Whether you’re craving a classic New York-style fold or a gourmet Neapolitan masterpiece, Newark offers a selection of pizza spots that promise to satisfy every palate.
From crispy thin crusts adorned with local produce to hearty deep-dish wonders that ooze with molten cheese, Newark’s pizza scene offers something to satiate every palate. This guide curates the city’s standout pizzerias, each offering a unique slice of culinary heaven.
Pizza Village Cafe
8.8/10 (438 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 973-344-0707
Variety of pizzasDelicious Caesar salad pizzaFriendly staff
Pizza Village Cafe offers a unique dining experience with a wide array of delicious pizza options. While some customers may find the buffalo pizza a bit lacking in sauciness and the occasional disappointment with delivery times, the overall quality of the food and service shines through. The Caesar salad pizza is a standout item, sure to satisfy your cravings with its fantastic flavor profile. The friendly staff adds to the welcoming ambiance, making each visit a pleasant one. Whether you’re a fan of Brooklyn-style pizza or enjoy Brazilian influences, this pizzeria caters to a variety of tastes with its thin crust and delectable toppings.
Blaze Pizza
9/10 (1885 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 973-206-4278
Friendly staffVariety of optionsAllergy-friendly
Blaze Pizza is a definite winner! The staff is genuinely nice, making the whole dining experience even better. The food is consistently good, with a variety of delicious options to choose from. The clean and modern atmosphere adds to the appeal, creating a pleasant ambiance to enjoy your meal. The only potential hiccup could be parking, but that’s a minor inconvenience considering the overall positive experience. If you’re looking for great food, friendly service, and a sleek environment, Blaze Pizza is worth a visit.
Queen Pizza
8.6/10 (182 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 973-624-7322
Spacious dining areaDelicious “military salad”Friendly and welcoming staff
Walking into Queen Pizza is like stepping into a food oasis in downtown Newark. The expansive canteen-like space provides ample seating for diners to enjoy their meals comfortably. The variety of options on the menu is impressive, from breakfast items to cold and hot sandwiches to mouth-watering pizzas. The standout dish for me was the “military salad” with chicken, which brought a burst of joy with each bite. The perfect portion size, flavorful dressing, and juicy chicken made it a meal worth savoring. The staff at Queen Pizza exude warmth and friendliness, making every visitor feel welcome and valued. It’s no surprise why this place has become a go-to spot for many, including myself.
Queen Pizza II
9.2/10 (283 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 973-242-1829
Quick serviceGenerous portionsMust-try plain cheese pizza
Located near NJ Penn Station, Queen Pizza II offers quick service and delicious NY-style pizza at great prices. Customers rave about the generous portions and friendly staff, along with the clean and convenient location. The plain cheese pizza receives high praise, standing out as a must-try item, proving to be a favorite among locals and visitors alike. With easy payment options and fast preparation time, Queen Pizza II is definitely worth a visit for a satisfying meal.
Mulberry Street Pizza
8.8/10 (138 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 973-900-6785
Delicious BBQ chickenFriendly serviceClean, welcoming atmosphere
Mulberry Street Pizza has made a significant impression on its customers since new management took over, offering delicious pizza options at reasonable prices. The BBQ chicken slice is a favorite among customers, and the service has been highlighted for its friendliness and attentiveness. The clean and welcoming atmosphere of the pizzeria, combined with the genuine care put into the food by the staff, ensures a pleasant dining experience. With offerings like the chicken penne vodka and large plain pizza, Mulberry Street Pizza is proving itself to be a standout in the Newark area.
Brazilian Pizza
8.6/10 (316 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 973-817-9400
Unique flavorsFamily-owned vibeAuthentic Brazilian experience
Upon stepping foot into Brazilian Pizza, customers are immediately met with warm hospitality and a cozy atmosphere. The menu offers a unique twist on traditional pizza flavors, featuring crunchy and spicy crusts with top-notch ingredients. This family-owned establishment truly delivers an authentic Brazilian pizza experience that keeps patrons coming back for more.
Robert’s Pizzeria
8.6/10 (273 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 973-642-0082
Fresh spinach slicesFamily-owned establishmentLarge pizza slices
Robert’s Pizzeria offers a tasty and fresh dining experience next to Rutgers University Newark branch. The spinach slices are a standout option, with no slice flop and a fresh taste. The family-owned restaurant has been a beloved spot for many since 2008, serving up delicious pizzas and other menu items like chicken penne vodka. The friendly staff, reasonable prices, and large pizza slices make it a great choice for a casual meal in the area.
Ellie’s Bistro
9.2/10 (198 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 973-732-2385
Cozy atmosphereDiverse menuTop-notch service
Ellie’s Bistro is a hidden gem near the Prudential Center in Newark, offering a warm and inviting atmosphere that feels like a cozy trattoria. The Napolitano wood oven pizza is a standout, with a perfect balance of flavors and a crispy crust. The menu is diverse, catering to all tastes, and the attentive and friendly staff go above and beyond to ensure a pleasant dining experience. The clam linguine is a must-try, although be aware it packs a punch with garlic. The quick service and delicious food make Ellie’s Bistro a top choice for a pre-game meal or a casual dinner in the area.
Queen Pizza & Deli
8.6/10 (118 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 973-802-1661
Fresh pizzaFriendly staffCustomizable breakfast sandwiches
Queen Pizza & Deli has quickly become a neighborhood favorite for its fresh and delicious pizza, along with a wide variety of other menu options. The staff is friendly and efficient, providing quick service that’s perfect for a busy day. Not only does the deli offer excellent pizza, but their breakfast sandwiches are also a hit with customers, offering customization for a truly unique dining experience.