Whether you’re craving a classic New York-style fold or a gourmet Neapolitan masterpiece, Peoria offers a selection of pizza spots that promise to satisfy every palate.
From crispy thin crusts adorned with local produce to hearty deep-dish wonders that ooze with molten cheese, Peoria’s pizza scene offers something to satiate every palate. This guide curates the city’s standout pizzerias, each offering a unique slice of culinary heaven.
Hoops Pub & Pizza
8.6/10 (865 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 309-637-0533
Best slicesFlavorful appetizersWelcoming atmosphere
Hoops Pub & Pizza is a legendary spot in Peoria, known for serving up the best slices in town since the 90s. The specialty slices are a favorite among customers, along with the tasty appetizers like the pigs in a blanket with spicy mustard. The Wednesday buy one get one special is a steal, and the friendly service adds to the inviting atmosphere. Whether you’re grabbing a slice after a night out or enjoying a meal before a game at the Rivermen, Hoops Pub & Pizza is a must-visit spot for delicious food and a good time.
Nick-N-Willy’s Pizza Peoria
9.2/10 (121 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 309-691-2345
Quality pizzasFriendly staffGenerous portions
Nick-N-Willy’s Pizza Peoria stands out for its quality take-and-bake pizzas that are consistently well-made and flavorful. The inviting atmosphere and friendly staff add to the overall experience, making it a must-visit spot for pizza lovers in the area. The menu offers a variety of delicious options, with standout choices like the Outback and Magellan pizzas. The garlic cream sauce is a popular choice for creating custom pizzas, and the generous portions make it easy to feed a crowd. Whether you’re a regular or a first-timer, Nick-N-Willy’s Pizza Peoria is sure to impress with its great food, reasonable prices, and attentive service. Don’t miss out on this hidden gem at the Metro Center!
Brienzo’s Wood Fired Pizza
8.8/10 (955 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 309-966-7852
Unique wood-fired pizzaDelicious szechuan wingsFriendly and attentive staff
Brienzo’s Wood Fired Pizza offers a unique dining experience in Peoria with top-notch food quality. The pizza is a standout, with delicious flavors and quality ingredients. The wood-fired wings are worth trying, especially the szechuan flavor. The atmosphere is lovely and the staff is friendly and attentive, providing excellent recommendations. The gluten-free options are surprisingly tasty, making it a great spot for those with dietary restrictions. The convenience fee for credit card payments may be a downside, but the overall experience and food quality make it a must-visit spot in Peoria.
Veterans Pub & Pizza
9.2/10 (382 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 309-713-3029
Friendly atmosphereDelicious pizzaLive music
Veterans Pub & Pizza is a neighborhood gem known for its friendly atmosphere and top-notch pizza. The bartenders are attentive, the drinks are good, and the live music on Saturday nights is a must-see. The overall vibe of the place is inviting, and you’ll feel right at home from the moment you walk in the door. The menu is filled with delicious options, but the standout is definitely the pizza—each bite is a burst of flavor that will leave you craving more. Whether you’re looking for a fun night out with friends or a casual meal with great food, Veterans Pub & Pizza has it all.
Monical’s Pizza
8.6/10 (618 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 309-691-6477
Local favoriteWide varietyBest French dressing
As a highly regarded food journalist, Monical’s Pizza is a local favorite with good coupons, a wide variety of toppings, and the best French dressing in Illinois. The restaurant offers a comfortable environment for enjoying their fresh and flavorful pizzas, making it a go-to spot for many customers. While some may find the prices slightly high, the quality of the food, cleanliness of the restaurant, and friendly staff make it worth the visit. The General Manager, Roy, receives high praise for his excellent customer service and efficient management, adding to the overall positive experience at Monical’s Pizza.
Herold’s Pizza Oven
8.8/10 (360 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 309-682-3722
Delicious tavern-style pizzaFresh salad barFriendly and attentive staff
Nestled in the heart of town, Herold’s Pizza Oven is a must-visit for pizza lovers. The tavern style pizza is a standout, with flavors that leave a lasting impression. Whether you opt for the original crust or the cauliflower crust, each bite is a delight. The staff’s warm hospitality and prompt service only enhance the dining experience, making it a favorite among locals. The salad bar is fresh, and the prices are reasonable, offering a great value for delicious food. The small group we dined with had rave reviews, from the hot and fresh pizza to the exceptional salad bar. The buffet option is definitely on our radar for our next visit.
Sugar Wood-Fired Bistro
9/10 (1119 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 309-676-0848
Thin-crust wood-fired pizzasHelpful and accommodating staffFree refills on soda
Sugar Wood-Fired Bistro offers a unique dining experience in a redeveloped warehouse setting with a nice rustic ambiance. The staff is helpful and accommodating, creating a welcoming atmosphere for all guests. The thin-crust pizzas are cooked to perfection in a wood-fired oven, giving them a delicious charred flavor. Additionally, the diverse menu includes a variety of desserts for those with a sweet tooth, making it a great spot for a casual meal. The establishment also offers free refills on soda and ample parking options, adding to the overall convenience of dining here.
460° Pizza
9/10 (186 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 309-322-1460
Affordable pricesVariety of toppingsIndividual TVs at tables
460° Pizza offers delicious food at affordable prices, making it a hidden gem in the Peoria area. The unique concept of individual TVs at each table adds a fun element to the dining experience, especially for families. The variety of toppings on the pizzas ensures there is something for everyone, and the sweet marinara sauce adds a delightful twist to the classic pie. The all-you-can-eat buffet is a great deal, including a drink and salad bar, making it a perfect spot for a budget-friendly meal. While the decor may be lacking, the mouthwatering food more than makes up for it, making 460° Pizza a must-visit spot for locals and visitors alike.
Double A’s Pizza Sports Bar and Grill
8.8/10 (1030 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 309-692-0800
Convenient locationDelicious breadsticksFriendly staff
Nestled in a convenient location, Double A’s Pizza Sports Bar and Grill offers a variety of bar foods like burgers, sandwiches, and pizza. While the service can be slow at times, the friendly staff ensures refills without even being asked. The highlight of the menu has to be the delicious breadsticks that are a must-try. With decently fast service and a welcoming atmosphere, this spot is perfect for a casual meal and catching the game.
Peoria LaGondola Spaghetti House + Leonardo’s
9/10 (563 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 309-688-0800
Drive-thru windowMassive cookiesFriendly staff
Peoria LaGondola Spaghetti House + Leonardo’s is a unique dining experience, with a drive-thru window and disposable dinnerware that sets it apart from traditional restaurants. The cozy atmosphere and friendly staff make you feel right at home, and the massive chocolate chip cookies are a must-try. However, the lackluster presentation and inconsistent food quality may leave something to be desired. Despite some drawbacks, the convenience and welcoming staff keep customers coming back for more.
Firehouse Pizza & Pub
9/10 (722 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 309-698-9111
Flavorful Italian beefGenerous grilled saladsUnique sweet tomato sauce
Nestled in a charming firehouse-themed setting, Firehouse Pizza & Pub serves up some impressive dishes that have gained a loyal following. From the flavorful Italian beef sandwich to the generous salads with perfectly grilled chicken, there’s a dish for every palate. The star of the show, however, is undoubtedly the pizza – with a sweet tomato sauce that sets it apart, and an array of hot sauces available for those seeking an extra kick. The attentive staff and delightful service only add to the overall experience, making Firehouse Pizza & Pub a must-visit spot in Peoria.
Mickies Pizzeria
8.6/10 (723 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 309-966-0448
Flavorful wingsQuality thin-crust pizzaAttentive service
Nestled in a slightly dim space, Mickies Pizzeria serves up a selection of beers and wings that have customers raving. The wings are a standout, being described as some of the best in the area. The thin-crust pizza receives high praise, especially for its flavorful toppings and quality. The wait staff has been consistently commended for their attentive and friendly service, making sure that customers feel well taken care of throughout their visit. Mickies Pizzeria seems to be a reliable spot for a casual meal or a fun night out, with its welcoming atmosphere and delicious offerings.
Chicago Grill
9.2/10 (235 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 309-691-6900
Authentic Chicago flavorsPersonalized serviceStandout deep dish pizza
Chicago Grill is a slice of Chicago right in Peoria, offering delicious Italian beef sandwiches and deep dish pizza that will transport you to the Windy City. The gyros, Chicago dogs, and hand-cut fries are also standout menu items, providing a taste of home for Chicagoans in the area. The personal touch and welcoming service from Rose add to the overall experience of dining at this local family restaurant, making it a must-visit spot for those craving authentic Chicago fare.
Rizzi’s Italian Restaurant
9/10 (505 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 309-689-0025
Exquisite Italian fareImpeccable serviceIntimate ambiance
Rizzi’s Italian Restaurant is a must-visit gem for those craving exquisite Italian fare. The intimate ambiance and impeccable service sets the stage for a dining experience like no other. From arancini to sumptuous main dishes like chicken picata and chicken albanese, each dish is a masterpiece. The Italian wedding soup and house salad are too good to pass up, leaving you craving more. A complimentary treat of 2 chocolate-dipped strawberries adds a sweet touch to a memorable meal at Rizzi’s.
Jack’s on Adams
9/10 (143 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 309-839-2855
Unique JACKd up sauceExcellent Cuban sandwichNeat interior
Jack’s on Adams is a must-visit dining destination in Peoria. The unique JACKd up sauce on the shrimp appetizer is a standout, with a flavor that is both unique and delicious. The Cuban sandwich is excellent, the pulled beef sandwich is fabulous, and the Bacon and Chicken pizza is a must-try. The interior is neat, creating a great atmosphere for enjoying a cold brew and good food. Despite some inconsistencies with online orders, the friendly staff and quality food make Jack’s a great choice for a casual meal in downtown Peoria.
La Pecora Bianca UWS
8.6/10 (400 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 212-300-9870
Beautiful seatingAttentive serviceDelicious fresh pasta
La Pecora Bianca UWS is a beautiful establishment with plenty of indoor and outdoor seating. The outdoor area is enclosed and equipped with heaters for those chilly days. The decor is elegant and provides a great setting for dinner with loved ones. The service is top-notch, with friendly and attentive staff making sure your dining experience is pleasant. The food is delicious, with fresh pasta dishes that are a standout, along with well-seasoned scallops and a must-try burrata cheese appetizer.
Knuckles Pizza & Sports Bar
9/10 (574 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 309-243-5900
Flavorful hand-tossed pizzasWide drink selectionSpacious location
Knuckles Pizza & Sports Bar serves up a unique dining experience, perfect for sports enthusiasts and pizza lovers alike. Despite some hiccups in service, patrons rave about the flavorful hand-tossed pizzas, like the Hawaiian, which blend high-quality ingredients for a tasty treat. The bar offers a wide selection of drinks, including bourbon for those looking to unwind. The spacious location is ideal for meeting friends, though parking can be a bit tricky. While the service may have been hit or miss, the lively atmosphere and killer pizza make it a spot worth trying.
Agatucci’s Restaurant
9/10 (536 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 309-688-8200
Crispy thin pizzaNostalgic bar ambienceLocally family owned
Agatucci’s Restaurant in Peoria is a beloved spot that exudes tradition and nostalgia. The cracker thin square cut bar pizza is a standout, packed with flavor and crispiness. The bar/dining room ambiance adds to the experience, making it a perfect spot for locals and visitors alike to gather and enjoy a classic family-owned pizza pub meal.
Fat Jack’s Pizza LLC
9.2/10 (99 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 309-692-9000
Perfect crustHomemade sausageExceptional customer service
Nestled in Peoria, Fat Jack’s Pizza LLC has been a hidden gem for a decade, serving up delectable pizzas that have locals raving. The crust strikes the perfect balance between chewy and floppy, providing the ideal base for their ample toppings. Their homemade sausage adds a flavorful kick, elevating each bite. The owners, Mark and his lovely wife, are known for their exceptional customer service, making every visit a delightful experience. Whether you’re a fan of classics like Hawaiian or eager to try something new, like the all-meat pizza, Fat Jack’s is a must-visit for any pizza lover in the area.
Fedora’s Pizza & Gyro’s
9.4/10 (332 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 309-685-4976