Whether you’re craving a classic New York-style fold or a gourmet Neapolitan masterpiece, St. Petersburg offers a selection of pizza spots that promise to satisfy every palate.
From crispy thin crusts adorned with local produce to hearty deep-dish wonders that ooze with molten cheese, St. Petersburg’s pizza scene offers something to satiate every palate. This guide curates the city’s standout pizzerias, each offering a unique slice of culinary heaven.
Sergimmo Salumeria
8.8/10 (543 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 212-967-4212
Delicious sandwichesFresh breadInviting atmosphere
Known for its incredibly delicious sandwiches and charming atmosphere, Sergimmo Salumeria is a must-visit spot for Italian food enthusiasts. The extensive menu offers a variety of options that are perfect for a quick and satisfying meal. The standout favorite, the Le “vip” sandwich, consistently impresses guests with its flavors and quality. The bread, always fresh and soft, complements the fillings perfectly, making every bite a delightful experience. The cozy indoor seating and friendly staff create a warm and inviting ambiance that adds to the overall dining experience. Whether you’re in the mood for a classic sandwich or a delectable pasta dish, Sergimmo Salumeria promises a culinary adventure that will keep you coming back for more.
Ace’s Pizza
9/10 (200 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 718-764-8200
Detroit-style piesBurnt cheese crustPolite staff
Ace’s Pizza is a gem serving up Detroit-style pies with a delightful burnt cheese crust that brings a unique and delicious twist to traditional pizza. The cheese pulls are on point, and the Hot Burrata adds a flavorful kick to the menu. The staff is polite and attentive, offering great service and creating a welcoming atmosphere. The location inside the Rockefeller Center subway terminal may be a bit tricky to find, but the search is worth it for the delicious pizza experience that awaits. With a mix of classic and innovative toppings, Ace’s Pizza is a must-visit spot in NYC for pizza lovers looking for a tasty and satisfying meal.
Bread & Salt
9/10 (488 reviews)
| Directions | +1 201-500-7338
Star pizzaPerfect portionsAuthentic Italian fare
Bread & Salt offers a unique dining experience with their star of the show pizza – thin and crispy with the perfect amount of sauce and fresh mozzarella. The half pie is more than enough for two people, making it a great option for sharing. The chicken cutlet sandwich is good on its own, but could use some mayo and tomatoes to take it further. The bombolone dessert is a must-try, and don’t forget to wash it down with the refreshing Italian sprite. The variety of menu items, from breakfast sandwiches to cappuccinos, makes Bread & Salt a must-visit spot.
The Frenchman’s Dough
8.6/10 (168 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 646-868-6000
Crispy truffle pizzaSpicy pepper ravioliCharming ambiance
The Frenchman’s Dough is a delightful pizza restaurant with a charming ambiance and impressive dishes. The calamari appetizer was a standout with sprinkled parmesan cheese adding a nice touch. The ravioli was a crowd pleaser, perfectly blending spicy peppers with sweet cheese. The truffle pizza was light, crispy, and aromatic – a must-try. The tiramisu was a bit on the sweeter side but had a great texture. Overall, this spot is a top-notch option for Italian cuisine in the area.
Pasta Louise Cafe
9/10 (492 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 347-725-3883
Freshly made pastaUnique daily pasta shapesFlavorful sauces
Pasta Louise Cafe is a neighborhood gem known for its freshly made pasta and delicious dishes. Customers rave about the unique pasta shapes offered daily, allowing for a custom experience with a variety of flavorful sauces. The cacio e pepe with spicy prosciutto crisps is a standout favorite, along with the whipped ricotta that adds a creamy twist to many dishes. The consistent quality of the food, from the prosciutto to the winter citrus salad, keeps patrons coming back for more. Despite some inconsistent experiences with service and bread texture, Pasta Louise Cafe continues to impress with its flavorful offerings.
Ci Siamo
9.2/10 (1187 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 212-219-6559
Trendy atmosphereExcellent serviceDelicious rabbit pasta
Ci Siamo is a trendy restaurant with excellent service and a chic atmosphere. Situated on the 2nd floor, the expansive space features great decor and an open kitchen. The staff is friendly and provides great recommendations – the rabbit pasta is a standout dish, while the smashed potatoes and onion torta are must-tries. The vibes are fun and lively, making it a great spot for a sophisticated Italian American dining experience. The caramelized onion tart could use some improvement, but overall, Ci Siamo is a fantastic choice for high-quality food and top-notch service.
Cafe Spaghetti
9.6/10 (380 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 718-207-6084
Amazing serviceFlavorful foodCharming decorations
Cafe Spaghetti is truly a gem in NYC, offering amazing service, flavorful food, delicious cocktails, and charming decorations. The patio is a sunny and cheerful spot for dining, filled with families, friends, and even a vintage Italian scooter as decor. The attention to detail is evident throughout, from the tribute to Maradona in the restroom to the knowledgeable server who guided us through the menu and Amari selection. The pasta dishes, especially the Fussili grosso genovese ragu, are unforgettable, and the tiramisú is a perfect ending to a meal filled with Italian indulgence.
Masala Cafe Chettinad
9/10 (716 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 201-420-7635
Flavorful non-vegetarian dishesEfficient and attentive serviceAuthentic South Indian flavors
Upon stepping into Masala Cafe Chettinad, diners are immediately transported to a culinary journey through South India. The menu boasts a range of mouth-watering non-vegetarian options that truly capture the essence of Chettinad flavors. The fish fry, chicken dishes, and Kerala paratha all stand out as must-try items for those seeking a robust and flavorful dining experience. The attentive and efficient service adds to the overall ambience of the restaurant, making it a top choice for those craving authentic South Indian cuisine.
Fresco’s Pizzeria
9/10 (419 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 212-740-2737
Delicious pizzaVariety of toppingsExcellent pasta
Located in the heart of NYC, Fresco’s Pizzeria is a true gem when it comes to delicious pizza. Whether you’re a local or just passing through, Fresco’s is a must-visit destination. Their plain cheese slice is a standout, but don’t stop there – their specialty slices with a variety of toppings are equally mouthwatering. And don’t overlook their pasta and salads, which are just as excellent as their pizza offerings. If you’re looking for a new go-to spot for authentic NYC pizza, look no further than Fresco’s Pizzeria on 187th.
Pete’s Tavern
8.6/10 (1418 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 212-473-7676
Thin Crust PizzaFriendly StaffHouse Ale
Pete’s Tavern is a timeless gem, boasting a cozy ambiance and a menu that hits all the right notes. The Thin Crust Pizza with Buratta Cheese is a standout dish, perfect for sharing. The staff is friendly and professional, providing quick service that enhances the overall dining experience. The house ale is a must-try, offering a lighter option for those looking for a refreshing beer. The Gnocchi Spinach Pesto and Chicken Parmigiana are both delicious entrees, showcasing the restaurant’s commitment to quality and flavor. The updated bathrooms are a welcome addition, reflecting the attention to detail that sets Pete’s Tavern apart.
La Bonne Soupe
8.8/10 (1473 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 212-586-7650
Consistently delicious foodFriendly and attentive serviceCozy bistro setting
Amidst the hustle and bustle of New York City, La Bonne Soupe stands out as a charming eatery, attracting both locals and tourists alike. The food is consistently delicious, with standout dishes like escargot, French onion soup, and steak au poivre transporting diners to the streets of France. The service is friendly and hospitable, ensuring a memorable dining experience. The bistro setting adds to the cozy ambiance, making it a top spot for anyone craving a taste of authentic French cuisine in the heart of Manhattan.
Barbuto
8.8/10 (921 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 212-924-9700
Diverse MenuOpen KitchenLively Ambiance
Barbuto is a versatile restaurant with a menu that transcends traditional culinary boundaries. Offering a mix of Italian and American dishes, the restaurant provides a diverse range of options, ensuring there is something for everyone. The open kitchen adds a layer of excitement to the dining experience, while the well-stocked beverage selection complements the flavorful and fresh dishes. The ambiance is lively yet cozy, making it a perfect spot for a casual get-together or a date night. Overall, Barbuto offers a unique dining experience with delicious food and a welcoming atmosphere.
Bruno’s Pizza
8.8/10 (642 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 973-473-3339
Simple yet delicious pizzaGenerous portionsThai Fried Calamari appetizer
Bruno’s Pizza is a spot that doesn’t need frills to shine. The simple pies are a hit, especially the sicilian with extra cheese and fresh garlic. The service is quick and portions are generous, making it a must-visit for a no-fuss dinner. The Thai Fried Calamari appetizer is a standout, topped with sweet chili sauce, scallions, and toasted sesame seeds. The main entrees like Chicken Pesto and Meat Lasagna are crowd pleasers, with only a slight issue of overly salty cheese in the lasagna. The rice balls with vodka sauce are a must-try, and the sicilian pie and broccoli rabe are top-notch. Bruno’s dedication to flavorful dishes, friendly service, and clean environment makes it a reliable choice for a satisfying meal.
Joey Brooklyn’s Famous Pizza Kitchen
9/10 (2005 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 727-822-6757
Generous slice sizesEfficient serviceCozy atmosphere
Review: Joey Brooklyn’s Famous Pizza Kitchen is a must-try for lovers of New York style pizza. The slices are generous and delicious, with options for both cheese and pepperoni lovers. The staff is welcoming and efficient, providing excellent service whether you’re dining in or ordering pickup. The cozy atmosphere, complete with standing room inside and picnic tables outside, adds to the overall experience. Open late, this micro pizza place is the perfect spot to enjoy great food and maybe even catch some live music from nearby Jannus Live.
Slice of The Burg
9.4/10 (1573 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 727-275-2874
Vegan optionsCustomizable ordersClean and inviting atmosphere
Slice of The Burg stands out for its attention to detail and quality ingredients. Customers rave about the vegan options, particularly the garlic knots that are described as “off the hook.” The ability to customize orders, like splitting a pizza half and half, is a unique and appreciated touch. The clean and inviting indoor seating, complete with ample napkins and condiments, adds to the overall dining experience. The friendly staff and efficient kitchen operations also receive high praise, making Slice of The Burg a top choice for pizza lovers seeking a memorable and delicious meal.
Redds
8.6/10 (923 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 201-933-0015
Convenient bus serviceDelicious foodWelcoming owner
Redds is a must-visit spot for those attending events at the nearby stadium. The convenience of their round trip bus service is a game-changer, making transportation to and from the venue a breeze. The food and service are top-notch, with perfectly cooked dishes and friendly staff. The owner, Doug, adds a personal touch to the experience, making everyone feel at home. Despite some minor issues reported by customers, Redds remains a standout option for a pre-game or post-event meal and drinks.
Top Slice Pizzeria
8.8/10 (700 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 727-685-5846
Crisp crustExceptional customer serviceNew York-style pizza
Top Slice Pizzeria is a slice of New York City right in the heart of St. Petersburg. The New York-style pizza served here is a standout, with a crisp crust and generously sized slices that are sure to satisfy any pizza lover. What truly sets this place apart, however, is the exceptional customer service. The staff goes above and beyond to make sure every customer feels welcome and well taken care of, truly making the dining experience here top-notch. The owner’s passion for the business and the clean, inviting ambiance of the restaurant only add to the overall appeal of Top Slice Pizzeria.
Circo Italian Kitchen
9.4/10 (134 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 727-273-7137
Genuine Italian flavorsExceptional serviceCozy atmosphere
Circo Italian Kitchen is a hidden gem on Tierra Verde, offering genuine and flavorful Italian food at great prices. The handmade Gnocchi seafood special was a standout, as well as the Eggplant lasagna and Giant crèmbule for dessert. The service is exceptional, with staff accommodating dietary restrictions and taking great pride in their restaurant. The cozy and tasteful atmosphere adds to the overall dining experience, making it a must-visit for Italian food lovers.
Gratzzi Italian Grille
9/10 (1761 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 727-623-9037
Unique tableside pastaExceptional serviceMemorable birthday desserts
Gratzzi Italian Grille offers a unique dining experience that stands out among other Italian restaurants in the area. The ambiance sets the perfect mood for a casual dinner or a special occasion, with attentive service and knowledgeable staff to guide you through the menu. The Cavatelli Bada Bing is a must-try dish that tantalizes the taste buds with fresh ingredients and a cheesy sauce that delights with every bite. The tableside pasta preparation adds an extra element of excitement to the dining experience, making it a memorable meal that keeps you coming back for more. The free dessert for birthdays adds a sweet touch to the evening, with options like crème brûlée and limoncello cake that are sure to please.
Hungry Howie’s Pizza & Subs
9.6/10 (168 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 727-390-8777
Buttery cheese crustUnique special requestsFriendly and helpful staff
Hungry Howie’s Pizza & Subs is a clear standout in the world of pizza joints. The buttery cheese crust is a must-try, adding a flavorful touch to every delicious bite. One unique quality of this spot is their willingness to go the extra mile for customers, like fulfilling a special request for a gender reveal party. The independent business owner, Yasser, ensures a seamless and friendly experience, making sure even big orders are ready right on time. The variety of options, from stuffed crust to different sauces and spices, means everyone can find their new favorite slice. The staff’s friendliness and helpfulness only add to the overall experience.