Whether you’re craving a classic New York-style fold or a gourmet Neapolitan masterpiece, Rochester offers a selection of pizza spots that promise to satisfy every palate.
From crispy thin crusts adorned with local produce to hearty deep-dish wonders that ooze with molten cheese, Rochester’s pizza scene offers something to satiate every palate. This guide curates the city’s standout pizzerias, each offering a unique slice of culinary heaven.
The Pizza Shoppe
9.6/10 (78 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 585-203-1122
Outstanding Detroit PizzaCozy atmosphereQuality beyond just pizza
The Pizza Shoppe has quickly become a favorite in town, serving Detroit style pizza that is truly outstanding. The crust strikes the perfect balance between crispy and fluffy, topped with just the right amount of flavorful ingredients. The small and cozy atmosphere adds to the charm, making it a great spot to enjoy your meal in peace. The variety of options, including homemade pasta, meatballs, and chicken cutlets, showcases their culinary talent beyond just pizza. The dedication to quality shines through in every bite, making The Pizza Shoppe a must-visit for any food lover.
The Pizza Stop
9.4/10 (681 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 585-546-7252
Authentic NY-style pizzaPersonalized serviceCozy NYC-inspired atmosphere
The Pizza Stop in Rochester is a beloved spot for many, with loyal customers praising the authentic New York-style pizza and the friendly service from staff members like Chris and Carisha. The variety of slice options, fresh ingredients, and delicious sauce all contribute to making this a standout pizza joint in the area. One unique aspect that sets The Pizza Stop apart is their willingness to go above and beyond for customers, like helping with a gender reveal by creating a special pizza featuring a “G” for a girl. The cozy atmosphere with nods to old NYC adds to the charm of this downtown pizzeria.
Peels On Wheels Pizza Garage
9.6/10 (238 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 585-355-4111
Crispy crustAuthentic NYC styleFresh ingredients
Peels On Wheels Pizza Garage in Rochester is a must-try for all pizza lovers. The pies come in multiple styles and flavors, with Detroit style on Wednesdays and Pan Pizza on Thicc Thursday. The crust is insanely crispy, and the homemade ranch and hot honey are perfect accompaniments to the delicious pizzas. The staff is friendly and provides fast service, making the overall experience even more enjoyable. This spot truly stands out in Rochester with its authentic NYC style pizza that rivals even the best spots in the city. The fresh ingredients and unique pizza options make Peels On Wheels a top choice for pizza in the area. Travel from near and far to experience the best pizza Rochester has to offer.
Salty Bread Pizza Cafe
9.6/10 (165 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 585-270-8383
Exceptional pizzaVariety of optionsFriendly staff
Salty Bread Pizza Cafe in Rochester, New York is a must-visit for anyone in search of exceptional pizza offerings. From the mouthwatering Margherita French bread pizza to the delightful baked goods, this establishment delivers on both taste and value. The friendly staff adds to the overall inviting atmosphere, making it a gem in the Irondequoit food scene. Whether you dine in or grab takeout, Salty Bread Pizza Cafe is sure to impress with their inventive menu and five-star service.
Squatcho’s
9.8/10 (133 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 585-434-5002
Unique vegan optionsFlavorful buffalo chicken pizzaFriendly staff
Squatcho’s is a hidden gem in the heart of Rochester, offering a variety of vegan options that will satisfy even the most dedicated meat-eaters. The buffalo chicken pizza is a standout item, boasting flavors that are unmatched by other pizza joints in the area. The thoughtful addition of a spicy agave sauce shows the care and attention to detail that Squatcho’s puts into their dishes. The welcoming atmosphere and friendly staff only add to the overall experience, making it a must-visit destination for plant-based food lovers and pizza enthusiasts alike.
Linda’s New York Pizzeria
9/10 (607 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 585-458-8900
Authentic NY pizzaFriendly staffNostalgic dining area
Linda’s New York Pizzeria in Rochester is a slice of the Big Apple in upstate New York. The New York-style pizza is reminiscent of the city’s best with oil dripping from the triangle slice, perfectly folded with a slight crack in the dough. The pizza crust is cooked to perfection, with subtle seasoning in the sauce that doesn’t overpower the flavors. The dining area’s nostalgic 90s vibe adds to the charm, while the friendly staff makes you feel right at home. If you’re craving an authentic New York slice, Linda’s is the place to go for a taste of the city in Rochester.
Mavrik’s Pizza
9/10 (51 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 585-256-7437
Delicious pizzaExceptional serviceQuick delivery
Mavrik’s Pizza is a popular spot known for their delicious pizza and exceptional service. Customers rave about the flavorful sauce, fresh toppings, and perfect crust that make each bite a delight. The manager’s friendly and attentive service, going above and beyond to ensure a great experience, sets this place apart. With quick and punctual delivery, a variety of menu options, and a simple online ordering system, Mavrik’s is a go-to for many pizza lovers. The thin crust pizzas are cooked perfectly, with a healthy amount of toppings, making for a satisfying meal every time.
Galleria Pizza
9.2/10 (246 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 585-262-2222
Outstanding foodUnique setupFriendly staff
Galleria Pizza in Rochester offers outstanding food and exceptional customer service. The owner, Tony, provides a pleasant and smooth experience for guests. The setup of the restaurant is unique, with orders being read out via a PA system, creating a homely atmosphere. The sheet pizza is a standout, with generous toppings and flavorful seasonings. The staff works diligently to ensure that each dish is cooked perfectly. Despite the challenge of parking, this hidden gem is worth a visit for delicious and affordable food options.
R Pizzeria
8.8/10 (857 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 585-338-7929
Fresh foodPersonalized serviceReasonable prices
Nestled on North Street, R Pizzeria offers a hidden gem for locals seeking fresh and delicious food. The staff’s warm demeanor and personalized service create a welcoming atmosphere that keeps customers coming back. The menu boasts a variety of options at reasonable prices, with standouts like the Country Sweet chicken wings and perfectly cooked burgers that can be customized to your liking. The community-focused approach and openness to feedback add to the charm of this neighborhood spot. With quality food and great service, R Pizzeria is a must-visit for a satisfying meal.
Pizza Wizard
9.4/10 (444 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 585-565-4557
Detroit-style slicesFlavorful toppingsDiverse menu options
Pizza Wizard has quickly become a go-to spot for pizza lovers in Rochester, and it’s not hard to see why. The Detroit-style slices are thick, but not dense, with a light and airy dough that forms a crispy crust. The toppings are flavorful and diverse, with options like buffalo chicken and BBQ chicken that are sure to please any palate. The red sauce is rich and the cheese is creamy, creating a delightful cheese pull with each bite. The vegan options are a standout, with meat substitutes that are so good, even pescatarians and vegetarians are raving about them. The atmosphere is laid-back and fun, the service is top-notch, and the gluten-free crust is a revelation. Pizza Wizard truly hits the mark when it comes to great pizza.
Arthur Jaxon Slice & Scoop
8.8/10 (246 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 585-581-0222
Thin crust pizzaPulled pork pizzaGenerous portion sizes
Arthur Jaxon Slice & Scoop is a true hidden gem in Rochester. Their thin crust pizza is a real treat, perfectly crispy with delicious toppings. The pulled pork pizza is always a hit and the portion sizes are generous. The affordable prices and friendly staff make this a must-visit spot for pizza lovers. The variety of menu options, from boneless wings to Italian sausages, ensures there’s something for everyone. The location may not be the best, but the quality of the food more than makes up for it.
BTB Wood fired Pizza Bar & Grill
8.8/10 (1007 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 585-865-6510
Wood-fired pizzasDiverse menuWeekly specials
BTB Wood Fired Pizza Bar & Grill is a bustling spot with a cozy interior, ideal for casual outings or watching sports. The wood-fired oven gives the pizzas a distinctive flavor, with the chicken wing pizza being a standout. The diverse menu offers something for everyone, from Philly steak quesadillas to unique December specials like pesto-topped pizzas. Service can be hit or miss, with some servers going above and beyond during busy times. Specials like $15 for two margaritas and two tacos on Tuesdays are great deals, but be aware that gratuity may be included in the bill. Overall, it’s a solid choice for a fun night out with good food and drinks.
Pudgie’s Pizzeria
8.8/10 (1042 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 585-266-6605
Nostalgic AtmosphereAmazing PizzaFriendly Staff
Pudgie’s Pizzeria offers a nostalgic dining experience in the city of Rochester. The pizza stands out with amazing taste, flavor, and quality, making it worth the drive from other areas like Greece or Irondequoit. The staff is extremely friendly, adding to the overall positive atmosphere of the restaurant.
Rhino’s Pizzeria
9/10 (283 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 585-288-7492
Beautifully topped pizzasDelicious veggie optionsFriendly and welcoming staff
The pizzas at Rhino’s Pizzeria are truly a sight to behold, with beautifully arranged toppings that catch your eye from across the room. Despite being a meat lover, I decided to try the veggie pizza based on a recommendation, and I was not disappointed. The flavors were fresh and satisfying, making me eager to try their meat pies in the future, confident that they will be just as impressive. The quality of the pizza alone is enough to make me a repeat customer.
Tony Pepperoni
8.8/10 (531 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 585-334-2830
Authentic flavorsQuality ingredientsFriendly service
Tony Pepperoni is a standout pizza joint, serving up some of the best pies in Rochester. The taste of their food is far from cheap, clearly using superior ingredients that keep customers coming back for more. From the perfectly sauced pizzas to the delicious salads and wings, everything is fresh and flavorful. Reminiscent of the authentic Italian pizza you’d find in cities like Syracuse or NYC, Tony Pepperoni stands out for its quality and uniqueness. The friendly staff and quick service add to the overall experience, making this spot a must-visit, whether you’re a local or a tourist.
Brandanis Pizza
9/10 (447 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 585-272-7180
Unique and tasty pizzaPlump and tasty bourbon wingsFriendly and attentive staff
Brandanis Pizza in Rochester offers unique and delicious pizza options that are sure to satisfy any craving. The Ham and Ricotta Pizza for lunch is a standout, and the bourbon wings are a must-try for those looking to add some flavor to their meal. The slices are generously sized, with a thin crust and fresh ingredients that showcase the skill and dedication of the kitchen staff. The variety of options available, even at odd hours, ensures that there is something for everyone. The staff is friendly and helpful, creating a welcoming atmosphere for customers to enjoy their meal.
GG’s Pizza
9.6/10 (117 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 585-360-2050
Freshly made doughCreamy mozzarellaHomemade blue cheese
At GG’s Pizza, the freshly made pizza dough and sauce truly stand out, along with their creamy, freshly shredded mozzarella. The unique flavors of the crust, paired with quality toppings, really make these pies a must-try. The homemade blue cheese is a standout component, adding an extra layer of flavor to each bite. And don’t forget to pair your pizza with their perfectly cooked wings for a delicious meal that won’t disappoint.
Carbone’s Pizzeria
9.2/10 (769 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 585-865-7300
Delicious pizzaOutstanding wingsFriendly service
Carbone’s Pizzeria on Dewey truly stands out in Rochester’s pizza scene, consistently serving up mouth-watering pizza and some of the best wings in town. Despite its small kitchen, the quick and friendly service keeps customers coming back, even willing to drive a bit further for a taste of their delectable pies and crispy, tender wings. Whether you’re a local or a visitor from out of town, the quality and consistency of Carbone’s offerings make it a must-try spot for delicious, no-fuss pizza and wings.
The Pizza Stop
8.6/10 (233 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 585-225-5552
Amazing saucePerfect cheese ratioThin, delicious crust
The Pizza Stop is the perfect spot for pizza lovers looking for a delicious, thin crust pie. The sauce is flavorful, the cheese to sauce ratio is just right, and the crust is thin and scrumptious. The pizza is cooked to perfection, neither burnt nor undercooked. The friendly staff adds to the welcoming atmosphere, making it a great place to grab a slice or a whole pie.
Savastano’s Bakery & Pizzeria
9/10 (334 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 585-247-0448
Authentic Italian flavorsTop-notch customer serviceVariety of delicious baked goods
Savastano’s Bakery & Pizzeria is a local gem that offers delicious Italian delights. From fresh pizza dough to Italian cookies to delightful mini pizzas, this spot is a must-visit for those craving authentic Italian flavors. The bakery also offers a variety of baked goods, desserts, and breads that will surely satisfy your cravings. Additionally, their customer service is top-notch, with friendly and helpful employees always ready to assist you. Make sure to call ahead to order your favorite mini pizzas and enjoy a fantastic dining experience at Savastano’s Bakery & Pizzeria.