Whether you’re craving a classic New York-style fold or a gourmet Neapolitan masterpiece, Pasadena offers a selection of pizza spots that promise to satisfy every palate.
From crispy thin crusts adorned with local produce to hearty deep-dish wonders that ooze with molten cheese, Pasadena’s pizza scene offers something to satiate every palate. This guide curates the city’s standout pizzerias, each offering a unique slice of culinary heaven.
California Pizza Kitchen at Pasadena
8.6/10 (1011 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 626-585-9020
Refreshing Watermelon+Strawberry SaladDelectable Paloma drinkDiscounted frozen pizzas
California Pizza Kitchen at Pasadena offers a refreshing Watermelon+Strawberry Salad and a delectable Paloma drink, along with a delicious buffalo Cauliflower appetizer. The restaurant also provides a great happy hour deal and a unique opportunity to take home discounted frozen pizzas. The inviting ambiance, friendly service, and diverse menu options make it a must-visit spot in the Pasadena area for a satisfying dining experience.
Settebello Pizzeria Napoletana
9/10 (800 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 626-765-9550
Authentic Neapolitan pizzaFresh, flavorful ingredientsWood-fired oven perfection
Settebello Pizzeria Napoletana truly shines with their Neapolitan-style pizza, transporting diners straight to Italy with each delicious bite. The fresh bread and perfectly baked crust, with just the right amount of chewiness, showcase the authentic flavors of Naples. While the service is good and atmosphere slightly peculiar, it’s the outstanding pizza that steals the show and keeps customers coming back time and time again.
Pie Life Pizza
9.2/10 (242 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 626-720-7095
Convenient locationQuality ingredientsFriendly staff
Pie Life Pizza offers a unique experience with their New York style pizza, conveniently located next to a coffee shop. The ability to order pizza from the coffee shop and enjoy it at either location provides a cozy atmosphere for patrons seeking a delicious slice. The warehouse pizza, mushroom slice, veggie slice, and white slice are highly recommended choices, with perfectly baked crust and quality ingredients making them stand out. The staff is friendly and the prices are reasonable, making Pie Life Pizza a must-visit spot for pizza lovers in the Pasadena area.
Pasadena Pizza Co.
9/10 (328 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 626-793-9020
Personalized Alfredo pizzaDelicious cookiesFriendly customer service
As I entered Pasadena Pizza Co., I was greeted with a variety of options that ranged from traditional to more unique choices. The standout for me was the personalized pizza with Alfredo sauce, a creamy and indulgent option that satisfied my cravings. Alongside the delicious pizza, the cookies stole the show with their delectable flavors that left me wanting more. I appreciated the attention to detail in the food, although some menu items like the calzone fell short of expectations. Despite this, the friendly customer service and overall pleasant dining experience left a positive impression.
The Luggage Room Pizzeria & La Grande Orange
8.8/10 (2635 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 626-356-4444
Unique flavorsConnected parkingCozy atmosphere
With the Luggage Room Pizzeria & La Grande Orange, you’re in for a treat with its connected parking structure, family-friendly vibe, and unique menu offerings. The shared history of the building adds to the overall charm, and the staff is welcoming and knowledgeable. While the portions may be on the smaller side, the flavors pack a punch, and the recommendations from the staff are spot-on. Don’t miss out on the underground parking validation, or the chance to try their gladiator pizza and flavorful fries. The cozy atmosphere and covered open-air bar are perfect for a relaxed dining experience.
Tarantino’s Pizzeria Inc
9.2/10 (549 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 626-796-7836
Traditional Italian fareGreat pizzaCozy, family-owned feel
Located in San Gabriel Valley, Tarantino’s Pizzeria Inc is a hidden gem serving up traditional-style Italian dishes that will transport you to the streets of Rome. The star of the show here is undoubtedly the pizza – perfectly seasoned, not greasy at all, and boasting a great crust that will leave you craving for more. The menu also features other Italian classics like pasta dishes that are top-notch. While the restaurant may be small and unassuming, the service here is warm and welcoming, treating every guest like family. Just remember, this cash-only spot is worth every penny for the authentic Italian experience.
Blaze Pizza
9/10 (743 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 626-238-6026
Fresh ingredientsAttentive staffVegan options
Blaze Pizza stands out for its fresh ingredients and attentive staff who go the extra mile for their customers. The dough is made fresh, ingredients are top-notch, and the vegan options are a plus. The cleanliness of the bar and the care in making each pizza are evident. While some customers have experienced issues like forgetting toppings or slow service, overall, Blaze Pizza offers a delicious dining experience worth revisiting.
Mamma’s Brick Oven Pizza & Pasta
9/10 (1030 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 626-799-1344
Thin & crispy crustFreshly made menuSelf-pour beer
Nestled in a bustling neighborhood, Mamma’s Brick Oven Pizza & Pasta is a local gem serving up New York-style pizza with a thin and crispy crust that packs a flavorful punch. The food offerings feel freshly made, with standout menu items like the Manhattan pizza adorned with sun dried tomatoes, feta, fresh basil, and garlic. The addition of garlic knots with every pizza order is a delightful touch, adding a savory bite to your meal. The spacious restaurant offers ample indoor and outdoor seating options, making it a go-to spot for a relaxed dining experience. The self-pour beer selection provides a perfect accompaniment to your pizza feast, with options like the refreshing mango beer adding a touch of summer vibes to your meal. Mamma’s is a solid choice for those seeking a satisfying pizza fix in a laid-back setting.
The Kitchen Italian Cafe & Pizzeria
8.6/10 (355 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 626-796-9802
Cozy ambianceStandout loaded pizzaMust-try lasagna
Nestled in Old Town Pasadena, The Kitchen Italian Cafe & Pizzeria offers a cozy ambiance and good Italian fare. The Sautéed spinach side dish and loaded cheese-less pizza with 6 toppings are standout choices. The lasagna is a must-try, cheesy and delicious, perfect for sharing. Service is top-notch, with attentive staff ensuring a pleasant dining experience. The garlic bread could use more garlic, but the hot Chicken Alfredo pasta is a standout dish, perfect for those looking for a comforting meal. The outdoor seating is a plus, making it an ideal spot for a casual Italian meal.
Brooklyn Square
9/10 (95 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 626-345-5275
Expansive menuDelicious calzonesInviting ambiance
Brooklyn Square Pizza in Pasadena truly shines with its expansive menu, showcasing more than just your typical pizza joint fare. The NY style pizzas are a standout, with the perfect bread-to-cheese ratio and a medley of fresh ingredients. The Lucky Lou sandwich is a must-try, offering generous portions that can easily satisfy two. The calzones, marinated with a delicious marinara sauce, are also a hit, making it a go-to spot for a satisfying meal. The friendly service and inviting ambiance add to the overall experience, making Brooklyn Square a destination worth revisiting.
Domenico’s
9.4/10 (685 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 626-797-6459
Seamless online orderingBig “D” special pizzaAttentive staff
Domenico’s is a longstanding Italian restaurant in Pasadena that continues to impress diners with its delicious food and attentive service. The menu offers a variety of classic Italian dishes, such as tortellini pasta, lasagna, and pizza, all cooked to perfection. The standout item seems to be the Big “D” special pizza, which has received rave reviews for its flavor and generous toppings. The online ordering process is seamless and efficient, with text updates ensuring a smooth and timely delivery. The staff at Domenico’s goes above and beyond to ensure a positive dining experience, making it a must-visit for Italian food enthusiasts in the area.
Blaze Pizza
9/10 (1288 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 626-802-5352
Customizable pizzasFriendly staffFresh ingredients
Blaze Pizza provides a unique dining experience through their customizable pizzas that cater to individual tastes. The variety of toppings ensures that each pizza is tailored to perfection, without feeling overly greasy. Despite some service hiccups, the friendly staff at Blaze create a welcoming atmosphere, making customers feel like valued members of the pizza-loving community. The fast-paced ordering process and fresh ingredients add to the overall appeal of dining at Blaze, offering a satisfying and enjoyable meal every time.
Pinocchio’s Pizza
8.6/10 (1026 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 626-791-7591
Genuine Italian experienceWelcoming and family-friendly ambianceWarm and hospitable staff
Nestled in Pasadena, Pinocchio’s Pizza is a gem for those seeking a genuine Italian dining experience. From their mouth-watering pizza to their delectable lasagna, each dish is crafted with precision and flavor that is undeniable. The ambiance is welcoming and family-friendly, making it an ideal spot for any occasion, whether it’s a casual visit or a special celebration. The staff exudes a sense of warmth and hospitality, ensuring that every patron feels right at home. With reasonable prices and a variety of options to choose from, Pinocchio’s Pizza truly stands out as a must-visit destination for authentic Italian cuisine lovers.
Cafe Bambino’s
8.8/10 (134 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 626-577-5007
Attention to detailQuality ingredientsExcellent customer service
Cafe Bambino’s stands out for its attention to detail and fantastic customer service. The staff goes above and beyond to ensure that each dish is made to perfection, accommodating specific requests like ensuring no burnt edges or crusts on pizzas. The quality of the ingredients truly shines through in every bite, with flavors that stand out, such as garlic and various spices that elevate the taste experience. Even during uncertain times like the pandemic, the service remains top-notch, with quick and efficient pickup options. Cafe Bambino’s is a hidden gem that deserves multiple visits to truly appreciate the delicious offerings and warm hospitality.
Pietro’s
9.2/10 (139 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 626-791-1826
Authentic flavorsMust-try hot pastramiFreshly prepared ingredients
Nestled in the heart of the city, Pietro’s is a hidden gem that delivers authentic Italian flavors with each bite. The simple cheese and tomato sauce pizza is a standout, striking the perfect balance between crust, sauce, and cheese. The hot pastrami sandwich, served on a sesame seed hoagie roll, is a must-try, boasting tender juicy pastrami complemented by mustard, pickles, and melted cheese. The menu offers a variety of sandwiches, pizza, pasta, and salads, ensuring there is something for everyone to enjoy.
Mi Piace
8.6/10 (1703 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 626-795-3131
Exceptional pastaOutstanding pizzaCharming outside seating
Mi Piace is a bustling Italian restaurant known for its exceptional pasta and outstanding pizza. The delightful combination of flavors in their pasta dishes and the high quality of their pizza are standout features. In addition, the charming outside seating provides a lovely atmosphere for enjoying authentic Italian cuisine.
PIZZANISTA! San Marino
9.6/10 (58 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 626-988-9825
Generous pepperoniUnique Kalamata olivesValue for money
PIZZANISTA! San Marino is a standout pizza joint with some unique offerings that set it apart from the rest. The Sicilian slice is a fan favorite, loaded with pepperoni that adds a salty kick to every bite. The crust is a standout feature, providing the perfect base for the generous toppings. While the regular slices may fall short with a slightly dry texture, the veggie slice surprises with the use of Kalamata olives, offering a burst of flavor. The value here is impressive, with slices that are large enough to satisfy even the heartiest appetites.
Pizza Of Venice
8.8/10 (319 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 626-765-9636
Delicious thin crustFresh and inventiveUnique cauliflower bites
Pizza Of Venice serves up delicious thin crust pizzas with a wide array of fresh ingredients and inventive pies. The mushroom pizza and the POV were both incredibly satisfying, while the house salad had an excellent balance of greens, crunchy almond slices, and a perfectly dressed finish. The cauliflower bites in mango habanero sauce were a standout, offering a yummy and unique flavor profile. The laid-back vibe, interesting art, and friendly staff contribute to an overall enjoyable dining experience, making Pizza of Venice a great spot for pizza lovers of all ages.
Tony’s Pizza
9.2/10 (257 reviews)
| Directions | +1 626-793-4114
Classic NY-style pizzaFriendly and courteous staffAffordable lunch specials
Tony’s Pizza is a San Marino institution, serving up classic NY-style pizza that has kept customers coming back for generations. The crust is flavorful and the toppings are always on point. The restaurant has become a favorite lunch spot for locals, offering great deals like two large slices and a soda for just $7. The staff is friendly and courteous, making you feel like part of the family as soon as you walk through the door. Whether you’re a regular or just passing through, Tony’s Pizza is definitely worth a try.
Prime Pizza
8.8/10 (161 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 626-714-1774
Authentic NY styleFriendly staffDelicious flavors
Prime Pizza Altadena is a gem in the pizza world, delivering huge flavors and authentic NY style pies. The crust is crisp and crunchy, the marinara sauce flavorful, and the pesto delicious. The staff is friendly and the oven non-stop, churning out the best pies straight from the oven. From classics to Sicilian to vodka slices, every bite is filled with pizza love. The only thing missing is powdered garlic to make it absolute perfection. Don’t let me eat too much Prime Pizza, I can’t resist.