Whether you’re craving a classic New York-style fold or a gourmet Neapolitan masterpiece, Pompano Beach offers a selection of pizza spots that promise to satisfy every palate.
From crispy thin crusts adorned with local produce to hearty deep-dish wonders that ooze with molten cheese, Pompano Beach’s pizza scene offers something to satiate every palate. This guide curates the city’s standout pizzerias, each offering a unique slice of culinary heaven.
Little Italian Pizza
9/10 (532 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 954-941-0550
Great pizzaExceptional serviceCozy atmosphere
Nestled in a cozy space that seats about 18-20 patrons, Little Italian Pizza packs a big punch in the culinary world. The food here is exceptional, with a standout Grandma Pizza that can be customized to a crispy perfection. The house salad with Balsamic dressing is a must-try, adding a burst of flavor to your meal. Regulars rave about the chicken and veal dishes, each prepared in various delectable ways. The garlic bread is hot and generously portioned, while the thin crust cheese pizza is a harmonious blend of flavors. The welcoming atmosphere, despite the small size, adds to the allure of this hidden gem.
Zuccarelli East
9.2/10 (1639 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 954-941-1261
Generous PortionsReasonable PricesHouse Vinaigrette
Located in Florida, Zuccarelli East offers an authentic Italian dining experience that is consistently delicious and worth the visit. With generous portion sizes and reasonable prices, this spot is a must-try for Italian food enthusiasts. The house vinaigrette, crispy garlic rolls, and creamy cannoli are just some of the highlights to look out for when you dine at this gem of a restaurant.
Cannoli Kitchen Pizza
8.8/10 (148 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 954-737-3737
Crispy crustGluten-free optionsFriendly service
Cannoli Kitchen Pizza is a neighborhood gem that offers quality pizza with generous toppings. The crust is crispy and flavorful, and the gluten-free option is definitely worth trying. The service is exceptional, with staff members like Johnny who make the dining experience enjoyable. The menu features a variety of combo specials, making it a great spot for families and groups looking for a satisfying meal near the pier.
Phil’s Heavenly Pizza
9/10 (866 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 954-943-9270
Thin, crispy pizzaHigh-quality cheeseAttentive service
Nestled in a peaceful corner of Pompano, Phil’s Heavenly Pizza offers more than just delicious food. The thin, crispy pizza is cooked to perfection and topped with high-quality cheese that will leave your taste buds dancing. The traditional, old-school vibe of the restaurant, complete with indoor and outdoor seating, is a refreshing change of pace. The attentive and polite service adds an extra touch of class to the dining experience, making you feel right at home in this slice of pizza paradise.
My Pizza Place
9/10 (576 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 954-788-5551
Thin crust pizzaUnbeatable pricesFlavorful lemon pepper wings
My Pizza Place is a neighborhood gem, known for their delicious thin crust pizza at unbeatable prices. The House Pie is a standout, even for those who don’t usually favor thicker pizza. And let’s not forget about their lemon pepper wings – some of the best you’ll ever taste. With a welcoming atmosphere and fast service, this place is definitely worth a visit. If you’re in the mood for a satisfying and wallet-friendly meal, My Pizza Place is the spot to hit up.
Jet’s Pizza
8.6/10 (551 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 954-782-5387
Flavorful PizzaFriendly StaffDetroit-Style Deep Dish
Located along Atlantic Blvd., Jet’s Pizza is a small pizzeria offering a variety of specialty pizzas and build-your-own options. I tried the Jet 10 loaded with toppings. The prices may seem high at first, but the quality of the pizza makes it worth every penny. The sauce, cheese, and toppings all complement each other perfectly, and the crunchy yet soft crust adds a nice contrast. The Detroit-style deep dish pizza is a must-try, and I’ll definitely be back to sample more of their offerings.
Ruby’s by the Sea
9.2/10 (146 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 954-785-7700
Flavorful garlic knotsSplendid four cheese pizzaAttentive and friendly service
Based on customer feedback, Ruby’s by the Sea seems to excel in providing a warm and welcoming atmosphere with top-notch service. The garlic knots are repeatedly praised for being flavorful and authentic, with just the right amount of garlic. The four cheese pizza is described as splendid, perfectly cooked, and generously cheesy. The thin crust offers a satisfying crunch without overwhelming the toppings. Customers appreciate the attentive and friendly servers who go above and beyond to make dining experience memorable. Overall, Ruby’s by the Sea seems to deliver consistently delicious food with great service, making it a must-visit spot in Pompano Beach.
Gianni’s
9.2/10 (1832 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 954-942-1733
Delicious table breadGenerous portion sizesWelcoming and energetic ambiance
Gianni’s, a beloved pizza restaurant, has quickly gained a reputation as one of the best Italian spots in town. The staff and owner are incredibly welcoming and the energy is top-notch, making you feel right at home. The table bread is to die for, the salads are unique and delicious, and the Italian specialty dinners are simply amazing. The portions are generous, and the quality of the food is outstanding. The personal touch from the staff, who engage in friendly conversations throughout your meal, adds an extra layer of charm to the dining experience. It’s no wonder Gianni’s has become a go-to spot for locals and tourists alike.
Mama Mia Pasta & More Pompano Beach
9.8/10 (66 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 954-361-2670
Fresh ingredientsIncredible sauceAttentive customer service
Mama Mia Pasta & More Pompano Beach is a true standout in the pizza scene of Pompano. The fresh ingredients, incredible sauce, and crispy crust created in their rotating oven make for a flavorful masterpiece that has even New Yorkers raving. The authentic Italian dishes are cooked with love and care, and the owner goes above and beyond to ensure guests have a memorable experience, from explaining their philosophy of using the freshest ingredients to offering free desserts. The food hall setting may come as a surprise, but the quality of the food, including the best fettuccine Alfredo ever tasted, is what truly shines at Mama Mia.
Anthony’s Coal Fired Pizza & Wings
8.8/10 (1182 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 954-942-5550
Consistent flavorsGreat birthday dealDelicious coal-fired options
Nestled in the bustling Pompano Marketplace, Anthony’s Coal Fired Pizza & Wings is a must-try for pizza enthusiasts. The coal-fired chicken, though slightly charred in places, remains tender and flavorful. The variety of wings, especially when paired with Mike’s Hot Honey, adds a delightful kick to the meal. The Caesar salad, wings, and pepperoni pizza were all fresh and satisfying, promising a return visit to savor yet another dish – a testament to the delicious offerings at this location. The staff, particularly server Gabrielle, excel in providing exceptional service, enriching the dining experience with warmth and efficiency. At Anthony’s Coal Fired Pizza & Wings, good food and impeccable service are the norm, ensuring a pleasant meal for all patrons.
Pasquales Pizza
8.8/10 (408 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 954-943-4752
Crispy thin crustRich tomato sauceFriendly staff
Pasquales Pizza is a quaint spot known for its Italian influenced dishes. While some have found the tomato sauce and white pizza to be a standout, others have reported mixed experiences. The crispy thin crust and rich sauce have left a positive impression on many, making it a top choice for locals and newcomers alike to enjoy a slice of authentic pizza. Some have pointed out that the interior lacks ambiance, but the welcoming staff and quick service make up for it. For those seeking a traditional pizza experience, Pasquales Pizza is worth a visit.
Anne Marie’s Pizza & Wine Co.
8.8/10 (914 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 954-889-6600
Unique specialty pizzasDelicious garlic rollsWeekly events
Anne Marie’s Pizza & Wine Co. stands out for its unique specialty pizzas and delicious garlic rolls. The calm atmosphere, dim lighting, and wall displays of wine bottles create an intimate setting perfect for a casual dinner. The diverse menu offers a wide range of Italian dishes, including vegan options, and the desserts are worth a try. The restaurant is known for its friendly and attentive staff, making every visit a pleasant experience. If you’re lucky, you might catch one of their weekly events like karaoke or live music nights, adding to the overall charm of this pizza joint.
MarToni Pizza Lounge
9/10 (81 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 954-366-6190
Delicious thin and deep dish pizzaHomemade sauce and crust perfectionWelcoming atmosphere and great service
MarToni Pizza Lounge offers a unique experience with their delicious thin and deep dish pizzas, as well as their must-try Stromboli. The homemade sauce and crust truly set them apart, creating a taste explosion in every bite. The welcoming vibe and awesome service, especially from bartender Nikita, make this spot a hidden gem. The Sicilian pizza is a standout item, showing off the chef’s skills and holding its own against any skeptics. The bar atmosphere and live music on weekends add to the overall experience, making MarToni a must-visit for pizza lovers looking for great food and laid-back vibes.
Brooklyn Pizza
8.6/10 (394 reviews)
| Directions | +1 954-393-0322
Generous portionsReasonable pricesFriendly service
Brooklyn Pizza offers an expansive menu with a variety of options, from pizzas to pasta to calzones, ensuring there is something for everyone to enjoy. The portions are generous, and the prices are reasonable, making it a great spot for a delicious meal that won’t break the bank. The staff is friendly and attentive, providing top-notch service that adds to the overall dining experience. The garlic knots are a standout, perfectly baked with just the right amount of garlic, while the chicken parmigiana is tender and flavorful, though some may prefer a bit more sauce on the pasta.
The Doughfellas
10/10 (143 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 954-850-0507
Passionate ownerDelicious Neapolitan pizzaUnique menu options
The Doughfellas truly stands out as a hidden gem in the world of pizza. The passion and warmth displayed by the owner, Andre, elevates the dining experience to another level. The Neapolitan-style crust is perfectly crispy, and the homemade sauce and fresh, flavorful toppings create a delicious combination that will keep you coming back for more. The menu offers a variety of unique and delicious options, including the White Pizza with Truffle Oil and the Prosciutto Pizza, both of which are mouthwatering. The attentive and friendly service adds an extra layer of charm to this already fantastic dining spot.