Whether you’re craving a classic New York-style fold or a gourmet Neapolitan masterpiece, San Diego offers a selection of pizza spots that promise to satisfy every palate.
From crispy thin crusts adorned with local produce to hearty deep-dish wonders that ooze with molten cheese, San Diego’s pizza scene offers something to satiate every palate. This guide curates the city’s standout pizzerias, each offering a unique slice of culinary heaven.
Joe G Pizza & Restaurant
8.8/10 (548 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 212-765-3160
Superb foodDivine ambienceImpeccable service
Joe G Pizza & Restaurant truly stands out as a delightful dining destination. The food special is undeniably superb, offering top-notch quality that keeps customers coming back for more. The ambience exudes warmth and charm, creating a cozy atmosphere that instantly makes diners feel at home. The staff, from the Owner to the wait staff, are praised for their exceptional service that goes above and beyond, making every visit a memorable experience. With a combination of delicious food, divine ambience, and impeccable service, Joe G Pizza & Restaurant is a true gem that should not be missed.
Pop’s Pizzas
9.8/10 (657 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 212-784-8863
Generously Topped PizzasThin, Crispy CrustEfficient and Friendly Service
Pop’s Pizzas, located near Central Park, offers a wide selection of delicious and generously topped pizzas that are perfect for a quick snack or lunch on-the-go. The pizza has a thin, crispy crust that manages to strike the perfect balance between crunch and chewiness. The buffalo chicken pizza, in particular, stands out with its perfectly balanced flavors and crispy exterior. The size of the slices is impressive, providing great value for the price. The staff is friendly and efficient, adding to the overall pleasant experience at this gem of a pizza place.
Marinara Pizza
8.8/10 (225 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 646-649-5282
Unique pizza selectionFriendly staffHidden menu gems
Marinara Pizza offers a wide and unique selection of delicious pizzas, from traditional New York Pie to unique creations like the MVP (Marinara, Vodka, Pesto) pizza. The staff is friendly and accommodating, allowing customers to enjoy their meal even after closing time. The garlic knots covered in cheese and pepperoni with a side of vodka sauce is a hidden gem on the menu. While some customers have mixed reviews about certain dishes, overall Marinara Pizza is a must-visit spot for pizza lovers in town.
Il Gusto Pizza
8.8/10 (270 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 646-767-0056
Incredible valueHigh-quality ingredientsBest New York-style pizza
Il Gusto Pizza offers incredible value for delicious New York-style pizza made with high-quality ingredients. The pepperoni pie is a work of art with plenty of cheese and meat, cooked to perfection and served piping hot from the oven. The small and clean space is welcoming, with friendly and accommodating staff, especially Sergio, who makes the absolute best pizza. Stop by for a truly enjoyable dining experience and some of the best pizza you’ve had in years.
B Side Pizza Bar
9.2/10 (1208 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 646-679-7225
Unique pizza flavorsFreshly made pizzasInviting atmosphere
B Side Pizza Bar in Hell’s Kitchen is a must-visit for pizza lovers. The Killer Bee pizza is a standout, with its unique combination of sweet honey and spicy meat. The freshly made pizzas are not overwhelming in size, and the crust is perfectly cooked – not soggy like other Napoli-style pizzas. The atmosphere is inviting, with a clean and fun open kitchen, great music, and friendly staff. This is the perfect spot for a mid-week girls night or a date night – the prices are reasonable and the service is top-notch. I cannot wait to return and try more of their delicious pizzas!
Made In New York Pizza
9.2/10 (904 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 646-484-6200
Varied selectionEfficient serviceSpacious atmosphere
Made In New York Pizza on the Upper West Side is a reliable spot to grab a slice or two. The selection is varied, with options like spicy pepperoni, margarita, and grandma style always available. The service is efficient, and the atmosphere is spacious, making it a comfortable place to dine in. Don’t forget to try the margherita sauce on the side for dipping the crusts; it’s a game-changer. For a quick and satisfying meal, Made In New York Pizza is a solid choice.
$1 Pizza
8.6/10 (681 reviews)
AffordableTastyQuick service
$1 Pizza offers delicious slices at an unbeatable price point. With just the right amount of sauce and a perfect cheese-to-sauce ratio, these $1 slices are a steal. The quick service ensures you can satisfy your pizza cravings in no time, making it a convenient option for a tasty meal on the go. While the lack of seating may be a downside, the quality of the pizza more than makes up for it. For authentic NYC pizza at an affordable price, $1 Pizza is a must-visit.
Sofia Pizza Shoppe
9/10 (404 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 212-888-8816
Thin crust delightStandout SicilianAllergy-friendly options
Sofia Pizza Shoppe is a quintessential pizza spot, offering thin crust pizzas with high-quality sauce and cheese. The Sicilian and Vodka pizzas are standouts, with flavors that truly shine. The pepperoni slice is a bit salty but still delicious. The Spinach Dip Pie is a must-try for spinach lovers, and the caramelized onions and honey topping on the pepperoni slice is a delightful surprise. This neighborhood gem may not have the best temperature for delivery, but the flavors and toppings make up for it. The allergy-friendly options are a hidden gem, with classic NY style pizzas that cater to various dietary needs. The garlic knots are also highly recommended. The Season Grandma slice with cup and char pepperoni and hot honey is worth a try, but there are other great pizza options in the area as well. Spinach lovers will be delighted by the Spinach Dip Pie, a standout slice at Sofia Pizza Shoppe.
Adoro Lei
9/10 (731 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 646-666-5096
Fun pizza makingBottomless drinksCozy atmosphere
Adoro Lei offers a unique and fun dining experience with their pizza making classes. Customers rave about the bottomless drinks and the friendly and accommodating staff. The atmosphere is cozy and welcoming, making it the perfect spot for a night out with friends or a special date. The pizza itself is cooked to perfection, with customers noting how surprisingly delicious it is. The interactive pizza making experience adds an extra element of enjoyment to the meal. Adoro Lei truly stands out as a memorable and enjoyable dining destination.
Saluggi’s East
8.8/10 (981 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 646-896-1163
Delicious foodVariety of drinksCustom pizza options
Review: Saluggi’s East is a hidden gem in the world of pizza joints. The baked ziti and cheese fries are simply to die for, perfectly portioned and delicious. The staff at this restaurant is speedy and welcoming, providing top-notch service. The wide variety of liquor and beer options pairs perfectly with the amazing food selections, making it a spot worth visiting with loved ones. The custom pizza options add an extra touch of excitement to the dining experience, with unique ingredients like capers and anchovies setting this place apart from the rest.
Ovest Pizzoteca
8.8/10 (905 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 212-967-4392
Cozy atmosphereDelicious brick-oven pizzaFast service
Ovest Pizzoteca offers a cozy atmosphere with a focus on delicious, comforting food. The brick oven pizza steals the show, particularly the crust, which stands out as a highlight. The chili olive oil adds a flavorful kick, enhancing the overall pizza experience. Additionally, the papardelle with mushrooms is also a standout dish, well-executed and satisfying for any pasta lover. The restaurant’s commitment to quality ingredients and fast service makes it a solid choice for a casual meal with friends or a romantic night out.
Pizza e Birra San Diego
9.6/10 (627 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 619-550-5796
Delicious buffalo wingsFresh and tasty San Diego pizzaExcellent customer service
Located in San Diego, Pizza e Birra serves up delicious pizza and wings that leave customers coming back for more. The buffalo wings, especially the mango habanero flavor, are juicy, crispy, and bursting with flavor. The homemade ranch adds a perfect touch of sweetness that complements the spice of the wings. The San Diego pizza is a must-try, with fresh and tasty ingredients on a soft yet crispy crust. The excellent service, including owner Sam’s attentive care, makes dining here a delightful experience. The energy and friendliness of the staff, combined with the top-notch food, make Pizza e Birra a standout in the San Diego dining scene.