Whether you’re craving a classic New York-style fold or a gourmet Neapolitan masterpiece, Naperville offers a selection of pizza spots that promise to satisfy every palate.
From crispy thin crusts adorned with local produce to hearty deep-dish wonders that ooze with molten cheese, Naperville’s pizza scene offers something to satiate every palate. This guide curates the city’s standout pizzerias, each offering a unique slice of culinary heaven.
Louie’s Pizza : Pizza, Gyros, Crepes
9.6/10 (185 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 630-364-2367
Delicious gyrosAmazing pizzaSuperb hospitality
Louie’s Pizza : Pizza, Gyros, Crepes offers a delightful experience that truly stands out. The gyros are a must-try, with flavors that are reminiscent of the authentic Greek dish. Additionally, the pizza is a work of art, boasting a perfect crust and delicious toppings. The owner’s superb hospitality adds a personal touch to the dining experience, making every visit unforgettable.
Pizza Twist
9.2/10 (279 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 630-995-9981
Indian-inspired flavorsFresh and flavorful toppingsGluten-free and vegan options
Pizza Twist offers a unique twist on traditional pizza by infusing Indian flavors into their dishes. The pizzas are cooked to perfection, with fresh and delicious toppings that add a burst of flavor in every bite. The Paneer Manchurian Pizza and Achari Gobi are standout options that showcase the perfect balance of spice and freshness. The restaurant also caters to a variety of dietary preferences with their gluten-free and vegan pizza options, including a pillowy crust and delicious sauces. The staff’s attentive service and friendly demeanor add to the overall dining experience, making Pizza Twist a must-visit for those looking for a tasty and unique pizza experience.
Naperville – Lou Malnati’s Pizzeria
9/10 (3623 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 630-717-0700
Perfectly cooked crustDelicious sausage toppingAttentive service
Naperville – Lou Malnati’s Pizzeria serves up a delightful deep-dish pizza experience that keeps customers coming back for more. The perfectly balanced portions of cheese and sauce, along with the delicious sausage topping, make for a memorable meal. The crust is cooked to perfection, adding a satisfying crunch to each bite. The attentive service ensures a pleasant dining experience, although the close seating arrangement may be a downside for some. The relaxed atmosphere and top-notch Chicago-style pizza make this spot a must-visit for pizza lovers.
Calogero’s
9.8/10 (120 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 630-536-8344
Authentic Italian flavorsFresh, quality ingredientsPersonalized dining experience
Calogero’s, a hidden gem tucked away in Naperville, serves up authentic Italian cuisine that transports you to the streets of Sicily. The wood oven pizza boasts a perfect crust that complements the fresh, quality ingredients used in every dish. Salvatore, the owner, infuses each plate with a touch of his passion for food and family traditions, making every bite a delightful experience. The personalized touch of one-on-one pizza making sessions and an ever-expanding menu keeps diners coming back for more, eager to explore new flavors and textures that Calogero’s has to offer.
Little Pops NY Pizzeria
9/10 (896 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 630-210-8084
Thin crustGenerous toppingsCozy family atmosphere
Little Pops NY Pizzeria offers a wonderful NY style pizza experience, perfect for those who prefer a thinner crust over the thick dough of Chicago style pies. The crust, almost buttery, is a standout on its own, enticing you to eat even the crusts. Generous toppings, fast service, and reasonable prices make this pizzeria a great choice for a casual meal. The cozy family atmosphere adds to the charm, with delightful menu options like Buffalo Chicken Pizza, Garlic Knots, and clams with red sauce, all receiving accolades from patrons. Make sure to save room for the owner’s homemade crumble cake, a unique and nostalgic treat.
Papa Ray’s Pizza And Wings Naperville
9.2/10 (237 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 331-529-0500
Jumbo slicesSpicy garlic wingsCreamy Mac n cheese
Nestled in Naperville, Papa Ray’s Pizza And Wings is a hidden gem offering jumbo slices and delectable wings. The Greek pizza might not have met expectations, but the build-your-own option allows for customization. The spicy garlic wings are a must-try, not too overpowering but perfectly sauced. The Mac n cheese varieties are creamy and flavorful, with generous portions that can easily be shared. The Italian sausage thin crust pizza is a crowd-pleaser, and the family-size salads are a great deal. With fast delivery and friendly service, Papa Ray’s is a solid choice for a satisfying meal.
Freedom Brothers Pizzeria & Alehouse Naperville
9/10 (178 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 331-249-6613
Authentic PizzasRock AmbianceVast Beer Selection
Nestled in Naperville, Freedom Brothers Pizzeria & Alehouse offers a unique dining experience with its authentic Neopolitan and Detroit-style pizzas. The crispy yet soft crusts and generous variety of toppings make each 12” pizza a flavorful delight. The ambiance, adorned with rock memorabilia, provides a lively setting for enjoying a wide selection of fresh beers. While the service may have its ups and downs, the expansive menu, including gluten-free options, and ample parking make it a must-visit pizzeria for families, friends, and pizza lovers alike.
Old Town Pizza Of Naperville
9/10 (164 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 630-922-4600
Generous ToppingsFlavorful WingsFriendly Staff
Naperville is home to a hidden gem known as Old Town Pizza. The menu features a wide variety of pizzas with generous toppings that will satisfy any pizza craving. The Chicago stuffed pizza is a must-try, with crumbled sausage that adds a unique touch to the dish. The wings are perfectly crispy and flavorful, making them a great accompaniment to any meal. The staff is friendly and accommodating, providing excellent customer service. If you find yourself in Naperville, do yourself a favor and stop by Old Town Pizza for a truly satisfying dining experience.
Bricks Wood Fired Pizza – Naperville
8.6/10 (736 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 630-799-6860
Amazing gluten-free pizzaCreamy pesto and thin crust optionsAttentive and professional staff
Bricks Wood Fired Pizza in Naperville is a hidden gem for those seeking top-notch gluten-free pizza. The dough is thick and doughy, rivaling even non-gluten-free options. The creamy pesto and thin crust pizzas are a must-try, along with the mouth-watering ice cream and canoli. The staff is attentive and professional, making you feel like part of the family. With a spacious patio, attentive service, and delicious food, Bricks Wood Fired Pizza is a go-to spot for quality and tasty pizza without the long waits.
GIA MIA Naperville
9.2/10 (445 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 331-204-7222
Half-priced pizzasWood oven-bakedCozy atmosphere
GIA MIA Naperville exudes a warm, cozy atmosphere nestled in a historic building in downtown Naperville. The restaurant offers a Monday special with half-priced pizzas, which are wood oven-baked and delicious, making it one of the best pizza spots in the area. The service is attentive and friendly, with managers checking on each table. While the restaurant can get busy, the beautiful ambiance, tasty sangria, and mouth-watering zucchini fries make it a must-visit spot for a special celebration or a cozy date night. Parking may be a challenge due to construction, but the overall experience at GIA MIA Naperville is worth the effort.
Giordano’s
8.8/10 (1390 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 630-428-2111
Delicious deep dishOutstanding Greek saladPleasant service
Giordano’s is a hidden gem of a pizza place, with their deep dish pizza standing out as a true masterpiece. The flavors are rich and the ingredients are fresh, creating a mouthwatering experience with each bite. The Greek salad is a delightful surprise, perfectly complementing the hearty pizza. The impeccable service only adds to the overall fantastic dining experience at Giordano’s.
Giordano’s
8.6/10 (573 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 630-904-9800
Stringy cheeseFresh ingredientsAbundant seasoning
Giordano’s is a well-loved pizza joint that continues to impress customers with its deep dish offerings. The stringy cheese on the pizza is a crowd favorite, creating a tasty and fun dining experience. The fresh ingredients, perfectly cooked without being mushy, elevate the overall quality of the pizza. The abundance of fresh crushed red pepper, Parmesan, and Italian herbs for seasoning is a delightful touch that adds to the flavorful experience. The crust is just as outstanding as remembered, making Giordano’s a top choice for deep-dish lovers.
Aurelio’s Pizza Naperville
8.8/10 (663 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 630-922-3600
Flavorful pizzaExceptional serviceAccommodating for events
Naperville is lucky to have Aurelio’s Pizza in its midst. The cheese pizza with extra sauce and extra cheese is a crowd favorite for good reason – it’s flavorful and satisfying. The service at this establishment is top-notch, with staff going above and beyond to ensure a great dining experience. From accommodating large parties to providing excellent customer service, Aurelio’s truly stands out. Whether you’re in for a casual meal or hosting a special event, this pizzeria is a reliable choice.
Rosati’s Pizza
9/10 (121 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 630-428-0400
Hassle-free orderingOn-time deliveryDelicious thin-crust pizza
As a food journalist, I had the chance to experience Rosati’s Pizza firsthand, and I must say, this pizza joint truly stands out. From the hassle-free ordering process to the on-time delivery, every step of the way was smooth sailing. The gluten-free and veggie options were not only accommodating but also delicious, making it a real treat for all. The thin-crust pizza was a standout, along with the phenomenal salads that left a lasting impression. The overall experience was fantastic, and I will definitely be returning for more of Rosati’s delectable offerings.
Little Italian Pizza West
9.2/10 (172 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 630-904-4242
Tangy sauceGenerous toppingsEfficient staff
The sauce at Little Italian Pizza West brings a tangy punch to each bite, though some find it a tad too acidic. Toppings are generously piled high, but the minuscule size of the peppers may leave you torn between coverage and texture contrast. While some have experienced a mix-up in crust preferences, others rave about the perfectly cooked thin crust pizzas and the top-notch sauce, cheese, and crust. The efficiency of the staff and the inviting atmosphere at the new location are certainly highlights of this Naperville gem.
Little Italian Pizza
9/10 (568 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 630-983-8200
Amazing thin crustFriendly staffCozy neighborhood spot
Little Italian Pizza in Naperville is a neighborhood gem, known for its incredibly delicious thin crust pizza. The crispy yet soft crust paired with a flavorful sauce and perfect blend of cheese makes for a mouthwatering experience that keeps customers coming back. The newly remodeled space is clean and inviting, with a friendly staff who ensures a pleasant dining experience every time.
Sugo Mio Pizza & Pasta
8.6/10 (121 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 630-983-8414
Friendly staffAuthentic Italian flavorsCustomizable pizzas
Sugo Mio Pizza & Pasta offers a delightful dining experience with its friendly and accommodating staff. The authentic Italian flavors shine in their dishes, with the pizza being a standout item. The option to customize your pizza allows for a truly personalized meal, and the wood fire oven ensures a perfectly crispy thin crust every time. In addition to the delicious food, the owner’s dedication to customer satisfaction is evident, making each visit a pleasant and memorable one.
Traverso’s
9/10 (1048 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 630-305-7747
Generous portion sizesExceptional staffDelicious homemade desserts
Traverso’s is a dining destination that impresses with its delicious food and generous portion sizes. The staff is exceptional, providing a welcoming and friendly atmosphere that adds to the overall dining experience. Whether you’re enjoying a classic pasta dish, indulging in a margarita, or savoring the homemade desserts, Traverso’s is a spot worth visiting for a memorable meal.
Ninety Fifth – Lou Malnati’s Pizzeria
8.6/10 (435 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 630-904-4222
Crispy crustTangy tomato sauceGooey three-cheese blend
Ninety Fifth – Lou Malnati’s Pizzeria is more than just a pizza joint – it’s an experience that will transport you to pizza paradise in one bite. The crispy crust, tangy tomato sauce, gooey three-cheese blend, and fresh mozzarella come together in a harmony that will have you wondering if you’ve stumbled upon the holy grail of pizza perfection. And let’s not forget the mikes hot honey wings, with their perfect balance of heat and crunch that will have you coming back for more. This is Chicago-style pizza at its finest, made with care and attention to detail that truly sets it apart from the rest.