Whether you’re craving a classic New York-style fold or a gourmet Neapolitan masterpiece, Milwaukee offers a selection of pizza spots that promise to satisfy every palate.
From crispy thin crusts adorned with local produce to hearty deep-dish wonders that ooze with molten cheese, Milwaukee’s pizza scene offers something to satiate every palate. This guide curates the city’s standout pizzerias, each offering a unique slice of culinary heaven.
Ian’s Pizza Milwaukee | East Side
8.8/10 (1766 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 414-727-9200
Unique flavor combosWide variety of toppingsChicago-style vibe
Ian’s Pizza Milwaukee | East Side is the go-to spot for late-night revelers looking for unique flavor combinations like mac and cheese and buffalo chicken. With a wide variety of toppings and a Chicago-style vibe, Ian’s is a must-try for those seeking something different from the typical pepperoni and sausage options. The crust may be a hit or miss for some, crispy yet chewy with a lack of flavor, but the toppings are where Ian’s shines. The cheesy potato ranch slice is an absolute standout, with delicious flavors that will have you coming back for more. The kale, tomatoes, and feta slice may be hit or miss, but with such a wide range of options, there’s something for everyone’s palate at Ian’s. Whether you’re a traditionalist or an adventurous eater, Ian’s Pizza Milwaukee | East Side is worth a visit for its unique and varied offerings.
MKE Classic Pizza
9/10 (408 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 414-744-7400
Convenient pickupFriendly staffDelicious pizza
MKE Classic Pizza offers a convenient pickup experience, with orders ready in around 30 minutes. The staff is friendly and accommodating, making customers feel welcomed. The pizza is described as delicious with generous toppings and a crispy crust. The menu offers a variety of options, all of which have received positive feedback from customers. Overall, MKE Classic Pizza is a solid choice for a satisfying meal with high quality, fresh ingredients.
Transfer Pizzeria Café
9.2/10 (1877 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 414-763-0438
Exceptional crustUnique flavor combinationsFriendly service
Transfer Pizzeria Café offers a variety of delicious appetizers and pizzas, with a stand-out crust that is crisp on the outside and tender on the inside. The flavors are well balanced, as seen in unique pizzas like the dill and “The Radical” with goat cheese, beets, and fresh sage. The service is friendly and attentive, making for a great dining experience. The atmosphere is inviting and the diverse menu options cater to dietary restrictions, making it a must-visit spot in Milwaukee.
Brute Sourdough Pizza
9.6/10 (70 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 414-231-3996
Unique sourdough crustFresh and delicious ingredientsCozy atmosphere
Nestled in a unique location within a building, Brute Sourdough Pizza offers a refreshing twist on traditional pizza with their sourdough crust that adds a delicious depth of flavor. The P.P.P.P Pizza and cinnamon bites are standout menu items, showcasing the freshness of ingredients and the perfect balance of flavors. The thin, crisp, and stretchy crust sets Brute apart, providing a delightful dining experience. The staff is friendly, the atmosphere cozy, and with options for both dine-in and carryout, Brute Sourdough Pizza is definitely a hidden gem worth discovering.
Fixture Pizza Pub
9.4/10 (1349 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 414-736-8709
Unique toppingsPerfectly cooked eggplantFriendly service
Fixture Pizza Pub offers a variety of unique and fun topping options that are sure to please any pizza lover. The fried eggplant is a standout dish that is perfectly cooked and flavorful, making it a must-try appetizer. The cream cheese on pizza may sound unconventional, but it adds a savory twist that is surprisingly delicious. While the pizza may not necessarily be mind-blowing, the flavors are well-balanced, and the crust is expertly done. The friendly service and welcoming atmosphere make Fixture Pizza Pub a great spot to enjoy a casual meal with friends or family.
Brick 3 Pizza
8.8/10 (729 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 414-224-6040
Oversized pizza slicesVariety of unique flavorsFriendly service
Brick 3 Pizza in Milwaukee offers an array of delicious, oversized pizza slices at budget-friendly prices. Whether you’re in the mood for a classic slice or a unique flavor like mac n cheese or loaded baked potato, there’s something for everyone. The welcoming atmosphere and friendly service make it a standout spot downtown. With quick service and a variety of options, it’s the perfect place for a satisfying and convenient meal.
Proof Pizza
8.6/10 (167 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 414-270-4433
Freshly baked pizzasFlavorful topping optionsLively atmosphere
Proof Pizza offers a unique pizza experience in the lively atmosphere of St. Kate’s hotel lobby. The freshly baked pies boast thin, chewy crusts and flavorful toppings, with options like prosciutto and mozzarella or custom creations with truffle honey and ricotta. While some reviewers found the pizzas a bit soggy, the overall consensus is that the flavors shine through, making Proof a must-visit spot for pizza lovers. The quick service and welcoming staff add to the appeal, and the option to enjoy your pizza in the hotel lounge with live music makes for a memorable dining experience.
Classic Slice
9.2/10 (1425 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 414-238-2406
Fresh, creative pizzasGenerous slice sizesFriendly service
Classic Slice offers an array of fresh and creative pizzas that are a cut above the rest. Whether you opt for a traditional pepperoni slice or something more unique like the cheese curds, jalapenos, and bacon pie, you’re sure to be satisfied. The crust and sauce stand out, and the size of the slices is generous. The atmosphere is charming and the service is friendly, making it a great spot to enjoy a delicious meal. The “400” pizza is a must-try, and the pesto pizza with pine nuts is also a fan favorite. Despite the occasional burnt mishap, Classic Slice continues to deliver quality pizzas that keep customers coming back for more.
Ian’s Pizza Milwaukee | Downtown
8.8/10 (1485 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 414-727-9200
Unique specialty slicesVariety of optionsHUGE vegan menu
Ian’s Pizza Milwaukee | Downtown offers a unique experience with their cool specialty slices like the classic mac & cheese. The dining area upstairs with games is a nice touch for a casual gathering. The variety of options, including vegetarian and vegan choices, make it a great spot for those with dietary preferences. The baked penne pizza is a personal favorite, and the creative veg pizza options are a standout. While the staff and space may have some room for improvement, the focus here is truly on the delicious and innovative pizza creations.
Ned’s Pizza
9/10 (1875 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 414-645-2400
Flavorful sauceFriendly serviceCharming ambiance
Ned’s Pizza is a beloved neighborhood spot, with customers driving out of their way to savor every bite of their delicious thin crust pizza. The sauce is a standout, packed with flavor that keeps them coming back for more. The service is top-notch, with friendly staff who ensure a pleasant dining experience. The historical charm of the restaurant adds to the overall ambiance, making it a must-visit for any pizza enthusiast.
Zaffiro’s Pizza The Original
9/10 (1345 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 414-289-8776
Crispy cracker crustFamily traditionOld school vibes
Zaffiro’s Pizza The Original is a Milwaukee institution, exuding old school vibes from the moment you walk in. The crispy cracker crust pizzas are a standout, with flavors that do not disappoint. The sausage special with onion is a fan favorite, showcasing the incredible family tradition behind this beloved pizza joint.
State Street Pizza Pub
9.4/10 (189 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 414-249-5386
Epic Chicago beefFriendly staffFun robot waiter
State Street Pizza Pub offers an excellent selection of beer and epic Chicago beef pizza that’s a true highlight. The staff is friendly and attentive, with the added bonus of a robot waiter delivering to tables, creating a fun atmosphere. The retro fit on the building adds to the charm, making it a great spot to grab a bite before heading to an event at Fiserv Forum or simply enjoying a night out. The quick service, delicious food, and welcoming owner, Andy, truly make State Street Pizza a standout dining destination. Highly recommend for a memorable dining experience!
Ian’s Pizza Milwaukee | Story Hill
8.8/10 (472 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 414-727-9200
Vegan optionsFresh pizzaPatio seating
Ian’s Pizza Milwaukee | Story Hill is a place where pizza dreams come true. With a plethora of vegan options available, the menu caters to all tastes. The vegan pizza with cheese and potatoes is a standout, offering a delicious and fresh take on the classic dish. The patio furniture outside provides a pleasant ambiance to enjoy your meal, adding to the overall dining experience. While the customer service may need a bit of improvement, the amazing food more than makes up for it.
San Giorgio Pizzeria Napoletana
9.4/10 (767 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 414-276-2876
Authentic Neapolitan pizzasDelicious meatball appetizerFriendly and knowledgeable service
Had a remarkable dining experience at San Giorgio Pizzeria Napoletana, the go-to spot for authentic Neapolitan pizza in Milwaukee. The individual-sized pizzas are a must-try, especially the San Giorgio with a sunny side egg. The meatball appetizer is a standout, and the calamari is fried to perfection. The service is top-notch, with attentive waitstaff like Brittany and Megan making the experience truly enjoyable. Don’t miss out on the delicious desserts, like the pistachio torte, and be sure to pair your meal with a local Wisconsin beer, such as Leinenkugel. The bustling atmosphere and cozy setting make this the perfect spot for a romantic dinner for two or a fun gathering with friends.
Sal’s Pizza East Side
8.8/10 (815 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 414-967-8040
Delicious BBQ chickenAffordable lunch specialCozy atmosphere
Sal’s Pizza East Side is a hidden gem in Milwaukee, offering some of the best pizza in the state. The BBQ chicken pizza steals the show with its perfect balance of sweet and tangy flavors, complemented by well-seasoned chicken on a just-right crust. The lunch special of 2 slices, a garlic knot, and a drink for under $10 is a steal. The cozy atmosphere and friendly service make it a must-visit spot in town. Make sure to try the mozzarella sticks and garlic knots, they’re equally delicious additions to the already fantastic menu.
Karina’s Pizza
8.6/10 (138 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 414-810-3004
Quality cheeseExceptional serviceAffordable prices
Karina’s Pizza has quickly become a go-to spot for pizza enthusiasts in Milwaukee. The ingredients and service are consistently top-notch, making it a reliable choice for a delicious meal. The cheese bread and garlic bread are standout items that add a flavorful twist to the menu. The pepperoni pizza stands out with its great crust and nice flavors, although a tad greasy. The extensive menu offers a variety of options, making it a great choice for lunchtime pickups. The staff’s exceptional customer service, willingness to go above and beyond, truly sets Karina’s Pizza apart from the rest. With affordable prices and quality ingredients, this hidden gem is a must-try for any pizza lover.
Marco’s “World Famous” Pizza – Northwest
8.6/10 (430 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 414-461-1100
Delicious pizzaFriendly serviceConsistent quality
Nestled in Milwaukee, Marco’s “World Famous” Pizza – Northwest, is a hidden gem that has been serving up delectable pies for years. Customers rave about the magical combination of their crust, sauce, cheese, and sausage, which come together perfectly to create a truly unforgettable pizza experience. While the prices may have crept up slightly over the years, the quality of the food and the friendly service have remained consistently exceptional. The cheese Rollo, in particular, stands out as a crowd favorite, with its perfect balance of flavors and textures that keep customers coming back for more.
Toppers Pizza
8.8/10 (943 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 414-226-2626
Prompt serviceCleanlinessFast carryout fulfillment
Toppers Pizza has garnered mixed reviews from customers, but there are unique aspects that stand out. Customers have appreciated the prompt service and cleanliness of the restaurant. The fast order fulfillment for carryout is a definite plus. However, some customers have raised concerns about the quality and accuracy of their orders, with issues like undercooked pizza and missing items. Additionally, discrepancies in menu pricing and tax charges have left a few customers dissatisfied. The restaurant could benefit from improving order accuracy and customer service to enhance the overall dining experience.
Upper Crust Pizza
8.6/10 (183 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 414-332-6820
Hot & fresh pizzasPhenomenal thin crustAttentive staff
Upper Crust Pizza has been a staple in the community for decades and consistently delivers hot and fresh pizzas that are loved by all. Despite some service hiccups, the pizzas themselves are phenomenal, with crispy edges and delicious toppings. The wings may need a little extra sauce for some, but overall the quality of the food remains satisfying. The thin crust, flavorful sauce, and attentive staff make Upper Crust stand out among other pizza places in Milwaukee. If you haven’t tried it yet, you’re missing out on a must-try pizza experience.
Vinchi’s Pizza
9.4/10 (118 reviews)
| Directions | +1 414-384-8040
Incredible thin crustHuge, amazing sandwichesFlavorful cheese garlic bread
Vinchi’s Pizza is a hidden gem in Milwaukee, known for its incredible thin crust pizzas and huge, amazing sandwiches. The classic Milwaukee thin crust pizza joint, located inside a classic Milwaukee bar, offers a unique and flavorful dining experience. With reasonably priced drinks, plenty of TVs to watch the game, and friendly service, Vinchi’s is a must-try spot for pizza lovers in the area. The customizable toppings, right amount of sauce, and non-soggy cheese make their pizzas stand out as one of the best in the city. The cheese garlic bread is also a standout menu item, with a tremendous amount of cheese and flavorful garlic sauce. The fun atmosphere inside The Bubbler adds to the overall dining experience at Vinchi’s Pizza.