Whether you’re craving a classic New York-style fold or a gourmet Neapolitan masterpiece, Peoria offers a selection of pizza spots that promise to satisfy every palate.
From crispy thin crusts adorned with local produce to hearty deep-dish wonders that ooze with molten cheese, Peoria’s pizza scene offers something to satiate every palate. This guide curates the city’s standout pizzerias, each offering a unique slice of culinary heaven.
Mike’s Pizza
9.4/10 (113 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 623-486-4807
Delicious pizzaFriendly atmosphereUnexpected gem
In a nondescript strip mall in the suburbs lies Mike’s Pizza, a hidden gem that defies expectations. The pizza, a delightful surprise that stands out amongst the ordinary, boasts the perfect balance of sauce and cheese, creating a flavor sensation that leaves you craving more. Pair it with the wings combo for a delicious meal that won’t disappoint. What truly sets Mike’s Pizza apart is the warm and welcoming atmosphere, reminiscent of home and family, making it a comforting and safe space that beckons you to return time and time again.
Ray’s Pizza
9.6/10 (1363 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 623-825-7005
Delicious pizzasFresh dough dailyFriendly staff
Ray’s Pizza offers an exceptional dining experience with their delicious pies and calzones. The light and flavorful sauce paired with the perfectly cooked and foldable crust will keep you coming back for more. The commitment to freshness and quality is evident in every bite. The inviting atmosphere and friendly staff make this spot a neighborhood favorite. Whether you’re a local or just passing through, Ray’s Pizza is a must-visit for a satisfying meal.
Original #1 Brothers Pizza
9.4/10 (932 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 623-486-4111
Cozy atmosphereIconic thin crustFriendly service
Original #1 Brothers Pizza is a cozy spot that offers delicious pizza with an iconic thin NY style crust. The atmosphere is welcoming, and the lunch specials are not to be missed. The meatball sub is a tasty choice, and the service is always friendly. Whether you’re a regular or a first-time visitor, this pizza place is sure to leave you satisfied.
Bruno’s Pizza
9/10 (545 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 623-412-3372
Delicious special pizzaEngaging live pizza-makingWelcoming and friendly service
Bruno’s Pizza is known for its delicious special pizza and perfectly cooked dough. The friendly customer service and cute environment create a welcoming dining experience. The live pizza-making process adds a unique touch, allowing customers to witness Bruno’s handling skills in action. The flavorful pizza and engaging owner make Bruno’s a must-visit for those seeking a tasty and enjoyable dining experience.
Chrissy’s Nino’s Pizzeria
9/10 (644 reviews)
| Directions | +1 623-972-1993
Delicious pizzaCrispy wingsCozy atmosphere
Chrissy’s Nino’s Pizzeria is a hidden gem in Maricopa County, offering delicious pizza and wings that keep customers coming back for more. The cozy, local vibe and welcoming service make you feel right at home, whether you’re a regular or a first-time visitor. The sweet potato fries are a must-order, crispy and flavorful, while the brownies are a sweet treat that you won’t want to miss. The wings are a fan-favorite, always cooked perfectly and not overly sauced. The pizza crust is cooked to perfection, with just the right amount of crispiness. With a selection of beer on tap and a laid-back atmosphere, Chrissy’s Nino’s Pizzeria is the perfect spot to enjoy tasty food and good company.
Fabio On Fire | Pizzeria Italiana
9/10 (1056 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 623-680-5385
Homemade tasteQuick serviceOutstanding ravioli
Fabio On Fire | Pizzeria Italiana is a must-visit spot in Peoria where the food never disappoints. The homemade taste and quick service make this a top choice among locals and visitors alike. While the service can sometimes be stretched thin, the personable staff and flavorful dishes more than make up for it. The highlight of the menu is the outstanding butternut squash ravioli, bruschetta, and Diavola pizza with spicy salami, making Fabio On Fire a perfect date night destination for those craving authentic and delicious Italian cuisine.
CHAR Pizzeria Napoletana
8.8/10 (765 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 623-249-5366
Fresh IngredientsTableside ServiceLively Atmosphere
CHAR Pizzeria Napoletana takes the concept of subway-style pizzeria to the next level with their fresh ingredients and top-notch quality. The restaurant brings the pizza right to your table, creating a dining experience unlike any other. The lively atmosphere, patio seating, and full bar with a great selection of rotating beers make this spot a must-visit for Neapolitan pizza lovers. Despite the slightly higher prices, the delicious flavors and friendly staff make it worth every penny.
#1 Brothers Pizza
8.6/10 (363 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 623-572-5577
Delicious pizzaFriendly staffClean environment
#1 Brothers Pizza in Peoria offers a delightful dining experience with its lunch specials and fast service. The expansive seating area and clean surroundings make it a pleasant place to enjoy a meal, especially on the side patio with umbrella-covered tables. The pizza and calzones are flavorful and the staff is accommodating and friendly. Despite some hiccups reported by customers, the overall atmosphere and food quality make it an inviting spot for a casual meal.
Streets of New York
8.6/10 (471 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 623-875-6600
Roasted chicken and pizza comboSaucy and perfectly cooked wingsFrosty beer selection
Streets of New York offers a pleasant dining experience, with generous portions and attentive service. Their roasted chicken and pizza combination is a unique offering, perfect for those looking for variety. The frosty beer and saucy wings are standout items on the menu. While some customers have experienced issues with reheated food or pricing discrepancies, overall, Streets of New York is a solid choice for a casual meal with family or friends. The newly added items like the New York Combo 18″ and antipasta are worth a try, and the chicken pesto pizza with sun-dried tomatoes and fresh mozzarella comes highly recommended for its flavorful and satisfying taste.
The Rec Pizza and Detroit Eats
9/10 (307 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 623-328-9131
Crispy crustFlavorful toppingsExcellent service
The Rec Pizza and Detroit Eats is a game-changer when it comes to Detroit-style pizza. The pizzas here boast a perfect combination of a crispy crust and flavorful toppings, leaving customers in awe. The rectangular shape of the pizzas sets them apart, with a thick yet light and airy texture that is a true standout feature. The crust, caramelized and cheese-filled on the edges, adds to the unique experience that The Rec provides. Whether you’re a die-hard pizza fan or simply looking for a new dining experience, The Rec is sure to leave you impressed.
Ballpark Pizza & Subs
9.4/10 (439 reviews)
| Directions | +1 623-979-8222
NY style pizzaFlavorful honey hot wingsUnique Sonoran Chicken sub
Ballpark Pizza & Subs is a hidden gem worth discovering. The menu is extensive, offering a wide variety of options from huge hand-tossed pizzas to flavorful wings. The standout for many customers is the perfectly cooked NY style pizza, especially the meatball pizza. The wings, dressed in honey hot sauce, are also a fan favorite. The Sonoran Chicken hot sub is described as ‘ridiculously good’, with a pepporncini sauce that customers can’t get enough of. The atmosphere, complete with a baseball theme, adds to the charm of this mom and pop establishment. If you appreciate fresh ingredients and great service, Ballpark Pizza & Subs is a must-visit spot for delicious pizza and wings.
Stevies Pizza Vistancia
8.6/10 (508 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 623-388-6242
Authentic New York pizzaFlavorful wingsFriendly atmosphere
Stevies Pizza Vistancia is a local gem in Vistancia that offers a unique dining experience. The menu includes delicious options like pizza, calzones, wings, and more. Customers rave about the authentic New York style pizza and the flavorful wings. The atmosphere is friendly and welcoming, perfect for a casual meal with family or friends. The restaurant can get busy, but the service is efficient and the staff is attentive. With options like gluten-free pizza and beer on tap, Stevies Pizza Vistancia is a must-visit for pizza lovers looking for a tasty and satisfying meal.
Buca di Beppo Italian Restaurant
9.4/10 (8394 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 623-412-9463
Large portion sizesVintage atmosphereExceptional customer service
When stepping into Buca di Beppo Italian Restaurant, guests are transported to a cozy, nostalgic atmosphere filled with vintage photographs adorning the walls. The large portion sizes of the dishes served family-style make it the perfect spot for a celebration or gathering with loved ones. Staff members like Katie and Laura provide exceptional customer service, adding to the overall memorable dining experience. The menu items, such as the pasta dishes and garlic cheesy bread, are flavorful and satisfying, catering to various tastes. Additionally, the restaurant’s ADA compliance and elevator access demonstrate their commitment to accommodating all guests and ensuring a pleasant visit. Buca di Beppo is a delightful spot to create lasting memories over a delicious meal.
Bubba’s 33
9.2/10 (3798 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 623-412-9933
Generous PortionsEfficient WaitstaffDiverse Menu
Tucked away in the heart of the city, Bubba’s 33 is a hidden gem for those seeking a satisfying meal at a reasonable price. The portions are generous, leaving diners pleasantly surprised by the value they receive for their money. The waitstaff at Bubba’s 33 are efficient and work seamlessly together to ensure that each customer is content and well taken care of. With a diverse menu featuring American and Italian classics like burgers, pizzas, pastas, and sandwiches, Bubba’s 33 offers a little something for everyone. The food is flavorful and delicious, from the juicy steaks to the spicy fire fries, leaving patrons impressed and eager to return for more.
The Sicilian Butcher
9/10 (1955 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 623-471-5771
Flavorful meatball Ferris wheelTasty fritto mistoJuicy, tender steak
Tucked away in the heart of the city, The Sicilian Butcher offers a unique dining experience that is a feast for both the eyes and the taste buds. The atmosphere is warm and inviting, with a touch of elegance that sets the stage for a memorable meal. From the moment you walk in, you are greeted with friendly and attentive service that makes you feel right at home. The food is the real star here, with dishes that are as delicious as they are creative. The meatball Ferris wheel is a must-try, offering a fun and tasty way to start your meal. The fritto misto is a flavorful delight, and the steak is cooked to perfection with every juicy bite. Whether you’re a fan of salads or have a sweet tooth, the menu has something for everyone, ensuring a dining experience that is sure to please even the pickiest of eaters.
BJ’s Restaurant & Brewhouse
8.8/10 (3159 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 623-772-6470
Impeccable serviceVaried menuReasonable prices
BJ’s Restaurant & Brewhouse is a gem hidden in the bustling restaurant scene. The impeccable service provided by Manager Todd shines brighter than any dish on the extensive menu. Not only is the staff friendly and attentive, but they go above and beyond to ensure every customer has a delightful dining experience. The menu offers a wide variety of options, from calamari and fried mac & cheese balls to Philly cheesesteaks and margarita flights with boba flavors. The large portions and delicious food make it a perfect spot for any occasion. With excellent customer service, tasty food, and reasonable prices, BJ’s is a must-visit for anyone looking for a memorable dining experience.
Long Wong’s Hot wings
8.6/10 (213 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 623-322-3285
Crispy customizable wingsSurprisingly delicious pizzaFriendly and welcoming service
Long Wong’s Hot wings is a hidden gem that guarantees a delightful dining experience. The crispy and flavorful wings, ranging from garlic parmesan to honey hot, are the stars of the show. The option to customize the wings to your desired crispiness level is a unique touch that sets this place apart. The pizza is a surprising hit, reminiscent of the beloved Costco pizza. While the fries can be a bit too salty for some, they still manage to satisfy. The friendly service adds to the welcoming atmosphere, making each visit to Long Wong’s Hot wings a memorable and satisfying experience.
Father Sarducci’s Pizza, Pasta & More
8.8/10 (305 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 623-526-0164
Fresh daily doughFriendly serviceTiki patio vibes
Father Sarducci’s Pizza, Pasta & More is a hidden gem, featuring the BEST pizza I’ve ever had. The dough is made fresh daily, ensuring a delicious and flavorful experience. The tiki vibes on the patio add to the unique atmosphere, making it a perfect spot for enjoying great food and drinks. The service is friendly and efficient, with a touch of personalization that sets it apart from the rest. The wide variety of daily specials and live entertainment options make it a must-visit destination for a fun and enjoyable dining experience.
Outta Bronx Peoria
9/10 (343 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 623-215-6000
Deno’s Pizza surprise AZ
9/10 (530 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 623-975-2600