Whether you’re craving a classic New York-style fold or a gourmet Neapolitan masterpiece, McKinney offers a selection of pizza spots that promise to satisfy every palate.
From crispy thin crusts adorned with local produce to hearty deep-dish wonders that ooze with molten cheese, McKinney’s pizza scene offers something to satiate every palate. This guide curates the city’s standout pizzerias, each offering a unique slice of culinary heaven.
Cadillac Pizza Pub
9.2/10 (1904 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 972-547-3833
Handcrafted sweet crustFlavorful and fresh toppingsWonderful service
Cadillac Pizza Pub is a must-visit for pizza lovers. The handcrafted sweet crust sets it apart from other pizzas in town, with fresh and flavorful toppings. The bees knees and boss hog creations showcase a perfect balance of sweet and savory. The staff offer wonderful service, ensuring a pleasant dining experience from start to finish. The lunch special is a steal, providing a great value for a drink, salad, and generously sized personal pizza. The atmosphere is vibrant, and the thin and crispy crust on the pizzas is simply exceptional. If you’re craving delicious pizza in a cozy setting, Cadillac Pizza Pub is the place to be.
Rosati’s Pizza
9.2/10 (2701 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 972-548-3900
Tasty deep dishCheese pullFriendly service
Rosati’s Pizza delivers a taste of Chicago right in your backyard. From the perfectly cooked deep dish to the cheesy goodness that will give you a three-foot cheese pull, this place knows how to make you feel right at home. With friendly service and a family-friendly atmosphere, Rosati’s is the perfect spot for a delicious and satisfying meal that won’t break the bank.
Cavalli Pizza Napoletana
8.8/10 (792 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 972-540-1449
Diverse menuSmoky wood-fired ovenStellar service
Cavalli Pizza Napoletana in the Adriatica Village offers a diverse and robust menu that goes beyond just pizza. The Parma pizza topped with prosciutto ham is a stand-out item, and the wood-fired brick oven adds a delicious smoky flavor to all their dishes. The jalapeño and artichoke dip served with double zero Salina bread is a delightful starter, and the smoked chicken Panini sandwich and McKinney pizza are both tasty choices. The staff, especially Marcus, provide excellent service and are knowledgeable about the house-made mozzarella and imported San Marzano tomatoes used in their dishes. The QR code payment system is a convenient and modern touch that enhances the overall dining experience at this gem of a pizzeria.
Durkin’s Pizza
9/10 (648 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 972-727-8400
Flavorful pizzasQuaint atmosphereExceptional service
Durkin’s Pizza is a unique and locally-owned gem in McKinney that stands out for its flavorful and innovative pizzas. The Paneer Tikka pizza is a standout, offering a delicious twist on a classic dish. The quaint atmosphere adds to the charm of the dining experience, creating a cozy and inviting space to enjoy your meal. The service, exemplified by staff members like Raj, goes above and beyond to make every customer feel welcome and well taken care of, ensuring a memorable visit.
Jim’s Pizza
8.8/10 (850 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 972-542-1293
Welcoming StaffDelicious Red Velvet CookiesVariety in Buffet
Jim’s Pizza in McKinney has made quite an impression on its customers, both good and bad. Despite some consistent complaints about the quality of toppings and occasionally inconsistent service, Jim’s has managed to gain a loyal following with its welcoming staff, delicious red velvet cookies, and a variety of flavors offered in their buffet. Their spaghetti sauce has some devoted fans, with many praising the fresh buffet offerings and friendly service. The pricing, especially in today’s economy, is another standout factor, with many customers mentioning that the value for the quality of food received is worth a generous tip. While there have been mixed reviews, Jim’s Pizza seems to be a local gem worth giving a chance.
Barro’s Pizza
9.4/10 (486 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 469-625-2898
Welcoming atmosphereDelicious white pizzaExtensive beer selection
Nestled in the heart of Dallas, Barro’s Pizza offers more than just a slice of your favorite comfort food. With a welcoming atmosphere and top-notch customer service, this family-friendly establishment is a hidden gem for locals and visitors alike. The menu boasts a variety of mouth-watering options, from the chicken supreme to their famous white pizza. Plus, the extensive beer selection adds an extra layer of enjoyment to your dining experience. Whether you’re in the mood for a casual lunch or a special date night, Barro’s Pizza is a definite contender for your next meal out.
Zio Al’s pizza & pasta McKinney
9.2/10 (357 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 469-631-0029
Clean storeDelicious pizzaLate-night hours
Zio Al’s pizza & pasta McKinney stands out for its clean and bright store, friendly staff, and delicious pizza and wings. The pizza scores high on the “Ooey Gooey” index, while the wings are crisp and flavorful. The restaurant’s convenient late-night hours make it a perfect spot for those late-night cravings, and the welcoming atmosphere and top-notch service ensure a pleasant dining experience.
Sicily’s Pizza & Pasta
8.8/10 (755 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 972-542-9365
Tasty Italian dishesGiant, soft bread rollsFriendly, prompt service
Sicily’s Pizza & Pasta offers tasty Italian dishes at reasonable prices. The spaghetti, baked ziti, and pizza were all enjoyable, with consistent quality each visit. The dining area is clean, and the staff provides friendly and prompt service. The giant, soft bread rolls are a highlight, along with the tasty marinara sauce that accompanies the dishes. While some customers experienced issues with incorrect orders and long wait times, the overall dining experience at Sicily’s Pizza & Pasta seems to be positive and worth a visit.
Brother’s Pizza
8.6/10 (231 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 972-548-4900
Fresh ingredientsDiverse menuCharming hospitality
Brother’s Pizza is a family-owned gem that has been serving up delicious New York-style pizza since 2013. The food quality is top-notch, with fresh ingredients that shine through in every bite. The diverse menu includes not only incredible pizzas but also must-try calzones and Stromboli. The charming hospitality adds to the overall experience, making this restaurant a standout in the McKinney area.
Shelby’s Pizza
9/10 (341 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 469-617-7065
Unique flavorsLocal ownershipFresh ingredients
Shelby’s Pizza in Frisco provides delicious, made-to-order pizzas that are a cut above the rest. The menu offers a variety of unique flavors and options that set them apart from typical franchise pizza places. The stuffed crust and Zaatar Herb Pie are must-tries and stand out for their creativity and taste. With a focus on fresh ingredients and local ownership, Shelby’s delivers a top-notch pizza experience that keeps customers coming back for more.
MrJims.Pizza
8.6/10 (252 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 972-200-9929
Flavorful pizzaOutstanding customer serviceSpicy hot wings
MrJims.Pizza truly stands out among the crowded pizza scene, offering a top-notch dining experience that keeps patrons coming back again and again. The pizza itself is consistently delicious, with just the right amount of toppings and a flavorful crust that keeps diners coming back for more. One unique aspect of MrJims.Pizza is their commitment to excellent customer service, with staff members going above and beyond to ensure that every customer leaves satisfied. Another standout feature is their spicy hot wings, a mouthwatering addition to any pizza order that is sure to please even the most discerning taste buds. With a welcoming atmosphere and late opening hours, MrJims.Pizza is a must-visit for anyone craving a delicious slice of pie.
Napoli’s Pizza On The Go – McKinney
8.8/10 (56 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 214-548-5838
Quality pizzaGenerous portionsFriendly staff
Napoli’s Pizza On The Go in McKinney is a hidden gem for Italian cuisine lovers looking for quality and value. The Tortellini Cheese with Alfredo sauce stood out with its creamy, well-seasoned sauce and generously stuffed tortellini. The portions were substantial, ensuring a satisfying meal at a great price. In addition to their delicious pizza, the Napoli salad was excellent, made with great quality ingredients. The friendly staff and owner added a personal touch to the dining experience, making it a must-visit spot for pizza and pasta lovers alike.
Italian Garden
9/10 (957 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 972-540-9333
Generous portionsDelicious foodAttentive service
Italian Garden is a popular spot known for its generous portions and delicious food. The menu offers a variety of options, with standout dishes like shrimp arrabiata and chicken Parmesan receiving high praise. The service here is top-notch, with attentive servers who provide helpful recommendations and ensure a positive dining experience. While some customers mention small portion sizes at dinner, the overall consensus is that Italian Garden is a great choice for casual dining with great food and friendly service.
400 Gradi McKinney
9.2/10 (316 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 325-275-7456
Fresh ingredientsExcellent serviceHomemade pasta
400 Gradi McKinney is a standout Italian restaurant in McKinney, offering delicious dishes and exceptional service. The menu features traditional Italian fare made with fresh ingredients, including standout dishes like pasta Al funghi and the meatballs. The ambiance of the restaurant is cool and inviting, making it a great spot for a special occasion or a last-minute date night. The staff, like Casandra and Giovanni, provide top-notch service and are knowledgeable about the menu, helping diners make the best choices. The homemade pasta and farm-fresh produce add an extra touch of authenticity to the dining experience, making 400 Gradi McKinney a must-visit spot for Italian food lovers.
Sali’s Italian
8.6/10 (425 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 469-247-0083
Authentic flavorsFriendly staffCozy atmosphere
Sali’s Italian offers an authentic Italian dining experience with generous portions and friendly staff. The cozy atmosphere, complete with real flowers on each table, adds to the charm of this gem. The food shines with delicious dishes like Chicken Pesto and chicken mimoza, accompanied by fresh bread and salads. Despite the counter service setup, Sali’s delivers on taste and hospitality, making it a must-try spot for those craving a homecooked Italian meal.
Fontina Ristorante
8.8/10 (179 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 214-842-8527
Impeccable serviceDelicious Italian dishesCharming ambiance
Located just off the charming Downtown McKinney square, Fontina Ristorante offers a slice of Italian charm in the heart of Texas. The service here is impeccable, with attentive staff who are warm and welcoming. The menu boasts delicious, perfectly cooked food with sensible portions and right-priced meals. From the tender meatballs to the seafood risotto, Fontina Ristorante serves up delightful Italian dishes that transport diners to Italy with every bite. Don’t miss out on their signature cocktails, such as the espresso martini, to round out your dining experience.