Whether you’re craving a classic New York-style fold or a gourmet Neapolitan masterpiece, Mesa offers a selection of pizza spots that promise to satisfy every palate.
From crispy thin crusts adorned with local produce to hearty deep-dish wonders that ooze with molten cheese, Mesa’s pizza scene offers something to satiate every palate. This guide curates the city’s standout pizzerias, each offering a unique slice of culinary heaven.
Brothers Pizza
9/10 (230 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 718-768-1700
Consistent flavorsDelicious pizza varietiesFriendly staff
Brother’s Pizza in Brooklyn is a must-try for delicious and consistent food. From the Penne Alla Vodka Pizza to the Jalapeño Poppers, each item is packed with flavor. The small size of the restaurant doesn’t hinder the friendly service, making every visit enjoyable. The Garlic Knots and Margherita Pizza combo is a standout, leaving you wanting more with each bite. The thin crust grandma pizza is a standout, reminiscent of authentic Italian flavors, drawing in even the pickiest pizza eaters.
Pizza Roma Italian Cafe
9.6/10 (244 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 480-361-3394
Perfectly baked pizzaFlavorful Chicken ParmCaring and helpful service
Pizza Roma Italian Cafe in East Mesa has quickly become a favorite among locals, and it’s easy to see why. The pizza here is baked to perfection, with a crispy yet not overly crispy crust that is never soggy. The cheese has the perfect chewiness to it, and the top is always toasted perfectly. In addition to the delicious pizza, the Chicken Parm and marinara sauce are standout dishes worth trying. The staff is always friendly and professional, and the restaurant itself is clean and welcoming. From the caring and helpful service to the great taste and fresh ingredients, Pizza Roma Italian Cafe is a must-visit for Italian food lovers.
Au Za’atar – Midtown East
9/10 (1060 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 212-625-3982
Fresh ingredientsFlavorful mezzesCharming ambiance
Hidden in Midtown East, Au Za’atar is a delightful Lebanese restaurant that offers an incredible dining experience. The food here is top-notch, with fresh ingredients and dishes that are full of flavor. The mezzes are particularly outstanding, showcasing the chef’s dedication to quality and authenticity. The ambiance is another highlight of the restaurant, whether you choose to dine inside or on the charming patio. The variety of sauces available truly elevates the meal, adding an extra punch of flavor to each bite. The attentive staff ensures that your dining experience is seamless, with just the right amount of attention. Au Za’atar is a gem that shouldn’t be missed for anyone craving delicious Lebanese cuisine with a cozy atmosphere.
Organ Stop Pizza
9.2/10 (7470 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 480-813-5700
Unique Organ EntertainmentDelicious Combination PizzaFun Communal Seating Experience
Nestled in Mesa, Organ Stop Pizza offers a unique experience that combines delicious thin-crust pizzas with the incredible sounds of a massive organ and accompanying instruments, creating an unforgettable dining atmosphere. The combination pizza stood out with its flavorful toppings, while the Hawaiian pizza fell a bit short in taste. Despite the busy crowd, service was prompt and efficient, allowing us to enjoy the live entertainment while waiting for our food. The musician’s talent shone through in a diverse range of iconic songs, captivating guests of all ages. The communal seating and self-service system added to the fun and relaxed vibe of the restaurant, making it a must-visit for those seeking a one-of-a-kind dining experience.
Nello’s Pizza Mesa
9.2/10 (1909 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 480-820-5995
Tasty pizzasGreat saladExcellent staff
Nello’s Pizza Mesa offers a variety of delicious pizzas, with a standout being The Murphy. The dough is incredibly tasty, and the flavor combinations are top-notch. The deep dish may not be traditional Chicago style, but it’s definitely worth a try for its thickness and great sauce. In addition to the pizzas, the salads and house dressing are a hit, making for a well-rounded dining experience. The staff is also mentioned for being great, adding a positive element to the overall visit.
Sourdough Pizza Italian Restaurant
9/10 (763 reviews)
| Directions | +1 480-985-6658
Sourdough Pizza Italian Restaurant is a hidden gem serving up truly original and delicious pizza. The family-owned establishment prides itself on friendly service and top-notch food, including a mouthwatering #11 pizza that is a must-try. The beer selection, including mini-pitchers, adds to the overall experience. The ambiance is inviting, with unique decor and a welcoming atmosphere. The attention to detail, from the small triangle sections of the pizza to the attentive and professional staff, truly sets this restaurant apart. If you’re looking for a memorable dining experience, make sure to go out of your way to eat here.
#Highlights: Original pizza. Family-owned. Inviting ambiance.
Venezia’s Pizzeria
9.2/10 (2067 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 480-396-2000
Exceptional Customer ServiceDelicious Thin-Crust PizzasWelcoming Staff
Venezia’s Pizzeria in Mesa, AZ has left customers impressed with their delicious thin-crust pizzas and exceptional customer service. One patron was pleasantly surprised when their order was incorrect, and the staff not only apologized but went above and beyond to rectify the mistake by providing extra pizzas and sodas. Another customer was happy with the fresh and tasty food, particularly recommending the margarita pizza and Greek salad. The staff at Venezia’s are praised for their accuracy, speed, and welcoming attitudes, making it a favorite spot for pizza nights with friends and family. The ambiance is described as old-fashioned yet modern, adding to the overall enjoyable dining experience.
Twisted Pies Pizzeria
8.8/10 (557 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 480-699-8022
Fresh doughLarge portionsMeticulously crafted pizzas
Twisted Pies Pizzeria has been making waves in AZ for their top-notch pizza. The dough is always fresh and perfect, resulting in delicious offerings like pizza, breads, and knots. The portions are large, ensuring you get your money’s worth. Their attention to detail is evident in every order, from meticulously crafted pizzas to flavorful hot wings with the perfect kick. Twisted Pies is a must-visit for pizza lovers looking for a satisfying and diverse dining experience.
Master Pizza
9/10 (644 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 480-838-2368
Quality ingredientsPassionate ownerUnique culinary experience
Nestled in Mesa, Master Pizza is a must-visit for pizza enthusiasts seeking a unique culinary experience. The Master pizza, a true standout, boasts quality ingredients that showcase the owner’s passion and dedication to the craft. From the crispy thin crust to the delightful blend of cheese and sauce, each bite leaves a lasting impression. The love and care put into every detail truly shine through, setting this pizzeria apart from the rest. Don’t miss out on this gem, where flavor takes center stage and transports you to pizza paradise.
Myke’s Pizza
9.2/10 (467 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 480-687-8526
Top-notch pizzasUnique and cool atmosphereFast and accommodating service
Myke’s Pizza is a hidden gem tucked away inside Cider Corps. The pizzas are top-notch, especially the Margherita and pepperoni with cracked pepper. The atmosphere is unique and cool, with plenty of seating and a shared space with a bar and coffee bar. The service is fast and accommodating, making for a seamless dining experience.
Pizzicata Pizzeria Ristorante Mesa
8.6/10 (127 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 480-648-1094
Delicious Wood-Fired PizzaFreshly Made PastaNice Ambiance
Pizzicata Pizzeria Ristorante Mesa offers top-notch food with a wood-fired pizza that is simply delicious. The Meatballs and bolongnes were perfectly balanced, and the pasta was fresh and flavorful. The ambiance is nice and there is plenty of seating, including a lovely outdoor patio. The GM even comes out to introduce himself, adding a personal touch to the dining experience. The Fettuccine Alfredo is a must-try, and the homemade dough and pastas truly set this Italian gem apart.
Venezia’s Pizzeria
9/10 (1749 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 480-380-1111
Variety of combosChicken pesto pizzaNew York-style pizza
Nestled in the valley, Venezia’s Pizzeria has won the hearts of many with its incredible flavors and quick service. With a variety of combo deals like two slices and a drink, a slice with wings and a drink, or a salad and slice, customers can mix and match to their heart’s desire. The pitchfork pizza is a fan favorite, and the chicken pesto pizza is a must-try, especially for those with nut allergies. The restaurant offers a welcoming atmosphere, whether dining in or ordering takeout, and the friendly customer service ensures a pleasant experience. Venezia’s is a true gem for pizza lovers, offering delicious New York-style pizza and a wide range of menu options for all to enjoy.
La Famiglia Pizza & Pasta
9/10 (1004 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 480-722-1777
Delicious homemade foodAttentive family-owned serviceCozy Italian atmosphere
La Famiglia Pizza & Pasta is a charming family-run Italian spot in Mesa, AZ that’s worth a visit. The care put into every dish is evident, from the Fried Artichokes to the Meat Lovers pizza cooked to perfection. The cozy atmosphere and attentive service make you feel right at home, with the owners often checking in on your meal. The food is full of flavor and made from scratch, creating an ultimate dining experience. Whether you’re a regular or a first-time visitor, La Famiglia Pizza & Pasta is a hidden gem serving up delicious food and excellent service.
Mellow Mushroom Mesa
8.6/10 (2529 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 480-892-1399
Flavorful stone-baked crustsUnique and creative toppingsFun and colorful atmosphere
As soon as you walk into Mellow Mushroom Mesa, you can feel the fun and laid-back energy that fills the place. The stone-baked crusts are truly the star of the show here, offering a delicious base for any combination of toppings. Whether you go for a classic cheese pizza or opt for something more unique like the Red Skin Potato Pie, you can be sure that each bite will be bursting with flavor. The Maui Wowie pizza is a must-try, with its creative combination of jerk chicken, pesto base, and tropical toppings. The atmosphere at this location is a standout, with colorful art and unique architecture that adds to the overall dining experience.
Pizza Mart
9/10 (912 reviews)
| Directions | +1 480-962-4233
Nostalgic atmosphereDelicious pizzaAffordable prices
Pizza Mart is a nostalgic gem in Mesa that brings you back to the ‘80s with its retro vibe and arcade games. The food is top-notch, especially the pizza with the right thickness of crust and tasty wings. The prices are unbeatable, with deals like a 4-topping personal pizza and salad bar for only $10. And let’s not forget the one dollar soft serve ice cream cones, a rare find these days. It’s the perfect spot for a kids’ birthday party or a casual date night, with friendly staff and ample parking. Don’t miss out on this hidden gem that offers a fun and delicious dining experience.
Vito’s Pizza & Italian Ristorante
9.2/10 (3246 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 480-832-3311
Flavorful dishesGenerous portion sizesWelcoming atmosphere
Vito’s Pizza & Italian Ristorante offers a welcoming atmosphere with top-notch service. The menu features a variety of flavorful dishes, including the signature Alfredo and tortellini sunrise with their unique “sunrise sauce.” The pricing is reasonable for the generous portion sizes and quality of the food. The cannolis are a must-try for dessert. Overall, Vito’s is a great dining choice whether you’re with family, friends, or hosting a special event.
Amici Pizza
9/10 (622 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 480-361-0006
Authentic NY-style pizzaFriendly family-run atmosphereExtensive menu beyond pizza
Amici Pizza, a cozy spot in Mesa, delivers the real deal when it comes to NY-style pizza. Slice enthusiasts will delight in the thin crust, reminiscent of pizzerias in Brooklyn and Staten Island. The friendly, family-run joint offers more than just pizza, with pasta dishes and subs also on the menu. The attentive and pleasant service adds to the experience, making it a neighborhood gem worth visiting.
Milano’s Pizzeria
8.8/10 (636 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 480-325-1600
High-quality menuFriendly staffVisually appealing
Milano’s Pizzeria offers a variety of high-quality menu selections in a welcoming atmosphere. The pleasant staff, including the accommodating Sal and the friendly bartender David, add to the overall positive experience. The visual appeal of the restaurant, with ample parking and a charming patio, is a pleasant surprise. While some dishes like the gluten-free pizza receive praise for being tasty and prompt, others like the Alfredo and chipotle chicken options fall short with their lack of flavor and quality. Despite some disappointments with certain dishes, Milano’s Pizzeria still has the potential to be a hidden gem for those seeking a comfortable dining experience with attentive service and a warm ambiance.
Streets of New York
8.6/10 (713 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 480-986-6175
Varied menuThin, crispy pizzaFriendly service
Streets of New York has gained mixed reviews from customers. Some have expressed disappointment in receiving undercooked and poorly assembled pizzas, while others have praised the delicious food and excellent service. The menu offers a variety of options, from thin and crispy New York-style pizza to flavorful meatballs and chicken strips. The atmosphere is clean and pleasant, with friendly staff members like store manager Austin providing professional service. While some customers have experienced issues with orders and phone service, others have raved about the quality of the food and beverages, such as the agave creme soda. Overall, Streets of New York offers a diverse menu and a welcoming dining experience.
Papa Kelsey’s Pizza & Subs
8.8/10 (756 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 480-380-3185