18 Best Pizza Spots in Olathe, KS

Whether you’re craving a classic New York-style fold or a gourmet Neapolitan masterpiece, Olathe offers a selection of pizza spots that promise to satisfy every palate.

From crispy thin crusts adorned with local produce to hearty deep-dish wonders that ooze with molten cheese, Olathe’s pizza scene offers something to satiate every palate. This guide curates the city’s standout pizzerias, each offering a unique slice of culinary heaven.

Marco’s Pizza

8.6/10 (366 reviews)

Website | Directions | +1 913-764-0332

Unique crust optionsExcellent flavor balanceFriendly staff

The craftsmanship that goes into Marco’s Pizza is truly impressive, elevating the humble pizza pie to new heights. The flavors and textures are expertly balanced, with unique offerings like the cauliflower crust catering to various dietary needs. The staff at this establishment are friendly and accommodating, ensuring that every customer’s experience is a positive one.

Minsky’s Pizza

8.8/10 (689 reviews)

Website | Directions | +1 913-261-8080

Varied menuExceptional serviceUnique pizza creations

Minsky’s Pizza offers a range of pizza options, with some standout dishes that have captured the hearts of patrons. The staff, particularly Manager Steve and server Morgan, have been praised for their exceptional service, making the dining experience memorable. The menu offers a variety of options, from traditional American-style pizzas to unique creations like the mac and cheese pizza. While some dishes may fall short of expectations, Minsky’s dedication to quality ingredients and service sets it apart from other pizza joints in town.

Sarpino’s Pizzeria Olathe

9.2/10 (170 reviews)

Website | Directions | +1 913-361-8646

Premium ingredientsQuick deliveryVariety of menu options

Sarpino’s Pizzeria Olathe is a standout pizza joint in Johnson County that truly knows how to deliver when it comes to taste. The quality ingredients truly shine through in every bite, from the premium Italian sausage and pepperoni to the magical cheese and authentic sauce. The service is top-notch, with quick delivery and friendly staff who go above and beyond for their customers. The variety of options on the menu, including calzones and customizable pizzas, make it a go-to spot for any pizza lover looking for a delicious and satisfying meal.

SPIN! Pizza

8.8/10 (1051 reviews)

Website | Directions | +1 913-764-7746

Crust perfectionSelf-serve sodasFresh Italian Meatballs

SPIN! Pizza is a place where the crust is cooked to perfection in a brick oven pizza fired up with care. They offer a unique experience, allowing customers to pour their own sodas including brands like Stubborn Soda. The Italian Meatballs appetizer is fresh and flavorful, definitely not frozen. While the service might be hit or miss, once you get the attention of the staff, the warmth and gooeyness of every bite will make it worth your while.

The Other Place Olathe

8.6/10 (1246 reviews)

Website | Directions | +1 913-791-9500

Wide menu varietyMouthwatering burgersRelaxing ambiance

The Other Place Olathe’s menu offers a wide variety of bar food staples, from delicious pizza to mouthwatering burgers. The Long Branch burger, stacked high with fresh toppings and drenched in a unique house dressing, was a culinary delight. The fried mushrooms appetizer arrived piping hot, with a golden brown crust and delightful crispiness. The facility is massive yet well-designed, clean, and exudes a relaxing ambiance. The professional service provided was attentive and helpful, but not pushy. Overall, The Other Place offers a level of quality rarely encountered in bar experiences and is a clear cut above its competition. Give this place a try for a little class and a lot of delicious food.

Minsky’s Pizza

8.6/10 (931 reviews)

Website | Directions | +1 913-780-9922

Generous portionsHot wingsHospitable service

Minsky’s Pizza offers a satisfying lunch special with fresh salads and generous pizza slices. The hot wings are also a hit, and the hospitality from servers like Sara and Malyssa adds to the positive dining experience. Despite some mixed reviews, the overall consistency and quality of the food make it worth a second visit.

Toni’s Italian Restaurant

9.2/10 (1121 reviews)

Website | Directions | +1 913-768-1912

Generous portionsFriendly staffDelicious pasta dishes

Toni’s Italian Restaurant is a cozy spot where the staff goes above and beyond to make you feel at home. The menu boasts a wide selection of pasta dishes and freshly baked pizzas that are sure to satisfy your cravings. The bring your own bottle policy allows you to enjoy your favorite wine with your meal, enhancing the dining experience. The complimentary bread served is just the beginning of the generous portions that are served, ensuring you leave fully satisfied. Plus, the warm and welcoming atmosphere coupled with the friendly service makes Toni’s a must-visit for those seeking authentic, homemade Italian cuisine.

Pizza Shoppe

8.6/10 (362 reviews)

Website | Directions | +1 913-397-7117

Personalized pizzasFresh saladFantastic lunch special

Pizza Shoppe provides a unique dining experience that leaves a lasting impression. The staff members go above and beyond, with one employee even engaging with customers and surprising a child with a small gesture that made their day. The variety of pizzas available, such as the buffalo chicken pizza with a customizable option for those who prefer to skip certain ingredients, is a definite highlight. The salad with the “pink stuff” is a fresh and delicious side option that complements the main dish perfectly. Additionally, the restaurant offers a lunch special that is hard to beat, making it a great option for a midday meal. Whether dining in or opting for takeout, Pizza Shoppe stands out for its exceptional service and flavorful menu offerings.

Joe’s Kansas City Bar-B-Que

9.4/10 (6098 reviews)

Website | Directions | +1 913-782-6858

Unique menu optionsFlavorful meatsSpicy sides

Located in Kansas City, Joe’s Kansas City Bar-B-Que is a popular spot for barbecue enthusiasts. With a bustling atmosphere and a variety of meats to choose from, this restaurant has earned a reputation for its flavorful offerings. The large portions and unique menu options such as Rocket Cow and fried jalapeños set it apart from traditional barbecue joints. Customers appreciate the quality of the meats, with many praising the moist and well-seasoned ribs and brisket. The spicy sides, like the corn topped with Parmesan and chilis, add an extra kick to the meal. While some have found the decor and noise levels to be a bit overwhelming, the overall dining experience at Joe’s Kansas City Bar-B-Que seems to leave customers satisfied and coming back for more.

Pickleman’s Olathe

9.2/10 (240 reviews)

Website | Directions | +1 913-391-7006

Fresh sandwichesFriendly serviceVaried menu

Nestled in Olathe, Pickleman’s never fails to deliver fresh and tasty sandwiches that will leave you craving for more. The Hodge Podge is a crowd favorite, while the Italian club with added peppers is a must-try. The menu offers a variety of options, including mouthwatering chicken, bacon, ranch mac and cheese that even the kids will love. The service is top-notch, with friendly staff members who make your visit a pleasant experience. Watching the sandwiches being made adds to the charm of this establishment.

Minsky’s Pizza

9/10 (1182 reviews)

Website | Directions | +1 913-491-5252

Gourmet pizzasExtended late-night hoursQuick delivery

Minsky’s Pizza is a neighborhood gem with gourmet pizzas crafted with love and craftsmanship by talented pizza makers. The extended late-night hours until 2:00 am are a fantastic feature, providing a cozy atmosphere to linger longer over delicious food and drinks. The BBQ Z-Man Gourmet Pizza is a standout, as well as the blue cheese dressing and real ingredients used in the Margareta pizza that make Minsky’s a Kansas City staple. The quick delivery service and cheesy garlic bread are additional highlights that make Minsky’s a must-visit spot.

Jason’s Deli

8.8/10 (1344 reviews)

Website | Directions | +1 913-825-4422

Free soft-serve ice creamFresh made-to-order itemsExcellent value

Jason’s Deli is consistently a go-to lunch spot for many, offering a wide variety of options that hit the spot for hungry diners. The sandwiches, salads, and soups are excellent choices, with the California club and broccoli cheese soup standing out as delicious picks. The standout feature is the free soft-serve ice cream, adding a sweet touch to the dining experience. Additionally, the prices are reasonable, especially during these challenging times, making it a great value for the quality of food and service provided. The seating is ample to accommodate a busy lunch rush, and the staff are attentive and welcoming, ensuring a pleasant dining experience. The combination of fresh, tasty food and friendly service makes Jason’s Deli a reliable choice for a satisfying meal.

Rosati’s Pizza

9.4/10 (461 reviews)

Website | Directions | +1 913-242-8133

Chicago-style perfectionMouthwatering garlic butterFamily-friendly menu

Nestled in a quiet corner of the metro area, Rosati’s Pizza has garnered quite the reputation for its authentic Chicago-style deep dish and stuffed pizzas. The dedication to quality shines through in every bite, making it a go-to spot for pizza enthusiasts seeking the real deal. From the generous toppings to the irresistible garlic butter, each dish is crafted with care and attention to detail. Whether you’re a deep dish devotee or a thin crust fan, Rosati’s has something for everyone, ensuring a truly satisfying dining experience.

Planet Sub

8.8/10 (242 reviews)

| Directions | +1 913-390-6221

Fast serviceDelicious subsClean environment

Planet Sub is a popular spot offering fresh, hot subs that are a hit with many customers. The fast and friendly service is a standout, along with the delicious food served in a clean environment. The Big Dipper and the chocolate chip cookie receive particular praise, with the subs coming out quick even during busy times. While some customers had mixed experiences with certain subs, the overall consensus is that Planet Sub is a solid choice for a satisfying meal.

Crazy Good Barbeque – Bar & Eats

8.6/10 (706 reviews)

Website | Directions | +1 913-839-1774

Burnt endsVariety of saucesInviting atmosphere

Crazy Good Barbeque – Bar & Eats offers a unique experience in the Kansas City area. While some customers have mixed reviews about the food quality and portions, the standout items seem to be the burnt ends and variety of sauces. The atmosphere is inviting and the staff take pride in their work, which adds to the overall experience. Despite some inconsistencies, the prices are reasonable and the whiskey selection is a major draw for many patrons. The BBQ nachos and sandwiches receive mixed reviews, but the fries seem to be a consistent hit with customers. With some menu items like the meatballs earning rave reviews, it’s clear that Crazy Good Barbeque has potential to please many palates and become a must-try for BBQ enthusiasts.

Schlotzsky’s

8.8/10 (936 reviews)

Website | Directions | +1 913-782-2867

Fresh SandwichesComfortable Dining AreaFriendly Service

Schlotzsky’s was a pleasant surprise – the sandwiches were filled with fresh toppings and toasted perfectly, making for a satisfying meal. The bread had a great texture, crispy yet soft chewy. The dining area was comfortable and clean, with good booths for seating. The service was friendly and attentive, making the overall experience enjoyable. While the online ordering experience may need improvement, the in-person visit was definitely worth it.