Whether you’re craving a classic New York-style fold or a gourmet Neapolitan masterpiece, Syracuse offers a selection of pizza spots that promise to satisfy every palate.
From crispy thin crusts adorned with local produce to hearty deep-dish wonders that ooze with molten cheese, Syracuse’s pizza scene offers something to satiate every palate. This guide curates the city’s standout pizzerias, each offering a unique slice of culinary heaven.
Pavone’s Pizza – Syracuse, NY
8.8/10 (480 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 315-471-1980
Tasty PizzaMemorable WingsAffordable Prices
Nestled in Syracuse, Pavone’s Pizza churns out delightful slices that keep locals coming back for more. The pizza is a standout here with just the right amount of crisp and not too greasy, making it a satisfying meal. Pair that with some memorable wings and fried zucchini that tastes like French fries, and you have a winning combination. The small garlic pizza with broccoli and mushrooms, served alongside garlic knots, is a particularly noteworthy choice. The affordable prices are another draw, making Pavone’s a great option for a delicious and budget-friendly meal.
Varsity Pizza Syracuse
8.8/10 (1220 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 315-478-1235
Fresh Chef SaladBlueberry Lemon CookieFriendly staff
Varsity Pizza Syracuse is a must-visit spot in the heart of Syracuse University. The Chef Salad is always fresh and delicious, and the Blueberry Lemon Cookie is a perfect sweet treat. The staff is attentive and ensures you have a great dining experience. The Varsity Cheese Steak is a standout, and the buffalo wings are a big hit. The atmosphere is full of college charm, making it a perfect spot to enjoy a meal before a game or catch up with old friends. If you find yourself near Syracuse University, be sure to stop by Varsity Pizza!
Nick’s Tomato Pie
9/10 (283 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 315-472-7703
Local flavorStandout crustWide variety
Nick’s Tomato Pie in Syracuse delivers a slice of local flavor that is not to be missed. The Chicken Bacon Ranch pizza and Spicy Honey are standout slices, and the teriyaki pizza is a must-try. The substantial portions are perfect for a quick and satisfying meal. While the ambiance may be a bit outdated, the friendly service more than makes up for it. The standout player here is the crust, perfectly complemented by the delicious toppings. The menu offers a wide variety of specialty slices, with the poutine pizza being a fan favorite. Nick’s Tomato Pie is a hidden gem that deserves more recognition for its quality and consistency.
Mario & Salvo’s Pizzeria
9/10 (609 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 315-446-8479
Efficient chaosTempting menuPerfect pizza dough
Nestled in Syracuse, Mario & Salvo’s Pizzeria is a bustling hub of energy and delicious aromas. The chaotic yet organized scene inside the small space is a testament to the efficiency and passion behind the scenes. The menu offers tempting options for all, from vegetarians to pepperoni lovers. The pizza dough is a standout, with perfectly cooked crust and ideal toppings. The New York style pizza is a hidden gem worth the trip, even if it means navigating a busy parking lot and tight seating arrangements. With a loyal following and a growing reputation, Mario & Salvo’s delivers a slice of pizza paradise in Syracuse.
Nick’s Pizza
9/10 (439 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 315-463-6425
Great valueFlavorful dishesAttentive service
Nick’s Pizza is a hidden gem that offers great value and flavorful dishes. From the crispy garlic knots to the perfectly crunchy crust on their pizzas, every bite is a treat. The staff goes above and beyond to ensure a pleasant dining experience, making sure to correct any mistakes with grace. With a diverse menu and attentive service, Nick’s Pizza is a must-visit for a delicious and satisfying meal.
Apizza Regionale
9.4/10 (1371 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 315-802-2607
Tasty pizzaLocal ingredientsCozy atmosphere
Apizza Regionale in downtown Syracuse is a must-visit spot for delicious pizza and impressive food offerings. The star of the show is definitely the pizza, with a tasty dough and perfect cheese ratio that customers rave about. From the Salsiccia pizza to the Meatball pizza, the flavors are exceptional and sourced locally, adding to the overall dining experience. The cozy and intimate atmosphere, along with the friendly and attentive service, makes this restaurant a gem in Syracuse’s dining scene. The olive oil cake dessert is a must-try, and the affordable prices make it a great value for the quality of food you receive. Highly recommended for a memorable dining experience in Syracuse.
East of Chicago Pizza – Syracuse
8.6/10 (136 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 315-400-3047
Flavorful toppingsCrispy crustOutstanding service
Review: East of Chicago Pizza – Syracuse truly delivers an exceptional pizza experience. The buffalo chicken wing pizza was a hit with its flavorful and generously topped slices that pleased the whole family. The Chicago Style Deep Dish Pizza showcased expert layering and crispy perfection that left me wanting more. The staff’s attention to detail and friendly service truly elevated the dining experience. If you’re seeking delicious pizza made with care and served with a smile, East of Chicago Pizza is a must-visit spot in Syracuse.
Cardano’s Pizza & Wings
8.6/10 (106 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 315-299-7755
Excellent Hawaiian pizzaGenerous portionsEfficient service
Located in Syracuse, Cardano’s Pizza & Wings has quickly become a local favorite. The Hawaiian pizza is excellent, with a subtle crunch on the crust allowing for the flavors to shine. It’s arguable the best pizza in the area, and the generous portions at a reasonable price make it a go-to spot. The efficient service, fresh and on-time food, and a variety of delivery options make this underrated gem a must-try for pizza lovers.
Tangy Tomato
8.8/10 (191 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 315-314-6090
Affordable pricesGenerous portionsFriendly staff
Tangy Tomato stands out for their affordable prices and generous portions. Customers rave about the amazing deals on their New York style pizza and wings, with one customer saving over 40% compared to other popular places. The pizzas are made to order and delicious, with options like Buffalo chicken and veggie that leave customers completely satisfied. The staff at Tangy Tomato are also highly praised for their friendliness and professionalism, making customers feel welcomed and eager to return for more of the flavorful offerings.
Johnny Mac’s Pizzeria & Deli
9.2/10 (249 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 315-468-4052
Fresh ingredientsFriendly staffCrispy crust
Nestled in Syracuse, Johnny Mac’s Pizzeria & Deli shines with its friendly staff and top-tier dough that holds up with every bite. The New York style thin crust is a crowd-pleaser, done just right with non-greasy toppings. The fresh ingredients shine through in every delicious slice, making this local gem a must-visit spot with excellent pizza and welcoming staff.
Kostas Pizza House
9.6/10 (460 reviews)
| Directions | +1 315-432-9943
Authentic charmFlavor-packed menuPhenomenal pizza
Nestled in Syracuse, Kostas Pizza House is a cozy gem that exudes old-school charm. From the welcoming decor adorned with plants and vintage clippings to the lively banter of the owner, this place screams authenticity. The gyro, hailed as the best in town, and the crispy wings served at lightning speed are just a glimpse of the flavor-packed experience awaiting you. With the perfect cheese-to-topping ratio and a buttery, crisp crust, the pizza here is simply phenomenal. The cash-only policy may harken back to simpler times, but don’t let that deter you – an ATM is conveniently located on-site for your convenience.
Toss & Fire Wood-Fired Pizza
9.2/10 (1121 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 315-458-9380
Variety of optionsInviting atmosphereQuality ingredients
At Toss & Fire Wood-Fired Pizza, the menu offerings are truly impressive with a variety of options to please any palate. The atmosphere is inviting and cozy, making it the perfect spot to enjoy a meal with friends and family. The staff is incredibly thoughtful and hardworking, ensuring that every customer feels well taken care of. The Detroit style pizza with cup & char pepperoni is a standout, while the wood-fired pizza with garlic base and mushrooms is also a crowd pleaser. The quality of ingredients shines through in every bite, resulting in a delightful and satisfying dining experience that will have you coming back for more.
Pavone’s Pizza & Eatery
8.6/10 (660 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 315-251-2500
Unique pin wheelsDelicious pizzaAffordable prices
Nestled in the heart of the city, Pavone’s Pizza & Eatery is a go-to spot for pizza lovers craving a unique culinary experience. The pinwheels are a standout item on the menu, with the perfect combination of flavors and just the right amount of crunch. Pair them with a refreshing salad and drink for a satisfying meal that won’t break the bank. Whether you opt for pepperoni or chicken with bacon, Pavone’s delivers consistently fantastic food that leaves customers coming back for more.
Paladino’s Pizza
9.4/10 (635 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 315-455-6477
Crispy crustSavory sauceFresh salads
Paladino’s Pizza is a true gem in Syracuse, offering a perfect NY-style pizza experience. The crust strikes the ideal balance of crispiness and softness, making folding your slice effortless. The savory sauce and gooey cheese create the ultimate cheese pull, enhancing every bite. Additionally, the freshness of the salads and the well-executed appetizers truly elevate the dining experience. The restaurant’s attention to detail and dedication to quality make it a standout in the pizza scene.
Dolce Vita
8.6/10 (247 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 315-475-4700
Gluten-free calzoneKeto-friendly optionsFriendly staff
Located in Syracuse, Dolce Vita is a gem for those with dietary restrictions, offering delicious gluten-free and keto-friendly options that are hard to come by. The calzone and bacon-wrapped pork are standout dishes that cater to those following specific diets, providing a flavorful and satisfying meal. The friendly and accommodating staff ensure a pleasant dining experience, making it a go-to spot for those looking for unique and tasty food options.
Trapper’s
9/10 (541 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 315-438-4444
Unique dining experienceFriendly staffDelicious pizza and wings
Trapper’s is a hidden gem tucked away in an industrial business sector, offering a unique dining experience with multiple rooms, a bar area, and even outdoor volleyball courts. The staff and owner are helpful and friendly, making the atmosphere welcoming. The food is a standout, with delicious pizza and wings that are sure to impress. The prices are reasonable, making it a great choice for a night out.
Angotti’s | Family Restaurant
9.2/10 (475 reviews)
| Directions | +1 315-472-8403
Authentic flavorsGenerous portionsReasonable prices
Nestled in Syracuse, Angotti’s delivers authentic Italian flavors that will transport you straight to the heart of Italy. Their home-style cooking offers generous portions at reasonable prices, making it a go-to spot for those craving comforting Italian meals. The stuffed shells and antipasto are standout dishes, showcasing their outstanding sauce and delightful mozzarella. Despite operating on a takeout-only basis, the food at Angotti’s still manages to impress with its delicious taste and Italian perfection. This family-run gem is sure to become your new favorite spot for hearty Italian favorites.
Pastabilities
9.2/10 (3369 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 315-474-1153
Cool vibeTop-notch serviceDelicious pasta
Nestled in an old warehouse building, Pastabilities offers a cool vibe and top-notch service. The pasta dishes are a must-try, with tender chicken riggies and outstanding calamari stealing the show. The homemade bread with a hot and spicy dipping sauce is worth the visit alone. The restaurant impresses from start to finish, making it a great spot for a special dinner or celebration. Reservations are a must as this gem fills up fast!
Bianchi’s Catering & Pizza
8.8/10 (253 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 315-488-2931
Flavorful lasagnaHot pizza deliveryCommunity-oriented owner
Bianchi’s Catering & Pizza offers a variety of catering options that are perfect for both large events and small gatherings. The Thursday Lasagna Dinner special is a crowd favorite, with flavorful lasagna that is sure to impress. Their commitment to quality and freshness shines through in every bite, making it a go-to spot for delicious Italian comfort food. The hot and generous pizza delivery service, particularly appreciated by schools, showcases the owner’s dedication to the local community and ensuring customer satisfaction. Whether it’s a salad, wings, or lasagna, Bianchi’s knows how to deliver a satisfying meal that keeps customers coming back for more.
Utica Pizza Company
9/10 (683 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 315-214-3060
Flavorful garlic knotsAttentive and friendly staffMust-try desserts
Utica Pizza Company offers much more than just pizza, as evidenced by the rave reviews from customers. The garlic knots are a standout, with the perfect balance of flavor and texture. The Italian wedding soup may not be for everyone, but it showcases the restaurant’s willingness to push boundaries and offer unique dishes. The service is top-notch, with attentive and friendly staff who enhance the overall dining experience. The desserts are a must-try, showcasing the restaurant’s commitment to quality and innovation in every aspect of their menu.