Home / United States / New Jersey / Paterson

Get more leads!

Get featured here for 6 months.

18 Best Pizza Spots in Paterson, NJ

Whether you’re craving a classic New York-style fold or a gourmet Neapolitan masterpiece, Paterson offers a selection of pizza spots that promise to satisfy every palate.

From crispy thin crusts adorned with local produce to hearty deep-dish wonders that ooze with molten cheese, Paterson’s pizza scene offers something to satiate every palate. This guide curates the city’s standout pizzerias, each offering a unique slice of culinary heaven.


Lefty’s Pizzeria and Restaurant

9/10 (551 reviews)

Website | Directions | +1 973-998-9055

Top-notch Grandma PieClean and spacious environmentFriendly and attentive staff

At Lefty’s Pizzeria and Restaurant, you can expect a top-notch Grandma Pie that is a must-try. The spacious and clean environment is perfect for grabbing a quick slice or enjoying a sit-down dinner with family. The extensive menu includes delicious Italian dishes that are sure to satisfy any craving. The friendly owner and attentive staff, like Kim, create a welcoming atmosphere that keeps customers coming back for more. Whether you’re looking for a quick meal to go or a relaxing dining experience, Lefty’s is the place to be.

Note: The review and highlights are based on the customer reviews provided.


Broadway Pizza

9/10 (888 reviews)

| Directions | +1 973-279-3996

Delicious slicesReasonable pricesFriendly staff

Based on multiple customer reviews, Broadway Pizza in Paterson is known for serving some of the best slices around. The pizza is described as delicious, with a generous amount of cheese and a crispy crust that complements the flavorful sauce. The meatball sub is also a standout, with fresh sauce and tender meatballs, although some find the bread too soft. Prices are reasonable, making Broadway Pizza a great spot for delicious and satisfying food. Many reviewers appreciate the tasty pepperoni, large slices, and copious amounts of cheese and toppings that define a good American-style pizza. With friendly staff and a welcoming atmosphere, Broadway Pizza continues to be a favorite for locals and visitors alike.


Patsy’s Tavern & Restaurant

9.2/10 (645 reviews)

Website | Directions | +1 973-742-9596

Classic atmosphereTop-notch pizzaExcellent service

Patsy’s Tavern & Restaurant, established in 1930, is a true gem in Paterson, NJ. The atmosphere transports you back in time with its old-world Italian charm and classic tavern vibe. The pizza is a standout feature, with a thin and crispy crust that holds together perfectly and a tangy, sweet sauce that complements the cheese beautifully. The menu also features other delicious options like shrimp with broccolini and linguine, baked clams, and stuffed artichokes. Despite the neighborhood’s challenges, Patsy’s dedication to serving top-notch food shines through, making it a must-visit spot in Paterson.


33rd Pizza

9/10 (282 reviews)

| Directions | +1 973-881-1525

Classic slicesReasonable pricesCharming owner

33rd Pizza is a beloved establishment that has been serving delicious pizza and Italian dishes for decades. The no-frills environment takes patrons back to a simpler time, where quality slices and reasonable prices reign supreme. The owner greets customers with charm and respect, making everyone feel welcome. The Italian hero is fresh and flavorful, showcasing the consistent service and great taste that has kept customers coming back for years. This old school pizzeria is a staple in Paterson, with loyal customers praising the food and the welcoming atmosphere.


Joe’s Pizzeria

8.8/10 (76 reviews)

| Directions | +1 973-345-4707

Family-oriented serviceTraditional Italian fareReasonable prices

Nestled in the heart of Paterson, Joe’s Pizzeria is a neighborhood gem known for its exceptional service and mouthwatering food. The welcoming owner ensures that each guest feels like part of the family, serving up classic pizzas, hearty Italian subs, and comforting pastas at reasonable prices. While the ambiance may not be the star of the show, the warm and inviting atmosphere makes you feel right at home. Whether you’re a longtime patron or a first-time visitor, Joe’s Pizzeria promises a memorable dining experience filled with love, tradition, and of course, delicious food.


Taormina

9.2/10 (678 reviews)

| Directions | +1 973-742-1163

Taormina, a local Italian spot in Paterson, serves up rich and tangy tomato sauce that keeps customers coming back for more. Despite some mixed reviews, the food consistently impresses with top-tier pizza and mouthwatering garlic knots. The friendly staff and fresh ingredients add to the overall dining experience, making it a must-visit for those craving a delicious slice in the neighborhood. Love this place! Always fresh food and slices. Ask about the pasta special.


Giovanni’s Pizza

9.2/10 (177 reviews)

| Directions | +1 973-279-7174

Delicious pizzaSpecial offer valueWelcoming atmosphere

Giovanni’s Pizza is a beloved spot in Paterson, known for their delicious pizza and welcoming atmosphere. Customers rave about the quality of the food, with many citing it as the best pizza in town. The special offer of 2 plain slices and a drink for $5.50 is a crowd favorite, making it a great value for customers. Despite the lack of parking, patrons appreciate the quick service and tasty food, making it a go-to spot for many. With fresh and hot pizzas, Giovanni’s Pizza continues to be a favorite of both locals and visitors alike.


Ellison Pizza & Deli

9.2/10 (199 reviews)

Website | Directions | +1 973-742-8683

Fresh ingredientsSpeedy deliveryCozy atmosphere

Ellison Pizza & Deli offers a diverse menu with mouth-watering options that will satisfy any pizza lover. The slices are generously topped with fresh ingredients, allowing customers to taste a burst of flavors in every bite. The speedy delivery service ensures that you can enjoy your hot and delicious pizza in no time. The cozy atmosphere and friendly staff make dining at Ellison Pizza & Deli a delightful experience, complementing the outstanding food.


Tony’s Pizza

9.2/10 (219 reviews)

Website | Directions | +1 973-345-9547

Flavorful plain pieCrunchy garlic breadAffordable buy one get one offer

Entering Tony’s Pizza, you’re immediately drawn to the lively atmosphere and vibrant mural gracing the wall. The plain pie is a standout here, boasting a flavorful experience despite the lighter coating of sauce and cheese. The soft crust is a pleasant surprise, adding to the overall enjoyable dining experience. The garlic bread is a definite must-try, with its crunchy exterior and delicious taste. The wings, though not breaded, still manage to impress. If you’re looking for a great deal, the buy one get one offer is worth considering. Despite some hiccups in consistency, Tony’s Pizza remains a solid choice for a satisfying meal.


Pan Pizza Bakery

8.6/10 (94 reviews)

| Directions

Authentic Colombian flavorsDelicious pan de bonoFreshly baked bread

Pan Pizza Bakery offers a delectable selection of Colombian bread, with pan de bono standing out as a must-try delicacy. Despite some negative reviews about customer service, the quality of the food speaks for itself. The bakery could benefit from improving the service aspect to truly shine as a top-notch establishment. The inviting aroma of freshly baked bread and the authentic flavors of Colombia make Pan Pizza Bakery a hidden gem for those seeking a taste of traditional Colombian cuisine. The delightful pan de bono alone is worth a visit, showcasing the bakery’s dedication to crafting delicious treats. The bakery may have room for improvement in terms of service and attention to detail, but the overall experience is sure to satisfy any cravings for authentic Colombian bread.


Greatest Falls Restaurant and Pizzeria

9/10 (57 reviews)

Website | Directions | +1 973-523-8888

Welcoming staffHomemade dishesGreat service

Nestled in a serene setting, Greatest Falls Restaurant and Pizzeria offers a delightful dining experience. The friendly staff creates a welcoming atmosphere where you can enjoy delicious food at a very good price. The diverse menu offers homemade dishes like rice, pernil, and grilled chicken salad that will surely satisfy your cravings. The new section of hot foods is a must-try, showcasing the chef’s culinary expertise. Don’t miss out on this gem where service is unmatched and every bite is a true delight.


Alaeddin’s Pizza

8.8/10 (804 reviews)

Website | Directions | +1 973-247-9922

Fresh Halal ingredientsBuffalo chicken pizza with unique twistGenerous portions at reasonable prices

Alaeddin’s Pizza has a loyal following who appreciate the fresh and Halal ingredients used in their pizzas and other menu items. The Buffalo chicken pizza with carrots and celery may sound unconventional, but customers find it surprisingly delicious. The Philly cheesesteak Stromboli is a must-try according to many diners, who appreciate the generous portions and reasonable prices. Despite some negative reviews, the overall consensus is that Alaeddin’s Pizza is a great spot for those looking for flavorful Halal options and friendly service.


Sam’s Pizza by City Catering

8.8/10 (106 reviews)

Website | Directions | +1 973-684-5929

Crispy seasoned friesAttentive customer serviceFair price point

Sam’s Pizza by City Catering offers a range of dishes that are hit or miss, according to recent customers. While some rave about the Penne alla Vodka and the delicious grilled chicken, others have been disappointed by the quality of the salads and pizzas. The customer service is highlighted as a positive aspect, with many mentioning the kind and attentive staff members. However, issues with food hygiene have been raised, such as finding hair strands in dishes. Despite these drawbacks, the crispy and perfectly seasoned fries seem to be a consistent favorite among patrons. With a fair price point and good service, Sam’s Pizza by City Catering could be worth a try for those looking for a quick and satisfying meal.


KKC & NYC Restaurant Halal Platters & Pizza

8.6/10 (614 reviews)

Website | Directions | +1 973-569-9500

Flavorful chicken tendersBest honey biscuitsQuick delivery

Located in the heart of the city, KKC & NYC Restaurant Halal Platters & Pizza has quickly become a favorite among locals and visitors alike. The menu boasts a variety of mouth-watering options, from crispy chicken tenders to savory pepperoni pizza, all cooked to perfection. The attention to detail in each dish is evident, with flavors that pack a punch and leave you craving more. The friendly and welcoming staff provide top-notch service, making every dining experience a memorable one. Whether you’re in the mood for a classic pizza or craving some juicy fried chicken, KKC & NYC Restaurant Halal Platters & Pizza has got you covered.


Pizza City

8.6/10 (132 reviews)

Website | Directions | +1 973-881-8377

Large, affordable slicesUnique slice optionsSpecial beverage selections

Pizza City offers large slices at affordable prices, making it a great spot for a quick and satisfying meal. The wide variety of slices available, including unique options like chicken Caesar and veggie with potatoes, cater to different tastes. In addition, the carry Sunkist orange and Pizza City brand root beer add a special touch to the beverage selection. Despite some minor drawbacks like early closing hours and occasional issues with cleanliness, Pizza City’s tasty pizza offerings and budget-friendly prices make it a must-visit for pizza lovers in search of a filling meal.


Pide 28

9/10 (624 reviews)

Website | Directions | +1 862-256-2828

Delicious flatbread-style pizzasHuge and tasty portionsGreat service and relaxing vibe

Pide 28 offers delicious flatbread-style pizzas that are super filling and great for sharing. The lahmacun and pides are a real gem of Paterson, with the flavors being better than in Türkiye. The portions are huge, and each dish is packed with unique and delicious toppings. The service is great, the vibe is relaxing, and the music adds to the pleasant experience. The complimentary dessert is a nice touch, making this restaurant a definite recommendation for those looking for a flavorful and satisfying meal.


Master Pizza

9/10 (377 reviews)

Website | Directions | +1 973-772-4333

Great foodExcellent serviceCozy atmosphere

Master Pizza is known for its fantastic food and top-notch service. The mozzarella and scrambled eggs sandwich, as well as the meatball parm, are popular menu items that customers rave about. The cozy atmosphere and friendly staff make dining at Master Pizza a pleasant experience. However, some customers have noted issues with long wait times and inconsistent quality of the food, so there is room for improvement in these areas. Overall, Master Pizza is a recommended spot for delicious meals and great service.

Book Now


KRAL PIDE

9/10 (471 reviews)

Website | Directions | +1 973-310-9966

Delicious lahmacunHomemade ayranCrispy pide dough

KRAL PIDE is a gem of a restaurant, offering delicious and fresh Turkish cuisine that is sure to satisfy your taste buds. The lahmacun is a standout dish, with a perfect balance of flavors that will leave you wanting more. The homemade ayran is a refreshing complement to the meal, and the pide dough is crispy and delightful. The staff is friendly and attentive, adding to the warm and welcoming atmosphere of the restaurant. The prices are reasonable, making it a great value for the quality of food you receive.