Whether you’re craving a classic New York-style fold or a gourmet Neapolitan masterpiece, Pueblo offers a selection of pizza spots that promise to satisfy every palate.
From crispy thin crusts adorned with local produce to hearty deep-dish wonders that ooze with molten cheese, Pueblo’s pizza scene offers something to satiate every palate. This guide curates the city’s standout pizzerias, each offering a unique slice of culinary heaven.
MEXiCUE
8.6/10 (1722 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 332-249-8600
Vibrant dishesGenerous portionsHomemade tortillas
MEXiCUE offers a vibrant and colorful dining experience, with visually appealing dishes that are generously portioned, allowing for sharing and cutting down on costs. The homemade tortillas make a noticeable difference, adding an extra layer of flavor to the dishes. The fajitas and tacos are standout items, with perfectly cooked chicken and flavorful fillings that leave a lasting impression. However, some reviews mention a high oil content in certain dishes and inconsistent portion sizes. The atmosphere is lively and welcoming, perfect for a casual meal with friends or family.
Blackjack Pizza & Salads
9/10 (937 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 719-583-0900
Delicious pizzaFriendly staffAffordable prices
Blackjack Pizza & Salads offers incredible food that surpasses the big chain competitors in the area. The cheese bread is a standout, as is their selection of salads. The staff is consistently friendly and helpful, providing top-notch customer service. The build-your-own pizza options are fresh and delicious, with generous toppings that are sure to satisfy your cravings. The prices are extremely reasonable, making it an ideal spot for families or individuals looking for a great deal on quality pizza. The dedication to customer satisfaction and high-quality ingredients sets Blackjack Pizza & Salads apart from the rest.
Pizza King
8.6/10 (356 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 719-542-0193
Great pizzaAffordable pricesFriendly service
Pizza King offers top-notch pizza that is a cut above the rest. The aroma inside the restaurant is inviting and the overall cleanliness is impressive. The customer service is friendly and highly recommended for carry out. The prices are incredibly affordable, making it a great option for anyone looking for a delicious and satisfying meal. The pizza is the star of the show, with generous toppings and a satisfyingly greasy texture that is sure to please any pizza lover.
Do Drop Inn
8.6/10 (1531 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 719-542-0818
Sweet dough pizzaVaried menuVintage atmosphere
Do Drop Inn offers a unique twist on pizza with its sweet dough, creating a flavor profile that stands out amongst other options in Pueblo. The loaded toppings on the pizzas ensure each bite is satisfying, and the menu variety, including burgers and appetizers, caters to a range of tastes. The vintage atmosphere adds charm to the dining experience, accompanied by friendly staff that enhance the overall vibe. While some may find the sweetness of the dough overpowering, those who appreciate a thicker crust will enjoy the pizzas here. The overall unique character of Do Drop Inn makes it a must-visit spot for pizza lovers in the area.
Pasta Cottage
9/10 (233 reviews)
| Directions | +1 719-564-0095
Generous portionsFlavorful homemade pastaFriendly staff
Nestled in the heart of Pueblo, Pasta Cottage is a hidden gem that offers mouthwatering homemade pasta dishes that are sure to leave you satisfied. The portions are generous, perfect for sharing with a friend or enjoying as leftovers the next day. The Saturday special of spaghetti and meatballs is a crowd favorite, complete with a flavorful salad topped with blue cheese crumbles. The friendly staff adds to the welcoming atmosphere, making every visit a pleasant experience. The menu is constantly evolving and offers a wide variety of options, ensuring there is something for everyone to enjoy. If you’re in the mood for comforting Italian cuisine, Pasta Cottage is the place to be.
La Forchetta da Massi
9.4/10 (836 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 719-253-0126
Masterfully crafted cuisineEnchanting flavorsWelcoming staff
La Forchetta da Massi is a culinary gem in Pueblo, offering masterfully crafted authentic Italian cuisine that enchants your taste buds. The flavors in every dish are harmonious, with the bolognese and squid ink pasta standing out as must-tries. The welcoming staff makes you feel at home, and the ambiance is warm and inviting, perfect for a special night out. Remember to make reservations in advance to experience this hidden gem to its fullest.
Collette’s Catering-Carry Out
8.8/10 (846 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 719-543-2467
Delicious Italian fareHot, high-quality foodReasonable prices
Collette’s Catering-Carry Out is a hidden gem in Pueblo West, serving up piping hot, delicious Italian fare that will make you want to come back for more. From perfectly cooked pasta to mouthwatering meatballs and homemade sausage, every dish is a treat for your taste buds. The quality of the food is top-notch, and the prices are definitely worth it. Whether you’re picking up catering for a special event or grabbing a quick sandwich, Collette’s is sure to impress with its flavorful offerings.
BISTORO
9.2/10 (446 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 719-696-9672
Amazing dishesExceptional serviceLocal charm
BISTORO truly delivers on the food front with amazing dishes like the Basque Pork and Chicken al Fungo that are light and flavorful, alongside incredible potatoes. The standout experience, however, was the exceptional service from Rachel, who went above and beyond to provide a charming and knowledgeable dining experience that left us feeling truly taken care of. The local vibe added a special touch, with everyone seemingly knowing each other and spreading warmth throughout the restaurant.
East Coast Pizza
8.8/10 (760 reviews)
| Directions | +1 719-583-9000
Flavorful garlic knotsUnique pressed cookiesExtensive gluten-free menu
Located in a nondescript area, East Coast Pizza offers a delightful dining experience. From perfectly baked garlic knots to flavorful entrees like the jalapeño and pepperoni pizza and pasta with meat sauce, every dish is a pleasant surprise. Don’t miss out on their house salad with scrumptious dressing and a variety of unique desserts like pressed cookies and red velvet cake. The service is impeccable, with attentive staff who go above and beyond to ensure a memorable meal. The extensive gluten-free menu, including homemade bread and crust, is a rare find and a highlight for those with dietary restrictions.