Whether you’re craving a classic New York-style fold or a gourmet Neapolitan masterpiece, Newport News offers a selection of pizza spots that promise to satisfy every palate.
From crispy thin crusts adorned with local produce to hearty deep-dish wonders that ooze with molten cheese, Newport News’s pizza scene offers something to satiate every palate. This guide curates the city’s standout pizzerias, each offering a unique slice of culinary heaven.
The Original Pizza Sam
9.4/10 (390 reviews)
| Directions | +1 757-807-2742
Authentic NY pizzaVariety of slicesWarm and welcoming staff
The Original Pizza Sam is a hidden gem serving up delicious, authentic NY style pizza that will transport you back to the bustling streets of the Big Apple. One bite of their Sicilian pizza will have you hooked, with flavors that are simply unmatched. The variety of slices available throughout the day ensures that no matter when you visit, you’ll be treated to a fresh and satisfying meal. The employees are always warm and welcoming, adding to the overall experience of dining at this charming pizzeria. The attention to detail in each pizza, from the sauce to the crust, sets The Original Pizza Sam apart from the rest. Don’t miss out on this local favorite that has quickly become a must-visit spot for both residents and visitors alike.
Donatos Pizza
9/10 (697 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 757-525-4944
Unique flavor combinationsGluten-free indulgenceFriendly service
Donatos Pizza offers a unique twist on classic pizza flavors that surprised many customers who were looking for something different. The Mariachi Beef and Hot Chicken pizzas were standout items that left a lasting impression on customers, even those skeptical of unconventional toppings like pickles. The gluten-free options were also a hit, providing a delicious alternative for those with dietary restrictions. The friendly service and clean environment added to the overall positive dining experience, making it a must-visit spot for pizza lovers on the lookout for something special.
Vinnys pizza and pasta
9.2/10 (1004 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 757-594-3354
Fresh ingredientsCrispy crustFriendly service
Vinnys Pizza and Pasta offers a variety of mouthwatering dishes that have customers coming back for more. The white Capri pizza stands out with its fresh ingredients, while the ziti pizza and classic cheese slices are favorites among regulars. The friendly service and welcoming atmosphere make dining in a pleasant experience, and the crispy crust on their pizza sets them apart. Despite some inconsistencies in the amount of cheese on certain orders, Vinnys remains a go-to spot in Hampton Roads for top-notch pizza and Italian fare.
$5 Pizza
9.2/10 (475 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 757-595-1555
AffordableDeliciousWelcoming
$5 Pizza offers delicious, affordable pizzas that are miles ahead of any fast-food chain. The XL cheese pizza and cheese bread sticks are standout items that are a steal at just $15. The sauce is excellent, and the pies are consistently good. What truly sets $5 Pizza apart is the unique experience of interacting with the owner, who adds a welcoming touch that is rare to find in a pizza joint. The speed of service and the quality of the food make this spot a must-visit for those looking for great value and taste in their pizza.
Vinny’s Pizza and Pasta
9/10 (414 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 757-369-3554
Generous portionsFriendly serviceDelicious carrot cake
Vinny’s Pizza and Pasta offers a great variety of delicious food at an affordable price. The portions are generous, ensuring you get your money’s worth. The service is exceptional – friendly and attentive. The standout dish is the carrot cake, a must-try for dessert lovers. While some menu items like the garlic knots received high praise, others like the pizza fell short of expectations. Overall, Vinny’s is a reliable spot for Italian cuisine, especially if you’re in the mood for pizza or Stromboli.
Anna’s Pizza
8.8/10 (887 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 757-595-0723
Authentic Sicilian pizzaFresh ingredientsCozy family atmosphere
Anna’s Pizza is a family-owned gem in Newport News serving up delicious Sicilian style pizza that doesn’t disappoint. The mozzarella Caprese salad and chicken Alfredo are standout dishes that showcase the quality ingredients and attention to detail in the kitchen. The cozy atmosphere and hardworking staff create a welcoming dining experience that keeps customers coming back for more. The brick oven New York-style pizza is a must-try, and the friendly service adds an extra touch of warmth to the meal.
Azzurri Italian Restaurant
9/10 (535 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 757-926-4890
Generous portionsNY-style pizzaCozy environment
Azzurri Italian Restaurant is a hidden gem that offers generous portions of authentic Italian cuisine at reasonable prices. The crispy thin crust NY-style pizza and delicious pasta dishes are a must-try, with fresh salads and complimentary bread adding to the overall dining experience. The cozy environment and friendly staff create a welcoming atmosphere for diners seeking a taste of homemade Italian comfort food.
Mediterranean Kebab and Pizza House
8.6/10 (495 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 757-223-7311
Traditional Turkish dishesFriendly and attentive staffUnique and delicious pizza
Mediterranean Kebab and Pizza House is a hidden gem that offers a warm and welcoming atmosphere. The food is diverse, delicious, and fresh, with traditional Turkish dishes standing out. The lamb dishes are a must-try, and the Turkish yogurt drink, Ayran, is highly recommended. The staff is friendly and attentive, making you feel like family from the moment you walk in. The pizza is a standout as well, with a unique twist that will leave you craving more. Whether you’re looking for a special dinner or a casual meal, this restaurant is a fantastic choice for a memorable dining experience.
Gus’s New York Pizza & Bar
8.8/10 (369 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 757-833-0704
CheesesteakFriendly staffNew bar
Gus’s New York Pizza & Bar offers a variety of menu options, with the cheesesteak and potato salad standing out as a favorite among customers. The staff is known for being friendly and attentive, creating a welcoming atmosphere for diners. While some dishes like the wings may fall short in terms of flavor and size, the pizza remains a solid choice with delicious toppings and a well-crafted crust. The addition of a new bar adds to the restaurant’s appeal, making it a great place to grab a meal when you’re looking to dine out without the hassle of cooking at home.
Vancostas Restaurant
8.6/10 (899 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 757-874-1060
Cozy diner charmHearty, affordable breakfastGenerous portions
Nestled in a quiet neighborhood, Vancostas Restaurant exudes a cozy diner charm that has stood the test of time. The dated decor may not be modern, but it adds to the authentic, nostalgic feel of the place. The breakfast options are hearty and satisfying, with generous portions that won’t break the bank. The French toast is flavorful, the eggs are cooked just right, and the bacon is crispy – everything you’d expect from a comforting breakfast spot. The service is friendly and attentive, with staff members like Heather and Little Stephanie making sure every guest feels welcome. Plus, the affordability of the menu further adds to the appeal of this local gem. Whether you’re in the mood for pizza, subs, or a classic breakfast spread, Vancostas Restaurant delivers a delicious dining experience that won’t disappoint.
Dino’s Pizza Shop
9.4/10 (678 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 757-877-1894
Variety of toppingsCozy family atmosphereBrick oven
Dino’s Pizza Shop is a local gem in the neighborhood, serving up delicious pizzas with a variety of toppings to suit every palate. The menu offers something for everyone, making it a go-to spot even for those who aren’t in the mood for pizza. The attentive service and cozy family atmosphere add to the overall experience, making it a perfect spot for a casual meal or even a special occasion celebration.
Al Fresco
9.2/10 (645 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 757-873-0644
Generous portionsAuthentic flavorsExcellent service
Al Fresco is a hidden gem tucked away in a plaza, offering a wide range of authentic Italian dishes. The ambiance is pleasant, the service is excellent, and the portions are generous. The complimentary bread is delicious, the lobster ravioli is a standout, and the tiramisu is a must-try dessert. Whether you’re looking for a romantic date night spot or a place to gather with friends and family, Al Fresco is a solid choice that won’t disappoint.
Carrabba’s Italian Grill
8.8/10 (1814 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 757-269-4917
Excellent hospitalityDelicious foodAffordable prices
Located in the heart of town, Carrabba’s Italian Grill is a hidden gem that offers more than just your average pizza joint. From the double-bone 22oz pork chop, which is hailed as the best in town, to the warm and welcoming hospitality of their staff, this place is a must-visit for those looking for a delightful dining experience. Whether you’re attending one of their bourbon dinners or simply stopping by for happy hour, Carrabba’s ensures that you are well taken care of with delicious food and drinks at a very reasonable price. The attention to detail in their dishes and the top-notch service provided by servers like Jen, Corey, and Greg truly elevates this Italian grill to a higher standard.
Vineyards Trattoria & Pizzeria
8.6/10 (561 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 757-874-0114
Locally sourced seafoodCozy ambianceFlavorful Tiramisu
Located in a bustling area, Vineyards Trattoria & Pizzeria offers a solid Italian dining experience with a cozy ambiance. The menu features locally sourced seafood dishes, such as the Penne Siciliano, which impressed with its flavorful sausage. The Tiramisu was a standout dessert that provided a delightful finish to the meal. Although the wait staff was friendly, the service could have been more efficient, especially on busy nights.
Desi Kitchen – Best Indian Restaurants in Newport News, Va, USA
9.4/10 (215 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 757-586-5832
Authentic flavorsWarm hospitalityExpanding menu
Nestled in Newport News, Desi Kitchen is a hidden gem serving up delicious, authentic Indian cuisine. The Butter Chicken and Curry Chicken are must-try dishes, while the Garlic Naan is a crowd favorite. The attention to detail shines through in every dish, from the specially spiced rice to the refreshing Mango Lassi. The owner, Amit, goes above and beyond to ensure each guest has a memorable dining experience with his warm hospitality and traditional flavors. The expanding menu promises even more delectable options to come, making Desi Kitchen a go-to spot for those craving true Indian comfort food.