyDelicious pizzaFun play area
Peter Piper Pizza is a top choice for families and friends looking to enjoy a fun and delicious meal together. The manager is helpful, the play area is spacious, and most of the games are in working order. The pizza is hot and tasty, with no long lines to order. While there were some minor issues with incorrect orders and prices, the overall experience is positive. The restaurant is clean, the service is excellent, and it’s a great spot for birthday celebrations. The crust could be improved for those who prefer a crunchier texture, but with a simple fix of using a pan to reheat the pizza, it can easily be remedied. Whether you’re a child or just a child at heart, Peter Piper Pizza has something for everyone to enjoy.
Blue Onion
8.8/10 (558 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 956-682-9884
Perfectly cooked dishesKnowledgeable and friendly serversGenerous portions
Blue Onion is a hidden gem, attracting customers with its perfectly cooked dishes and knowledgeable servers like Nicholas who make dining an enjoyable experience. The El Pastor wrap and sides are standout items on the menu, with generous portions that leave customers satisfied. The attention to detail in the food preparation is evident, making each visit a memorable and delicious one.
Dave & Buster’s McAllen
8.6/10 (2459 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 956-217-5800
Vibrant atmosphereDiverse game selectionAttentive service
Located in McAllen, Dave & Buster’s offers a vibrant atmosphere perfect for a night of dining and gaming. The diverse game selection ensures entertainment for all ages, with options ranging from classics to newer releases. The attentive service adds to the overall experience, making you feel like a valued guest throughout your visit. While the food menu may have its hits and misses, standouts like the salmon plate and watermelon margarita are fan favorites. The extensive drink menu also impresses with delicious options, adding to the enjoyment of your time at Dave & Buster’s. With plenty of big screens and a clean environment, this establishment is a fantastic choice for a fun night out.
Romano’s Macaroni Grill
8.8/10 (1185 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 956-687-3500
Flavorful lasagnaStellar serviceClean and well-kept
Romano’s Macaroni Grill offers hearty lasagna that never disappoints, full of flavor and cheesy goodness. The polite and attentive staff make every visit a pleasure, providing stellar service. The restaurant is clean and well-kept, with quick seating and delicious food, making it a go-to spot for a delicious Italian feast.
Bubba’s 33
9/10 (2476 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 956-661-2233
Flavorful dishesCool atmosphereLarge menu variety
Bubba’s 33 offers a variety of flavorful dishes, from the Crunchy Fried Shrimp to the classic burger with bacon. The atmosphere is cool and fun, with refreshing cold beer and a large menu to choose from. The staff may have some inconsistencies in service but the food is delicious, with highlights like the juicy well-cooked steak, amazing fried pickles, and flavorful garlic knots. If you’re looking for a place with great food and a laid-back vibe, Bubba’s 33 is worth a visit.
Chuck E. Cheese
8.6/10 (1028 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 956-682-4944
Great pizzaFun gamesClean atmosphere
Chuck E. Cheese is not just for kids – it’s a great spot for a fun night out with friends or a significant other. The pizza is a standout, with hot and delicious pies that exceed expectations. The show put on by Chuck E. himself adds to the overall excitement, and the variety of games make for a memorable experience. While the salad bar may be a bit pricey, the overall atmosphere is clean and inviting, making it a nostalgic visit for all.
Malfitany Pasta Company
8.8/10 (324 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 956-686-5529
Clam chowderComplimentary garlic knotsExceptional service
Malfitany Pasta Company offers a delightful dining experience with standout dishes like the clam chowder, lasagna, and complimentary garlic knots that customers rave about. The attention to detail in addressing customer feedback, like promptly removing a disliked dish from the tab, shows a commitment to customer satisfaction and exceptional service. The warm and inviting ambiance, paired with attentive servers who provide excellent recommendations, make Malfitany Pasta Company a must-visit spot for delicious Italian fare.
BJ’s Restaurant & Brewhouse
8.6/10 (1457 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 956-687-2005
Generous portionsFriendly staffComfortable ambiance
BJ’s Restaurant & Brewhouse offers a consistently satisfying dining experience, with a menu that caters to a variety of tastes. The friendly staff ensures that customers feel welcome, and the generous portions make it a great value for your money. The prime rib is a standout dish, while the pizookies are a must-try dessert. The ambiance is inviting, with a perfect balance of music and conversation creating a comfortable atmosphere for dining. Whether you’re a long-time fan or a first-time visitor, BJ’s is a reliable choice for a delicious meal and enjoyable dining experience.
Stefano’s Pizza Express
9/10 (466 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 956-884-7715
Specialty pizzasCozy atmosphereFriendly staff
Stefano’s Pizza Express stands out for its vast array of specialty pizzas, with options like shrimp Alfredo and chicken bacon ranch that are guaranteed to satisfy any craving. The cozy atmosphere and friendly staff create a welcoming environment, perfect for a casual lunch or dinner with friends. The reasonable prices make it even more appealing, with personal-sized pizzas starting at just $8.99. Whether you’re in the mood for traditional marinara or a sweet BBQ sauce, Stefano’s Pizza Express delivers on both taste and value.
PHILLY 77
9/10 (1084 reviews)
| Directions | +1 956-627-2577
Generous portionsUnique milkshake flavorsClean and friendly atmosphere
PHILLY 77 offers a variety of delicious options that keep customers coming back for more. The sub sandwiches are a standout, with crunchy fries and sweet potatoes that are a must-try. The portion sizes are generous and the dessert options, like the Nutella milkshake and cookies and cream milkshake, are not to be missed. While the original Philly sandwich may be just okay, the friendly service and clean atmosphere make for an enjoyable dining experience. The sweet potato fries are fresh and crispy, and the abundance of flavors in the food make it a worthwhile visit for a tasty meal that won’t disappoint. The unique milkshake options are a highlight and truly set PHILLY 77 apart from other restaurants in the area.