Whether you’re craving a classic New York-style fold or a gourmet Neapolitan masterpiece, Port St. Lucie offers a selection of pizza spots that promise to satisfy every palate.
From crispy thin crusts adorned with local produce to hearty deep-dish wonders that ooze with molten cheese, Port St. Lucie’s pizza scene offers something to satiate every palate. This guide curates the city’s standout pizzerias, each offering a unique slice of culinary heaven.
Roma pizzeria and restaurant of sandpiper
9/10 (510 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 772-337-1700
Consistent food qualityOutstanding serviceFamily-friendly atmosphere
Roma Pizzeria and Restaurant of Sandpiper offers an old school New York vibe with consistent and amazing food. Whether dining in or getting delivery, the quality is outstanding, from the pasta dishes to the no flop crunch crust pizzas. The service is impeccable, adding to the charming family atmosphere. The shrimp Parmigian and baked ziti are excellent choices, and the Meat Lovers Pizza, hot wings, and Lemonicello cake are must-tries. The peaceful atmosphere and fast, friendly service make Roma Pizza a gem worth visiting time and time again.
Al Forno Port St Lucie
8.6/10 (260 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 772-249-0294
Fresh made doughAffordable lunch specialFriendly staff
Al Forno Port St Lucie is a hidden gem in the pizza world, offering fresh and delicious options at an affordable price point. The lunch special with 2 huge pizza slices and a soda for only $8 is a steal, especially when the pizza is as flavorful as the sausage, ham, and pepperoni combo. The newly made in-house dough sets this pizzeria apart, ensuring each bite is fresh and satisfying. The friendly staff, like owner Chris, adds to the overall positive dining experience. Whether you’re a local or just passing through, Al Forno is a must-visit for pizza lovers craving a authentic NY style slice.
Francesca’s Pizza
9.4/10 (608 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 772-344-4748
Flavorful pizzasDelicious wingsKid-friendly atmosphere
Francesca’s Pizza is a gem for both lunch and dinner. The variety of pizzas like The Blakey and The Niagara are top-notch, and the wings are unmatched in flavor. The meatball appetizer is a must-try, and the kids will love the parm poppers. The lively atmosphere and kid-friendly environment make it a go-to spot. The service is always exceptional, with staff who are warm and welcoming, ensuring a delightful dining experience. The breakfast pizza and Blakley pizza are not to be missed – you’ll be planning your next visit before you’ve even left the restaurant. Gluten-free options, such as the bruschetta, are a welcome addition to the menu. Francesca’s Pizza truly delivers on both food quality and service.
Don’s Pizzeria
9.2/10 (261 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 772-905-8160
Flavor-packed sauceFresh ingredientsExcellent customer service
Don’s Pizzeria is a true gem in the pizza world. The flavor-packed sauce, fresh ingredients, and reasonable prices make it a go-to spot for locals and visitors alike. The attention to detail, from ensuring orders are correct to providing extra sauce on the side, truly sets Don’s apart from the rest. The customer service is top-notch, with friendly staff and efficient service. For a delicious and satisfying pizza experience, look no further than Don’s Pizzeria.
3rd Avenue Alta Cucina
8.8/10 (573 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 772-877-2176
Perfectly cooked shrimpCrispy pizza crustGreat lunch deals
Nestled in the heart of the bustling 3rd Avenue, Alta Cucina boasts a cozy atmosphere and a variety of mouthwatering dishes. Despite some hiccups reported by some customers, the shrimp stands out for being perfectly cooked, contrasting the overcooked pasta. The pizza crust is commendable – crispy and flavorful, drawing patrons in from near and far. The lunch deals have been particularly praised, offering a great value with quality ingredients. With a new owner at the helm, improvements are on the horizon, promising a brighter future for this neighborhood gem.
Frank & Al’s Pizzeria
8.6/10 (745 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 772-323-2700
Authentic NY/NJ pizzaDelicious gluten-free optionsFlavorful salads with unique ingredients
Frank & Al’s Pizzeria shines with their authentic NY/NJ style pizza, boasting boardwalk-sized slices that will transport you straight to the east coast. The welcoming atmosphere, accompanied by attentive and friendly staff, adds to the overall dining experience. Their dedication to quality is evident in their gluten-free pies, delicious toppings like mushrooms and onions, and flavorful salads. The addition of unique ingredients like provolone and creamy Italian dressing sets their menu apart from the rest. If you’re looking for a spot with excellent customer service and mouth-watering pizza, Frank & Al’s is the place to be.
Downtown Benny’s Pizza
8.6/10 (96 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 772-249-5110
Authentic NY pizzaGenerous portionsMouth-watering Zeppolis
Downtown Benny’s Pizza in Port Saint Lucie is a must-visit for anyone craving authentic New York-style pizza. From the generous and flavorful large pizzas to the top-notch Italian staple meals like the House Philly Steak Grinder, this place hits the mark when it comes to taste and quality. The Zeppolis are a standout, with extra servings of the mouth-watering dessert making it a memorable treat. Overall, Benny’s adds a tasty touch to the city’s dining scene and is definitely worth a visit.
Blaze Pizza
8.6/10 (431 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 772-828-2829
Customizable pizzasFriendly staffUnique menu options
Blaze Pizza prides itself on its customer service and the willingness of its staff to go above and beyond. The team at Blaze Pizza in Tradition is known for creating customizable pizzas that are delicious and freshly made to order, with unique offerings such as white sauce and high rise dough. Despite some occasional mishaps with orders, Blaze Pizza is a popular choice for those looking for a welcoming atmosphere and a variety of menu options to choose from. The BBQ Chicken pizza is particularly recommended, although some customers have noted that certain toppings could be improved. With a focus on cleanliness, friendly service, and a commitment to quality, Blaze Pizza continues to draw in patrons who appreciate a personalized dining experience.
Bella Roma Bakery & Pizzeria
9/10 (1446 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 772-343-7405
Authentic Italian cuisineFriendly staffAmazing desserts
Bella Roma Bakery & Pizzeria excels in providing authentic Italian cuisine in a cozy setting perfect for a bustling lunch crowd. The arancini and pepperoni and onion pizza are standout dishes, with the arancini boasting a perfect mix of fresh, crispy, and flavorful elements, while the pizza arrives timely, fresh, and perfectly cooked. The lobster tails and Italian bread are not to be missed, offering a delightful taste of Italy. The staff is friendly and attentive, enhancing the overall experience at this hidden gem of a bakery and pizzeria.
Mama’s Italian Restaurant & Pizzeria
9.4/10 (107 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 772-800-3108
Authentic NY pizzaFriendly serviceGenerous portions of marinara sauce
Mama’s Italian Restaurant & Pizzeria in Port St Lucie is a charming spot that truly makes you feel at home. The updated decor and welcoming atmosphere set the stage for some fantastic food. The pizza, reminiscent of New York slices, is a standout here. The garlic knots are a must-try appetizer, and the extra marinara sauce provided is a generous touch. From the friendly service to the delicious desserts, Mama’s is a top contender for a family night out or a casual meal with friends.
Da Vinci’s Italian Grill
9/10 (960 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 772-466-9331
Flavorful FettucciniSucculent chicken tendersCozy atmosphere
Nestled in Port Saint Lucie, Da Vinci’s Italian Grill may appear unassuming, but rest assured, its offerings pack a flavorful punch. The Fettuccini Alfredo and succulent chicken tenders are standout menu items, lauded by regulars for their creamy richness and tender, well-prepared meat. The lentil soup, served in a charming clay pot, delivers a comforting warmth alongside the satisfyingly crispy garlic knots. With a range of dishes, from the beloved pizza to the delicious chicken Marsala, Da Vinci’s serves up classic Italian fare with a side of friendly service, making it a go-to spot for both dine-in patrons and takeout aficionados alike. Eager to taste authentic, old-time family recipes? Look no further than Da Vinci’s Italian Grill.
Domino’s Pizza
8.8/10 (390 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 772-218-1600
Fast deliveryDelicious pizzasEasy app
Domino’s Pizza offers fast delivery with well-made, delicious pizzas. The friendly staff is happy to provide excellent, courteous service. The app is easy to use and rewards loyal customers. Despite some recent disappointments, Domino’s consistently provides awesome tasting pizzas at great prices. The hot and fresh food makes it a top choice for delivery options. Kids love it and overall, Domino’s has stepped up their game.
Cam’s Pizzeria
8.6/10 (70 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 772-877-2558
Perfectly cooked crustFresh and flavorful toppingsClassic NY-style pizza
Cam’s Pizzeria in Port St. Lucie West has quickly gained a loyal following for its delicious pizzas. The pepperoni pizza with double cheese is a standout, with a perfectly cooked crust that strikes the balance between crispy and airy. The white pie, topped with fresh mozzarella, garlic, and tomato, is also a hit among customers, especially when cooked to a light perfection. While some reviewers note the need for a little extra sauce, overall, Cam’s Pizzeria offers a great dining experience for pizza lovers looking for a new favorite spot in town.
Tavola Pizza
9/10 (726 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 772-335-0344
Hand-made wrapsCraft beersFriendly staff
As you step into Tavola Pizza, located in the heart of Port St. Lucie, Florida, you can feel the mellow beach vibe wash over you. The menu offers traditional pizza favorites with a laid-back twist, including hand-made wraps and a wide variety of craft beers on tap. The atmosphere is lively, with a clean and welcoming environment that is perfect for families and friends alike. The staff is friendly, knowledgeable, and provides top-notch service, ensuring that your dining experience is nothing short of exceptional.
Tutto Fresco
9/10 (1955 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 772-464-8988
Authentic Italian cuisineTop-notch serviceWarm and inviting atmosphere
Tutto Fresco is a hidden gem that offers delicious and authentic Italian fare, making it the best restaurant in Port St. Lucie. With top-notch service and consistently high-quality food, Tutto Fresco excels in creating a warm and inviting atmosphere for all guests. From perfectly crafted drinks to flavorful dishes like the crab and scallop risotto and veal parmesan, every aspect of the dining experience is sure to leave a lasting impression. Whether dining in or ordering for delivery, Tutto Fresco’s attention to detail and dedication to excellent cuisine truly set it apart in the area. With friendly staff, beautiful decor, and impeccable presentation, Tutto Fresco is a must-visit Italian institution that promises an unforgettable dining experience every time.
Ruffinos Italian Restaurant & Pizzeria
8.6/10 (595 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 772-335-2988
Authentic Italian flavorsDelicious alla vodka sauceFamily-owned with exceptional service
Ruffinos Italian Restaurant & Pizzeria is a hidden gem known for its delicious and authentic Italian flavors. The margherita and buffalo chicken pizzas are staples, but every item on the menu is sure to please. The alla vodka sauce is a standout, with a rich and flavorful taste that you’ll want to savor. Don’t miss out on the desserts, especially the cannolis with their light, crispy shells and decadent filling. The family-owned restaurant exudes love and passion, evident in the exceptional service and attention to detail. Whether you dine in or take your food to go, you’re guaranteed a wonderful experience at Ruffinos Italian Restaurant & Pizzeria.
Toni’s Pizzeria
9/10 (71 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 772-249-5373
Generous portionsVariety of pizzasFriendly staff
Toni’s Pizzeria stands out for its consistently delicious menu offerings and friendly staff. The Eggplant Parm, Penne Alavodka, and Chicken Alfredo are crowd favorites, along with the flavorful Knots and Bruchetta. Portions are generous, and the clean restaurant provides a welcoming atmosphere for diners to enjoy their meals. The variety of pizza options, including the margarita, pepperoni, and cheese pizzas, are equally satisfying. Despite some changes in ingredients, the quality of the food remains top-notch, making Toni’s a go-to spot for a satisfying meal.
LaMattina’s Trattoria & Pizza Bar
9.2/10 (206 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 772-667-6755
Hand-tossed pizzasGarlic KnotsWarm, friendly service
Hidden in the bustling Torino plaza, LaMattina’s Trattoria & Pizza Bar is a cozy gem that offers a menu enriched not only in quality but in love. The dough, both light and crispy, plays the perfect canvas for customizable pizzas that burst with fresh flavors. An array of house specialties, from the mouthwatering garlic knots to the delightful meatball calzone, showcase the restaurant’s commitment to premium ingredients. The service, led by a team of warm and friendly staff members like Megan and Heather, enhances the experience. The clean and comfortable decor adds a trendy yet rustic touch to the ambiance, making it a perfect spot for families and pizza enthusiasts alike. The attention to detail and passion poured into every dish makes LaMattina’s a must-visit spot for those craving an authentic Italian dining experience.
Pastaio Handmade Pasta•Pizza
8.8/10 (684 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 772-800-5999
Delicious CannoliUnique Kung Fu Chicken PizzaHearty Cavatelli with Sunday Sauce
Nestled in a charming locale, Pastaio Handmade Pasta•Pizza serves up delectable Italian cuisine that is a cut above the rest. The cannoli, generously filled with homemade cream and sprinkled with chocolate chips, is a standout dessert that will leave you craving for more. The kung fu chicken pizza is a unique and flavorful creation that showcases a perfect balance of ingredients, including sweet Asian BBQ sauce and fresh mozzarella. The cavatelli with Sunday sauce is a hearty pasta dish that bursts with flavors from pork ribs, sausage, meatballs, and savory herbs. The restaurant’s ambiance is inviting, with amusing signs scattered throughout, adding a touch of whimsy to your dining experience.
Frank & Als Pizza
8.6/10 (545 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 772-460-7827
Authentic NY-style pizzaFriendly and efficient staffAffordable prices
Frank & Als Pizza promises an authentic taste of New York with their crispy yet airy crust and generous toppings that pack a flavorful punch. Despite its unassuming location in a strip mall, the food and service shine above the rest. The prices are surprisingly affordable, making it a hidden gem for those seeking a satisfying meal. The staff greets you with warmth and efficiency, ensuring a pleasant dining experience. The All The Way pizza is a crowd-pleaser, while the pepperoni and mushroom calzone is a savory delight. Don’t miss out on their garlic knots, perfectly seasoned and a must-try. For a taste of true NY-style pizza, Frank & Als Pizza is a must-visit spot for both locals and newcomers alike.