Whether you’re craving a classic New York-style fold or a gourmet Neapolitan masterpiece, Santa Rosa offers a selection of pizza spots that promise to satisfy every palate.
From crispy thin crusts adorned with local produce to hearty deep-dish wonders that ooze with molten cheese, Santa Rosa’s pizza scene offers something to satiate every palate. This guide curates the city’s standout pizzerias, each offering a unique slice of culinary heaven.
Mombo’s Pizza
8.8/10 (438 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 707-528-3278
WingsLoaded friesLively ambiance
Mombo’s Pizza is a neighborhood spot that has its ups and downs according to customer reviews. The standout items seem to be the wings and the loaded fries, although there have been some inconsistencies with the quality of the pizza. Some customers have raved about the friendly staff and the abundance of TVs, making it a lively spot to catch a game. However, others have been disappointed by the lack of attention to detail in their orders, resulting in missing ingredients or undercooked pizzas. Despite some mixed reviews, it seems like Mombo’s Pizza has the potential to be a solid choice for a casual night out with friends.
Nonna Rosa Trattoria Pizzeria
9.2/10 (309 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 201-559-1370
Authentic Italian flavorsWarm and welcoming atmosphereTop-notch pizza
Situated in a small strip mall, Nonna Rosa Trattoria Pizzeria offers a taste of Italy right here in the states. The pizza shines as one of the best ever sampled, landing a spot in the top 3. The chicken vodka dish is a must-try, as well as the Linguine Marechiara for seafood enthusiasts. The atmosphere is warm and inviting, welcoming guests like family. The homemade cannoli is a perfect finale to a meal that transports diners to the heart of Italy.
Gio’s Pizza
9.2/10 (262 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 707-542-2797
Life-changing Mac & Cheese PizzaFresh and delicious ingredientsSmall, but mighty location
Gio’s Pizza truly stands out as the number one pizzeria in Sonoma County, consistently delivering top-notch dishes that exceed expectations. The Mac & Cheese Pizza is a game-changer, with the perfect balance of pasta and flavor that keeps you coming back for more. The Prima Vera pasta is also worth a try, boasting a smooth and delicious sauce that will satisfy any comfort food cravings. The attention to detail with fresh ingredients and the delicious taste of every bite make Gio’s a must-visit for any pizza lover looking for an unforgettable dining experience.
Rosa’s Pizza
9/10 (2326 reviews)
| Directions | +1 718-446-5910
Authentic Italian flavorsReasonable pricesFriendly staff
Rosa’s Pizza in Queens is well-loved for its authentic Italian dishes and delicious pizzas. The Grandma pie and Upside Down Sicilian are standout menu items that customers rave about. The staff are friendly and the prices are reasonable, making it a must-stop place for anyone craving a flavorful slice. Despite the worn-down appearance, Rosa’s Pizza remains a hidden gem worth visiting for a satisfying meal.
Sandy’s Take & Bake Pizza
9.4/10 (110 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 707-528-1919
Greek pizzaSanta Fe SpecialTake & Bake option
Sandy’s Take & Bake Pizza has been a hidden gem in Santa Rosa, offering some of the best pizza in town. The local favorite Greek pizza and Santa Fe Special are must-tries, and the option to order take and bake or have it baked in-house adds convenience. The welcoming atmosphere, perfect for watching sports with neighbors over a cold beer and a slice, makes Sandy’s a standout choice for pizza lovers in the area.
San Carlo Osteria Piemonte
9.2/10 (813 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 212-625-1212
Authentic Turin cuisineTruffle menu$26 lunch special
San Carlo Osteria Piemonte offers an outstanding dining experience with authentic Turin cuisine at fair prices. The truffle menu is a standout, especially the delicious truffle fries. The service is attentive, the atmosphere relaxed yet chic, and the food is amazing. The Vitello Tonnato and antipasto meat board are must-try dishes, and the risotto and lamb chops are exceptional. The friendly and energetic waitstaff, especially Domenico, add an extra touch of charm to the overall experience. The $26 lunch special is unbeatable and includes ample portions of delicious pasta and appetizers, making it a great value for a satisfying meal. Juventino Mauro ensures impeccable service, completing a memorable dining experience at San Carlo Osteria Piemonte.
Fat Daddy’s Pizza – Santa Rosa Beach
9/10 (480 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 850-267-4992
Delicious fresh ingredientsFriendly and efficient serviceLaid-back inviting atmosphere
As a renowned food journalist, I recently had the pleasure of visiting Fat Daddy’s Pizza in Santa Rosa Beach and was pleasantly surprised by the hidden gem tucked away from the tourist hubbub. The pizza was undeniably delicious, with fresh ingredients that shone through in every bite. What truly stood out was the friendly and efficient service – a rarity in the bustling pizza industry. The atmosphere was laid back and inviting, making it the perfect spot for a relaxing meal. If you find yourself in the area, I highly recommend giving Fat Daddy’s a try for a taste of authentic, mouthwatering pizza that will leave you craving for more.
La Pecora Bianca Bryant Park
8.8/10 (1048 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 212-924-4040
Outstanding serviceDelicious Italian fareCozy, modern setting
Nestled near Bryant Park, La Pecora Bianca exudes modern charm in a cozy setting. The outstanding service ensures your experience is seamless, whether it’s a bustling Friday night or a casual weeknight dinner. The menu boasts delicious Italian fare, from creamy whipped ricotta to savory Rigatoni pasta. Make sure to save room for the signature tiramisu – cute but generously portioned. With its inviting atmosphere, this gem is a top choice for an unforgettable dining experience in Manhattan.
Rosso
8.8/10 (566 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 707-544-3221
Fresh ingredientsAccommodating serviceDelicious dishes
Rosso, a local pizzeria, stands out for its fresh, locally sourced ingredients and affordable prices, offering excellent service and a welcoming atmosphere. The dedicated staff provides accommodating service while the menu showcases delicious dishes such as the Moto Guzzi pizza and the dry Vermintino wine. The apple dessert is a standout, and the atmosphere is friendly and inviting, making it a great spot for families and couples alike.
Sonoma Crust Pizza Catering
9/10 (147 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 707-477-4510
Crispy chickenDelectable beignetsQuaint atmosphere
Nestled in Sonoma, Sonoma Crust Pizza Catering is a spot worth seeking out, even if it means dealing with a bit of a line and potentially understaffed operations. With a menu highlighting crispy fried chicken sandwiches on soft waffles, each dish is uniquely satisfying. The beignets are a crowd-pleaser, and the attention to detail in the food preparation shines through. The little restaurant exudes charm, boasting a cozy outdoor seating area enveloped by succulents and string lights. A hidden gem, Sonoma Crust Pizza Catering is a delightful dining experience well worth any wait.
CIBO Rustico Pizzeria
8.8/10 (230 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 707-623-9906
Buffalo mozzarellaTraditional pizza ovenCharming ambiance
CIBO Rustico Pizzeria offers a delightful dining experience with delicious food and a charming ambiance. The buffalo mozzarella on the Francesca pizza is a standout, while the traditionally prepared pizzas in the massive oven are a visual delight. The friendly staff and owner add a personal touch to the meal, making it a must-visit spot for pizza lovers.
Carbone New York
8.8/10 (1913 reviews)
Impeccable serviceFlavorful startersPerfectly paced meal
Carbone New York is a must-visit for anyone seeking an unforgettable dining experience. The service is perfectly paced, allowing you to savor each dish without feeling rushed. The staff’s expertise shines through their impeccable recommendations, ensuring you enjoy every bite. The cocktails are refreshing, setting the tone for a delightful meal. The starters, like the Ceasar Salad and Yellowtail with Salsa Verde, are fresh and flavorful, while the mains, such as the Spicy Rigatoni Vodka and Tortellini, are nothing short of perfection. The dessert, a layered cake that is not too sweet, provides a wonderful conclusion to a fantastic meal. Don’t miss out on the fresh mozzarella and garlic bread, a delightful prelude to the main event. Carbone New York’s impeccable service and exceptional dishes truly make for a dining experience like no other.
Emily
8.8/10 (1622 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 347-844-9588
Emmy BurgerKorean ChickenColony Pizza
Nestled in Brooklyn, Emily has gained quite the reputation for its Emmy burger. The messy, cheesy concoction is a standout, with a generous portion of onions to satisfy any burger lover’s cravings. If you’re looking for a unique twist on a classic favorite, this burger is a must-try. The Korean Sticky & Sour Fried Chicken is a surprising delight, offering a perfect balance of saucy flavor and crispy texture. And while the Colony Pizza may not be the star of the show, the pepperoni and hot honey toppings provide an unexpected burst of flavor. Despite the cozy space and crowded tables, the friendly service and diverse menu make Emily a worthwhile dining experience.
L’oro Di Napoli
9.4/10 (156 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 707-541-6394
Perfectly cooked pizzasWelcoming and professional staffAuthentic Neapolitan experience
L’oro Di Napoli is a must-visit for those craving an authentic Neapolitan-style pizza experience. The chef’s mastery of the craft shines through in every bite, producing perfectly cooked pizzas with a light, slightly chewy, and slightly crisp crust. The pistachio pizza with mortadella is a standout dish, along with the hearty and satisfying lasagna. The welcoming and professional staff adds to the overall pleasant dining atmosphere, making guests feel right at home. With a fabulous Italian wine selection to complement your meal, L’oro Di Napoli is a hidden gem that deserves all the praise it receives.
Rosemary’s
8.6/10 (2237 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 212-647-1818
Cozy ambianceExceptional serviceTraditional Italian dishes
Rosemary’s is a cozy Italian spot in the West Village that offers exceptional food and service. The ambiance is inviting, with festive decor and great acoustics, making it perfect for a night out. The menu features traditional Italian dishes, with standouts like the whipped burrata and spicy rigatoni. The staff goes above and beyond to ensure a great dining experience, making you feel well taken care of throughout your visit.
FRANCHETTIS’ Gasthaus + Biergarten
8.8/10 (685 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 707-526-1229
Unique German/Italian menuFriendly and accommodating staffLovely mix of casual and sophisticated atmosphere
Upon stepping into FRANCHETTIS’ Gasthaus + Biergarten, I was immediately struck by the lovely mix of casual and sophisticated vibes in the atmosphere. The staff was not only very friendly and helpful but also accommodating to large parties, creating a welcoming environment. The menu, which offers a unique blend of German and Italian cuisine, boasts delicious options like sausages and meatloaf sandwiches that are to die for. The portion sizes are generous, and the presentation of the dishes is aesthetically pleasing. While slightly on the expensive side, the quality of the food and service make it well worth the price. The indoor and outdoor seating options provide a versatile dining experience, catering to a range of preferences. If you’re in the mood for a real German-style meal, this hidden gem is definitely worth checking out.
Supper
8.8/10 (1152 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 212-477-7600
Authentic Italian cuisineLively and fun atmosphereCreative and flavorful dishes
Supper is an authentic Italian gem tucked away in the heart of the city, serving up some of the best pasta dishes you’ll find outside of Italy. The tomato sauce is bright and flavorful, perfectly complementing the firm and delicious pasta. The attention to detail is evident in every dish, from the homemade desserts to the creamy buffalo cheese and tomato appetizer. The atmosphere is lively and fun, with a unique decor and a wine cellar that’s to die for. The staff are welcoming and attentive, making every dining experience a special occasion. Be sure to try the Saturday special osso bucco and the chocolate hazelnut panna cotta for a truly unforgettable meal.
Villaggio Pizzeria
8.6/10 (240 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 914-961-3200
White slicesBuffalo chicken pizzaVegetable pizza
Villaggio Pizzeria is a neighborhood gem known for its wide selection of delicious, high-quality slices and calzones. The white slices here are a must-try, especially if you’re a cheese lover. The Buffalo chicken pizza is another standout, perfectly blending flavors for a satisfying bite. Located just a short walk from the Tuckahoe train station, it’s a convenient stop for travelers and locals alike looking for a tasty meal. The dedication to using quality ingredients and the pride in their pies truly make this place stand out, ensuring a flavorful experience with each visit. The vegetable pizza is a top choice for those looking for a fresh and tasty option, with homemade dough that elevates the entire dining experience. Enjoy a family-friendly atmosphere and a variety of menu options that cater to all tastes at Villaggio Pizzeria.
MEXiCUE
8.8/10 (1747 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 332-263-3200
Vibrant decorFlavorful tacosQuick service
Upon entering MEXiCUE, diners are greeted with a vibrant and colorful decor that sets the tone for a lively dining experience. The menu is filled with unique and flavorful dishes, like the garden guacamole with a generous serving of veggies alongside tasty guacamole scoops. The shrimp, beef brisket, and fish tacos were standouts, each with their own presentation and delicious toppings. The service was quick and efficient, adding to the overall experience. MEXiCUE offers a cool ambiance that is perfect for a casual solo date or a fun night out with friends. The food is fresh, the staff is friendly, and the drinks are a hit, especially the Smoky Margarita made by Mark. If you’re a fan of Mezcal and good Mexican bites, this spot is a must-visit for an affordable yet enjoyable meal.
Thai Villa
9.4/10 (5970 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 212-802-9999