Whether you’re craving a classic New York-style fold or a gourmet Neapolitan masterpiece, New Haven offers a selection of pizza spots that promise to satisfy every palate.
From crispy thin crusts adorned with local produce to hearty deep-dish wonders that ooze with molten cheese, New Haven’s pizza scene offers something to satiate every palate. This guide curates the city’s standout pizzerias, each offering a unique slice of culinary heaven.
Modern Apizza
9.4/10 (5206 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 203-776-5306
Authentic flavorsVaried pizza optionsCharcoal crust
Modern Apizza in New Haven is a must-visit for pizza lovers seeking an exceptional dining experience. The clam pizza is a standout, with a thin crust that boasts a charcoal flavor. The margarita pizza also impresses with its spectacular crust and tomato sauce combination. The veggie bomb pizza is a top pick for those who enjoy a healthy amount of toppings, despite some issues with cheese overload. Modern Apizza truly shines in delivering delicious pizzas that are worth the wait and the price.
Frank Pepe Pizzeria Napoletana
9/10 (8611 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 203-865-5762
High-quality ingredientsPerfectly charred crustFriendly staff
Frank Pepe Pizzeria Napoletana is a must-visit when in New Haven. The pizza is crafted to perfection with high-quality ingredients, resulting in outstanding flavors and a perfectly charred crust. The staff is friendly and adds to the overall great experience, making it a historic gem in the city. The local favorite clam pie is a garlic dream and a true taste of Connecticut, while the fire-roasted flavor of their pizzas is sure to hit the spot for any pizza lover.
Sally’s Apizza
8.8/10 (3875 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 203-624-5271
Delicious pizzaCasual ambianceLong lines
Sally’s Apizza on Wooster Street in New Haven is renowned for its delicious, authentic New Haven-style pizza. With a thin, crispy crust and high-quality toppings, their pies are a must-try for any pizza enthusiast. The ambiance is casual and inviting, perfect for a laid-back meal with friends or family. Be prepared for long lines during peak hours, as this popular spot tends to get crowded. Sally’s offers a fantastic dining experience with mouthwatering pizza that keeps customers coming back for more. Sally’s Apizza: Delicious New Haven-style pizza. Casual and inviting ambiance. Be prepared for long lines.
Zeneli Pizzeria e cucina Napoletana
9.8/10 (1339 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 203-745-4194
Perfectly Seasoned PastaComforting Homemade MeatballsCarefully Curated Wine Selection
Nestled in the heart of New Haven, Zeneli Pizzeria e Cucina Napoletana stands out as a hidden gem amongst the bustling pizza scene. The perfectly seasoned Spaghetti al Pomodoro is a standout dish that will leave you craving more, while the Homemade Italian Meatballs offer a comforting and delectable accompaniment. The attentive staff and cozy atmosphere create a welcoming dining experience, and the carefully curated wine selection adds an extra layer of luxury to your meal. Zeneli Pizzeria truly shines as a must-visit spot for those seeking authentic and delicious Italian cuisine.
Est Est Est Pizza & Restaurant
8.8/10 (635 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 203-777-2059
Wide menu varietyGenerous portionsFriendly service
Est Est Est Pizza & Restaurant, a New Haven institution since 1973, has solidified its spot as a local favorite for good reason. The menu boasts a wide variety of options, from savory wings to hearty pasta dishes to, of course, mouthwatering pizzas. The BBQ chicken pizza is a standout, with a perfectly balanced BBQ sauce that hits all the right notes. The portions are generous, with the chef salad teeming with fresh ingredients and the buffalo wings boasting a satisfying crispiness. The baked ziti is served piping hot and remains delicious until the last bite. The Oreo pie is a perfect way to end the meal on a sweet note, rounding out a visit to Est Est Est Pizza as a must-do dining experience in New Haven.
One6Three
9.4/10 (698 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 203-777-5141
Wood-fired ApizzaVariety of piesEfficient service
Tucked away in a quiet corner of New Haven, One6Three is an underrated gem serving up fantastic wood-fired Apizza. The menu boasts a variety of delicious pies, including the Clams Casino, Buffalo Chicken, and a flavorful vegan sandwich. The cozy atmosphere and efficient service make it a must-visit spot, whether you’re dining in or picking up a pie to go.
Yorkside Pizza & Restaurant
8.8/10 (847 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 203-787-7471
Delicious Greek-style pizzasFriendly and efficient staffClassic pizza parlor vibe
Yorkside Pizza & Restaurant is a beloved establishment in the heart of New Haven, serving up delicious Greek-style pizzas and a variety of other Mediterranean dishes. The location couldn’t be better, nestled within the Yale campus and boasting a classic pizza parlor ambiance. The efficient and friendly staff handle busy nights with ease, ensuring a seamless dining experience. The menu is expansive, offering options for everyone, from traditional cheese pizzas to mouthwatering Musaka. Whether you’re a local or just passing through, Yorkside Pizza is a must-try destination for a satisfying meal.
Town Pizza
9/10 (60 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 203-865-6065
Authentic NY Style pizzaFlavorful gyrosFriendly owners
Town Pizza in New Haven offers a unique dining experience with their delicious NY Style thin crust pizza and flavorful gyros. The owners are friendly and welcoming, making every visit a pleasant one. The pizza, though underrated compared to other local spots, deserves recognition for its authentic taste and generous toppings. Whether you’re grabbing a slice or enjoying a gyro, Town Pizza is a great spot for a satisfying meal.
Costa Pizza Restaurant
8.6/10 (214 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 203-782-6782
Gluten-free goodnessVegan optionsFriendly service
Costa Pizza Restaurant serves up some of the best gluten-free pizza around, with a crispy crust that was both tasty and satisfying. The jazz music playing in the background creates a relaxing and stylish ambiance, making it a great spot for a quick snack. The Vegan options are also a hit, with delicious subs and pizza slices that are full of flavor. The service is top-notch, with friendly staff who are knowledgeable and helpful. If you’re in the mood for a great pie and a welcoming atmosphere, Costa Pizza Restaurant is the place to be. Great place, humble service, and fantastic pizza options.
Casa Bianca Pizza New Haven
9.2/10 (370 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 203-691-7278
Crispy crustFlavorful toppingsExceptional customer service
Located in New Haven, Casa Bianca Pizza is a hidden gem that delivers top-notch pizzas at affordable prices. The crispy crust brings a perfect balance to the rich sauce and generous toppings. Whether you’re a traditional margherita fan or a meat-lover, Casa Bianca offers mouthwatering pies that will have you coming back for more. Additionally, the customer service is exceptional, making each visit a memorable and enjoyable experience. The perfectly baked pizza, flavorful toppings, and attentive staff definitely set Casa Bianca apart from other pizzerias. If you’re in the area, don’t miss the opportunity to savor the authentic flavors that Casa Bianca Pizza has to offer.
Family Mediterranean Pizza
9.2/10 (193 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 203-865-0088
Unique pizza flavorsFlavorful lamb ShawarmaFriendly staff
Family Mediterranean Pizza offers a unique twist on traditional pizza with their falafel and lamb Shawarma options. The cheese slice with a light, fluffy falafel and garlic sauce is a must-try, while the lamb Shawarma pizza offers a burst of flavor that is unlike any other. The sauce to cheese ratio is on point, with a nice toasty undercarriage that adds a great crunch to each bite. The Buffalo Stromboli is also a standout, with manageable slices that make it easy to enjoy. The friendly staff and quick service are definitely a plus, making it a convenient and delicious spot for a quick meal or takeout option.
Whalley Pizza
8.8/10 (728 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 203-789-8100
Delicious pizzaFriendly staffDiverse menu
Whalley Pizza is a neighborhood gem that has been serving up delicious food for years. The menu is diverse, offering options like grilled chicken over rice, pepperoni pizza, and a variety of subs. The staff is friendly and attentive, ensuring that customers have a positive experience. The pizza is a standout with a crispy thin pan-style crust and flavorful toppings, making it a must-try. The clean and welcoming atmosphere, complete with plants in the windows, adds to the overall dining experience.
Aladdin Crown Pizza
8.6/10 (388 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 203-773-3772
Flavorful pizzasSatisfying sandwichesInviting ambiance
The inviting ambiance at Aladdin Crown Pizza, along with the warm and attentive staff, ensures a pleasant dining experience. The menu boasts flavorful pizzas, like the shawarma pizza, and satisfying cold sandwiches with generous portions of fresh ingredients. Whether you’re looking for a taste of Middle Eastern cuisine or simply craving a delicious slice of pizza, Aladdin Crown Pizza delivers exceptional quality and taste that is sure to impress.
New Haven Pizza Place
8.8/10 (237 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 203-693-3500
Modern atmosphereFlavorful toppingsFamily-owned passion
Nestled in a strip mall, New Haven Pizza Place surprises with its modern and exciting atmosphere, complete with a recently expanded bar area. While the thin-crust pizza lacked a crunch and consistency, the pepperoni offered a zingy kick and the meatballs were flavorful and fresh. The wood-fired pizza topped with meats and cheeses bursting with flavor is a local favorite, along with the stuffed breads. The service may have been understaffed, but the passion of the family-owned operation shines through in the quality of the food and overall dining experience.
Frisco’s Pizza
9.2/10 (175 reviews)
| Directions | +1 203-821-7237
Generous ToppingsPerfectly Cooked CrustFriendly Service
Frisco’s Pizza in New Haven has quickly become a local favorite, known for serving up some of the best pizzas in the area. Customers rave about the tasty and generous toppings, perfectly cooked crusts, and overall deliciousness that Frisco’s Pizza has to offer. Whether you opt for a traditional crust or try their cauliflower crust, you’re in for a treat with each and every bite. The friendly and efficient service ensures that your pizza comes out quickly, leaving you satisfied and eager to come back for more. If you’re in the mood for a truly exceptional pizza experience, make sure to stop by Frisco’s Pizza and see for yourself what all the hype is about.
Pizza at the Brick Oven
9/10 (1527 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 203-777-4444
Spectacular pizzasRich flavorful sauceImpeccable friendly service
Pizza at the Brick Oven is a culinary gem that is worth the drive, offering spectacular pizzas with perfectly balanced crusts and fresh, generously applied toppings. The rich and flavorful sauce complements the gooey cheese, creating a pizza experience that transports you to pizza heaven with every bite. The impeccable service from the friendly and passionate staff adds to the overall wonderful dining experience.
Kesté Pizza e Vino
9.2/10 (2657 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 212-243-1500
Innovative flavor combinationsExceptional serviceDedicated gluten-free kitchen
Kesté Pizza e Vino truly shines as a top-notch pizzeria in NYC. Their innovative range of flavors and styles ensures that every visit is a unique and delightful experience. The Calzone with mushrooms and Martadella with pistachios are standout dishes that are sure to satisfy any pizza lover’s cravings. The staff’s dedication to providing excellent service is evident in every interaction, making guests feel right at home. The separate gluten-free kitchen is a thoughtful touch that sets Kesté apart, catering to all dietary preferences without compromising on taste. A visit to Kesté Pizza e Vino is a must for anyone seeking delicious pizza in a warm and welcoming atmosphere.
Zuppardi’s Apizza
9.4/10 (2263 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 203-934-1949
Authentic flavorsFriendly staffBustling atmosphere
Zuppardi’s Apizza in Connecticut is a must-visit for pizza lovers seeking an authentic and delicious experience. The sausage pizza is a standout, but don’t overlook the meatball and pepperoni options. The service is top-notch, with friendly staff that enhance the overall dining experience. The Garden Veggies Pizza may be a bit soggy for some, but the Chicken Pesto Pizza emerges as a crispy and flavorful winner. The atmosphere is bustling and authentic, adding to the charm of this pizza gem.
Next Door
9.2/10 (313 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 475-234-5969
Unique brussels sproutsDelicious New Haven pizzaCozy ambiance
Next Door is a hidden gem in New Haven, offering a cozy ambiance with plenty of space to meet up with friends and enjoy delicious food and drinks. The menu features a variety of options, from unique fried brussels sprouts to traditional New Haven-style pizza. The friendly and attentive staff ensure a pleasant dining experience, making it a great spot for a casual night out. The bar area offers a generous selection of beer and liquor, while the live music adds to the warm and welcoming vibe of the restaurant.
BAR
8.8/10 (2935 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 203-495-8924
Unique mashed potato pizzaCreative flavors like BBQ BrisketLively atmosphere
Bar, located in New Haven, CT, stands out for its perfectly cooked, flavorful pizza. The unique mashed potato pizza is a must-try, along with other creative flavors like BBQ Brisket and Herbivore. The light, airy, and crispy dough is complemented by fresh, wonderful ingredients and a great char. The service may be a bit slow at times, but the delicious cocktails and beer make up for it. Bar is the ideal spot to gather with friends, enjoy fantastic pizza, and soak up the lively atmosphere. Don’t miss out on this stellar pizza experience.