Whether you’re craving a classic New York-style fold or a gourmet Neapolitan masterpiece, Springfield offers a selection of pizza spots that promise to satisfy every palate.
From crispy thin crusts adorned with local produce to hearty deep-dish wonders that ooze with molten cheese, Springfield’s pizza scene offers something to satiate every palate. This guide curates the city’s standout pizzerias, each offering a unique slice of culinary heaven.
Gabatoni’s Restaurant
8.8/10 (1196 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 217-528-9629
Thin crust pizzasDelicious appetizersUnique ambiance
Gabatoni’s Restaurant is a spot beloved by many customers for its mouth-watering thin crust pizzas and delectable appetizers like fried mushrooms and garlic bread. The sauce and sausage toppings on the pizzas are noted for their delicious flavors. While the service may be a bit slow, the food comes out quickly with good portion sizes. The menu offers a variety of classic Italian dishes, making it a go-to spot for those craving a taste of Italy. The ambiance is quirky and fun, with pictures of dancing dogs and poker dogs adding a unique touch to the dining experience. If you’re in the Springfield area, Gabatoni’s is worth a visit for a satisfying and tasty meal experience.
Sapori Pizzeria & Italian Market
9.2/10 (126 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 217-679-3760
Unique market conceptDelicious Sophia Loren pizzaPerfectly seasoned meatballs
Located in Springfield, Sapori Pizzeria & Italian Market offers a unique dining experience with its combination of small market and delicious pizza options. The Sophia Loren pizza on their jersey-style crust is a standout, with flavorful ingredients that truly shine. The meatballs are perfectly seasoned, and the Detroit-Style “The Moe Green” pizza is a game-changer. The attention to detail in their food is evident, making it a must-visit spot for pizza lovers.
Bernie & Betty’s Pizza
9/10 (624 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 217-528-1821
Excellent thin crustFair pricesCharming neighborhood atmosphere
Nestled within a charming neighborhood in Springfield, IL, Bernie & Betty’s Pizza serves up excellent thin crust pepperoni pizza with a crispy cornmeal crust and robust flavor. The “soggier” thick sourdough crust also impresses with plenty of cheese and pepperoni. The hot, crisp fries and delicious garlic cheese breadsticks are not to be missed. While the service may have a slight hiccup, the fair prices, welcoming atmosphere, and attentive staff make Bernie & Betty’s a standout choice over chain restaurants.
La Piazza Cucina Italiana
9.4/10 (514 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 217-572-1442
Authentic pizzaFriendly staffGluten-free options
Located in the heart of the city, La Piazza Cucina Italiana is a hidden gem for those seeking authentic Italian cuisine. The warm, pillowy soft bread with a lightly crusted top is a delightful treat that is simply irresistible. The friendly staff adds to the inviting atmosphere, making every visit a memorable experience. While the ordering process may seem a bit confusing at first, the excellent pizza and reasonably priced menu make it worth the visit. The gluten-free pizza options are a standout, and the delicious dressing on the salads adds the perfect finishing touch to any meal.
Joe’s Italian Pizza in Springfield (not Lincoln)
8.8/10 (173 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 217-787-6005
Nostalgic pizzaDelicious lasagnaQuick carry-out
Nestled in Springfield, Joe’s Italian Pizza has been a long-standing favorite among locals. The pizza, with a perfect crust and just the right amount of toppings, brings back nostalgic memories of childhood. The lasagna is also not to be missed, offering a delicious alternative to the classic pizzas. While the atmosphere may lack luster given that it’s carry-out only, the quality of the food more than makes up for it. Whether you’re a regular or a first-time visitor, Joe’s Italian Pizza is sure to satisfy your cravings and leave you coming back for more.
Dillon’s Pizza
9.6/10 (160 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 217-544-3206
Thin crust pizzaGenerous toppingsFriendly service
Dillon’s Pizza is a beloved local institution in Springfield, known for its thin crust pizzas that are generously topped and bursting with flavor. The drivethru option makes it convenient for customers to grab a quick and delicious meal. The owners of Dillon’s Pizza are friendly, and their commitment to quality shines through in every bite. Despite the reasonable prices, the pizzas are always loaded with toppings and the sauce is excellent. A large pizza with two meats and two veggies for under $23 is a steal. It’s no wonder that Dillon’s Pizza is a go-to spot for many locals and visitors alike.
Mario’s Pizza
8.8/10 (721 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 217-523-2211
Delicious dishesEfficient serviceCozy atmosphere
Mario’s Pizza is a small gem worth discovering. Upon arrival, the charming exterior draws you in, and once inside, you’re greeted with a clean and inviting atmosphere. The service is efficient and the food arrives promptly. The menu offers a wide variety of options to choose from, and each dish is prepared with care and attention to detail. The Cheesy Italian Bread, Bacon Cheese Fries, and Pasta Platter are standout items that exemplify the delicious flavors Mario’s Pizza has to offer. Whether you’re a loyal regular or a first-time diner, Mario’s Pizza is a must-visit for those seeking quality food in a cozy setting.
Monical’s Pizza
8.6/10 (728 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 217-546-7258
Flavorful pizzaFriendly serviceExcellent garlic bread
Monical’s Pizza presents a delightful experience with their flavorful offerings and attentive service. The thin crust Mighty Meat pizza stands out as a crowd-pleaser, packed with a satisfying combination of bacon, ham, pepperoni, and sausage. The crispy crust complements the fresh and crunchy veggies perfectly, making it a standout dish. The garlic bread is a must-try, with a delectable sauce that enhances the dining experience. Whether you’re gluten-free or indulging in their classic options, Monical’s Pizza ensures a pleasant dining atmosphere with friendly staff and delicious food.
Nancy’s Pizza
8.6/10 (605 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 217-679-0456
Authentic Chicago-styleFlavorful stuffed pizzasWelcoming atmosphere
Nancy’s Pizza has quickly become a favorite amongst pizza enthusiasts, offering a delicious array of Chicago-style pizzas that are sure to satisfy any craving. The stuffed pizza, bursting with flavor and cooked to perfection, is a standout on the menu. The welcoming atmosphere adds to the dining experience, making it the perfect spot to indulge in authentic deep-dish pizza. Whether you opt for the Uncle Tony’s or stick with a classic like the medium stuffed with meat, Nancy’s Pizza guarantees a delightful meal every time.
J.T. Costelloe’s Pizza Pub and Grill
9/10 (227 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 217-697-8250
Delicious thin-crust pizzaEngaging and knowledgeable staffTop-quality, delicious food
J.T. Costelloe’s Pizza Pub and Grill is a neighborhood gem that truly delivers on delicious food and a welcoming atmosphere. Whether you’re grabbing some wings and a draft beer, enjoying a birthday celebration, or simply having a night out, this spot hits the mark. The Italian Beef with added cheese sauce is a must-try, and their thin-crust pizza is spot on. Despite some minor hiccups with service, the engaging and knowledgeable staff goes above and beyond to ensure a great dining experience. The quality of food, from custom-made frozen pizzas to fresh ingredients in every dish, is top-notch and definitely worth a return visit.
Antonio’s Pizza
8.8/10 (92 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 217-585-0323
Amazing pizzaFresh ingredientsFast service
Antonio’s Pizza is a standout in the pizza scene, offering some of the best pies you can find. The pizza is truly amazing, with fresh ingredients that elevate every bite. The service is both fast and efficient, ensuring you get your delicious pizza in no time. Customers rave about the quality and flavors of the pies at Antonio’s Pizza, with many declaring it the best they’ve ever had. Whether you’re a local or just passing through town, Antonio’s Pizza is a must-visit spot for a top-notch pizza experience.
Bella Milano Springfield
8.6/10 (1153 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 217-547-0011
Delicious foodOutstanding serviceRelaxing ambiance
Bella Milano Springfield offers delicious food at reasonable prices in a relaxed ambiance. The New York Strip with Cajun Gouda cream sauce is outstanding, along with the spinach artichoke dip and Milano salad. The atmosphere is totally relaxing, and the staff, particularly server Anthony, goes above and beyond to ensure a wonderful dining experience. The restaurant also offers great options for vegetarians and excellent customer service for pick-up orders. The food is flavorful and service is top-notch, making Bella Milano Springfield a must-visit spot in Springfield, Illinois.
Saputo’s
8.6/10 (1071 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 217-544-2523
Cozy atmosphereHomemade entreesVariety of wines
Nestled in Springfield, Saputo’s exudes a family-friendly and cozy atmosphere, making it ideal for intimate gatherings. The low lighting adds an air of exclusivity, while the menu offers a variety of homemade entrées and a selection of wines and cocktails. The combination of spaghetti and ravioli, suggested with marinara, is a standout dish that delights the taste buds. The tiramisu provides a satisfying conclusion to the meal. Despite some mixed reviews, Saputo’s remains a charming spot for a hearty Italian meal.
Mario’s Italian Restaurant & Pizzeria
8.6/10 (275 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 217-483-6888
Hot and tasty dishesProfessional and attentive staffUnique roast beef entrée
Nestled in the heart of the city, Mario’s Italian Restaurant & Pizzeria offers a delightful dining experience with flavors reminiscent of old-world Italy. From the hot and tasty dishes to the attentive and professional waitstaff, Mario’s truly delivers on both food and service. However, the atmosphere and service may leave something to be desired, but the roast beef smothered in cheese is a must-try delicacy that will have you coming back for more.
Da Nico Ristorante
8.6/10 (3639 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 212-343-1212
Genuine Italian flavorsStellar serviceCharming outdoor patio
Da Nico Ristorante is a standout spot on Mulberry Street, offering stellar service and authentic Italian dishes. The tomato sauce is true to its roots, and the patio adds to the overall charm of the restaurant. The Chicken Parmesan and perfectly ripe strawberry salad are must-try items on the menu, showcasing the chef’s talent and passion for culinary excellence. The complimentary bruschetta and zeppoles are a nice touch, adding to the wonderful atmosphere of Da Nico in Little Italy. Sitting outside on a sunny day with an Aperol Spritz in hand is the perfect way to experience this classic NYC restaurant.
Sam’s Italian Pizza
8.6/10 (237 reviews)
| Directions | +1 217-522-9111
Flavorful pastaFriendly staffHistoric ambiance
Nestled on Springfield’s north end, Sam’s Italian Pizza offers a comforting taste of Italian cuisine that keeps customers coming back. The pasta is a standout favorite, with flavorful dishes that truly hit the spot. The staff, while appearing a bit overwhelmed, manages to provide friendly service that adds to the overall dining experience. The historic walls inside create a unique ambiance that adds to the charm of this neighborhood gem.